D01 2 ^ with_IN so_QL many_AP problems_NNS to_TO solve_VB ,_, it_PP3 D01 2 would_MD be_BE a_AT great_JJ help_NN to_TO D01 3 select_VB some_DTI one_CD1 problem_NN which_WDTR might_MD be_BE the_ATI D01 3 key_NN to_IN all_ABN the_ATI others_APS ,_, and_CC D01 4 begin_VB there_RN ._. ^ if_CS there_EX is_BEZ any_DTI such_ABL D01 4 key-problem_NN ,_, then_RN it_PP3 is_BEZ undoubtedly_RB D01 5 the_ATI problem_NN of_IN the_ATI unity_NN of_IN the_ATI gospel_NN ._. ^ D01 5 there_EX are_BER three_CD views_NNS of_IN the_ATI D01 6 fourth_OD gospel_NN which_WDTR have_HV been_BEN held_VBN ._. D01 7 ^ some_DTI critics_NNS ,_, not_XNOT many_AP ,_, argue_VB that_CS D01 7 the_ATI gospel_NN is_BEZ the_ATI product_NN of_IN D01 8 one_CD1 mind_NN and_CC one_CD1 hand_NN ._. ^ for_IN them_PP3OS the_ATI D01 8 problems_NNS of_IN the_ATI fourth_OD gospel_NN D01 9 exist_VB only_RB in_IN the_ATI mind_NN of_IN its_PP$ detractors_NNS ._. D01 9 ^ the_ATI difficulties_NNS which_WDTR are_BER D01 10 felt_VBN by_IN modern_JJ critics_NNS are_BER due_JJ to_IN the_ATI D01 10 book_NN being_BEG read_VBN and_CC examined_VBN as_CS D01 11 it_PP3 was_BEDZ never_RB meant_VBN to_TO be_BE ._. ^ there_EX is_BEZ D01 11 some_DTI truth_NN in_IN this_DT contention_NN ,_, and_CC D01 12 one_CD1 must_MD always_RB remember_VB that_CS no_ATI book_NN of_IN D01 12 the_ATI new_JJ testament_NN was_BEDZ written_VBN D01 13 with_IN the_ATI special_JJ interests_NNS of_IN a_AT modern_JJ critic_NN D01 13 in_IN mind_NN ._. ^ many_AP of_IN the_ATI D01 14 questions_NNS which_WDTR the_ATI searching_JJ scrutiny_NN of_IN the_ATI D01 14 textual_JJ critic_NN raises_VBZ D01 15 were_BED of_IN no_ATI interest_NN to_IN the_ATI author_NN of_IN the_ATI D01 15 gospel_NN ._. ^ however_RB ,_, this_DT kind_NN D01 16 of_IN immaculate_JJ conception_NN of_IN John_NP is_BEZ difficult_JJ D01 16 to_TO maintain_VB in_IN the_ATI face_NN D01 17 of_IN the_ATI contrasts_NNS with_IN the_ATI other_AP gospels_NNS and_CC D01 17 of_IN the_ATI striking_JJ unanimity_NN D01 18 of_IN scholars_NNS who_WPR have_HV detected_VBN dislocations_NNS in_IN D01 18 the_ATI text_NN ._. ^ that_CS the_ATI D01 19 gospel_NN is_BEZ homogeneous_JJ is_BEZ the_ATI orthodox_JJ view_NN D01 19 of_IN the_ATI Roman_JNP Church_NPL ._. D01 20 ^ Loisy_NP ,_, who_WPR could_MD not_XNOT accept_VB this_DT view_NN ,_, D01 20 was_BEDZ excommunicated_VBN in_IN 1907_CD D01 21 after_CS a_AT Biblical_JNP commission_NN had_HVD answered_VBN three_CD D01 21 questions_NNS on_IN the_ATI fourth_OD D01 22 gospel_NN ,_, and_CC the_ATI Pope_NPT made_VBD their_PP$ three_CD D01 22 answers_NNS articles_NNS of_IN faith_NN ._. ^ the_ATI D01 23 first_OD article_NN affirmed_VBD the_ATI authorship_NN of_IN the_ATI D01 23 apostle_NN John_NP ._. ^ the_ATI second_OD D01 24 said_VBD that_CS the_ATI problems_NNS which_WDTR arise_VB from_IN D01 24 the_ATI comparisons_NNS with_IN the_ATI D01 25 synoptics_NNS can_MD be_BE reasonably_RB solved_VBN by_IN paying_VBG D01 25 due_JJ regard_NN to_IN the_ATI time_NN D01 26 and_CC plan_NN and_CC to_IN the_ATI different_JJ public_NN for_IN D01 26 which_WDTR ,_, or_CC against_IN which_WDTR ,_, the_ATI D01 27 author_NN wrote_VBD ._. ^ the_ATI third_OD article_NN excluded_VBD D01 27 any_DTI allegorical_JJ D01 28 interpretation_NN of_IN the_ATI gospel_NN ._. D01 29 ^ there_EX is_BEZ a_AT whole_JJ group_NN of_IN theories_NNS D01 29 which_WDTR attempt_VB to_TO explain_VB the_ATI D01 30 problems_NNS of_IN the_ATI fourth_OD gospel_NN by_IN explanations_NNS D01 30 based_VBN on_IN assumed_JJ textual_JJ D01 31 dislocations_NNS ._. ^ the_ATI present_JJ state_NN of_IN the_ATI D01 31 gospel_NN is_BEZ the_ATI result_NN of_IN an_AT D01 32 accident-prone_JJ history_NN ._. ^ the_ATI original_NN was_BEDZ D01 32 written_VBN on_IN a_AT roll_NN ,_, or_CC codex_NN ,_, D01 33 which_WDTR fell_VBD into_IN disorder_NN or_CC was_BEDZ accidentally_RB D01 33 damaged_VBN ._. ^ an_AT editor_NN ,_, who_WPR D01 34 was_BEDZ not_XNOT the_ATI author_NN ,_, made_VBD what_WDT he_PP3A D01 34 could_MD of_IN the_ATI chaos_NN by_IN placing_VBG the_ATI D01 35 fragments_NNS ,_, or_CC sheets_NNS ,_, or_CC pages_NNS ,_, in_IN D01 35 order_NN ._. ^ most_AP of_IN those_DTS who_WPR expound_VB a_AT D01 36 theory_NN of_IN textual_JJ dislocation_NN take_VB it_PP3 for_CS D01 36 granted_VBN that_CS the_ATI gospel_NN was_BEDZ D01 37 written_VBN entirely_RB by_IN one_CD1 author_NN before_CS the_ATI D01 37 disturbance_NN took_VBD place_NN but_CC a_AP D01 38 few_AP" leave_VB it_PP3 open_JJ to_TO suppose_VB that_CS the_ATI D01 38 original_JJ book_NN had_HVD been_BEN revised_VBN D01 39 even_RB before_IN the_ATI upheaval_NN ._. D01 40 ^ the_ATI ingenuity_NN of_IN the_ATI theories_NNS is_BEZ D01 40 impressive_JJ and_CC is_BEZ the_ATI best_JJT D01 41 argument_NN against_IN them_PP3OS ._. ^ if_CS the_ATI history_NN of_IN D01 41 the_ATI gospel_NN has_HVZ been_BEN as_QL D01 42 fortuitous_JJ as_CS they_PP3AS suppose_VB ,_, rational_JJ criticism_NN D01 42 is_BEZ impossible_JJ ._. ^ the_ATI D01 43 critic_NN hopes_VBZ to_TO discover_VB order_NN ,_, sequence_NN and_CC D01 43 purpose_NN ._. ^ the_ATI textual_JJ D01 44 dislocators_NNS recount_VB tales_NNS of_IN disorder_NN ,_, of_IN D01 44 transposition_NN ,_, and_CC of_IN the_ATI D01 45 wayward_JJ impulse_NN of_IN the_ATI editor_NN ,_, who_WPR at_IN one_CD1 D01 45 moment_NN compels_VBZ admiration_NN D01 46 for_IN his_PP$ spiritual_JJ insight_NN and_CC at_IN the_ATI next_AP D01 46 is_BEZ rolling_VBG dice_NNS ._. D01 47 ^ fortunately_RB ,_, the_ATI introduction_NN of_IN chance_NN into_IN D01 47 these_DTS schemes_NNS makes_VBZ D01 48 it_PP3 possible_JJ to_TO test_VB them_PP3OS statistically_RB ._. ^ D01 48 the_ATI result_NN confirms_VBZ the_ATI D01 49 impression_NN that_CS ingenuity_NN is_BEZ their_PP$ only_AP virtue_NN D01 49 ._. ^ one_CD1 must_MD not_XNOT pass_VB D01 50 over_RP the_ATI derangement_NN theories_NNS without_IN D01 50 acknowledgment_NN of_IN the_ATI truth_NN D01 51 which_WDTR they_PP3AS contain_VB ._. ^ the_ATI exponent_NN of_IN D01 51 such_ABL a_AT theory_NN has_HVZ seen_VBN some_DTI D01 52 regularities_NNS in_IN the_ATI structure_NN of_IN the_ATI gospel_NN ._. D01 52 ^ the_ATI regularities_NNS are_BER not_XNOT D01 53 simple_JJ nor_CC are_BER they_PP3AS continuous_JJ ._. ^ the_ATI D01 53 critic_NN then_RN assumes_VBZ that_CS the_ATI D01 54 underlying_JJ order_NN was_BEDZ based_VBN on_IN the_ATI sheets_NNS ,_, D01 54 or_CC pages_NNS ,_, on_IN which_WDTR the_ATI D01 55 original_NN was_BEDZ written_VBN ,_, and_CC that_CS the_ATI disorder_NN D01 55 was_BEDZ due_JJ to_IN some_DTI D01 56 rearrangements_NNS of_IN those_DTS sheets_NNS or_CC pages_NNS ._. ^ D01 56 to_TO dismiss_VB the_ATI D01 57 textual-derangement_JJB theories_NNS out_RP of_IN hand_NN is_BEZ to_TO D01 57 discard_VB some_DTI acute_JJ D01 58 observation_NN because_CS it_PP3 is_BEZ incomplete_JJ and_CC has_HVZ D01 58 been_BEN wrongly_RB developed_VBN ._. D01 59 ^ the_ATI third_OD type_NN of_IN theory_NN would_MD account_VB D01 59 for_IN the_ATI difficulties_NNS of_IN D01 60 the_ATI fourth_OD gospel_NN in_IN terms_NNS of_IN its_PP$ having_HVG D01 60 been_BEN ,_, at_IN one_CD1 time_NN ,_, a_AT shorter_JJR D01 61 book_NN than_CS it_PP3 now_RN is_BEZ ._. ^ in_IN the_ATI enlargement_NN D01 61 of_IN this_DT little_JJ gospel_NN some_DTI D01 62 movements_NNS of_IN the_ATI text_NN took_VBD place_NN ._. D01 63 ^ the_ATI commentator_NN has_HVZ long_RB been_BEN a_AT leading_JJ D01 63 exponent_NN of_IN such_ABL a_AT view_NN ._. D01 64 ^ in_IN his_PP$ commentary_NN on_IN John_NP ,_, he_PP3A sets_VBZ out_RP D01 64 in_IN detail_NN the_ATI case_NN for_IN D01 65 enlargement_NN ._. ^ a_AT theory_NN of_IN this_DT kind_NN offers_VBZ D01 65 considerable_JJ advantages_NNS ._. D01 66 ^ it_PP3 can_MD explain_VB the_ATI early_JJ substratum_NN D01 66 undoubtedly_RB present_JJ in_IN the_ATI D01 67 gospel_NN ,_, and_CC yet_RB also_RB account_VB for_IN passages_NNS D01 67 which_WDTR are_BER not_XNOT easily_RB D01 68 reconciled_VBN with_IN early_JJ and_CC accurate_JJ knowledge_NN of_IN D01 68 the_ATI background_NN of_IN D01 69 Jesus's_NP$ life_NN and_CC work_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 can_MD offer_VB a_AT D01 69 reason_NN for_IN the_ATI textual_JJ changes_NNS D01 70 which_WDTR is_BEZ neither_DTX chance_NN nor_CC accident_NN *-_*- two_CD D01 70 terms_NNS which_WDTR too_QL often_RB cover_VB D01 71 the_ATI absence_NN of_IN any_DTI reason_NN ._. D01 72 ^ the_ATI one_CD1 real_JJ weakness_NN of_IN the_ATI D01 72 commentator's_NN$ case_NN is_BEZ that_DT ,_, in_RB D01 73 common_RB" with_IN all_ABN his_PP$ colleagues_NNS ,_, he_PP3A has_HVZ D01 73 not_XNOT ,_, until_IN now_RN ,_, been_BEN able_JJ to_TO D01 74 exhibit_VB exactly_RB how_WRB this_DT enlargement_NN was_BEDZ D01 74 effected_VBN nor_CC has_HVZ he_PP3A been_BEN able_JJ D01 75 to_TO explain_VB the_ATI textual_JJ movements_NNS by_IN showing_NN D01 75 that_CS such_ABL changes_NNS are_BER part_NN D01 76 of_IN a_AT simple_JJ and_CC coherent_JJ plan_NN ._. ^ to_TO D01 76 understand_VB how_WRB this_DT is_BEZ possible_JJ it_PP3 D01 77 is_BEZ necessary_JJ to_TO examine_VB the_ATI text_NN of_IN the_ATI D01 77 gospel_NN ._. D01 78 ^ chapter_NN 3_CD ._. D01 79 ^ the_ATI text_NN of_IN the_ATI fourth_OD gospel_NN ._. D01 80 ^ the_ATI fourth_OD gospel_NN was_BEDZ almost_RB certainly_RB D01 80 written_VBN in_IN Greek_NNP ._. ^ a_AT D01 81 modern_JJ text_NN of_IN the_ATI gospel_NN represents_VBZ the_ATI D01 81 work_NN of_IN generations_NNS of_IN D01 82 scholars_NNS who_WPR have_HV compared_VBN the_ATI many_AP D01 82 manuscripts_NNS of_IN John_NP and_CC worked_VBN out_RP D01 83 the_ATI version_NN which_WDTR is_BEZ most_QL likely_JJ to_TO have_HV D01 83 been_BEN the_ATI original_JJ wording_NN ._. D01 84 ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ not_XNOT possible_JJ to_TO establish_VB any_DTI one_CD1 D01 84 text_NN with_IN absolute_JJ precision_NN ._. D01 85 ^ the_ATI most_QL convenient_JJ one_CD1 for_IN the_ATI authors_NNS D01 85 has_HVZ been_BEN the_ATI text_NN of_IN \0A_NP D01 86 Souter_NP ._. ^ in_IN this_DT version_NN of_IN the_ATI text_NN the_ATI D01 86 fourth_OD gospel_NN is_BEZ printed_VBN as_IN D01 87 just_RB over_RB 1,000_CD different_JJ nouns_NNS ,_, verbs_NNS ,_, D01 87 and_CC other_AP parts_NNS of_IN speech_NN D01 88 occurring_VBG 15,695_CD times_NNS in_IN their_PP$ different_JJ D01 88 grammatical_JJ forms_NNS ._. ^ there_EX D01 89 are_BER other_AP texts_NNS which_WDTR could_MD have_HV been_BEN D01 89 used_VBN ,_, and_CC (_( as_CS shown_VBN in_IN table_NN D01 90 1_CD1 )_) it_PP3 is_BEZ not_XNOT a_AT matter_NN of_IN the_ATI D01 90 greatest_JJT importance_NN which_WDTR text_NN is_BEZ used_VBN ._. D01 92 ^ at_IN first_OD sight_NN the_ATI difference_NN between_IN Souter_NP D01 92 and_CC the_ATI other_AP texts_NNS D01 93 is_BEZ rather_RB large_JJ ._. ^ but_CC the_ATI British_JNP text_NN D01 93 includes_VBZ the_ATI paragraph_NN D01 94 7.53-8.11_CD-CD ,_, the_ATI woman_NN taken_VBN in_IN adultery_NN ,_, D01 94 and_CC this_DT accounts_VBZ for_IN 178_CD D01 95 words_NNS out_RP of_IN 279_CD ,_, which_WDTR is_BEZ the_ATI D01 95 difference_NN between_IN the_ATI 15,695_CD words_NNS of_IN D01 96 Souter's_NP$ text_NN and_CC the_ATI 15,416_CD of_IN Nestle's_NP$ ._. ^ D01 96 the_ATI omission_NN or_CC inclusion_NN D01 97 of_IN this_DT paragraph_NN is_BEZ a_AT matter_NN of_IN editorial_JJ D01 97 decision_NN rather_RB than_IN D01 98 scribal_JJ emendation_NN ,_, and_CC it_PP3 must_MD be_BE included_VBN D01 98 in_IN the_ATI gospel_NN and_CC studied_VBN ,_, D01 99 even_CS if_CS" the_ATI result_NN of_IN the_ATI study_NN were_BED to_TO D01 99 decide_VB that_CS the_ATI paragraph_NN D01 100 should_MD then_RN be_BE excluded_VBN ._. ^ thus_RB the_ATI D01 100 difference_NN between_IN Souter's_NP$ text_NN D01 101 and_CC Nestle's_NP$ is_BEZ 101_CD words_NNS ._. ^ if_CS the_ATI true_JJ D01 101 content_NN of_IN the_ATI text_NN of_IN the_ATI D01 102 gospel_NN is_BEZ taken_VBN as_IN the_ATI average_NN of_IN the_ATI D01 102 two_CD figures_NNS ,_, then_RN the_ATI difference_NN D01 103 is_BEZ 101_CD words_NNS in_IN 15,555_CD ,_, a_AT figure_NN on_IN D01 103 which_WDTR the_ATI textual_JJ critics_NNS may_MD be_BE D01 104 congratulated_VBN ._. ^ one_CD1 can_MD assume_VB that_CS Souter's_NP$ D01 104 version_NN of_IN the_ATI fourth_OD D01 105 gospel_NN represents_VBZ 99_CD per_NNU cent_NNU" of_IN the_ATI D01 105 original_JJ text_NN ._. ^ of_IN the_ATI remainder_NN D01 106 not_XNOT much_AP is_BEZ of_IN consequence_NN ,_, for_IN the_ATI D01 106 variant_JJ readings_NNS often_RB concern_VB D01 107 verbal_JJ tenses_NNS ,_, or_CC word_NN order_NN ,_, or_CC the_ATI D01 107 insertion_NN or_CC omission_NN of_IN D01 108 qualifying_JJ clauses_NNS ,_, not_XNOT many_AP of_IN which_WDTR D01 108 affect_VB the_ATI content_NN or_CC meaning_NN of_IN D01 109 the_ATI text_NN to_IN any_DTI great_JJ extent_NN ._. D01 110 ^ Souter's_NP$ text_NN is_BEZ not_XNOT identical_JJ with_IN the_ATI D01 110 original_NN of_IN John_NP ._. ^ the_ATI D01 111 gospel_NN would_MD have_HV been_BEN written_VBN by_IN hand_NN in_IN D01 111 individual_JJ letters_NNS ;_; block_NN D01 112 capitals_NNS are_BER the_ATI nearest_JJT equivalent_NN today_NR ._. ^ D01 112 there_EX would_MD be_BE no_ATI spaces_NNS D01 113 between_IN words_NNS such_CS as_CS" we_PP1AS are_BER accustomed_VBN D01 113 to_TO see_VB and_CC punctuation_NN would_MD D01 114 be_BE kept_VBN to_IN a_AT minimum_NN ._. ^ the_ATI comma_NN ,_, the_ATI D01 114 full_JJ stop_NN ,_, the_ATI colon_NN ,_, and_CC the_ATI D01 115 interrogation_NN mark_NN are_BER all_ABN modern_JJ additions_NNS to_IN D01 115 the_ATI text_NN ._. ^ the_ATI chapter_NN D01 116 and_CC verse_NN divisions_NNS of_IN both_ABX old_JJ and_CC new_JJ D01 116 testaments_NNS date_VB from_IN the_ATI D01 117 reformation_NN ._. ^ the_ATI chapters_NNS were_BED marked_VBN by_IN D01 117 Stephen_NP Langton_NP ,_, an_AT D01 118 Archbishop_NPT of_IN Canterbury_NP ,_, and_CC the_ATI verses_NNS by_IN D01 118 the_ATI Parisian_JNP printer_NN D01 119 Stephanus_NP ,_, who_WPR produced_VBD the_ATI 1546_CD printed_JJ D01 119 edition_NN of_IN the_ATI new_JJ testament_NN D01 120 in_IN Greek_NNP ._. D01 121 ^ the_ATI only_AP punctuation_NN which_WDTR the_ATI originals_NNS D01 121 might_MD have_HV had_HVN is_BEZ D01 122 paragraphos_&FW markings_NNS ._. ^ the_ATI end_NN of_IN a_AT section_NN D01 122 of_IN the_ATI text_NN was_BEDZ D01 123 indicated_VBN by_IN a_AT little_JJ bar_NN drawn_VBN under_IN the_ATI D01 123 first_OD two_CD or_CC three_CD letters_NNS D01 124 of_IN the_ATI line_NN at_IN which_WDTR the_ATI section_NN finished_VBD D01 124 ._. ^ the_ATI bar_NN was_BEDZ the_ATI commonest_JJT D01 125 marking_NN ,_, but_CC others_APS were_BED also_RB used_VBN ._. ^ D01 125 dots_NNS sometimes_RB served_VBD in_IN place_NN of_IN D01 126 the_ATI bar_NN ,_, and_CC there_EX are_BER cases_NNS where_WRB D01 126 spacing_NN is_BEZ used_VBN as_CS it_PP3 is_BEZ now_RN used_VBN D01 127 to_TO mark_VB a_AT paragraph_NN ending_NN ._. D01 128 ^ frequently_RB paragraphos_&FW markings_NNS were_BED omitted_VBN D01 128 ._. ^ \0C_NP \0H_NP D01 129 Roberts_NP is_BEZ of_IN the_ATI opinion_NN that_CS in_IN the_ATI D01 129 original_NN of_IN the_ATI fourth_OD gospel_NN D01 130 some_DTI markings_NNS would_MD be_BE used_VBN ,_, although_CS D01 130 which_WDT ,_, it_PP3 is_BEZ impossible_JJ to_TO say_VB ._. D01 131 ^ Professor_NPT \0E_NP \0G_NP Turner_NP is_BEZ inclined_VBN to_TO D01 131 take_VB the_ATI view_NN that_CS the_ATI D01 132 original_NN of_IN the_ATI gospel_NN would_MD be_BE unmarked_JJ ._. D01 133 ^ the_ATI original_NN of_IN the_ATI gospel_NN ,_, whether_CS D01 133 written_VBN on_IN a_AT roll_NN or_CC codex_NN ,_, D01 134 whether_CS paragraphed_VBN or_CC not_XNOT ,_, would_MD be_BE laid_VBN D01 134 out_RP in_IN columns_NNS ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ the_ATI D01 135 invariable_JJ practice_NN of_IN ancient_JJ manuscripts_NNS ._. ^ a_AT D01 135 common_JJ size_NN of_IN column_NN D01 136 would_MD hold_VB about_RB one_CD1 third_NN of_IN a_AT page_NN of_IN D01 136 Souter's_NP$ print_NN ._. ^ the_ATI writing_NN D01 137 instrument_NN was_BEDZ a_AT stylus_NN ,_, a_AT wedge-shaped_JJ pen_NN D01 137 cut_VBN from_IN a_AT reed_NN ._. ^ the_ATI ink_NN D01 138 was_BEDZ a_AT mixture_NN of_IN carbon_NN black_NN in_IN water_NN D01 138 with_IN gum_NN Arabic_JNP as_IN a_AT solvent_NN ._. D01 139 ^ the_ATI *'_*' paper_NN **'_**' would_MD be_BE papyrus_NN or_CC D01 139 parchment_NN ,_, and_CC the_ATI form_NN of_IN the_ATI D01 140 book_NN a_AT roll_NN or_CC codex_NN ._. D01 141 ^ if_CS ,_, twenty_CD years_NNS ago_RB ,_, one_CD1 had_HVD asked_VBN D01 141 a_AT scholar_NN what_WDT form_NN the_ATI D01 142 original_NN of_IN the_ATI gospel_NN would_MD have_HV taken_VBN ,_, D01 142 he_PP3A would_MD have_HV answered_VBN ,_, D01 143 without_IN hesitation_NN ,_, that_CS the_ATI book_NN would_MD have_HV D01 143 been_BEN a_AT papyrus_NN roll_NN ._. ^ the_ATI D01 144 reason_NN why_WRB he_PP3A would_MD have_HV been_BEN so_QL confident_JJ D01 144 is_BEZ ,_, simply_RB ,_, that_CS the_ATI great_JJ D01 145 majority_NN of_IN surviving_JJ classical_JJ manuscripts_NNS are_BER D01 145 on_IN papyrus_NN rolls_NNS ._. ^ to_TO D01 146 make_VB a_AT book_NN of_IN this_DT kind_NN ,_, sheets_NNS of_IN D01 146 papyrus_NN were_BED glued_VBN edge_NN to_IN edge_NN D01 147 until_CS a_AT single_JJ sheet_NN ,_, often_RB twenty_CD to_IN D01 147 twenty-five_CD feet_NNS wide_JJ ,_, had_HVD been_BEN D01 148 made_VBN ._. ^ the_ATI edge_NN of_IN this_DT sheet_NN was_BEDZ D01 148 attached_VBN to_IN a_AT wooden_JJ dowel_NN and_CC the_ATI D01 149 sheet_NN wound_VBN round_IN this_DT central_JJ pin_NN ._. ^ the_ATI D01 149 roll_NN made_VBD a_AT simple_JJ and_CC D01 150 serviceable_JJ book_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 was_BEDZ robust_JJ *-_*- the_ATI D01 150 number_NN which_WDTR have_HV survived_VBN the_ATI D01 151 centuries_NNS is_BEZ ample_JJ evidence_NN of_IN this_DT *-_*- and_CC D01 151 it_PP3 was_BEDZ easily_RB stored_VBN ._. ^ it_PP3 D01 152 had_HVD two_CD disadvantages_NNS ._. ^ it_PP3 was_BEDZ generally_RB D01 152 a_AT single-sided_JJ form_NN of_IN book_NN ,_, D01 153 and_CC it_PP3 was_BEDZ not_XNOT an_AT easy_JJ form_NN of_IN book_NN D01 153 in_IN which_WDTR to_TO find_VB a_AT reference_NN ._. D01 154 ^ this_DT last_AP objection_NN might_MD have_HV had_HVN some_DTI D01 154 weight_NN in_IN ecclesiastical_JJ D01 155 circles_NNS ._. ^ in_IN his_PP$ natural_JJ history_NN ,_, 13_CD ._. D01 155 11-12_CD-CD ,_, the_ATI elder_JJR Pliny_NP D01 156 tells_VBZ of_IN the_ATI use_NN of_IN papyrus_NN in_IN roll-making_NN D01 156 ._. ^ as_CS Pliny_NP was_BEDZ killed_VBN in_IN D01 157 the_ATI eruption_NN of_IN Vesuvius_NP which_WDTR overwhelmed_VBD D01 157 Herculaneum_NP and_CC Pompeii_NP in_IN D01 158 \0A.D_RB 79_CD ,_, his_PP$ information_NN is_BEZ contemporaneous_JJ D01 158 with_IN the_ATI new_JJ D01 159 testament_NN ._. D01 160 ^ the_ATI other_AP form_NN of_IN book_NN was_BEDZ the_ATI codex_NN D01 160 ._. ^ in_IN this_DT the_ATI sheets_NNS were_BED D01 161 bound_VBN together_RB down_IN one_CD1 edge_NN much_RB as_CS they_PP3AS D01 161 are_BER in_IN modern_JJ books_NNS ._. D01 162 ^ normally_RB the_ATI sheets_NNS were_BED bound_VBN in_IN groups_NNS D01 162 ,_, called_VBN quires_NNS ,_, and_CC the_ATI D01 163 quires_NNS were_BED stitched_VBN together_RB to_TO make_VB a_AT book_NN D01 163 ._. ^ a_AT common_JJ size_NN of_IN D01 164 papyrus_NN codex_NN page_NN is_BEZ ten_CD inches_NNS by_IN eight_CD D01 164 inches_NNS ,_, the_ATI size_NN of_IN quarto_NN D01 165 paper_NN today_NR ,_, and_CC one_CD1 hundred_CD sheets_NNS make_VB a_AT D01 165 large_JJ book_NN ._. ^ there_EX are_BER D01 166 great_JJ variations_NNS in_IN the_ATI codex_NN form_NN ;_; some_DTI D01 166 have_HV single-sheet_JJB quires_NNS ,_, but_CC D01 167 most_AP have_HV multi-sheet_JJB quires_NNS ._. ^ some_DTI codices_NNS D01 167 were_BED made_VBN up_RP of_IN double_JJ D01 168 sheets_NNS folded_VBN and_CC stitched_VBN through_IN the_ATI fold_NN D01 168 ._. ^ the_ATI difference_NN between_IN D01 169 the_ATI codex_NN and_CC the_ATI roll_NN is_BEZ always_RB clear_JJ ._. ^ D01 169 compared_VBN to_IN the_ATI roll_NN the_ATI D01 170 codex_NN was_BEDZ more_QL economical_JJ ;_; it_PP3 was_BEDZ D01 170 generally_RB written_VBN on_IN both_ABX sides_NNS ;_; and_CC D01 171 it_PP3 was_BEDZ a_AT much_RB easier_JJR book_NN in_IN which_WDTR to_TO D01 171 find_VB a_AT textual_JJ reference_NN ._. D01 172 ^ against_IN these_DTS advantages_NNS the_ATI codex_NN was_BEDZ D01 172 fragile_JJ and_CC might_MD be_BE bulky_JJ ._. D01 173 ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ sometimes_RB possible_JJ to_TO tell_VB whether_CS D01 173 or_CC not_XNOT a_AT particular_JJ text_NN D01 174 was_BEDZ written_VBN on_IN a_AT roll_NN or_CC a_AT codex_NN ._. ^ D01 174 rolls_NNS were_BED prepared_VBN for_IN writing_NN ,_, D01 175 but_CC any_DTI papyrus_NN left_VBN unused_JJ at_IN the_ATI end_NN D01 175 could_MD be_BE cut_VBN off_RP ._. ^ if_CS the_ATI text_NN D01 176 was_BEDZ longer_JJR than_IN the_ATI roll_NN ,_, a_AT sheet_NN could_MD D01 176 easily_RB be_BE glued_VBN on_RP ._. ^ the_ATI verso_NN D01 177 of_IN the_ATI roll_NN was_BEDZ blank_JJ ,_, and_CC one_CD1 can_MD D01 177 not_XNOT think_VB of_IN an_AT author_NN ,_, Mark_NP for_IN D01 178 example_NN ,_, sending_VBG out_RP his_PP$ gospel_NN lacking_VBG the_ATI D01 178 ending_NN ,_, while_CS one_CD1 whole_JJ D01 179 side_NN of_IN his_PP$ roll_NN was_BEDZ unused_JJ ._. D01 180 ^ the_ATI codex_NN form_NN was_BEDZ not_XNOT so_QL accommodating_JJ D01 180 ._. ^ even_RB in_IN the_ATI case_NN of_IN the_ATI D01 181 single-sheet_JJB quire_NN ,_, an_AT extra_JJ sheet_NN glued_VBN on_RP D01 181 might_MD have_HV to_TO be_BE gummed_VBN on_RP D01 182 over_IN the_ATI binding_NN ,_, or_CC the_ATI whole_JJ codex_NN D01 182 rebound_VBN ._. D02 2 ^ 10_CD ._. D02 3 ^ worship_NN and_CC praise_NN ._. D02 4 ^ architecture_NN ._. D02 5 ^ the_ATI history_NN of_IN congregational_JJ worship_NN and_CC of_IN D02 5 its_PP$ habits_NNS of_IN D02 6 praise_NN is_BEZ a_AT complex_JJ study_NN for_IN which_WDTR many_AP D02 6 more_AP pages_NNS would_MD be_BE required_VBN D02 7 than_CS we_PP1AS have_HV here_RN at_IN our_PP$ disposal_NN ._. ^ a_AT D02 7 simple_JJ but_CC serviceable_JJ way_NN of_IN D02 8 presenting_VBG its_PP$ development_NN is_BEZ to_TO invite_VB the_ATI D02 8 reader_NN to_TO consider_VB three_CD D02 9 images_NNS :_: that_DT of_IN a_AT seventeenth-century_JJB D02 9 meeting-house_NN ,_, that_DT of_IN a_AT D02 10 nineteenth-century_JJB urban_JJ church_NN ,_, and_CC that_DT of_IN a_AT D02 10 church_NN built_VBN during_IN the_ATI D02 11 middle_JJB decades_NNS of_IN the_ATI twentieth_OD century_NN ._. ^ D02 11 consider_VB ,_, for_IN example_NN ,_, the_ATI D02 12 meeting-house_NN at_IN Old_NP Meeting_NP ,_, Norwich_NP ,_, or_CC D02 12 Swanland_NP ,_, east_NR Yorkshire_NP ,_, or_CC D02 13 Tadley_NP ,_, \0Hants_NP ;_; or_CC any_DTI of_IN those_DTS whose_WP$R D02 13 appearance_NN is_BEZ preserved_VBN only_RB in_IN D02 14 faded_JJ prints_NNS in_IN the_ATI vestries_NNS of_IN more_QL modern_JJ D02 14 churches_NNS ;_; then_RN consider_VB D02 15 union_NN Church_NPL ,_, Brighton_NP ,_, or_CC Elgin_NP Place_NPL ,_, D02 15 Glasgow_NP ,_, or_CC Westminster_NP D02 16 Chapel_NPL ,_, London_NP ,_, or_CC Richmond_NP Hill_NPL ,_, D02 16 Bournemouth_NP ;_; then_RN thirdly_RB ,_, consider_VB D02 17 the_ATI new_JJ churches_NNS at_IN Banstead_NP ,_, Surrey_NP ,_, D02 17 pilgrim_NN Church_NPL at_IN Plymouth_NP ,_, or_CC D02 18 (_( on_IN a_AT larger_JJR scale_NN )_) Southernhay_NP ,_, Exeter_NP ,_, D02 18 or_CC Eltham_NP ,_, Kent_NP ,_, or_CC D02 19 Leatherhead_NP ,_, Surrey_NP ._. D02 20 ^ whatever_WDT particular_JJ churches_NNS the_ATI reader_NN D02 20 holds_NNS in_IN his_PP$ imagination_NN ,_, D02 21 the_ATI conclusion_NN he_PP3A will_MD surely_RB draw_VB is_BEZ that_CS D02 21 congregational_JJ worship_NN can_MD D02 22 be_BE expressed_VBN in_IN the_ATI progression_NN through_IN three_CD D02 22 phases_NNS *-_*- family_NN ,_, D02 23 audience_NN and_CC community_NN ._. ^ in_IN any_DTI given_JJ place_NN D02 23 the_ATI emphasis_NN may_MD be_BE on_IN any_DTI D02 24 one_CD1 of_IN these_DTS phases_NNS :_: in_IN any_DTI given_JJ D02 24 building_NN you_PP2 may_MD well_RB find_VB a_AT blend_NN D02 25 of_IN two_CD or_CC all_ABN of_IN them_PP3OS ,_, or_CC a_AT kind_NN D02 25 of_IN halted_JJ transition_NN from_IN one_CD1 to_IN D02 26 another_DT ._. ^ but_CC very_QL broadly_RB it_PP3 can_MD be_BE said_VBN D02 26 that_CS the_ATI period_NN from_IN the_ATI D02 27 beginning_NN to_IN 1750_CD is_BEZ the_ATI *'_*' family_NN **'_**' D02 27 period_NN :_: that_DT from_IN 1750_CD to_IN 1900_CD ,_, D02 28 the_ATI *'_*' audience_NN **'_**' period_NN ;_; and_CC that_DT from_IN D02 28 1900_CD to_IN the_ATI present_NN ,_, the_ATI D02 29 *'_*' community_NN **'_**' period_NN ._. ^ to_TO paraphrase_VB D02 29 these_DTS categories_NNS :_: congregational_JJ D02 30 worship_NN comformable_JJ with_IN the_ATI Savoy_NP declaration_NN D02 30 and_CC the_ATI D02 31 principles_NNS of_IN classic_JJ congregationalism_NN is_BEZ family_NN D02 31 prayers_NNS :_: that_DT D02 32 comformable_JJ with_IN the_ATI evangelical_JJ revival_NN and_CC the_ATI D02 32 new_JJ D02 33 conurbations_NNS of_IN industrial_JJ society_NN is_BEZ oratory_NN :_: D02 33 and_CC that_DT comformable_JJ D02 34 with_IN modern_JJ socialism_NN (_( I_PP1A use_VB the_ATI word_NN D02 34 somewhat_RB liberally_RB )_) is_BEZ D02 35 community_NN ._. D02 36 ^ your_PP$ meeting-house_NN has_HVZ the_ATI aspect_NN of_IN a_AT D02 36 dwelling-house_NN ,_, and_CC its_PP$ D02 37 architecture_NN is_BEZ domestic_JJ in_IN the_ATI Georgian_JNP style_NN D02 37 :_: it_PP3 has_HVZ large_JJ square_JJ D02 38 windows_NNS which_WDTR are_BER later_RBR diversified_VBN by_IN that_DT D02 38 very_QL characteristic_JJ design_NN D02 39 of_IN a_AT rectangle_NN surmounted_VBN by_IN a_AT semi-circle_NN D02 39 which_WDTR the_ATI later_JJR D02 40 meeting-house_NN made_VBN into_IN its_PP$ own_AP kind_NN of_IN D02 40 ecclesiastical_JJ architecture_NN ._. D02 41 ^ within_RI ,_, the_ATI pulpit_NN and_CC table_NN are_BER usually_RB D02 41 in_IN the_ATI centre_NN of_IN the_ATI longer_JJR D02 42 side_NN of_IN the_ATI rectangle_NN ,_, and_CC nobody_PN sits_VBZ far_RB D02 42 from_IN the_ATI minister_NN ._. ^ within_RI D02 43 and_CC without_RI the_ATI emphasis_NN is_BEZ on_IN utility_NN and_CC D02 43 not_XNOT on_IN ceremony_NN ._. ^ the_ATI pews_NNS D02 44 are_BER fairly_RB closely_RB packed_VBN ,_, and_CC the_ATI best_JJT D02 44 use_NN is_BEZ made_VBN of_IN a_AT fairly_RB D02 45 restricted_JJ space_NN ._. ^ a_AT gallery_NN quite_RB often_RB is_BEZ D02 45 added_VBN to_TO make_VB use_NN of_IN space_NN D02 46 vertically_RB as_CC well_CC" as_CC" horizontally_RB ._. ^ the_ATI D02 46 technique_NN of_IN speech_NN D02 47 appropriate_JJ to_IN such_ABL a_AT building_NN does_DOZ not_XNOT D02 47 demand_VB a_AT high_JJ pitch_NN of_IN voice_NN ;_; D02 48 reasonably_RB careful_JJ enunciation_NN and_CC a_AT moderate_JJ D02 48 voice_NN are_BER all_ABN that_WPR are_BER D02 49 needed_VBN ,_, and_CC the_ATI very_QL long_JJ discourses_NNS which_WDTR D02 49 were_BED beloved_JJ of_IN classic_JJ D02 50 dissenters_NNS could_MD be_BE delivered_VBN ,_, and_CC presumably_RB D02 50 listened_VBN to_IN ,_, in_IN D02 51 tolerable_JJ comfort_NN ._. D02 52 ^ the_ATI contrast_NN between_IN this_DT kind_NN of_IN building_NN D02 52 and_CC the_ATI older_JJR of_IN those_DTS D02 53 buildings_NNS which_WDTR are_BER now_RN mostly_RB in_IN use_NN by_IN D02 53 congregationalists_NNS is_BEZ D02 54 enormous_JJ ._. ^ very_QL often_RB ,_, as_CS the_ATI faded_JJ vestry_NN D02 54 prints_NNS testify_VB ,_, a_AT meeting_NN D02 55 house_NN was_BEDZ demolished_VBN in_IN the_ATI nineteenth_OD century_NN D02 55 to_TO make_VB way_NN for_IN a_AT D02 56 larger_JJR church_NN ._. ^ now_RN it_PP3 is_BEZ always_RB assumed_VBN D02 56 that_CS this_DT larger_JJR church_NN was_BEDZ D02 57 built_VBN in_TO order_TO" to_TO" accommodate_VB a_AT larger_JJR D02 57 congregation_NN ,_, or_CC to_TO minister_VB to_IN D02 58 a_AT rapidly_RB growing_JJ district_NN ._. ^ that_DT is_BEZ only_RB D02 58 a_AT part_NN of_IN the_ATI truth_NN ,_, because_CS D02 59 it_PP3 must_MD be_BE noted_VBN that_CS the_ATI larger_JJR church_NN D02 59 was_BEDZ never_RB built_VBN in_IN imitation_NN D02 60 of_IN the_ATI style_NN of_IN the_ATI earlier_JJR one_CD1 ._. ^ in_IN D02 60 your_PP$ new_JJ church_NN you_PP2 placed_VBD the_ATI D02 61 pulpit_NN centrally_RB ,_, but_CC at_IN the_ATI end_NN of_IN the_ATI D02 61 church_NN ;_; the_ATI congregation_NN now_RN D02 62 faced_VBD down_IN the_ATI rectangle's_NN$ longer_JJR dimension_NN ,_, D02 62 and_CC from_IN an_AT appreciable_JJ D02 63 number_NN of_IN its_PP$ members_NNS the_ATI preacher_NN was_BEDZ D02 63 remote_JJ ._. ^ were_BED practical_JJ D02 64 necessities_NNS the_ATI only_AP consideration_NN ,_, a_AT larger_JJR D02 64 meeting-house_NN of_IN the_ATI same_AP D02 65 proportions_NNS would_MD have_HV met_VBN the_ATI need_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 D02 65 was_BEDZ never_RB in_IN fact_NN constructed_VBN D02 66 so_RB ._. D02 67 ^ what_WDT mattered_VBD to_IN the_ATI nineteenth-century_JJB D02 67 congregationalists_NNS was_BEDZ D02 68 that_CS they_PP3AS must_MD needs_RB express_VB the_ATI spirit_NN of_IN D02 68 success_NN and_CC enterprise_NN D02 69 which_WDTR the_ATI evangelical_JJ revival_NN ,_, the_ATI missionary_JJ D02 69 movement_NN ,_, and_CC the_ATI D02 70 possibilities_NNS of_IN reaching_VBG much_RB larger_JJR numbers_NNS D02 70 of_IN people_NNS locally_RB had_HVD D02 71 kindled_VBN in_IN them_PP3OS ._. ^ therefore_RB their_PP$ buildings_NNS D02 71 were_BED not_XNOT only_RB larger_JJR but_CC D02 72 more_QL eloquent_JJ :_: towers_NNS or_CC spires_NNS suggested_VBD D02 72 aspiration_NN and_CC domination_NN D02 73 over_IN surrounding_VBG buildings_NNS ;_; gothic_JJ arches_NNS in_IN D02 73 doors_NNS and_CC windows_NNS D02 74 suggested_VBD their_PP$ conviction_NN that_CS a_AT meeting_NN house_NN D02 74 must_MD *'_*' look_VB like_IN a_AT D02 75 church_NN **'_**' ._. ^ and_CC that_DT tradition_NN of_IN D02 75 large-scale_JJB evangelistic_JJ preaching_NN D02 76 which_WDTR was_BEDZ already_RB well_RB established_VBN by_IN 1850_CD D02 76 (_( which_WDTR was_BEDZ the_ATI first_OD year_NN D02 77 of_IN a_AT peak-decade_NN in_IN congregational_JJ church_NN building_NN D02 77 )_) made_VBD the_ATI idea_NN of_IN D02 78 meeting-house_NN intimacy_NN give_VB way_NN in_IN the_ATI minds_NNS D02 78 of_IN the_ATI designers_NNS to_IN that_DT D02 79 of_IN weighty_JJ and_CC rhetorical_JJ preaching_NN ,_, with_IN a_AT D02 79 certain_JJ amount_NN of_IN D02 80 attendant_JJ ceremony_NN ._. ^ nineteenth-century_JJB congregational_JJ D02 80 churches_NNS are_BER in_IN D02 81 themselves_PPLS ceremonious_JJ buildings_NNS ._. ^ the_ATI space_NN D02 81 is_BEZ still_RB used_VBN with_IN D02 82 puritan_JJ thrift_NN ,_, and_CC large_JJ congregations_NNS can_MD be_BE D02 82 packed_VBN into_IN the_ATI pews_NNS ._. D02 83 ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ still_RB assumed_VBN that_CS the_ATI proper_JJ D02 83 postures_NNS for_IN a_AT congregation_NN at_IN D02 84 worship_NN are_BER either_DTX standing_NN or_CC sitting_VBG ;_; room_NN D02 84 need_MD not_XNOT be_BE left_VBN to_TO D02 85 accommodate_VB the_ATI kneeling_NN posture_NN for_IN prayer_NN ._. ^ D02 85 but_CC from_IN outside_IN the_ATI D02 86 church_NN *'_*' looks_VBZ like_IN a_AT church_NN **'_**' ,_, and_CC D02 86 from_IN within_RI ,_, with_IN its_PP$ large_JJ D02 87 pulpit_NN or_CC even_RB rostrum_NN in_IN the_ATI centre_NN ,_, and_CC D02 87 its_PP$ table_NN dwarfed_VBN by_IN the_ATI D02 88 enlarged_JJ building_NN and_CC by_IN the_ATI enlarged_JJ pulpit_NN ,_, D02 88 it_PP3 proclaims_VBZ the_ATI primacy_NN D02 89 of_IN the_ATI preached_JJ word_NN ._. ^ the_ATI fact_NN that_CS D02 89 about_IN the_ATI middle_NN of_IN the_ATI D02 90 nineteenth_OD century_NN the_ATI fashion_NN for_IN large_JJ church_NN D02 90 organs_NNS in_IN Britain_NP was_BEDZ D02 91 just_RB beginning_VBG (_( the_ATI great_JJ exhibition_NN of_IN 1851_CD D02 91 had_HVD a_AT good_JJ deal_NN to_TO do_DO D02 92 with_IN that_DT )_) brought_VBD about_RP the_ATI familiar_JJ and_CC D02 92 somewhat_RB aesthetically_RB D02 93 distressing_JJ adornment_NN that_WPR is_BEZ now_RN almost_RB D02 93 inseparable_JJ from_IN buildings_NNS of_IN D02 94 this_DT kind_NN *-_*- the_ATI pattern_NN of_IN organ-pipes_NNS D02 94 behind_IN the_ATI pulpit_NN and_CC directly_RB D02 95 in_IN the_ATI focus_NN of_IN the_ATI congregation's_NN$ visual_JJ D02 95 attention_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 has_HVZ to_TO be_BE D02 96 said_VBN that_CS while_CS this_DT was_BEDZ ,_, to_IN the_ATI eye_NN ,_, D02 96 most_QL offensive_JJ ,_, the_ATI organ_NN D02 97 builder_NN usually_RB found_VBD that_CS in_IN a_AT dissenting_JJ D02 97 church_NN his_PP$ instrument_NN had_HVD D02 98 far_RB better_RBR *'_*' speaking_NN space_NN **'_**' ,_, and_CC D02 98 was_BEDZ consequently_RB heard_VBN to_IN better_JJR D02 99 advantage_NN ,_, than_CS when_WRB it_PP3 was_BEDZ tucked_VBN into_IN D02 99 a_AT transept_NN in_IN some_DTI ancient_JJ D02 100 parish_NN church_NN ._. D02 101 ^ the_ATI modern_JJ congregational_JJ church_NN differs_VBZ as_QL D02 101 widely_RB from_IN that_DT of_IN D02 102 1850_CD as_CS does_DOZ the_ATI middle-period_JJB one_CD1 from_IN D02 102 the_ATI meeting_NN house_NN ._. ^ the_ATI D02 103 reasons_NNS are_BER quite_RB simple_JJ ._. ^ in_IN modern_JJ times_NNS D02 103 the_ATI social_JJ activities_NNS of_IN D02 104 the_ATI church_NN take_VB a_AT more_QL significant_JJ share_NN in_IN D02 104 the_ATI church's_NN$ and_CC D02 105 minister's_NN$ time_NN than_CS they_PP3AS formerly_RB did_DOD ,_, D02 105 and_CC must_MD therefore_RB be_BE allotted_VBN D02 106 a_AT more_QL significant_JJ share_NN of_IN the_ATI church's_NN$ D02 106 space_NN ._. ^ in_IN your_PP$ 1850_CD church_NN D02 107 you_PP2 not_XNOT infrequently_RB find_VB *-_*- especially_RB in_IN D02 107 the_ATI north_NR of_IN England_NP *-_*- a_AT D02 108 dramatic_JJ contrast_NN between_IN the_ATI sumptuous_JJ D02 108 appointments_NNS of_IN the_ATI building_NN D02 109 itself_PPL (_( and_CC not_XNOT infrequently_RB ,_, of_IN the_ATI D02 109 minister's_NN$ vestry_NN )_) ,_, and_CC the_ATI D02 110 inhuman_JJ barrack-like_JJ living_NN conditions_NNS in_IN the_ATI *'_*' D02 110 church_NN rooms_NNS **'_**' ._. D02 111 ^ these_DTS are_BER sometimes_RB actually_RB placed_VBN underneath_IN D02 111 the_ATI church_NN building_NN :_: D02 112 if_CS not_XNOT there_RN ,_, they_PP3AS are_BER huddled_VBN behind_RP D02 112 or_CC alongside_RI in_IN an_AT apologetic_JJ D02 113 heap_NN ._. ^ by_IN contrast_NN ,_, your_PP$ full-scale_JJB church_NN D02 113 *'_*' plant_NN **'_**' of_IN today_NR makes_VBZ D02 114 the_ATI sanctuary_NN only_RB the_ATI centre-piece_NN of_IN a_AT D02 114 systematic_JJ group_NN of_IN D02 115 buildings_NNS ._. ^ in_IN consequence_NN of_IN this_DT *-_*- and_CC D02 115 not_XNOT only_RB because_CS funds_NNS are_BER D02 116 too_QL scarce_JJ to_TO permit_VB pretentious_JJ architecture_NN *-_*- D02 116 your_PP$ modern_JJ D02 117 congregational_JJ church_NN is_BEZ much_RB more_QL modest_JJ in_IN D02 117 its_PP$ outward_JJB deportment_NN D02 118 than_CS was_BEDZ that_DT of_IN your_PP$ great-grandfather_NN ._. ^ D02 118 but_CC along_IN with_IN" it_PP3 are_BER many_AP D02 119 buildings_NNS whose_WP$R social_JJ significance_NN is_BEZ D02 119 unmistakable_JJ ._. ^ too_QL seldom_RB is_BEZ it_PP3 D02 120 possible_JJ to_TO erect_VB a_AT complete_JJ system_NN of_IN D02 120 buildings_NNS :_: but_CC in_IN such_ABL cases_NNS it_PP3 D02 121 is_BEZ always_RB urged_VBN on_IN the_ATI architect_NN that_CS D02 121 provision_NN must_MD be_BE made_VBN for_IN D02 122 social_JJ activities_NNS ,_, youth_NN clubs_NNS ,_, departmental_JJ D02 122 children's_NNS$ worship_NN ,_, D02 123 week-night_JJB meetings_NNS ,_, and_RB so_RB" forth_RB" :_: and_CC D02 123 when_WRB nothing_PN better_JJR can_MD be_BE D02 124 achieved_VBN ,_, the_ATI new_JJ church_NN becomes_VBZ a_AT D02 124 dual-purpose_JJB building_NN ,_, D02 125 accommodating_VBG the_ATI ancillary_JJ activities_NNS under_IN the_ATI D02 125 same_AP roof_NN ,_, or_CC in_IN D02 126 extreme_JJ cases_NNS in_IN the_ATI same_AP room_NN ,_, as_IN the_ATI D02 126 public_JJ worship_NN ._. D02 127 ^ one_CD1 thing_NN ,_, however_RB ,_, all_ABN modern_JJ *'_*' D02 127 sanctuaries_NNS **'_**' have_HV in_RB common_RB" ._. D02 128 ^ there_EX is_BEZ not_XNOT ,_, as_CS there_EX was_BEDZ in_IN the_ATI D02 128 Victorian_JNP church_NN ,_, any_DTI attempt_NN to_TO D02 129 provide_VB seating_NN for_IN a_AT large_JJ crowd_NN of_IN D02 129 worshippers_NNS ._. ^ not_XNOT only_RB is_BEZ the_ATI D02 130 building_NN fairly_RB small_JJ :_: its_PP$ floor-space_NN is_BEZ D02 130 not_XNOT used_VBN up_RP to_IN anything_PN like_IN D02 131 the_ATI same_AP extent_NN ._. ^ the_ATI restful_JJ effect_NN of_IN D02 131 bare_JJ space_NN ,_, especially_RB at_IN the_ATI D02 132 front_NN of_IN the_ATI church_NN ,_, has_HVZ now_RN been_BEN D02 132 recognized_VBN and_CC admitted_VBN ._. ^ chairs_NNS ,_, D02 133 symbols_NNS of_IN congregational_JJ adaptability_NN ,_, have_HV D02 133 replaced_VBN in_IN many_AP places_NNS D02 134 the_ATI solid_JJ and_CC immovable_JJ pews_NNS ,_, which_WDTR are_BER D02 134 equally_RB symbols_NNS of_IN the_ATI local_JJ D02 135 rootedness_NN of_IN classic_JJ and_CC late-puritan_JJB D02 135 congregationalism_NN ._. ^ a_AT central_JJ D02 136 aisle_NN often_RB enhances_VBZ the_ATI impression_NN of_IN D02 136 spaciousness_NN ,_, and_CC the_ATI new_JJ D02 137 ceremonious_JJ regard_NN for_IN the_ATI communion_NN table_NN ,_, D02 137 brought_VBN by_IN the_ATI D02 138 contemporary_JJ sacramental_JJ revival_NN ,_, has_HVZ usually_RB D02 138 caused_VBN the_ATI removal_NN of_IN D02 139 the_ATI pulpit_NN to_IN the_ATI side_NN of_IN the_ATI church_NN ._. ^ D02 139 the_ATI *'_*' long_JJ **'_**' rather_RB than_IN the_ATI D02 140 *'_*' square_JJ **'_**' shape_NN is_BEZ still_RB usually_RB D02 140 preferred_VBN ,_, and_CC there_EX is_BEZ plenty_NN of_IN D02 141 evidence_NN still_RB of_IN that_DT half-sentimental_JJ aping_NN of_IN D02 141 the_ATI establishment_NN D02 142 which_WDTR caused_VBD so_QL much_AP confusion_NN in_IN the_ATI D02 142 architecture_NN of_IN the_ATI larger_JJR D02 143 churches_NNS of_IN the_ATI period_NN 1900-30_CD-CD ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ D02 143 too_QL much_AP to_TO say_VB that_CS now_RN a_AT new_JJ D02 144 sense_NN of_IN beauty_NN has_HVZ overtaken_VBN our_PP$ D02 144 congregations_NNS :_: but_CC the_ATI positive_JJ gain_NN D02 145 is_BEZ in_IN a_AT modesty_NN and_CC simplicity_NN of_IN demeanour_NN D02 145 which_WDTR deny_VB directly_RB the_ATI D02 146 chief_JJB vice_NN of_IN Victorianism_NNP ,_, which_WDTR was_BEDZ D02 146 not_XNOT so_QL much_RB ugliness_NN as_IN D02 147 pretentiousness_NN ._. D02 148 ^ there_EX are_BER ,_, of_RB course_RB" ,_, many_AP existing_JJ D02 148 examples_NNS of_IN churches_NNS which_WDTR D02 149 hardly_RB fall_VB tidily_RB within_IN any_DTI of_IN these_DTS three_CD D02 149 categories_NNS ._. ^ Carrs_NP Lane_NPL ,_, D02 150 Birmingham_NP ,_, for_IN example_NN ,_, though_CS of_IN massive_JJ D02 150 size_NN and_CC accommodation_NN ,_, D02 151 retains_VBZ a_AT fairly_RB *'_*' square_JJ **'_**' ground_NN plan_NN D02 151 and_CC an_AT austere_JJ un-spired_JJ D02 152 exterior_NN ._. ^ \0St_NPT James's_NP$ ,_, Newcastle_NP ,_, another_DT D02 152 famous_JJ *'_*' down-town_JJB D02 153 **'_**' church_NN ,_, combines_VBZ a_AT fairly_RB square_JJ plan_NN D02 153 with_IN an_AT unusual_JJ sense_NN of_IN dignity_NN D02 154 and_CC ceremony_NN imparted_VBN by_IN the_ATI use_NN of_IN fairly_RB D02 154 massive_JJ pillars_NNS and_CC an_AT D02 155 imaginative_JJ dispersal_NN of_IN the_ATI pews_NNS radially_RB from_IN D02 155 the_ATI central_JJ focus_NN of_IN D02 156 the_ATI pulpit_NN ._. ^ the_ATI oval_JJ experiment_NN at_IN D02 156 Wellingborough_NP ,_, though_CS over-large_JJ ,_, D02 157 was_BEDZ clearly_RB an_AT attempt_NN to_TO reproduce_VB on_IN a_AT D02 157 large_JJ scale_NN something_PN of_IN the_ATI D02 158 openness_NN of_IN the_ATI meeting_NN house_NN ._. ^ Bromley_NP ,_, D02 158 Kent_NP ,_, of_RB course_RB" ,_, with_IN its_PP$ D02 159 seven-sided_JJ plan_NN ,_, is_BEZ the_ATI most_QL impressive_JJ of_IN D02 159 all_ABN modern_JJ attempts_NNS to_TO D02 160 recapture_VB the_ATI *'_*' meeting_NN house_NN **'_**' shape_NN and_CC D02 160 integrate_VB it_PP3 with_IN D02 161 progressive_JJ church-thinking_NN ;_; for_CS there_RN the_ATI pulpit_NN D02 161 stands_VBZ on_IN a_AT large_JJ D02 162 platform_NN in_IN the_ATI middle_NN of_IN one_CD1 of_IN the_ATI *'_*' D02 162 long_JJ sides_NNS **'_**' *-_*- which_WDTR is_BEZ itself_PPL D02 163 composed_VBN of_IN three_CD planes_NNS set_VBN at_IN wide_JJ angles_NNS D02 163 to_IN one_PPLS another_PPLS" ,_, while_CS the_ATI D02 164 congregation_NN is_BEZ arranged_VBN to_TO move_VB out_RP from_IN D02 164 the_ATI pulpit_NN towards_IN each_DT of_IN D02 165 the_ATI other_AP four_CD sides_NNS ,_, again_RB arranged_VBN at_IN D02 165 very_QL wide_JJ angles_NNS ._. D02 166 ^ Redland_NP Park_NPL ,_, Bristol_NP ,_, though_CS opened_VBN D02 166 only_RB in_IN 1957_CD ,_, has_HVZ a_AT fairly_RB D02 167 traditional_JJ appearance_NN ,_, being_BEG large_JJ ,_, long_JJ ,_, D02 167 centre-aisled_JJ and_CC D02 168 side-pulpited_JJ but_CC with_IN no_ATI features_NNS especially_RB D02 168 eloquent_JJ of_IN new_JJ trends_NNS ._. D02 169 ^ the_ATI Church_NPL of_IN the_ATI peace_NN of_IN God_NP ,_, Oxted_NP D02 169 (_( 1936_CD )_) ,_, built_VBN to_IN a_AT cross-shaped_JJ D02 170 pattern_NN ,_, could_MD hardly_RB be_BE less_RBR like_IN a_AT D02 170 meeting-house_NN ,_, and_CC is_BEZ very_QL D02 171 ceremonious_JJ in_IN its_PP$ demeanour_NN :_: and_CC its_PP$ *'_*' D02 171 community_NN **'_**' buildings_NNS ,_, such_CS D02 172 as_CS" they_PP3AS are_BER (_( pleasant_JJ but_CC small_JJ )_) D02 172 suggest_VB that_CS the_ATI energetic_JJ community_NN D02 173 life_NN of_IN a_AT new_JJ area_NN is_BEZ hardly_RB looked_VBN for_IN D02 173 ._. ^ indeed_RB ,_, there_EX is_BEZ usually_RB a_AT D02 174 difference_NN between_IN the_ATI new_JJ church_NN built_VBN in_IN a_AT D02 174 new_JJ housing_NN estate_NN and_CC D02 175 the_ATI new_JJ church_NN built_VBN to_TO replace_VB an_AT old_JJ D02 175 one_CD1 on_IN or_CC near_IN the_ATI old_JJ site_NN :_: D02 176 this_DT is_BEZ understandable_JJ and_CC proper_JJ ,_, though_CS D02 176 imagination_NN has_HVZ sometimes_RB D02 177 failed_VBN at_IN crucial_JJ points_NNS either_DTX ,_, as_CS at_IN D02 177 Stowmarket_NP ,_, by_IN interrupting_VBG the_ATI D02 178 domestic_JJ architecture_NN of_IN a_AT pleasant_JJ village_NN street_NN D02 178 by_IN a_AT somewhat_RB D02 179 over-eloquent_JJ modern_JJ elevation_NN ,_, or_CC ,_, as_CS in_IN D02 179 some_DTI extension-experiments_NNS ,_, D02 180 by_IN the_ATI inadequate_JJ provision_NN of_IN ancillary_JJ halls_NNS D02 180 and_CC rooms_NNS or_CC the_ATI D02 181 ill-considered_JJ siting_NN of_IN the_ATI whole_JJ plant_NN ._. D02 182 ^ but_CC the_ATI pattern_NN is_BEZ in_RB general_RB" clear_JJ D02 182 enough_QLP :_: and_CC it_PP3 is_BEZ but_RI one_CD1 D02 183 aspect_NN of_IN a_AT pattern_NN of_IN development_NN that_WPR can_MD D02 183 be_BE seen_VBN in_IN the_ATI habits_NNS of_IN D02 184 worship_NN of_IN the_ATI various_JJ ages_NNS of_IN congregationalism_NN D02 184 ._. D02 185 ^ worship_NN ._. D02 186 ^ in_IN its_PP$ classic_JJ days_NNS there_EX was_BEDZ enough_DTI D02 186 of_IN the_ATI Anabaptist_NNP and_CC D02 187 enough_DTI of_IN the_ATI quaker_NN in_IN most_AP congregationalists_NNS D02 187 to_TO ensure_VB that_CS any_DTI D02 188 kind_NN of_IN fixed_JJ liturgy_NN would_MD be_BE entirely_RB D02 188 unwelcome_JJ ._. ^ when_WRB *'_*' family_NN D02 189 prayers_NNS **'_**' was_BEDZ the_ATI prevailing_JJ ethos_NN ,_, D02 189 worship-books_NNS of_IN any_DTI kind_NN D02 190 were_BED unnecessary_JJ ,_, and_CC would_MD have_HV been_BEN D02 190 thought_VBN an_AT intrusion_NN ._. ^ the_ATI D02 191 piping-hot_JJ devotion_NN of_IN the_ATI Brownists_NNPS needed_VBN D02 191 no_ATI such_ABL things_NNS ;_; nor_CC did_DOD D02 192 the_ATI crisis-outlook_NN of_IN the_ATI persecuted_JJ independents_NNS D02 192 ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ quite_RB D02 193 apart_IN from_IN" the_ATI conviction_NN that_CS worship-books_NNS D02 193 were_BED in_RB general_RB" a_AT popish_JJ D02 194 device_NN ,_, and_CC that_CS the_ATI book_NN of_IN common_JJ prayer_NN D02 194 was_BEDZ the_ATI cause_NN of_IN all_ABN their_PP$ D02 195 sorrows_NNS ._. D02 196 ^ in_IN the_ATI eighteenth_OD century_NN ,_, although_CS dissent_NN D02 196 settled_VBD down_RP to_TO D02 197 establish_VB itself_PPL and_CC soon_RB became_VBD well_RB able_JJ to_TO D02 197 look_VB after_IN its_PP$ own_AP D02 198 interests_NNS ,_, there_EX was_BEDZ little_AP inclination_NN to_TO D02 198 revise_VB these_DTS convictions_NNS ._. D03 2 ^ 3_CD ._. ^ gain_NN ._. D03 3 ^ the_ATI word_NN is_BEZ used_VBN nine_CD times_NNS in_IN the_ATI D03 3 book_NN and_CC belongs_VBZ to_IN the_ATI D03 4 world_NN of_IN commerce_NN ,_, meaning_VBG surplus_NN or_CC credit_NN D03 4 balance_NN ._. ^ life_NN ,_, says_VBZ D03 5 Qoheleth_NP ,_, pays_VBZ no_ATI dividends_NNS ._. D03 6 ^ 4_CD ._. ^ all_ABN the_ATI toil_NN at_IN which_WDTR he_PP3A toils_VBZ D03 6 ._. D03 7 ^ the_ATI word_NN for_IN toil_NN is_BEZ also_RB used_VBN of_IN D03 7 sorrow_NN and_CC vexation_NN ._. ^ the_ATI D03 8 emphasis_NN here_RN is_BEZ not_XNOT on_IN the_ATI physical_JJ labour_NN D03 8 but_CC on_IN the_ATI frustrating_JJ D03 9 nature_NN of_IN it_PP3 when_WRB the_ATI end_NN purpose_NN is_BEZ D03 9 not_XNOT known_VBN ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ the_ATI problem_NN D03 10 of_IN communication_NN in_IN the_ATI modern_JJ industrial_JJ world_NN D03 10 ._. D03 11 ^ 3_CD ._. ^ under_IN the_ATI sun_NN ._. D03 12 ^ the_ATI phrase_NN is_BEZ used_VBN some_DTI twenty-nine_CD D03 12 times_NNS in_IN this_DT book_NN but_CC not_XNOT D03 13 elsewhere_RB in_IN the_ATI old_JJ testament_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ D03 13 parallel_JJ to_IN *'_*' under_NC heaven_NC D03 14 **'_**' (_( \0cf_VB \0Ex_NP 17.14_CD ;_; \0Deut_NP 9.14_CD )_) and_CC D03 14 *'_*' upon_NC the_NC earth_NC **'_**' (_( \0cf_VB D03 15 \0Gen_NP 8.17_CD )_) ._. ^ it_PP3 means_VBZ simply_RB *'_*' alive_JJ D03 15 **'_**' ._. D03 16 ^ 5_CD ._. ^ hastens_VBZ to_IN the_ATI place_NN where_WRB it_PP3 D03 16 rises_VBZ ._. D03 17 ^ Qoheleth_NP notes_VBZ that_CS the_ATI progress_NN of_IN the_ATI D03 17 sun_NN is_BEZ an_AT illusion_NN ._. D03 18 ^ the_ATI end_NN of_IN the_ATI hastening_NN is_BEZ to_TO be_BE back_RP D03 18 where_WRB it_PP3 started_VBD ._. ^ the_ATI D03 19 original_JJ for_IN hastens_NC means_VBZ to_TO gasp_VB or_CC pant_VB ,_, D03 19 and_CC is_BEZ used_VBN of_IN D03 20 childbirth_NN pangs_NNS (_( \0Isa_NP 42.14_CD )_) and_CC the_ATI D03 20 psalmist's_NN$ longing_NN for_IN the_ATI D03 21 commandments_NNS of_IN the_ATI law_NN (_( \0Ps_NP 119.131_CD )_) ._. ^ D03 21 the_ATI figure_NN of_IN the_ATI sun_NN as_IN a_AT D03 22 participant_NN in_IN a_AT race_NN is_BEZ familiar_JJ ,_, and_CC even_RB D03 22 before_IN the_ATI exile_NN a_AT passage_NN D03 23 in_IN 2_CD Kings_NP 23.11_CD suggests_VBZ a_AT knowledge_NN of_IN D03 23 it_PP3 ._. ^ the_ATI thought_NN fits_VBZ D03 24 Qoheleth's_NP$ position_NN precisely_RB ._. ^ the_ATI finishing_NN D03 24 line_NN is_BEZ continually_RB D03 25 found_VBN to_TO be_BE but_RI the_ATI prelude_NN to_IN the_ATI D03 25 starting_NN post_NN *-_*- the_ATI sun_NN gets_VBZ D03 26 nowhere_RB !_! D03 27 ^ 6_CD ._. ^ the_ATI wind_NN blows_VBZ ..._... the_ATI wind_NN D03 27 returns_VBZ ._. D03 28 ^ this_DT verse_NN contains_VBZ the_ATI same_AP Hebrew_JNP word_NN D03 28 four_CD times_NNS and_CC is_BEZ D03 29 translated_VBN blows_VBZ ,_, goes_VBZ round_RP ,_, goes_VBZ round_RP D03 29 and_CC round_RP ,_, returns_VBZ on_IN its_PP$ D03 30 circuits_NNS ._. ^ the_ATI sheer_JJB monotony_NN of_IN repetition_NN D03 30 is_BEZ conveyed_VBN more_QL D03 31 strongly_RB in_IN the_ATI use_NN of_IN the_ATI same_AP root_NN and_CC D03 31 expresses_VBZ admirably_RB the_ATI D03 32 futility_NN that_WPR haunts_VBZ Qoheleth_NP ._. D03 33 ^ 7_CD ._. ^ the_ATI sea_NN is_BEZ not_XNOT full_JJ ._. D03 34 ^ this_DT represents_VBZ work_NN and_CC activity_NN that_WPR can_MD D03 34 not_XNOT hope_VB to_TO be_BE D03 35 completed_VBN since_CS the_ATI sea_NN will_MD never_RB be_BE too_QL D03 35 full_JJ !_! D03 36 ^ 8_CD ._. ^ the_ATI place_NN where_WRB the_ATI streams_NNS flow_VB ._. D03 37 ^ the_ATI references_NNS is_BEZ to_IN *'_*' the_ATI underworld_NN D03 37 ,_, which_WDTR was_BEDZ D03 38 thought_VBN to_TO be_BE the_ATI source_NN both_ABX of_IN the_ATI D03 38 fresh-water_JJB springs_NNS and_CC of_IN the_ATI D03 39 salt-water_NN oceans_NNS **'_**' ._. D03 40 ^ 9_CD ._. ^ the_ATI eye_NN is_BEZ not_XNOT satisfied_VBN ..._... D03 40 nor_CC the_ATI ear_NN filled_VBN ._. D03 41 ^ there_EX is_BEZ no_ATI lack_NN of_IN sensations_NNS for_IN D03 41 these_DTS organs_NNS to_TO be_BE occupied_VBN D03 42 with_IN but_CC there_EX is_BEZ no_ATI significance_NN in_IN what_WDT D03 42 they_PP3AS experience_VB ._. ^ the_ATI word_NN D03 43 for_IN satisfied_NC is_BEZ used_VBN of_IN hunger_NN and_CC appetite_NN D03 43 ._. ^ there_EX is_BEZ food_NN D03 44 enough_DTI but_CC the_ATI hunger_NN never_RB grows_VBZ less_AP ._. D03 45 ^ 10_CD ._. ^ there_EX is_BEZ nothing_PN new_JJ under_IN the_ATI sun_NN D03 45 ._. D03 46 ^ the_ATI complaint_NN is_BEZ deeper_JJR than_IN a_AT demand_NN D03 46 for_IN novelty_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ the_ATI D03 47 lack_NN of_IN an_AT advance_NN in_IN natural_JJ phenomena_NNS that_CS D03 47 appals_VBZ ._. ^ the_ATI verse_NN may_MD be_BE D03 48 compared_VBN with_IN \0Pss_NP 8_CD and_CC 104_CD to_TO bring_VB out_RP D03 48 the_ATI gulf_NN between_IN viewing_VBG D03 49 the_ATI physical_JJ world_NN as_IN a_AT soulless_JJ process_NN and_CC D03 49 viewing_VBG it_PP3 sacramentally_RB ._. D03 50 ^ 11_CD ._. ^ there_EX is_BEZ no_ATI remembrance_NN ._. D03 51 ^ the_ATI full_JJ force_NN of_IN this_DT verse_NN is_BEZ only_RB D03 51 to_TO be_BE seen_VBN when_WRB the_ATI D03 52 significance_NN of_IN the_ATI act_NN of_IN remembering_VBG in_IN D03 52 the_ATI Hebrew_JNP mind_NN is_BEZ D03 53 recognized_VBN ._. ^ the_ATI act_NN means_VBZ more_AP than_IN the_ATI D03 53 recalling_NN of_IN past_JJB events_NNS ._. D03 54 ^ the_ATI very_AP personality_NN of_IN a_AT man_NN continues_VBZ D03 54 into_IN the_ATI present_NN through_IN his_PP$ D03 55 being_BEG remembered_VBN ._. ^ there_EX is_BEZ an_AT element_NN of_IN D03 55 present_JJ reality_NN in_IN D03 56 remembering_VBG *-_*- the_ATI past_NN is_BEZ re-presented_VBN ._. ^ D03 56 to_TO say_VB there_EX is_BEZ no_ATI D03 57 remembrance_NN would_MD mean_VB spiritual_JJ annihilation_NN ._. ^ D03 57 hence_RB the_ATI frequency_NN of_IN D03 58 the_ATI biblical_JJ injunction_NN to_TO look_VB at_IN the_ATI past_NN D03 58 and_CC remember_VB ._. ^ (_( \0Cf_VB D03 59 \0Ex_NP 13.3_CD ;_; 20.8_CD ;_; \0Deut_NP 5.15_CD ;_; \0Isa_NP D03 59 51.1-3_CD-CD ;_; also_RB 1_CD1 \0Cor_NP 11.25_CD ._. )_) D03 60 ^ the_ATI search_NN for_IN the_ATI supreme_JJ good_NN ._. D03 61 ^ 1_CD1 ._. 12-2_CD-CD ._. 26_CD D03 62 ^ under_IN the_ATI pseudonym_NN of_IN Solomon_NP ,_, Qoheleth_NP D03 62 outlines_VBZ a_AT number_NN of_IN D03 63 quests_NNS or_CC even_RB experiments_NNS he_PP3A has_HVZ made_VBN in_IN D03 63 the_ATI search_NN for_IN an_AT ultimate_JJ D03 64 purpose_NN ,_, a_AT supreme_JJ good_NN in_IN human_JJ life_NN ;_; D03 64 but_CC all_ABN have_HV led_VBN him_PP3O to_IN the_ATI D03 65 same_AP moral_JJ impasse_NN ._. D03 66 ^ the_ATI quest_NN for_IN wisdom_NN ._. D03 67 ^ 1_CD1 ._. 12-18_CD-CD D03 68 ^ 12_CD ._. ^ I_PP1A the_ATI preacher_NN have_HV been_BEN king_NN D03 68 over_IN Israel_NP in_IN Jerusalem_NP ._. D03 69 ^ the_ATI author_NN clearly_RB intends_VBZ to_TO be_BE taken_VBN D03 69 as_IN Solomon_NP ._. ^ the_ATI use_NN of_IN D03 70 this_DT literary_JJ device_NN was_BEDZ really_RB a_AT means_NN of_IN D03 70 expressing_VBG Qoheleth's_NP$ D03 71 conviction_NN that_CS neither_DTX wealth_NN nor_CC wisdom_NN D03 71 provided_VBD the_ATI clue_NN to_IN the_ATI D03 72 final_JJ meaning_NN of_IN life_NN ._. ^ he_PP3A uses_VBZ here_RN D03 72 Solomon's_NP$ reputation_NN for_IN D03 73 precisely_RB these_DTS two_CD features_NNS ,_, his_PP$ renowned_JJ D03 73 wisdom_NN and_CC his_PP$ ostentatious_JJ D03 74 flaunting_NN of_IN wealth_NN ._. ^ his_PP$ attitude_NN is_BEZ not_XNOT D03 74 that_DT of_IN an_AT admirer_NN ,_, but_CC D03 75 rather_RB he_PP3A pillories_VBZ these_DTS characteristics_NNS ,_, D03 75 and_CC indirectly_RB Solomon_NP D03 76 himself_PPL ._. D03 77 ^ 13_CD ._. ^ I_PP1A applied_VBD my_PP$ mind_NN ._. D03 78 ^ \0Lit_RB *'_*' my_NC heart_NC **'_**' ._. ^ the_ATI Hebrew_JNP D03 78 word_NN le*?1b_&FW ,_, frequently_RB D03 79 translated_VBN *'_*' heart_NC **'_**' ,_, is_BEZ more_RBR concerned_VBN D03 79 with_IN thought_NN and_CC the_ATI will_NN D03 80 than_CS with_IN the_ATI emotions_NNS in_IN Hebrew_JNP thinking_NN ._. D03 81 ^ search_VB out_RP in_IN wisdom_NN ._. D03 82 ^ the_ATI original_NN for_IN search_NC out_NC is_BEZ used_VBN as_IN D03 82 a_AT technical_JJ term_NN for_IN D03 83 consulting_VBG the_ATI priest_NN or_CC the_ATI prophet_NN and_CC is_BEZ D03 83 what_WDT is_BEZ meant_VBN by_IN D03 84 *'_*' enquiring_VBG of_IN the_ATI Lord_NPT **'_**' ._. ^ the_ATI D03 84 root_NN is_BEZ da*?1rash_&FW and_CC the_ATI term_NN D03 85 Midrash_&FW *-_*- commentary_NN on_IN scripture_NN *-_*- comes_VBZ D03 85 from_IN it_PP3 ._. ^ with_IN by_NC wisdom_NC D03 86 compare_VB Job_NP 28.12_CD ,_, where_WRB the_ATI quest_NN for_IN D03 86 wisdom_NN is_BEZ considered_VBN beyond_IN D03 87 man's_NN$ capacity_NN ._. ^ see_VB the_ATI introduction_NN ,_, D03 87 \0pp_NNUS 274_CD \0f_RB ,_, for_IN the_ATI need_NN to_TO D03 88 distinguish_VB between_IN human_JJ wisdom_NN and_CC the_ATI divine_JJ D03 88 wisdom_NN ._. ^ there_EX are_BER two_CD D03 89 levels_NNS of_IN discussion_NN ,_, and_CC the_ATI wisdom_NN derived_VBN D03 89 from_IN the_ATI practical_JJ D03 90 experience_NN of_IN daily_JJ living_NN offers_VBZ no_ATI key_NN to_IN D03 90 the_ATI great_JJ ultimate_JJ D03 91 mysteries_NNS of_IN the_ATI divine_JJ wisdom_NN ._. D03 92 ^ 14_CD ._. ^ a_AT striving_NN after_IN wind_NN ._. D03 93 ^ this_DT is_BEZ a_AT favourite_JJB phrase_NN of_IN the_ATI D03 93 writer_NN and_CC it_PP3 is_BEZ used_VBN some_DTI D03 94 seven_CD times_NNS in_IN this_DT book_NN ._. ^ the_ATI literal_JJ D03 94 meaning_NN is_BEZ *'_*' a_AT feeding_NN on_IN the_ATI D03 95 wind_NN **'_**' ._. ^ the_ATI word_NN is_BEZ used_VBN of_IN D03 95 shepherds_NNS feeding_VBG their_PP$ flocks_NNS ._. ^ the_ATI D03 96 thought_NN is_BEZ that_CS for_IN all_ABN the_ATI satisfaction_NN D03 96 obtained_VBN all_ABN his_PP$ quests_NNS for_IN D03 97 meaning_NN are_BER like_IN trying_VBG to_TO make_VB a_AT meal_NN on_IN D03 97 food_NN that_WPR is_BEZ no_RB more_QL D03 98 substantial_JJ than_IN the_ATI wind_NN !_! ^ some_DTI scholars_NNS D03 98 derive_VB the_ATI word_NN from_IN a_AT root_NN D03 99 meaning_VBG *'_*' to_TO desire_VB **'_**' ._. ^ then_RN the_ATI D03 99 phrase_NN would_MD mean_VB *'_*' to_TO desire_VB the_ATI D03 100 unsubstantial_JJ or_CC illusory_JJ **'_**' ._. ^ the_ATI same_AP D03 100 note_NN of_IN bitterness_NN is_BEZ apparent_JJ D03 101 in_IN either_DTX case_NN ._. ^ all_ABN human_JJ activity_NN ,_, as_QL D03 101 far_RB as_CS its_PP$ final_JJ significance_NN D03 102 is_BEZ concerned_VBN ,_, is_BEZ like_IN feeding_VBG on_IN the_ATI D03 102 wind_NN or_CC desiring_VBG the_ATI shadowy_JJ D03 103 insubstantial_JJ air_NN ._. D03 104 ^ 15_CD ._. ^ what_WDT is_BEZ crooked_JJ ._. D03 105 ^ the_ATI root_NN meaning_NN of_IN crooked_NC is_BEZ *'_*' to_TO D03 105 twist_VB or_CC pervert_VB **'_**' ._. D03 106 ^ this_DT is_BEZ a_AT key_NN for_IN human_JJ sin_NN ._. ^ we_PP1AS D03 106 find_VB our_PP$ colloquial_JJ term_NN D03 107 *'_*' twister_NC **'_**' near_IN the_ATI mark_NN ._. ^ we_PP1AS note_VB D03 107 the_ATI preoccupation_NN of_IN wisdom_NN in_IN D03 108 its_PP$ profounder_JJR aspect_NN with_IN the_ATI problem_NN of_IN D03 108 sin_NN and_CC suffering_NN ._. D03 109 ^ 16_CD ._. ^ I_PP1A said_VBD to_IN myself_PPL ._. D03 110 ^ \0Lit_RB *'_*' I_PP1A ,_, personally_RB ,_, spoke_VBD with_IN D03 110 my_PP$ heart_NN ._. **'_**' D03 111 ^ all_ABN who_WPR were_BED over_IN Jerusalem_NP before_IN me_PP1O ._. D03 112 ^ this_DT completely_RB gives_VBZ away_RP the_ATI case_NN for_IN D03 112 Solomonic_JNP authorship_NN *-_*- D03 113 there_EX is_BEZ only_RB one_CD1 candidate_NN for_IN this_DT ,_, D03 113 David_NP ._. D03 114 ^ wisdom_NN and_CC knowledge_NN ._. D03 115 ^ these_DTS two_CD terms_NNS are_BER frequently_RB found_VBN in_IN D03 115 close_JJ association_NN ._. D03 116 ^ *'_*' in_IN the_ATI old_JJ testament_NN ,_, **'_**' says_VBZ D03 116 Vriezen_NP ,_, *'_*' knowledge_NN is_BEZ living_VBG in_IN a_AT D03 117 close_JJ relationship_NN with_IN something_PN or_CC somebody_PN ,_, D03 117 such_ABL a_AT relationship_NN as_CS D03 118 to_TO cause_VB what_WDT may_MD be_BE called_VBN communion_NN ._. D03 118 **'_**' ^ that_CS a_AT man_NN has_HVZ knowledge_NN of_IN D03 119 God_NP would_MD mean_VB that_CS he_PP3A had_HVD knowledge_NN of_IN D03 119 God's_NP$ revelation_NN of_IN himself_PPL ._. D03 120 ^ 17_CD ._. ^ to_TO know_VB wisdom_NN ..._... to_TO know_VB madness_NN D03 120 and_CC folly_NN ._. D03 121 ^ we_PP1AS note_VB again_RB the_ATI use_NN of_IN to_NC know_NC D03 121 denoting_VBG experience_NN within_IN D03 122 a_AT relationship_NN that_WPR is_BEZ immediate_JJ ,_, rather_RB than_IN D03 122 second-hand_JJB *'_*' knowing_NN D03 123 about_IN **'_**' from_IN another_DT source_NN ._. ^ wisdom_NN and_CC D03 123 folly_NN are_BER moral_JJ rather_RB than_IN D03 124 intellectual_JJ categories_NNS and_CC are_BER equivalent_JJ to_IN D03 124 good_JJ and_CC evil_JJ ._. ^ we_PP1AS must_MD D03 125 applaud_VB Qoheleth_NP on_IN the_ATI thoroughness_NN of_IN his_PP$ D03 125 research_NN when_WRB he_PP3A includes_VBZ D03 126 madness_NC and_NC folly_NC ._. ^ the_ATI verse_NN has_HVZ also_RB D03 126 been_BEN translated_VBN *'_*' to_TO know_VB D03 127 that_CS wisdom_NN and_CC knowledge_NN are_BER madness_NN and_CC D03 127 folly_NN **'_**' ._. ^ the_ATI word_NN D03 128 translated_VBN madness_NC means_VBZ *'_*' mad_JJ revelry_NN and_CC D03 128 wickedness_NN **'_**' ._. D03 129 ^ the_ATI quest_NN for_IN pleasure_NN and_CC material_JJ D03 129 satisfaction_NN ._. D03 130 ^ 2_CD ._. 1-11_CD-CD D03 131 ^ 1_CD1 ._. ^ I_PP1A will_MD make_VB a_AT test_NN of_IN pleasure_NN ._. D03 132 ^ \0AV_NN ,_, I_PP1A will_MD prove_VB thee_PP2 with_IN mirth_NN ._. ^ D03 132 the_ATI connotation_NN of_IN D03 133 pleasure_NN is_BEZ wider_JJR than_IN that_DT of_IN mirth_NN and_CC D03 133 is_BEZ to_TO be_BE preferred_VBN ._. ^ the_ATI D03 134 Hebrew_JNP word_NN is_BEZ used_VBN of_IN the_ATI ordinary_JJ D03 134 pleasures_NNS of_IN life_NN ,_, including_IN D03 135 goodness_NN and_CC joy_NN and_CC the_ATI rejoicing_NN associated_VBN D03 135 with_IN religious_JJ D03 136 festivals_NNS ._. ^ the_ATI word_NN for_IN *'_*' test_NC **'_**' is_BEZ D03 136 used_VBN of_IN God_NP testing_VBG Abraham_NP D03 137 (_( \0Gen_NP 22.1_CD )_) and_CC frequently_RB of_IN such_ABL trials_NNS D03 137 ._. D03 138 ^ enjoy_VB yourself_PPL ._. D03 139 ^ \0Lit_RB *'_*' look_VB upon_IN good_JJ **'_**' ._. ^ this_DT D03 139 phrase_NN contains_VBZ the_ATI D03 140 characteristic_JJ Hebrew_JNP idiom_NN which_WDTR uses_VBZ *'_*' to_NC D03 140 see_NC **'_**' meaning_VBG *'_*' to_TO D03 141 experience_VB ,_, to_TO participate_VB in_IN **'_**' ._. ^ it_PP3 D03 141 is_BEZ used_VBN of_IN experiences_NNS of_IN life_NN D03 142 and_CC death_NN ,_, happiness_NN and_CC sorrow_NN (_( \0cf_VB Job_NP D03 142 9.25_CD ;_; \0Ps_NP 16.10_CD ;_; \0Isa_NP D03 143 44.16_CD ;_; Luke_NP 2.26_CD ;_; John_NP 3.36_CD ;_; 8.51_CD )_) ._. ^ D03 143 the_ATI force_NN of_IN the_ATI phrase_NN is_BEZ not_XNOT so_QL D03 144 much_RB ~ *'_*' enjoy_VB all_ABN that_WPR is_BEZ good_JJ **'_**' as_IN ~ D03 144 *'_*' share_VB in_IN the_ATI experience_NN of_IN all_ABN D03 145 that_WPR is_BEZ good_JJ **'_**' and_CC then_RN give_VB a_AT verdict_NN D03 145 upon_IN it_PP3 ._. ^ the_ATI verb_NN is_BEZ parallel_JJ D03 146 to_IN test_NC and_CC must_MD be_BE taken_VBN in_IN this_DT sense_NN D03 146 of_IN trying_VBG and_CC D03 147 experimenting_VBG ._. ^ the_ATI typical_JJ Hebrew_JNP view_NN of_IN D03 147 life_NN is_BEZ not_XNOT a_AT denial_NN of_IN D03 148 pleasure_NN but_CC the_ATI reverse_NN ._. ^ we_PP1AS need_VB to_TO D03 148 remember_VB the_ATI particular_JJ quest_NN D03 149 that_CS Qoheleth_NP had_HVD in_IN mind_NN ._. ^ he_PP3A is_BEZ D03 149 seeking_VBG for_IN an_AT ultimate_JJ goal_NN to_IN the_ATI D03 150 merriment_NN and_CC happiness_NN that_WPR life_NN does_DOZ contain_VB D03 150 in_IN some_DTI of_IN its_PP$ separate_JJ D03 151 experiences_NNS ._. D03 152 ^ 2_CD ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ mad_JJ ._. D03 153 ^ the_ATI Hebrew_JNP participle_NN means_VBZ *'_*' acting_VBG D03 153 like_IN madmen_NNS **'_**' ._. ^ \0cf_VB 1_CD1 D03 154 \0Sam_NP 21.14_CD ;_; \0Jer_NP 25.16_CD ;_; 46.9_CD ;_; 50.38_CD ;_; D03 154 51.7_CD ._. D03 155 ^ 3_CD ._. ^ to_TO cheer_VB my_PP$ body_NN with_IN wine_NN ._. D03 156 ^ \0Lit_RB *'_*' to_TO draw_VB my_PP$ flesh_NN with_IN wine_NN D03 156 **'_**' ._. ^ the_ATI phrase_NN is_BEZ D03 157 difficult_JJ ._. ^ the_ATI word_NN translated_VBN cheer_NC can_MD D03 157 mean_VB *'_*' to_TO draw_VB or_CC D03 158 drag_VB **'_**' ,_, which_WDTR in_IN later_JJR Hebrew_NNP has_HVZ a_AT D03 158 meaning_NN of_IN *'_*' to_TO attract_VB **'_**' in_IN a_AT D03 159 figurative_JJ sense_NN ,_, that_DT is_BEZ ,_, to_TO stimulate_VB and_CC D03 159 so_RB to_TO refresh_VB ._. D03 160 ^ my_PP$ mind_NN still_RB guiding_VBG me_PP1O with_IN wisdom_NN ._. D03 161 ^ \0AV_NN ,_, *'_*' acquainting_VBG my_PP$ heart_NN with_IN D03 161 wisdom_NN **'_**' ._. ^ the_ATI word_NN for_IN D03 162 guiding_NC comes_VBZ from_IN a_AT root_NN that_WPR is_BEZ used_VBN D03 162 to_TO describe_VB the_ATI herding_NN of_IN D03 163 sheep_NNS or_CC the_ATI conducting_NN of_IN prisoners_NNS ._. ^ D03 163 Qoheleth_NP is_BEZ still_RB keeping_VBG his_PP$ D03 164 mind_NN on_IN his_PP$ job_NN ._. ^ he_PP3A is_BEZ not_XNOT blindly_RB D03 164 setting_VBG out_RP on_IN debauchery_NN or_CC D03 165 dissolution_NN as_IN an_AT escapist_JJ activity_NN ._. D03 166 ^ to_TO lay_VB hold_NN on_IN folly_NN ._. D03 167 ^ the_ATI word_NN used_VBN is_BEZ a_AT strong_JJ one_CD1 ,_, D03 167 meaning_VBG *'_*' to_TO seize_VB **'_**' ,_, and_CC it_PP3 D03 168 indicates_VBZ the_ATI urgency_NN of_IN Qoheleth's_NP$ quest_NN ._. ^ D03 168 here_RN is_BEZ no_ATI armchair_NN D03 169 doctrinaire_JJ dilettante_NN ._. D03 170 ^ 4_CD ._. ^ I_PP1A made_VBD great_JJ works_NNS ._. D03 171 ^ \0Lit_RB *'_*' I_PP1A made_VBD great_JJ my_PP$ works_NNS **'_**' D03 171 ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ a_AT reference_NN to_IN the_ATI D03 172 large-scale_JJB building_NN operations_NNS which_WDTR Solomon_NP D03 172 included_VBD in_IN the_ATI D03 173 construction_NN of_IN his_PP$ palaces_NNS and_CC the_ATI palace_NN D03 173 of_IN Pharaoh's_NP$ daughter_NN D03 174 (_( \0cf_VB 1_CD1 Kings_NP 7.1_CD \0ff_RB ;_; 9.15_CD \0ff_RB ;_; 2_CD D03 174 \0Chron_NP 8.4-6_CD-CD )_) ._. ^ close_RB to_IN D03 175 the_ATI building_NN projects_NNS would_MD be_BE the_ATI vineyards_NNS D03 175 (_( 1_CD1 Kings_NP 4.25_CD ;_; \0S_NN D03 176 of_IN \0Sol_NP 8.11_CD )_) ._. D03 177 ^ 5_CD ._. ^ parks_NNS ._. D03 178 ^ the_ATI word_NN is_BEZ a_AT Persian_JNP loan-word_NN ,_, D03 178 pairi-deaza_&FW ,_, from_IN which_WDTR D03 179 our_PP$ word_NN paradise_NN is_BEZ derived_VBN ._. ^ Qoheleth_NP D03 179 has_HVZ a_AT second_OD paradise_NN at_IN his_PP$ D03 180 disposal_NN but_CC he_PP3A is_BEZ no_RB happier_JJR than_CS Adam_NP D03 180 was_BEDZ !_! ^ the_ATI word_NN is_BEZ used_VBN in_IN the_ATI D03 181 singular_NN in_IN \0Neh_NP 2.8_CD and_CC \0S_NN of_IN \0Sol_NP 4.13_CD D03 181 ._. D03 182 ^ 6_CD ._. ^ pools_NNS from_IN which_WDTR to_TO water_VB ._. D03 183 ^ a_AT natural_JJ transition_NN from_IN gardens_NNS and_CC D03 183 orchards_NNS to_IN the_ATI vital_JJ D03 184 question_NN of_IN water_NN supply_NN ._. ^ the_ATI pools_NNS are_BER D03 184 probably_RB natural_JJ springs_NNS D03 185 enlarged_VBN to_TO become_VB reservoirs_NNS or_CC cisterns_NNS in_IN D03 185 the_ATI rock_NN ._. ^ King_NPT Mesha_NP of_IN D03 186 Moab_NP boasts_VBZ of_IN their_PP$ construction_NN in_IN lines_NNS 9_CD D03 186 ,_, 23-25_CD-CD of_IN the_ATI Moabite_JNP D03 187 stone_NN ,_, which_WDTR read_VBD :_: D03 189 *"_*' D03 190 ^ and_CC I_PP1A built_VBD Baal-meon_NP and_CC made_VBD in_IN it_PP3 D03 190 the_ATI reservoir_NN ..._... and_CC I_PP1A made_VBD D03 191 both_ABX the_ATI reservoirs_NNS for_IN water_NN inside_IN the_ATI D03 191 town_NN ._. ^ and_CC there_EX was_BEDZ no_ATI D03 192 cistern_NN inside_IN the_ATI town_NN at_IN Qrchh_NP ,_, so_CS I_PP1A D03 192 said_VBD to_IN all_ABN the_ATI people_NNS ,_, ^ *'_*' make_VB D03 193 yourselves_PPLS each_DT one_CD1 a_AT cistern_NN in_IN his_PP$ house_NN D03 193 ._. **'_**' D03 194 **"_**' D03 196 ^ \0cf_VB also_RB \0Neh_NP 2.14_CD ;_; 3.15_CD ;_; \0Isa_NP 1.30_CD D03 196 ;_; 58.11_CD ;_; \0S_NN of_IN \0Sol_NP D03 197 7.4_CD ;_; 2_CD \0Sam_NP 4.12_CD ._. D03 198 ^ 7_CD ._. ^ I_PP1A bought_VBD male_JJ and_CC female_JJ slaves_NNS ._. D03 199 ^ the_ATI acquisition_NN of_IN slaves_NNS would_MD be_BE the_ATI D03 199 necessary_JJ presupposition_NN D03 200 of_IN the_ATI scale_NN of_IN his_PP$ building_NN operations_NNS ._. ^ D03 200 behind_IN these_DTS practices_NNS is_BEZ D03 201 the_ATI mas_&FW or_CC forced_JJ labour_NN system_NN which_WDTR D03 201 Solomon_NP takes_VBZ from_IN Egyptian_JNP D03 202 practices_NNS (_( \0cf_VB the_ATI use_NN of_IN such_ABL labour_NN by_IN D03 202 the_ATI Egyptians_NNPS in_IN \0Ex_NP D03 203 1.11-14_CD-CD )_) ._. D03 204 ^ 8_CD ._. ^ any_DTI who_WPR had_HVD been_BEN before_IN me_PP1O in_IN D03 204 Jerusalem_NP ._. D03 205 ^ again_RB the_ATI mask_NN slips_VBZ ._. ^ this_DT rules_VBZ out_RP D03 205 Solomonic_JNP authorship_NN ._. D03 206 ^ see_VB introduction_NN ,_, \0pp_NNUS 257_CD \0f_RB D03 207 ._. ^ 9_CD ._. ^ my_PP$ wisdom_NN remained_VBD with_IN me_PP1O ._. D03 208 ^ \0Lit_RB *'_*' stood_VBD to_IN (_( or_CC for_IN )_) me_PP1O D03 208 **'_**' ._. ^ Qoheleth_NP retains_VBZ his_PP$ D03 209 objectivity_NN ._. ^ this_DT reinforces_VBZ \0v_NN 3_CD ._. ^ his_PP$ D03 209 experiencing_NN of_IN folly_NN as_CC D03 210 well_CC" as_CC" wisdom_NN still_RB leaves_VBZ him_PP3O able_JJ to_TO D03 210 tell_VB the_ATI difference_NN ._. D03 211 ^ 10_CD ._. ^ my_PP$ eyes_NNS desired_VBD ._. D03 212 ^ \0Lit_RB *'_*' asked_VBD **'_**' ._. ^ we_PP1AS may_MD compare_VB D03 212 1_CD1 John_NP 2.16_CD for_IN the_ATI D03 213 *'_*' lust_NN **'_**' (_( desire_NN )_) of_IN the_ATI eyes_NNS ,_, D03 213 and_CC also_RB 1_CD1 Kings_NP 20.6_CD ;_; \0Ps_NP 145.15_CD ;_; D03 214 \0Prov_NP 27.20_CD for_IN the_ATI eyes_NNS as_IN the_ATI seat_NN of_IN D03 214 desire_NN ._. ^ there_EX is_BEZ no_ATI D03 215 necessary_JJ suggestion_NN of_IN evil_JJ desire_NN ._. ^ the_ATI D03 215 previous_JJ verse_NN suggests_VBZ that_CS D03 216 his_PP$ wisdom_NN safeguards_VBZ him_PP3O from_IN this_DT temptation_NN D03 216 ._. D03 217 ^ this_DT was_BEDZ my_PP$ reward_NN ._. D03 218 ^ this_DT is_BEZ a_AT favourite_JJB word_NN with_IN Qoheleth_NP (_( D03 218 \0cf_VB 2.21_CD ;_; 3.22_CD ;_; 5.18_CD D03 219 \0ff_RB ;_; 9.6_CD ,_, 9_CD ;_; 11.2_CD )_) ._. ^ it_PP3 carries_VBZ D03 219 the_ATI idea_NN of_IN reward_NN or_CC profit_NN ._. D03 220 ^ Qoheleth_NP is_BEZ suggesting_VBG that_CS there_EX is_BEZ a_AT D03 220 gain_NN from_IN human_JJ experience_NN ._. D03 221 ^ he_PP3A has_HVZ found_VBN a_AT good_NN ,_, but_CC the_ATI next_AP D03 221 verse_NN indicates_VBZ that_CS it_PP3 is_BEZ a_AT D03 222 relative_JJ one_CD1 and_CC the_ATI supreme_JJ good_NN is_BEZ still_RB D03 222 to_TO be_BE sought_VBN ._. D04 2 ^ as_CS it_PP3 is_BEZ written_VBN :_: ^ *'_*' the_ATI earth_NN shalt_MD D04 2 thou_PP2 make_VB an_AT altar_NN for_IN D04 3 God_NP ._. ^ and_CC if_CS thou_PP2 wilt_MD make_VB an_AT altar_NN of_IN D04 3 stone_NN ,_, thou_PP2 shalt_MD not_XNOT D04 4 build_VB it_PP3 of_IN hewn_JJ stone_NN ,_, for_CS if_CS thou_PP2 D04 4 lift_VB up_RP thy_PP$ sword_NN upon_IN it_PP3 ,_, D04 5 thou_PP2 hast_HV polluted_VBN it_PP3 ._. **'_**' D04 6 ^ the_ATI Shamir_NP ._. D04 7 ^ and_CC they_PP3AS shall_MD seek_VB the_ATI Shamir_NP ,_, to_TO D04 7 make_VB an_AT altar_NN ._. D04 8 ^ according_IN to_IN" the_ATI legend_NN ,_, Solomon_NP had_HVD D04 8 asked_VBN the_ATI Prince_NPT of_IN the_ATI D04 9 demons_NNS ,_, *'_*' Ashmodeus_NP **'_**' to_TO bring_VB him_PP3O D04 9 the_ATI Shamir_NP and_CC Ashmodeus_NP told_VBD him_PP3O D04 10 that_CS the_ATI Shamir_NP had_HVD not_XNOT been_BEN placed_VBN under_IN D04 10 his_PP$ charge_NN ,_, as_CS there_EX is_BEZ no_ATI D04 11 Shamir_NP in_IN Gehenna_NP (_( hell_NN )_) ._. ^ an_AT eagle_NN D04 11 brought_VBD the_ATI Shamir_NP to_IN Solomon_NP from_IN D04 12 Eden_NP ,_, the_ATI paradise_NN ,_, the_ATI only_AP place_NN where_WRB D04 12 the_ATI Shamir_NP could_MD be_BE found_VBN ._. D04 13 ^ the_ATI Talmud_NP describes_VBZ that_CS the_ATI Shamir_NP D04 13 lives_VBZ in_IN a_AT sanctuary_NN ,_, and_CC D04 14 only_RB some_DTI rare_JJ birds_NNS know_VB the_ATI existence_NN of_IN D04 14 it_PP3 ._. D04 15 ^ these_DTS birds_NNS are_BER ,_, the_ATI Cherubim_NPS and_CC D04 15 the_ATI Seraphim_NPS ._. D04 16 ^ we_PP1AS are_BER also_RB told_VBN that_CS the_ATI Shamir_NP is_BEZ D04 16 the_ATI stylus_NN used_VBN by_IN Moses_NP ,_, and_CC D04 17 this_DT stylus_NN is_BEZ described_VBN as_IN a_AT very_QL precious_JJ D04 17 diamond-stone_NN and_CC very_QL D04 18 adamant_JJ ._. D04 19 ^ the_ATI word_NN Shamir_NP was_BEDZ used_VBN as_IN a_AT personal_JJ D04 19 name_NN (_( \0Git_NP 68a_CD )_) ._. ^ the_ATI D04 20 Hebrew_JNP word_NN *'_*' Shamir_&FW **'_**' means_VBZ guarded_VBN or_CC D04 20 preserved_VBN ._. D04 21 ^ therefore_RB ,_, the_ATI real_JJ man_NN ,_, who_WPR regards_VBZ D04 21 himself_PPL as_CS insignificant_JJ ,_, as_CS D04 22 the_ATI prayer_NN says_VBZ :_: ~ *'_*' what_WDT am_BEM I_PP1A ?_? ~ D04 22 a_AT worm_NN **'_**' ,_, he_PP3A is_BEZ the_ATI Shamir_NP and_CC D04 22 such_ABL a_AT D04 23 man_NN fulfils_VBZ the_ATI Shmah_NP ,_, loves_VBZ the_ATI Lord_NPT D04 23 God_NP with_IN all_ABN his_PP$ heart_NN ,_, and_CC with_IN D04 24 all_ABN his_PP$ soul_NN and_CC with_IN all_ABN his_PP$ might_NN and_CC D04 24 studies_VBZ the_ATI word_NN of_IN God_NP ._. ^ this_DT D04 25 man_NN is_BEZ the_ATI worm_NN ,_, the_ATI creature_NN that_WPR cuts_VBZ D04 25 and_CC polishes_VBZ altar-stones_NNS ._. D04 26 ^ such_ABL a_AT man_NN is_BEZ the_ATI Shamir_NP that_WPR guards_VBZ D04 26 himself_PPL against_IN all_ABN the_ATI D04 27 irrelevant_JJ pleasures_NNS ._. ^ such_ABL a_AT Shamir_NP possesses_VBZ D04 27 the_ATI real_JJ acid_NN to_TO mould_VB D04 28 our_PP$ character_NN ,_, to_TO melt_VB our_PP$ heart_NN of_IN stone_NN D04 28 ._. ^ this_DT Shamir_NP helps_VBZ us_PP1OS D04 29 earthly_JJ creatures_NNS to_TO build_VB an_AT altar_NN for_IN God_NP D04 29 to_TO come_VB nearer_RBR to_IN God_NP ._. D04 30 ^ the_ATI action_NN of_IN the_ATI Shamir_NP writes_VBZ books_NNS and_CC D04 30 their_PP$ books_NNS are_BER readable_JJ ._. D04 31 ^ this_DT Shamir_NP is_BEZ indeed_RB a_AT rare_JJ diamond_NN that_WPR D04 31 incises_VBZ the_ATI hardest_JJT rock_NN ,_, D04 32 the_ATI hardest_JJT facts_NNS ._. ^ and_CC these_DTS creatures_NNS D04 32 existed_VBD from_IN the_ATI beginning_NN ._. D04 33 ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ *'_*' the_ATI stone_NN ,_, which_WDTR the_ATI D04 33 builders_NNS refused_VBD ,_, but_CC it_PP3 is_BEZ to_TO become_VB D04 34 the_ATI head-stone_NN of_IN the_ATI corner_NN **'_**' ._. ^ (_( \0Ps_NP D04 34 118_CD ,_, 22_CD ._. )_) ^ and_CC the_ATI stone_NN D04 35 shall_MD tell_VB !_! ^ *'_*' for_CS the_ATI stone_NN shall_MD cry_VB D04 35 out_RP of_IN the_ATI wall_NN **'_**' ,_, like_IN D04 36 Baalam's_NP$ ass_NN ,_, *'_*' and_CC the_ATI purlin_NN of_IN timber_NN D04 36 shall_MD creak_VB in_IN answer_NN **'_**' *'_*' if_CS D04 37 the_ATI roof_NN of_IN our_PP$ security_NN is_BEZ crushing_VBG our_PP$ D04 37 soul_NN **'_**' (_( see_VB \0Hab_NP 2_CD ,_, D04 38 10-11_CD-CD )_) ._. ^ and_CC it_PP3 is_BEZ through_IN the_ATI Shamir_NP D04 38 :_: *'_*' that_CS the_ATI earth_NN shall_MD be_BE D04 39 filled_VBN with_IN the_ATI knowledge_NN of_IN the_ATI glory_NN of_IN D04 39 the_ATI Lord_NPT ,_, as_CS the_ATI waters_NNS D04 40 cover_VB the_ATI sea_NN ._. **'_**' ^ (_( \0Hab_NP 2_CD ,_, 14_CD ._. D04 40 )_) D04 41 ^ the_ATI Shamir's_NP$ daily_JJ life_NN writes_VBZ the_ATI D04 41 Decalogue_NP ,_, which_WDTR is_BEZ written_VBN on_IN D04 42 two_CD plates_NNS ,_, the_ATI hard_JJ facts_NNS of_IN life_NN ,_, D04 42 and_CC all_ABN facts_NNS are_BER *'_*' one_CD1 **'_**' ._. ^ we_PP1AS D04 43 have_HV all_ABN come_VBN across_IN human_JJ Shamirs_NPS and_CC D04 43 they_PP3AS leave_VB a_AT deep_JJ impression_NN on_IN D04 44 our_PP$ feelings_NNS and_CC senses_NNS ._. ^ they_PP3AS make_VB D04 44 us_PP1OS the_ATI altar_NN for_IN God_NP to_TO emit_VB the_ATI D04 45 light_NN which_WDTR can_MD be_BE read_VBN in_IN every_AT language_NN D04 45 ._. ^ the_ATI Shamir_NP is_BEZ the_ATI D04 46 *'_*' seventh_OD **'_**' and_CC most_QL important_JJ creature_NN ,_, D04 46 that_WPR was_BEDZ created_VBN on_IN the_ATI eve_NN D04 47 of_IN the_ATI sabbath_NN ,_, to_TO bring_VB the_ATI sabbath_NN ,_, D04 47 real_JJ peace_NN to_IN the_ATI whole_JJ world_NN ._. D04 48 ^ then_RN the_ATI whole_JJ earth_NN will_MD be_BE his_PP$ altar_NN ._. D04 49 ^ the_ATI second_OD lesson_NN of_IN the_ATI shmah_NN \0Deut_NP 11_CD D04 49 ,_, 13-21_CD-CD ._. D04 50 ^ *'_*' and_CC it_PP3 shall_MD come_VB to_TO pass_VB ,_, if_CS D04 50 ye_PP2 shall_MD hearken_VB diligently_RB D04 51 unto_IN my_PP$ commandments_NNS ,_, which_WDTR I_PP1A command_VB D04 51 you_PP2 this_DT day_NN ,_, to_TO love_VB the_ATI Lord_NPT D04 52 your_PP$ God_NP ,_, and_CC to_TO serve_VB him_PP3O with_IN all_ABN D04 52 your_PP$ heart_NN and_CC with_IN all_ABN your_PP$ D04 53 soul_NN ._. **'_**' ^ this_DT may_MD seem_VB very_QL good_JJ ,_, but_CC D04 53 there_EX is_BEZ something_PN deficient_JJ ._. D04 54 ^ to_TO love_VB the_ATI Lord_NPT your_PP$ God_NP with_IN all_ABN D04 54 your_PP$ might_NN is_BEZ lacking_VBG (_( \0Deut_NP 6_CD ._. D04 55 5_CD ._. )_) ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ this_DT lack_NN of_IN vision_NN D04 55 that_WPR may_MD make_VB us_PP1OS fail_VB ._. ^ and_CC without_IN D04 56 visionary_JJ power_NN the_ATI people_NNS will_MD perish_VB ._. ^ but_CC D04 56 nature_NN will_MD at_RB first_RB" not_XNOT D04 57 interfere_VB ._. ^ *'_*' that_CS I_PP1A will_MD give_VB you_PP2 the_ATI D04 57 rain_NN of_IN your_PP$ land_NN in_IN its_PP$ due_JJ D04 58 season_NN ,_, the_ATI first_OD rain_NN and_CC the_ATI latter_AP rain_NN D04 58 ,_, **'_**' but_CC the_ATI consequence_NN D04 59 will_MD be_BE *'_*' that_CS thou_PP2 mayest_MD gather_VB in_IN thy_PP$ D04 59 corn_NN ,_, and_CC thy_PP$ wine_NN ,_, D04 60 and_CC thine_PP$ oil_NN ._. **'_**' ^ under_IN such_ABL conditions_NNS D04 60 without_IN putting_VBG your_PP$ mind_NN D04 61 together_RB we_PP1AS can_MD not_XNOT solve_VB the_ATI further_JJB D04 61 summons_NN of_IN destiny_NN ,_, to_TO solve_VB the_ATI D04 62 economic_JJ problems_NNS ._. ^ hence_RB says_VBZ Rabbi_NPT Simeon_NP D04 62 ben_&FW Jochai_NP (_( Tanis_NP 6a_CD )_) D04 63 *'_*' if_CS Israel_NP does_DOZ not_XNOT fulfil_VB the_ATI wish_NN of_IN D04 63 the_ATI Lord_NPT ,_, failing_VBG to_TO serve_VB the_ATI D04 64 Lord_NPT God_NP with_IN all_ABN their_PP$ visionary_JJ power_NN ,_, D04 64 the_ATI work_NN will_MD have_HV to_TO be_BE done_VBN D04 65 by_IN each_DT individual_NN **'_**' ._. ^ they_PP3AS will_MD not_XNOT D04 65 work_VB in_IN union_NN ._. ^ if_CS physical_JJ D04 66 power_NN ,_, spiritual_JJ power_NN and_CC visionary_JJ power_NN is_BEZ D04 66 not_XNOT united_VBN ,_, man_NN will_MD D04 67 remain_VB in_IN his_PP$ heart_NN selfish_JJ and_CC think_VB only_RB D04 67 of_IN one's_CD1$ personal_JJ D04 68 advantage_NN to_TO gratify_VB selfish_JJ aims_NNS ,_, then_RN each_DT D04 68 man_NN will_MD gather-in_VB for_IN D04 69 himself_PPL only_RB ,_, instead_RB of_IN all_ABN to_TO help_VB to_TO D04 69 gather_VB your_PP$ corn_NN ,_, your_PP$ wine_NN D04 70 and_CC your_PP$ oil_NN ._. ^ freedom_NN from_IN want_NN can_MD not_XNOT D04 70 be_BE fulfilled_VBN nor_CC freedom_NN from_IN D04 71 fear_NN ,_, fear_NN of_IN starvation_NN in_IN the_ATI midst_NN of_IN D04 71 plenty_NN ._. ^ help_NN will_MD not_XNOT be_BE D04 72 easily_RB forthcoming_JJ for_IN the_ATI people_NNS in_IN need_NN ._. ^ D04 72 they_PP3AS will_MD think_VB of_IN the_ATI D04 73 animals_NNS first_RB (_( which_WDTR is_BEZ of_RB course_RB" our_PP$ D04 73 duty_NN )_) ._. ^ of_RB course_RB" the_ATI individual_NN D04 74 will_MD eat_VB and_CC be_BE full_JJ but_CC :_: ~ *'_*' take_VB heed_NN D04 74 to_IN yourself_PPL ,_, that_CS your_PP$ heart_NN be_BE D04 75 not_XNOT deceived_VBN ,_, and_CC ye_PP2 turn_VB aside_RP ,_, and_CC D04 75 serve_VB other_AP gods_NNS ,_, and_CC worship_VB D04 76 them_PP3OS **'_**' ,_, the_ATI yourself_PPL is_BEZ thy_PP$ greatest_JJT D04 76 enemy_NN ,_, the_ATI self-seeking_JJ self_NN ._. D04 77 ^ and_CC you_PP2 serve_VB Mammon_NP and_CC God_NP ._. ^ and_CC you_PP2 D04 77 can_MD not_XNOT serve_VB two_CD masters_NNS ,_, and_CC D04 78 you_PP2 worship_VB self-interest_NN ,_, isolating_VBG yourself_PPL ,_, D04 78 under_IN such_ABL conditions_NNS D04 79 the_ATI goods_NNS are_BER your_PP$ gods_NNS ._. ^ *'_*' and_CC then_RN D04 79 the_ATI Lord's_NPT$ wrath_NN be_BE kindled_VBN D04 80 against_IN you_PP2 ,_, and_CC he_PP3A shut_VB up_RP the_ATI heavens_NNS D04 80 ,_, that_CS there_EX is_BEZ no_ATI rain_NN ,_, and_CC D04 81 that_CS the_ATI land_NN yield_VB not_XNOT her_PP$ fruit_NN and_CC D04 81 lest_CS ye_PP2 perish_VB quickly_RB from_IN D04 82 off_IN the_ATI good_JJ land_NN which_WDTR the_ATI Lord_NPT giveth_VBZ D04 82 you_PP2 ._. **'_**' ^ for_CS without_IN the_ATI D04 83 vision_NN to_TO serve_VB the_ATI Lord_NPT your_PP$ God_NP with_IN D04 83 all_ABN your_PP$ heart_NN and_CC with_IN all_ABN D04 84 your_PP$ soul_NN and_CC with_IN all_ABN your_PP$ might_NN the_ATI D04 84 problem_NN of_IN life_NN can_MD not_XNOT be_BE D04 85 solved_VBN ._. D04 86 ^ *'_*' therefore_RB shall_MD ye_PP2 lay_VB up_RP these_DTS my_PP$ D04 86 words_NNS in_IN your_PP$ heart_NN and_CC in_IN D04 87 your_PP$ soul_NN ._. **'_**' ^ the_ATI text_NN adds_VBZ and_CC in_IN D04 87 your_PP$ soul_NN ,_, searching_VBG your_PP$ soul_NN ._. D04 88 ^ and_CC the_ATI sequence_NN in_IN the_ATI text_NN is_BEZ different_JJ D04 88 than_CS in_IN the_ATI first_OD part_NN of_IN D04 89 the_ATI Shmah_NP ,_, we_PP1AS have_HV first_RB *'_*' and_CC to_TO D04 89 bind_VB them_PP3OS for_IN a_AT sign_NN upon_IN your_PP$ hand_NN ,_, D04 90 that_CS they_PP3AS may_MD be_BE as_IN frontlets_NNS between_IN your_PP$ D04 90 eyes_NNS ._. **'_**' ^ first_RB to_TO bind_VB D04 91 them_PP3OS to_TO have_HV the_ATI vision_NN and_CC then_RN ^ *'_*' D04 91 and_CC ye_PP2 shall_MD teach_VB them_PP3OS to_IN your_PP$ D04 92 children_NNS ._. **'_**' ^ and_CC as_CS we_PP1AS have_HV gone_VBN D04 92 through_IN the_ATI mill_NN ,_, we_PP1AS need_MD not_XNOT teach_VB D04 93 them_PP3OS to_IN the_ATI children_NNS any_RB more_QL diligently_RB D04 93 and_CC the_ATI children_NNS will_MD grasp_VB D04 94 now_RN what_WDT will_MD befall_VB them_PP3OS without_IN visionary_JJ D04 94 power_NN ._. D04 95 ^ and_CC we_PP1AS will_MD nail_VB the_ATI divine_JJ law_NN on_IN D04 95 the_ATI door_NN posts_NNS of_IN the_ATI house_NN D04 96 and_CC upon_IN the_ATI gates_NNS ._. D04 97 ^ the_ATI reward_NN ._. D04 98 ^ *'_*' that_CS your_PP$ days_NNS may_MD be_BE multiplied_VBN and_CC D04 98 the_ATI days_NNS of_IN your_PP$ D04 99 children_NNS in_IN the_ATI land_NN ,_, which_WDTR the_ATI Lord_NPT D04 99 swear_VBD unto_IN your_PP$ father_NN to_TO give_VB D04 100 them_PP3OS ,_, as_IN days_NNS of_IN heaven_NN on_IN earth_NN D04 101 ._. **'_**' ^ that_DT means_VBZ the_ATI kingdom_NN of_IN D04 101 messianic_JJ righteousness_NN (_( Talmud_NP D04 102 \0Sanh_NP 99A_CD )_) ._. D04 104 ^ the_ATI Messusah_NP ,_, which_WDTR is_BEZ nailed_VBN on_IN the_ATI D04 104 doorposts_NNS contains_VBZ those_DTS two_CD D04 105 lessons_NNS ._. D04 106 ^ the_ATI third_OD lesson_NN of_IN the_ATI Shmah_NP (_( Numbers_NP D04 106 15_CD ,_, 37-41_CD-CD )_) is_BEZ called_VBN D04 107 *'_*' the_ATI going-out_NN of_IN the_ATI land_NN of_IN Egypt_NP **'_**' D04 107 ._. ^ it_PP3 starts_VBZ with_IN the_ATI story_NN D04 108 of_IN the_ATI fringes_NNS the_ATI *'_*' tsitsits_&FW **'_**' ._. D04 109 ^ this_DT lesson_NN used_VBD to_TO be_BE read_VBN only_RB in_IN D04 109 the_ATI morning_NN ._. ^ and_CC the_ATI Talmud_NP D04 110 tells_VBZ a_AT story_NN ,_, which_WDTR is_BEZ also_RB in_IN the_ATI D04 110 Hagadah_NP that_CS Rabbi_NPT Eleasar_NP ben_&FW D04 111 Assarja_NP said_VBD ,_, ~ *'_*' I_PP1A am_BEM nearly_RB seventy_CD D04 111 and_CC I_PP1A had_HVD not_XNOT succeeded_VBN that_CS D04 112 people_NNS should_MD read_VB *'_*' the_ATI going_NN out_RP of_IN D04 112 Egypt_NP **'_**' the_ATI passage_NN Numbers_NP 15_CD ,_, D04 113 37-41_CD-CD ,_, by_IN night_NN **'_**' ,_, because_CS the_ATI D04 113 fringes_NNS (_( tsitsits_&FW )_) are_BER only_RB used_VBN in_IN D04 114 the_ATI day_NN ;_; till_CS Ben_NP Zoma_NP came_VBD and_CC explained_VBD D04 114 the_ATI verse_NN (_( \0Deut_NP 16_CD ,_, 3_CD )_) D04 115 *'_*' that_CS thou_PP2 mayest_MD remember_VB the_ATI day_NN when_WRB D04 115 thou_PP2 camest_VBD forth_RP out_RP D04 116 of_IN the_ATI land_NN of_IN Egypt_NP all_ABN the_ATI days_NNS of_IN D04 116 thy_PP$ life_NN ._. **'_**' ^ Ben_NP Zoma_NP said_VBD :_: D04 117 ^ *'_*' the_ATI days_NNS of_IN thy_PP$ life_NN means_VBZ in_IN the_ATI D04 117 day-time_NN ;_; all_ABN the_ATI days_NNS of_IN thy_PP$ D04 118 life_NN means_VBZ even_RB at_IN night-time_NN ._. **'_**' ^ (_( D04 118 Berochoth_NP ._. )_) ^ and_CC the_ATI Rabbis_NPTS D04 119 thought_VBD it_PP3 important_JJ that_CS when_WRB we_PP1AS read_VB D04 119 the_ATI Shmah_NP *'_*' to_TO be_BE willing_JJ to_TO D04 120 hear_VB ,_, **'_**' we_PP1AS should_MD remember_VB the_ATI great_JJ D04 120 deliverance_NN :_: Passover_NP and_CC its_PP$ D04 121 connection_NN with_IN the_ATI fringes_NNS (_( the_ATI tsitsits_&FW )_) D04 121 ._. D04 122 ^ the_ATI tsitsits_&FW and_CC the_ATI Hagadah_NP ._. D04 123 ^ and_CC the_ATI tsitsits_&FW had_HVD a_AT message_NN sealed_VBN D04 123 inside_IN the_ATI knots_NNS just_RB as_CS D04 124 there_EX is_BEZ a_AT message_NN sealed_VBN in_IN the_ATI four_CD D04 124 emblems_NNS which_WDTR are_BER used_VBN on_IN D04 125 Passover_NP ,_, to_TO depict_VB the_ATI *'_*' time_NN of_IN our_PP$ D04 125 freedom_NN **'_**' ._. ^ and_CC they_PP3AS are_BER (_( 1_CD1 )_) D04 126 Matzo_NP ;_; (_( 2_CD )_) bitter_JJ herbs_NNS ;_; (_( 3_CD )_) D04 126 salt-water_NN and_CC charauses_&FW (_( a_AT kind_NN of_IN fruit_NN D04 127 mixture_NN in_IN likeness_NN of_IN the_ATI appearance_NN of_IN D04 127 mortar_NN )_) ;_; and_CC (_( 4_CD )_) an_AT attitude_NN D04 128 to_TO lean_VB back_RP ._. D04 129 ^ (_( 1_CD1 )_) ._. ^ Matzos_NPS is_BEZ deficient_JJ bread_NN ,_, D04 129 (_( lechem_&FW anjo_&FW in_IN Hebrew_NNP )_) ,_, D04 130 so_RB are_BER we_PP1AS deficient_JJ without_IN spiritual_JJ D04 130 knowledge_NN ,_, and_CC to_TO cure_VB our_PP$ D04 131 mental_JJ incapacity_NN we_PP1AS should_MD be_BE willing_JJ to_TO D04 131 learn_VB ._. ^ education_NN is_BEZ always_RB D04 132 the_ATI most_QL important_JJ task_NN ._. ^ education_NN gives_VBZ :_: D04 132 freedom_NN of_IN speech_NN ._. D04 133 ^ (_( 2_CD )_) ._. ^ bitter_JJ herbs_NNS symbolises_VBZ the_ATI D04 133 bitterness_NN that_WPR is_BEZ hurled_VBN D04 134 against_IN us_PP1OS ._. ^ we_PP1AS eat_VB it_PP3 ._. ^ we_PP1AS D04 134 accept_VB it_PP3 ,_, to_TO show_VB we_PP1AS have_HV self-control_NN D04 135 and_CC that_CS God_NP dwells_VBZ within_IN us_PP1OS ._. ^ D04 135 self-control_NN gives_VBZ us_PP1OS :_: freedom_NN to_TO D04 136 worship_VB God_NP ._. D04 137 ^ (_( 3_CD )_) ._. ^ salt_JJ water_NN and_CC charauses_&FW :_: D04 137 the_ATI salt-water_NN at_IN the_ATI D04 138 seder-table_NN represents_VBZ the_ATI covenant_NN of_IN the_ATI D04 138 Torah_NP (_( melach_&FW brith_&FW D04 139 elohecho_&FW in_IN Hebrew_NNP ,_, salt_NN is_BEZ the_ATI covenant_NN D04 139 of_IN thy_PP$ God_NP ,_, \0Levit_NP 2_CD ,_, D04 140 13_CD ._. )_) ^ salt_NN preserves_VBZ and_CC we_PP1AS should_MD have_HV D04 140 this_DT salt_NN in_IN ourselves_PPLS and_CC D04 141 have_HV peace_NN with_IN one-another_PPLS ._. ^ and_CC the_ATI sweet_JJ D04 141 mortar_NN (_( the_ATI charauses_&FW D04 142 in_IN Hebrew_NNP )_) that_WPR binds_VBZ all_ABN the_ATI *'_*' D04 142 hard-facts_NNS **'_**' together_RB and_CC explains_VBZ D04 143 them_PP3OS ,_, represents_VBZ the_ATI oral_JJ tradition_NN ._. ^ D04 143 we_PP1AS dip_VB into_IN both_ABX ,_, at_IN the_ATI seder_NN ._. D04 144 ^ and_CC we_PP1AS want_VB to_TO understand_VB more_AP of_IN the_ATI D04 144 Torah_NP and_CC the_ATI oral_JJ tradition_NN ,_, D04 145 our_PP$ inheritance_NN ._. ^ living_VBG the_ATI life_NN of_IN the_ATI D04 145 Torah_NP (_( *'_*' dipping-in_NN **'_**' )_) makes_VBZ D04 146 us_PP1OS meek_JJ :_: ^ *'_*' but_CC the_ATI meek_JJ shall_MD inherit_VB D04 146 the_ATI earth_NN ;_; and_CC shall_MD delight_VB D04 147 themselves_PPLS in_IN the_ATI abundance_NN of_IN peace_NN **'_**' (_( D04 147 psalm_NN 37_CD ,_, 11_CD )_) ._. ^ that_DT gives_VBZ us_PP1OS D04 148 freedom_NN from_IN want_NN ._. D04 149 ^ (_( 4_CD )_) ._. ^ we_PP1AS lean_VB back_RP on_IN the_ATI D04 149 seder-night_NN ,_, that_DT symbolises_VBZ we_PP1AS are_BER D04 150 unafraid_JJ ,_, for_CS we_PP1AS are_BER Israel_NP ,_, the_ATI D04 150 overcomer_NN ,_, the_ATI suffering_JJ servant_NN ,_, D04 151 *'_*' who_WPR will_MD leaven_VB the_ATI whole_JJ lump_NN **'_**' ,_, D04 151 chosen_VBN from_IN all_ABN the_ATI nations_NNS ,_, and_CC D04 152 we_PP1AS realise_VB that_CS all_ABN mankind_NN are_BER God's_NP$ D04 152 children_NNS ._. ^ that_DT gives_VBZ us_PP1OS freedom_NN D04 153 from_IN fear_NN ._. D04 154 ^ these_DTS four_CD emblems_NNS are_BER the_ATI substance_NN of_IN D04 154 the_ATI Passover_NP and_CC these_DTS D04 155 four_CD symbols_NNS are_BER also_RB the_ATI four_CD ways_NNS of_IN D04 155 interpreting_VBG the_ATI Torah_NP ._. D04 156 ^ (_( 1_CD1 )_) Matzo_NP represents_VBZ Peshat_NP ;_; (_( 2_CD )_) D04 156 Moraur_NP represents_VBZ Remez_NP ;_; (_( 3_CD )_) D04 157 dipping-in_NN represents_VBZ Derush_NP ;_; (_( 4_CD )_) leaning-back_NN D04 157 represents_VBZ Saud_NP ._. ^ (_( this_DT D04 158 is_BEZ the_ATI pardus_&FW ._. )_) ^ matzo_NN represents_VBZ the_ATI D04 158 literal_JJ meaning_NN of_IN Pesach_NP D04 159 which_WDTR is_BEZ called_VBN :_: the_ATI feast_NN of_IN Matzos_NPS ._. ^ D04 159 the_ATI bitter-herbs_NNS represent_VB the_ATI D04 160 spiritual_JJ principle_NN and_CC this_DT gives_VBZ us_PP1OS *'_*' a_AT D04 160 wink_NN **'_**' (_( Remez_NP )_) how_WRB to_TO live_VB D04 161 and_CC accept_VB all_ABN the_ATI bitterness_NN that_WPR is_BEZ D04 161 hurled_VBN against_IN us_PP1OS ._. ^ the_ATI D04 162 salt-water_NN and_CC the_ATI sweet_JJ mortar_NN in_IN which_WDTR D04 162 we_PP1AS dip-in_VB represents_VBZ the_ATI D04 163 richness_NN of_IN the_ATI law_NN and_CC that_CS we_PP1AS should_MD D04 163 immerse_VB into_IN it_PP3 ._. ^ leaning_VBG back_RP D04 164 carries_VBZ the_ATI concealed_JJ message_NN ._. D04 165 ^ and_CC we_PP1AS start_VB the_ATI seder_NN showing_VBG the_ATI D04 165 Matzos_NPS ,_, that_CS they_PP3AS represent_VB D04 166 the_ATI *'_*' bread_NN of_IN poverty_NN **'_**' which_WDTR our_PP$ D04 166 fore-fathers_NNS were_BED eating_VBG in_IN D04 167 Mitzrajim_NP ,_, to_TO show_VB they_PP3AS were_BED willing_JJ to_TO D04 167 learn_VB ;_; and_CC we_PP1AS invite_VB anybody_PN D04 168 who_WPR wishes_VBZ to_TO partake_VB in_IN our_PP$ discussions_NNS ,_, D04 168 saying_VBG :_: D04 169 ^ *'_*' anybody_PN who_WPR is_BEZ hungry_JJ ,_, let_VB him_PP3O D04 169 come_VB and_CC eat_VB ,_, D04 170 anybody_PN who_WPR is_BEZ thirsty_JJ ,_, let_VB him_PP3O come_VB D04 170 and_CC drink_VB ._. **'_**' D04 171 ^ and_CC we_PP1AS want_VB all_ABN to_TO eat_VB and_CC drink_VB D04 171 his_PP$ great_JJ philosophy_NN of_IN the_ATI four_CD D04 172 ways_NNS of_IN Israel's_NP$ redemption_NN ._. D04 173 ^ hence_RB *'_*' four_CD questions_NNS **'_**' ,_, which_WDTR D04 173 are_BER really_RB interrogations_NNS to_TO D04 174 examine_VB into_IN the_ATI principles_NNS of_IN the_ATI four_CD D04 174 redemptions_NNS are_BER asked_VBN at_IN the_ATI D04 175 seder-evening_NN about_IN these_DTS *'_*' four_CD symbols_NNS **'_**' D04 175 (_( the_ATI manishtano_&FW )_) ._. D04 176 ^ and_CC the_ATI person_NN who_WPR asks_VBZ these_DTS questions_NNS D04 176 is_BEZ seeking_VBG the_ATI opinion_NN of_IN D04 177 the_ATI one_CD1 who_WPR is_BEZ conducting_VBG the_ATI seder_NN ._. D04 178 ^ and_CC we_PP1AS answer_VB ,_, that_CS the_ATI Lord_NPT our_PP$ D04 178 God_NP gave_VBD us_PP1OS *'_*' four_CD freedoms_NNS D04 179 **'_**' without_IN which_WDTR society_NN can_MD not_XNOT make_VB D04 179 progress_NN ._. D04 180 ^ and_CC we_PP1AS drink_VB *'_*' four_CD cups_NNS **'_**' to_TO D04 180 thank_VB the_ATI Lord_NPT our_PP$ God_NP for_IN the_ATI D04 181 *'_*' four_CD freedoms_NNS **'_**' which_WDTR are_BER divine_JJ ._. D04 182 ^ there_EX are_BER four_CD ways_NNS of_IN redemption_NN :_: D04 183 ^ (_( 1_CD1 )_) ._. ^ I_PP1A will_MD bring_VB you_PP2 out_RP from_IN D04 183 under_IN the_ATI burdens_NNS of_IN Egypt_NP ._. D04 184 ^ (_( 2_CD )_) ._. ^ I_PP1A will_MD rid_VB you_PP2 of_IN their_PP$ D04 184 bondage_NN ._. D04 185 ^ (_( 3_CD )_) ._. ^ I_PP1A will_MD redeem_VB you_PP2 ._. D04 186 ^ (_( 4_CD )_) ._. ^ I_PP1A will_MD take_VB you_PP2 to_IN me_PP1O D04 186 for_IN a_AT people_NN ._. D04 187 ^ (_( 1_CD1 )_) ._. ^ I_PP1A will_MD bring_VB you_PP2 out_RP from_IN D04 187 under_IN the_ATI burdens_NNS of_IN Egypt_NP :_: D04 188 ^ how_WRB was_BEDZ it_PP3 that_CS Israel_NP was_BEDZ brought_VBN out_RP D04 188 from_IN under_IN the_ATI burdens_NNS of_IN D04 189 Egypt_NP ?_? ^ because_CS ,_, they_PP3AS kept_VBD the_ATI Passover_NP D04 189 and_CC they_PP3AS were_BED eating_VBG Matzos_NPS in_IN D04 190 Egypt_NP and_CC the_ATI *'_*' feast_NN of_IN Matzos_NPS **'_**' D04 190 was_BEDZ known_VBN even_RB to_IN Abraham_NP and_CC Lot_NP ._. D04 191 ^ (_( \0Gen_NP Rashi_NP 19_CD ,_, 3_CD ._. )_) D05 2 ^ Hooker_NP ,_, arguing_VBG that_CS human_JJ reason_NN and_CC common_JJ D05 2 sense_NN were_BED to_TO have_HV D05 3 their_PP$ place_NN alongside_IN the_ATI Bible_NP and_CC Church_NPL D05 3 authority_NN ,_, poured_VBD D05 4 sanctified_JJ oil_NN on_IN troubled_JJ waters_NNS ._. ^ there_EX D05 4 were_BED plenty_NN of_IN D05 5 cross-currents_NNS in_IN those_DTS waters_NNS and_CC clergy_NNS who_WPR D05 5 would_MD solemnly_RB have_HV D05 6 proclaimed_VBN their_PP$ loyalty_NN to_IN that_DT prayer_NN book_NN D05 6 found_VBD as_QL many_AP ways_NNS of_IN D05 7 interpreting_VBG that_DT loyalty_NN as_CS they_PP3AS do_DO to-day_NR D05 7 ._. ^ many_AP such_ABL men_NNS would_MD find_VB D05 8 they_PP3AS could_MD conscientiously_RB remain_VB in_IN this_DT D05 8 comprehensive_JJ Church_NPL ._. ^ but_CC D05 9 for_IN some_DTI of_IN them_PP3OS the_ATI path_NN must_MD end_VB in_IN D05 9 schism_NN ._. D05 10 ^ by_IN that_DT time_NN ,_, however_RB ,_, the_ATI Anglican_JNP D05 10 prayer_NN book_NN ,_, suppressed_VBN D05 11 though_CS it_PP3 would_MD be_BE ,_, would_MD have_HV become_VBN D05 11 indigenous_JJ ._. ^ and_CC would_MD have_HV been_BEN D05 12 the_ATI primer_NN of_IN saints_NNS *-_*- Lancelot_NP Andrewes_NP ,_, D05 12 George_NP Herbert_NP ,_, Jeremy_NP D05 13 Taylor_NP ,_, Margaret_NP Godolphin_NP ,_, and_CC so_QL many_AP D05 13 others_APS ._. D05 14 ^ the_ATI new_JJ century_NN opened_VBD with_IN James_NP 1_CD1 D05 14 ascending_VBG the_ATI throne_NN ._. ^ he_PP3A D05 15 was_BEDZ quite_RB prepared_VBN to_TO be_BE tolerant_JJ towards_IN D05 15 Rome_NP though_CS the_ATI gunpowder_NN D05 16 plot_NN spoiled_VBD that_DT ._. ^ the_ATI puritans_NNS had_HVD high_JJ D05 16 hopes_NNS ,_, for_CS James_NP had_HVD grown_VBN D05 17 up_RP in_IN Presbyterian_JNP Scotland_NP ,_, but_CC those_DTS hopes_NNS D05 17 were_BED dashed_VBN ._. ^ true_JJ ,_, a_AT new_JJ D05 18 prayer_NN book_NN was_BEDZ issued_VBN in_IN 1604_CD but_CC the_ATI D05 18 puritans_NNS derived_VBN little_AP comfort_NN D05 19 from_IN it_PP3 ._. ^ they_PP3AS objected_VBD to_IN the_ATI word_NN D05 19 absolution_NC ._. ^ so_RB the_ATI phrase_NN *'_*' or_CC D05 20 the_ATI remission_NN of_IN sins_NNS **'_**' was_BEDZ added_VBN ._. ^ D05 20 but_CC absolution_NC remained_VBD ._. ^ they_PP3AS D05 21 objected_VBD to_IN the_ATI word_NN confirmation_NC ._. ^ so_RB the_ATI D05 21 phrase_NN *'_*' or_CC the_ATI laying_NN on_RP D05 22 of_IN hands_NNS upon_IN children_NNS baptized_VBN and_CC able_JJ to_TO D05 22 render_VB an_AT account_NN of_IN their_PP$ D05 23 faith_NN according_IN to_IN" the_ATI catechism_NN following_VBG **'_**' D05 23 were_BED added_VBN ._. ^ but_CC D05 24 confirmation_NC remained_VBD ._. ^ other_AP changes_NNS in_IN the_ATI D05 24 book_NN were_BED equally_RB minor_JJ D05 25 except_IN for_IN" the_ATI new_JJ section_NN on_IN the_ATI D05 25 sacraments_NNS added_VBN to_IN the_ATI catechism_NN ._. D05 26 ^ this_DT indicated_VBD how_WRB ephemeral_JJ in_IN the_ATI Church_NPL D05 26 had_HVD been_BEN the_ATI mood_NN which_WDTR D05 27 produced_VBD the_ATI black_JJ rubric_NN ,_, for_CS it_PP3 says_VBZ D05 27 that_CS *'_*' the_ATI body_NN and_CC blood_NN of_IN D05 28 Christ_NP ,_, which_WDTR are_BER verily_RB and_CC indeed_RB taken_VBN D05 28 and_CC received_VBN by_IN the_ATI faithful_JJ D05 29 in_IN the_ATI Lord's_NPT$ supper_NN ._. **'_**' D05 30 ^ it_PP3 could_MD hardly_RB be_BE more_QL definite_JJ ._. D05 31 ^ it_PP3 was_BEDZ at_IN this_DT time_NN ,_, too_RB ,_, that_CS D05 31 King_NPT James_NP made_VBD himself_PPL immortal_JJ D05 32 by_IN becoming_VBG associated_VBN with_IN a_AT Bible_NP translation_NN D05 32 *-_*- the_ATI authorized_JJ D05 33 version_NN (_( which_WDTR was_BEDZ never_RB actually_RB authorized_VBN D05 33 !_! )_) ._. ^ in_IN that_DT year_NN D05 34 Shakespeare_NP had_HVD just_RB turned_VBN forty_CD and_CC had_HVD D05 34 written_VBN Hamlet_NP two_CD years_NNS D05 35 before_RI ._. ^ Bacon_NP was_BEDZ at_IN work_NN and_CC Milton_NP D05 35 was_BEDZ just_RB learning_VBG to_TO read_VB ._. D05 36 ^ James_NP was_BEDZ followed_VBN by_IN Charles_NP ,_, in_IN D05 36 whose_WP$R reign_NN came_VBD the_ATI Scottish_JNP D05 37 prayer_NN book_NN in_IN 1637_CD ._. ^ significantly_RB this_DT made_VBD D05 37 a_AT deliberate_JJ return_NN to_IN D05 38 the_ATI book_NN of_IN 1549_CD and_CC became_VBD the_ATI foster_JJB D05 38 mother_NN of_IN some_DTI of_IN the_ATI most_QL D05 39 important_JJ prayer_NN books_NNS in_IN the_ATI Anglican_JNP D05 39 communion_NN ._. D05 40 ^ forever_RB associated_VBN with_IN Charles_NP is_BEZ Archbishop_NPT D05 40 Laud_NP ,_, now_RN so_QL much_RB D05 41 nobler_JJR a_AT figure_NN than_CS former_AP historians_NNS led_VBD D05 41 us_PP1OS to_TO believe_VB ._. ^ Laud_NP was_BEDZ D05 42 enthusiastically_RB hated_VBN by_IN Calvinists_NNPS and_CC puritans_NNS D05 42 ,_, and_CC the_ATI sentiment_NN D05 43 was_BEDZ mutual_JJ ._. ^ but_CC Laud_NP was_BEDZ no_ATI Romanizer_NNP D05 43 ._. ^ one_CD1 of_IN his_PP$ first_OD public_JJ acts_NNS D05 44 was_BEDZ a_AT hard-hitting_JJ battle_NN with_IN the_ATI Jesuit_NNP ,_, D05 44 Fisher_NP ._. ^ but_CC anyone_PN who_WPR was_BEDZ D05 45 friendly_JJ with_IN James_NP and_CC Charles_NP ,_, the_ATI puritans_NNS D05 45 argued_VBD ,_, was_BEDZ necessarily_RB D05 46 a_AT menace_NN ._. ^ all_ABN Laud's_NP$ statements_NNS in_IN favour_NN D05 46 of_IN a_AT Church_NPL both_ABX catholic_JJ D05 47 and_CC reformed_JJ ,_, all_ABN the_ATI many_AP evidences_NNS that_CS D05 47 Laud_NP fully_RB represented_VBD the_ATI D05 48 heart_NN of_IN the_ATI English_JNP reformation_NN in_IN his_PP$ D05 48 beliefs_NNS ,_, meant_VBD nothing_PN to_IN D05 49 those_DTS who_WPR had_HVD drunk_VBN deep_RB at_IN Calvinistic_JNP D05 49 springs_NNS ._. D05 50 ^ Laud_NP was_BEDZ called_VBN upon_IN to_TO do_DO severe_JJ D05 50 things_NNS ._. ^ what_WDT else_RB could_MD an_AT D05 51 archbishop_NN do_DO when_WRB he_PP3A found_VBD that_CS clergy_NNS D05 51 had_HVD lost_VBN interest_NN in_IN their_PP$ D05 52 jobs_NNS ?_? ^ or_CC when_WRB he_PP3A found_VBD cock-fighting_NN D05 52 going_VBG on_RP in_IN church_NN ?_? ^ Laud_NP made_VBD a_AT D05 53 positive_JJ approach_NN ._. ^ he_PP3A set_VBD out_RP to_TO increase_VB D05 53 a_AT sense_NN of_IN reverence_NN ._. ^ the_ATI D05 54 prayer_NN book_NN was_BEDZ to_TO be_BE respected_VBN and_CC so_PN D05 54 was_BEDZ the_ATI office_NN of_IN a_AT bishop_NN ._. D05 55 ^ altars_NNS should_MD be_BE altars_NNS and_CC not_XNOT any_DTI D05 55 broken_JJ down_RP ,_, transportable_JJ table_NN D05 56 which_WDTR was_BEDZ handy_JJ for_IN the_ATI most_QL improbable_JJ D05 56 uses_NNS ._. D05 57 ^ Laud's_NP$ motives_NNS were_BED of_IN the_ATI highest_JJT but_CC D05 57 his_PP$ tact_NN did_DOD not_XNOT match_VB D05 58 them_PP3OS ._. ^ once_CS convinced_VBN he_PP3A was_BEDZ right_JJ ,_, D05 58 he_PP3A was_BEDZ willing_JJ to_TO go_VB to_IN most_AP D05 59 lengths_NNS to_TO establish_VB the_ATI fact_NN ._. ^ and_CC so_RB D05 59 he_PP3A became_VBD hated_VBN ._. ^ and_CC executed_VBN ._. D05 60 ^ and_CC in_IN the_ATI same_AP year_NN ,_, 1644_CD ,_, the_ATI D05 60 prayer_NN book_NN was_BEDZ declared_VBN illegal_JJ *-_*- D05 61 partly_RB on_IN the_ATI ground_NN that_CS it_PP3 had_HVD proved_VBN D05 61 *'_*' an_AT offence_NN to_IN the_ATI reformed_JJ D05 62 Churches_NPLS abroad_RB ._. **'_**' D05 63 ^ the_ATI puritan_JJ leaders_NNS were_BED plotting_VBG (_( though_CS D05 63 they_PP3AS did_DOD not_XNOT use_VB D05 64 colourful_JJ things_NNS like_IN gunpowder_NN in_IN interesting_JJ D05 64 places_NNS like_IN the_ATI Houses_NPLS D05 65 of_IN parliament_NN )_) ._. ^ both_ABX Church_NPL and_CC state_NN D05 65 were_BED their_PP$ target_NN ._. ^ the_ATI D05 66 doctrine_NN of_IN the_ATI divine_JJ right_NN of_IN kings_NNS made_VBD D05 66 the_ATI bull's_NN$ eyes_NNS of_IN these_DTS D05 67 targets_NNS almost_RB indistinguishable_JJ ._. ^ *'_*' no_ATI bishop_NN D05 67 ,_, no_ATI king_NN ,_, **'_**' said_VBD D05 68 James_NP ._. ^ and_CC ~ *'_*' no_ATI king_NN ,_, no_ATI bishop_NN D05 68 **'_**' was_BEDZ the_ATI obvious_JJ implication_NN ._. D05 69 ^ Charles_NP went_VBD even_RB further_RBR and_CC asserted_VBD a_AT D05 69 king_NN could_MD do_DO no_ATI wrong_NN ._. ^ in_IN D05 70 1629_CD he_PP3A dissolved_VBD parliament_NN and_CC announced_VBD D05 70 he_PP3A would_MD govern_VB by_IN royal_JJ D05 71 prerogative_NN ._. ^ there_EX was_BEDZ no_ATI outlet_NN for_IN the_ATI D05 71 expanding_JJ gases_NNS of_IN criticism_NN D05 72 and_CC the_ATI explosion_NN grew_VBD ._. ^ for_IN Scotland_NP the_ATI D05 72 introduction_NN of_IN the_ATI prayer_NN D05 73 book_NN had_HVD been_BEN the_ATI signal_NN ._. ^ in_IN England_NP D05 73 the_ATI puritans'_NNS$ day_NN came_VBD in_IN 1640_CD D05 74 and_CC the_ATI long_JJ parliament_NN began_VBD ._. D05 75 ^ English_JNP churches_NNS suffered_VBD yet_RB another_DT D05 75 despoliation_NN ._. ^ and_CC Evelyn_NP D05 76 the_ATI diarist_NN could_MD record_VB ^ *'_*' another_DT sad_JJ day_NN D05 76 !_! ^ the_ATI church_NN now_RN in_IN caves_NNS D05 77 and_CC dens_NNS of_IN the_ATI earth_NN ._. **'_**' ^ to_TO secure_VB D05 77 such_ABL an_AT end_NN men_NNS like_IN Will_NP Dowsing_NP D05 78 undertook_VBD to_TO smash_VB churches_NNS at_IN 8_CD \0s_NNU 6_CD D05 78 \0d_NNU a_AT time_NN ._. ^ he_PP3A was_BEDZ D05 79 disgusted_JJ in_IN one_CD1 place_NN where_WRB he_PP3A had_HVD only_RB D05 79 3_CD \0s_NNU 4_CD \0d_NNU because_CS D05 80 there_EX were_BED no_ATI more_AP than_IN *'_*' ten_CD superstitious_JJ D05 80 pictures_NNS and_CC a_AT cross_NN **'_**' to_TO D05 81 be_BE destroyed_VBN ._. D05 82 ^ finally_RB ,_, in_IN 1649_CD ,_, Charles_NP was_BEDZ beheaded_VBN D05 82 and_CC a_AT thrill_NN of_IN horror_NN ran_VBD D05 83 through_IN the_ATI country_NN ._. ^ a_AT dead_JJ king_NN and_CC a_AT D05 83 ravaged_JJ faith_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 was_BEDZ these_DTS D05 84 very_AP excesses_NNS which_WDTR sounded_VBD the_ATI death_NN knell_NN D05 84 of_IN the_ATI puritans_NNS as_IN a_AT D05 85 ruling_JJ force_NN ._. D05 86 ^ but_CC we_PP1AS can_MD not_XNOT leave_VB this_DT chapter_NN D05 86 with_IN a_AT picture_NN of_IN unrelieved_JJ D05 87 gloom_NN ._. ^ these_DTS were_BED also_RB the_ATI days_NNS when_WRB D05 87 Lancelot_NP Andrewes_NP was_BEDZ writing_VBG D05 88 his_PP$ preces_&FW privatae_&FW as_IN well_IN" as_IN" being_BEG a_AT D05 88 great_JJ bishop_NN ._. ^ the_ATI D05 89 days_NNS ,_, too_RB ,_, of_IN George_NP Herbert_NP ,_, many_AP of_IN D05 89 whose_WP$R poems_NNS have_HV become_VBN D05 90 much-loved_JJB hymns_NNS ._. ^ it_PP3 was_BEDZ now_RN that_CS John_NP D05 90 Cosin_NP ,_, one_CD1 day_NN to_TO be_BE a_AT bishop_NN ,_, D05 91 was_BEDZ growing_VBG up_RP and_CC preparing_VBG to_TO make_VB a_AT D05 91 major_JJ liturgical_JJ contribution_NN D05 92 as_QL soon_RB as_CS opportunity_NN offered_VBD ._. ^ contemporary_JJ D05 92 with_IN them_PP3OS was_BEDZ Jeremy_NP D05 93 Taylor_NP whose_WP$R holy_JJ living_NN and_CC holy_JJ dying_NN have_HV D05 93 helped_VBN so_QL many_AP to_TO D05 94 achieve_VB those_DTS titles_NNS ._. ^ and_CC it_PP3 was_BEDZ the_ATI D05 94 time_NN when_WRB Nicholas_NP Ferrar_NP was_BEDZ D05 95 making_VBG his_PP$ fascinating_JJ experiments_NNS in_IN Christian_JNP D05 95 community_NN living_VBG at_IN D05 96 Little_NP Gidding_NP ._. D05 97 ^ an_AT interesting_JJ age_NN !_! D05 98 ^ chapter_NN nine_CD ._. D05 99 ^ the_ATI seventeenth-century_JJB sixties_CDS ._. D05 100 ^ no_ATI Christian_NNP can_MD lightly_RB condemn_VB an_AT age_NN D05 100 and_CC a_AT system_NN of_IN D05 101 belief_NN which_WDTR produced_VBD Richard_NP Baxter_NP and_CC the_ATI D05 101 saints'_NNS$ everlasting_JJ D05 102 rest_NN or_CC John_NP Bunyan_NP and_CC pilgrim's_NN$ progress_NN ._. ^ D05 102 it_PP3 was_BEDZ the_ATI same_AP D05 103 age_NN ,_, too_RB ,_, which_WDTR gave_VBD birth_NN to_IN George_NP D05 103 Fox_NP and_CC the_ATI society_NN of_IN friends_NNS ._. D05 104 ^ all_ABN Christendom_NNP has_HVZ surely_RB been_BEN enriched_VBN by_IN D05 104 Fox's_NP$ striving_NN for_IN direct_JJ D05 105 access_NN to_IN God_NP and_CC his_PP$ joy_NN when_WRB he_PP3A felt_VBD D05 105 he_PP3A had_HVD attained_VBN it_PP3 and_CC *'_*' the_ATI D05 106 whole_JJ earth_NN had_HVD a_AT new_JJ smell_NN ._. **'_**' ^ D05 106 political_JJ history_NN ,_, too_RB ,_, must_MD surely_RB D05 107 have_HV been_BEN poorer_JJR without_IN the_ATI particular_JJ concept_NN D05 107 of_IN equality_NN which_WDTR the_ATI D05 108 quakers_NNS were_BED to_TO propagate_VB ._. D05 109 ^ even_RB the_ATI brand_NN image_NN of_IN the_ATI day_NN ,_, D05 109 Cromwell_NP ,_, must_MD remain_VB memorable_JJ D05 110 for_IN many_AP things_NNS other_AP than_IN his_PP$ warts_NNS ._. ^ D05 110 dictator_NN though_CS he_PP3A inevitably_RB D05 111 became_VBD ,_, Cromwell_NP had_HVD no_ATI burning_JJ desire_NN to_TO D05 111 prescribe_VB religious_JJ D05 112 conformity_NN ._. ^ true_JJ ,_, he_PP3A would_MD have_HV no_ATI D05 112 truck_NN with_IN bishops_NNS or_CC a_AT prayer_NN D05 113 book_NN ._. ^ but_CC he_PP3A burned_VBD for_IN the_ATI preaching_NN D05 113 of_IN a_AT pure_JJ word_NN ,_, yearned_VBD for_IN the_ATI D05 114 reform_NN of_IN morals_NNS ,_, and_CC *'_*' gave_VBD England_NP a_AT D05 114 nearer_JJR approach_NN to_IN religious_JJ D05 115 liberty_NN than_CS it_PP3 had_HVD known_VBN ._. **'_**' ^ *'_*' I_PP1A D05 115 meddle_VB not_XNOT with_IN any_DTI man's_NN$ D05 116 conscience_NN ,_, **'_**' he_PP3A said_VBD ._. ^ but_CC there_EX D05 116 were_BED times_NNS when_WRB his_PP$ actions_NNS implied_VBD D05 117 he_PP3A assumed_VBD that_CS Romans_NNPS and_CC Anglicans_NNPS had_HVD D05 117 no_ATI conscience_NN and_CC hence_RB D05 118 needed_VBD his_PP$ strong_JJ treatment_NN ._. ^ and_CC Irishmen_NNPS D05 118 ,_, were_BED ,_, of_RB course_RB" ,_, another_DT D05 119 matter_NN altogether_RB ._. D05 120 ^ there_EX was_BEDZ still_RB so_QL very_QL far_RB to_TO go_VB ._. D05 121 ^ English_JNP people_NNS ,_, for_IN example_NN ,_, did_DOD not_XNOT D05 121 think_VB much_AP of_IN that_DT degree_NN of_IN D05 122 liberty_NN which_WDTR forbade_VBD them_PP3OS to_TO observe_VB D05 122 Christmas_NP day_NN ._. D05 124 *"_*' D05 125 ^ England_NP was_BEDZ merry_JJ England_NP when_WRB D05 126 old_JJ Christmas_NP brought_VBD his_PP$ sports_NNS again_RB ,_, D05 127 **"_**' D05 129 said_VBD Sir_NPT Walter_NP Scott_NP ._. ^ and_CC men_NNS soon_RB D05 129 tired_VBD of_IN those_DTS who_WPR *'_*' hated_VBD D05 130 bear-baiting_NN ,_, not_XNOT because_CS it_PP3 gave_VBD pain_NN to_IN D05 130 the_ATI bear_NN ,_, but_CC because_CS it_PP3 D05 131 gave_VBD pleasure_NN to_IN the_ATI spectators_NNS ,_, **'_**' as_CS D05 131 Macaulay_NP expressed_VBD it_PP3 ._. ^ what_WDT 's_BEZ D05 132 more_AP ,_, people_NNS wanted_VBD God's_NP$ blessing_NN on_IN their_PP$ D05 132 weddings_NNS ._. ^ but_CC only_RB civil_JJ D05 133 marriages_NNS were_BED allowed_VBN ._. ^ the_ATI twenty_CD years_NNS D05 133 of_IN the_ATI commonwealth_NN proved_VBD a_AT D05 134 negative_JJ ,_, inhibiting_JJ experience_NN ._. ^ the_ATI puritans_NNS D05 134 were_BED obsessed_VBN with_IN D05 135 their_PP$ own_AP theological_JJ gloom_NN and_CC snuffed_VBD any_DTI D05 135 tiny_JJ candle_NN of_IN pleasure_NN D05 136 which_WDTR came_VBD within_IN their_PP$ reach_NN ._. ^ they_PP3AS D05 136 went_VBD straight_RB to_IN the_ATI old_JJ D05 137 testament_NN for_IN a_AT religion_NN designed_VBN for_IN doughty_JJ D05 137 desert_NN nomads_NNS ._. D05 138 ^ the_ATI restoration_NN of_IN Church_NPL and_CC King_NPT in_IN D05 138 1660_CD was_BEDZ as_QL much_RB for_IN basic_JJ D05 139 human_JJ reasons_NNS as_CS for_IN ideological_JJ motives_NNS ._. ^ D05 139 it_PP3 was_BEDZ not_XNOT so_QL much_RB because_CS D05 140 Richard_NP Cromwell_NP had_HVD a_AT weak_JJ character_NN as_CS D05 140 because_CS that_DT for_IN which_WDTR he_PP3A D05 141 stood_VBD was_BEDZ ,_, in_IN the_ATI truest_JJT sense_NN of_IN the_ATI D05 141 word_NN ,_, unnatural_JJ ._. ^ Christianity_NNP D05 142 is_BEZ for_IN the_ATI fullness_NN of_IN man_NN ,_, not_XNOT for_IN D05 142 his_PP$ suppression_NN ._. ^ and_CC that_DT was_BEDZ why_WRB D05 143 the_ATI bells_NNS rang_VBD out_RP and_CC bonfires_NNS blazed_VBD as_CS D05 143 Charles_NP came_VBD back_RP ._. D05 144 ^ the_ATI temporary_JJ dalliance_NN with_IN puritanism_NN had_HVD D05 144 shown_VBN that_CS salvation_NN ,_, D05 145 as_CC well_CC" as_CC" joy_NN ,_, lay_VBD elsewhere_RB ._. ^ how_WRB D05 145 much_RB greater_JJR the_ATI pity_NN ,_, then_RN ,_, that_CS D05 146 Charles_NP 2_CD could_MD not_XNOT prove_VB more_QL worthy_JJ on_IN D05 146 taking_VBG up_RP the_ATI crown_NN ._. ^ how_WRB D05 147 unfortunate_JJ that_CS his_PP$ name_NN must_MD remain_VB associated_VBN D05 147 in_IN the_ATI popular_JJ mind_NN D05 148 with_IN Nell_NP Gwynn_NP ,_, oranges_NNS and_CC low_JJ comedy_NN ._. ^ D05 148 and_CC how_WRB sad_JJ that_CS Charles_NP D05 149 should_MD have_HV attempted_VBN the_ATI same_AP sort_NN of_IN D05 149 rigorous_JJ suppression_NN as_CS had_HVD D05 150 disfigured_VBN English_JNP history_NN for_IN so_QL long_RB ._. ^ D05 150 Bunyan_NP and_CC Bedford_NP Gaol_NPL were_BED D05 151 one_CD1 example_NN ._. ^ and_CC there_EX were_BED the_ATI D05 151 conventicle_NN act_NN which_WDTR forbade_VBD D05 152 meetings_NNS for_IN worship_NN where_WRB the_ATI prayer_NN book_NN D05 152 was_BEDZ not_XNOT used_VBN ,_, the_ATI licensing_NN D05 153 act_NN which_WDTR imposed_VBD a_AT rigid_JJ press_NN censorship_NN ,_, D05 153 the_ATI five-mile_JJB act_NN which_WDTR D05 154 made_VBD nonconformist_JJ ministers_NNS wanderers_NNS in_IN the_ATI D05 154 wilderness_NN ,_, and_CC others_APS D05 155 which_WDTR made_VBD notorious_JJ the_ATI name_NN of_IN Clarendon_NP D05 155 and_CC his_PP$ code_NN ._. ^ then_RN there_EX D05 156 was_BEDZ the_ATI test_NN act_NN which_WDTR insisted_VBD that_CS all_ABN D05 156 civil_JJ or_CC military_JJ officers_NNS D05 157 should_MD take_VB the_ATI oath_NN of_IN supremacy_NN and_CC D05 157 allegiance_NN and_CC receive_VB the_ATI holy_JJ D05 158 communion_NN according_IN to_IN" the_ATI Church_NPL of_IN England_NP D05 158 rite_NN ._. D05 159 ^ it_PP3 was_BEDZ such_ABL legalistic_JJ ham-fistedness_NN which_WDTR D05 159 was_BEDZ to_TO make_VB the_ATI life_NN D05 160 of_IN the_ATI Church_NPL of_IN England_NP such_ABL an_AT artificial_JJ D05 160 observance_NN for_IN so_QL many_AP in_IN D05 161 the_ATI following_JJ century_NN ._. ^ and_CC such_ABL a_AT situation_NN D05 161 was_BEDZ imposed_VBN by_IN the_ATI state_NN ,_, D05 162 not_XNOT initiated_VBN by_IN the_ATI Church_NPL ._. D05 163 ^ there_EX is_BEZ so_QL much_AP one_CD1 could_MD condemn_VB about_IN D05 163 these_DTS sixties_CDS of_IN three_CD D05 164 centuries_NNS ago_RB ._. ^ but_CC there_EX is_BEZ so_QL much_AP also_RB D05 164 which_WDTR one_CD1 welcomes_VBZ ,_, not_XNOT D05 165 least_RBT the_ATI 1662_CD prayer_NN book_NN ,_, born_VBN under_IN D05 165 such_ABL strange_JJ portents_NNS ._. ^ we_PP1AS no_RB D05 166 longer_RBR look_VB starry-eyed_JJ and_CC refer_VB to_IN *'_*' this_DT D05 166 incomparable_JJ book_NN ._. **'_**' D05 167 ^ time_NN has_HVZ turned_VBN its_PP$ wheel_NN and_CC prescribed_VBN D05 167 revision_NN as_CS now_RN overdue_JJ ._. D05 168 ^ but_CC we_PP1AS must_MD revise_VB only_RB in_IN the_ATI full_JJ D05 168 awareness_NN of_IN what_WDT this_DT book_NN has_HVZ D05 169 meant_VBN ._. ^ first_RB of_IN all_ABN ,_, however_RB ,_, we_PP1AS D05 169 look_VB at_IN its_PP$ immediate_JJ background_NN ._. D05 170 ^ before_IN Christmas_NP 1660_CD five_CD editions_NNS of_IN the_ATI D05 170 1604_CD book_NN had_HVD been_BEN D05 171 printed_VBN ._. ^ fifteen_CD years_NNS without_IN a_AT prayer_NN D05 171 book_NN had_HVD certainly_RB not_XNOT made_VBN D05 172 people_NNS forget_VB it_PP3 or_CC lose_VB interest_NN in_IN it_PP3 ._. ^ D05 172 but_CC most_AP people_NNS regarded_VBN D05 173 these_DTS reprints_NNS of_IN the_ATI 1604_CD book_NN as_IN a_AT D05 173 stopgap_NN ._. ^ a_AT revision_NN was_BEDZ clearly_RB D05 174 called_VBN for_IN and_CC the_ATI object_NN of_IN that_DT revision_NN D05 174 was_BEDZ clearly_RB expressed_VBN by_IN D05 175 nine_CD bishops_NNS who_WPR were_BED still_RB alive_JJ ._. ^ the_ATI D05 175 nearer_RBR the_ATI forms_NNS *'_*' come_VB to_IN the_ATI D05 176 ancient_JJ liturgy_NN of_IN the_ATI Greek_JNP and_CC Latin_JNP D05 176 Churches_NPLS ,_, the_ATI less_RBR are_BER they_PP3AS D05 177 liable_JJ to_IN the_ATI objections_NNS of_IN the_ATI common_JJ enemy_NN D05 177 ._. **'_**' D05 178 ^ on_IN October_NR 25_CD ,_, 1660_CD ,_, Charles_NP issued_VBD a_AT D05 178 statement_NN calling_VBG a_AT D05 179 conference_NN of_IN all_ABN interested_JJ parties_NNS ._. ^ on_IN D05 179 August_NR 15_CD ,_, 1661_CD ,_, at_IN the_ATI D05 180 Savoy_NP Hospital_NPL ,_, that_DT conference_NN met_VBD ._. ^ to_IN D05 180 it_PP3 came_VBD twelve_CD bishops_NNS D05 181 (_( including_IN John_NP Cosin_NP of_IN Durham_NP ,_, Robert_NP D05 181 Sanderson_NP of_IN Lincoln_NP ,_, and_CC D05 182 Gilbert_NP Sheldon_NP of_IN London_NP )_) and_CC twelve_CD puritan_JJ D05 182 divines_NNS (_( including_IN D05 183 Richard_NP Baxter_NP )_) ._. ^ the_ATI Bishop_NPT of_IN London_NP D05 183 presided_VBD ._. D05 184 ^ as_QL far_RB as_CS the_ATI bishops_NNS were_BED concerned_VBN ,_, D05 184 it_PP3 was_BEDZ obvious_JJ and_CC natural_JJ D05 185 that_CS the_ATI Church's_NPL$ prayer_NN book_NN should_MD be_BE D05 185 restored_VBN ._. ^ the_ATI onus_NN of_IN D05 186 argument_NN was_BEDZ therefore_RB placed_VBN on_IN the_ATI puritans_NNS D05 186 who_WPR had_HVD plenty_NN to_TO say_VB ._. D05 187 ^ practically_RB all_ABN of_IN them_PP3OS wanted_VBD ,_, for_IN D05 187 example_NN ,_, the_ATI surplice_NN ,_, the_ATI sign_NN D05 188 of_IN the_ATI cross_NN in_IN baptism_NN ,_, kneeling_VBG to_TO D05 188 receive_VB the_ATI holy_JJ communion_NN ,_, the_ATI D05 189 season_NN of_IN Lent_NP ,_, and_CC the_ATI use_NN of_IN a_AT ring_NN D05 189 in_IN marriage_NN to_TO be_BE abolished_VBN ._. D05 190 ^ they_PP3AS wanted_VBD prayer_NN to_TO be_BE extemporary_JJ and_CC D05 190 unfettered_JJ ._. ^ there_EX were_BED D05 191 actually_RB puritans_NNS who_WPR took_VBD this_DT principle_NN to_IN D05 191 such_ABL an_AT extreme_NN that_CS they_PP3AS D05 192 described_VBD the_ATI Lord's_NPT$ prayer_NN as_IN a_AT Popish_JNP D05 192 invention_NN !_! ^ the_ATI puritans_NNS D05 193 wanted_VBD Sunday_NR to_TO become_VB the_ATI *'_*' Lord's_NPT$ day_NN D05 193 **'_**' and_CC Sabbatarian_JNP gloom_NN to_TO D05 194 prevail_VB ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ easy_JJ to_TO condemn_VB all_ABN this_DT D05 194 but_CC we_PP1AS must_MD never_RB forget_VB D05 195 their_PP$ very_QL real_JJ zeal_NN for_IN righteousness_NN ._. D05 196 ^ *'_*' had_HVD the_ATI objectors_NNS concentrated_VBD on_IN one_CD1 D05 196 or_CC two_CD points_NNS of_IN real_JJ D05 197 doctrinal_JJ importance_NN ,_, **'_**' says_VBZ Bishop_NPT Moorman_NP D05 197 ,_, *'_*' they_PP3AS might_MD have_HV made_VBN D05 198 some_DTI impression_NN on_IN their_PP$ opponents_NNS ,_, but_CC D05 198 their_PP$ absorption_NN in_IN details_NNS of_IN D05 199 little_AP moment_NN was_BEDZ their_PP$ undoing_NN ._. D05 200 **"_**' D06 2 ^ in_IN the_ATI first_OD place_NN it_PP3 is_BEZ not_XNOT a_AT D06 2 great_JJ deal_NN of_IN use_NN telling_VBG even_RB D06 3 children_NNS ,_, as_CS I_PP1A have_HV already_RB suggested_VBN ,_, D06 3 not_XNOT to_TO be_BE silly_JJ or_CC to_TO pull_VB D06 4 themselves_PPLS together_RB ._. ^ far_RB better_JJR to_TO help_VB D06 4 them_PP3OS to_TO face_VB whatever_WDT it_PP3 is_BEZ D06 5 that_WPR is_BEZ worrying_VBG them_PP3OS ,_, to_TO find_VB the_ATI D06 5 original_JJ cause_NN and_CC then_RN deal_VB with_IN D06 6 it_PP3 ;_; show_VB it_PP3 up_RP either_DTX for_IN the_ATI sham_NN D06 6 it_PP3 is_BEZ *-_*- and_CC many_AP fears_NNS are_BER based_VBN D06 7 upon_IN completely_RB irrational_JJ pre-conceived_JJ notions_NNS *-_*- D06 7 or_CC to_TO show_VB how_WRB we_PP1AS D06 8 may_MD deal_VB with_IN it_PP3 so_TO as_TO" to_TO" remove_VB the_ATI D06 8 power_NN to_TO torment_VB us_PP1OS that_CS it_PP3 seems_VBZ D06 9 to_TO possess_VB ._. D06 10 ^ even_RB worse_JJR is_BEZ to_TO laugh_VB ._. ^ tremendous_JJ D06 10 damage_NN may_MD be_BE done_VBN to_IN a_AT child_NN D06 11 by_IN laughing_VBG at_IN what_WDT are_BER very_QL real_JJ fears_NNS ._. D06 11 ^ as_IN adults_NNS ,_, we_PP1AS know_VB that_CS D06 12 their_PP$ fears_NNS are_BER groundless_JJ ,_, indeed_RB to_IN us_PP1OS D06 12 they_PP3AS appear_VB laughable_JJ ,_, but_CC to_IN D06 13 a_AT child_NN they_PP3AS are_BER very_QL real_JJ ._. ^ not_XNOT that_CS D06 13 I_PP1A am_BEM suggesting_VBG that_CS children_NNS D06 14 should_MD be_BE molly-coddled_VBN *-_*- they_PP3AS must_MD be_BE D06 14 made_VBN to_TO face_VB their_PP$ fears_NNS ,_, to_TO D06 15 see_VB through_IN them_PP3OS and_CC come_VB out_RP on_IN the_ATI D06 15 other_AP side_NN as_IN victors_NNS ._. ^ to_TO D06 16 ridicule_VB them_PP3OS only_RB pushes_VBZ them_PP3OS farther_RBR D06 16 into_IN themselves_PPLS ,_, so_CS that_CS" they_PP3AS D06 17 become_VB unable_JJ to_TO speak_VB about_IN it_PP3 to_IN anybody_PN D06 17 and_CC the_ATI seeds_NNS of_IN any_DTI amount_NN D06 18 of_IN trouble_NN are_BER sown_VBN ,_, the_ATI harvest_NN of_IN D06 18 which_WDTR may_MD still_RB be_BE being_BEG reaped_VBN at_IN D06 19 forty_CD or_CC fifty_CD ._. ^ far_RB better_JJR to_TO agree_VB with_IN D06 19 a_AT child_NN that_CS a_AT particular_JJ D06 20 situation_NN is_BEZ frightening_JJ ,_, and_CC then_RN to_TO face_VB D06 20 it_PP3 together_RB until_CS the_ATI child_NN D06 21 can_MD see_VB how_WRB unnecessary_JJ its_PP$ fears_NNS were_BED ._. D06 22 ^ because_CS situations_NNS which_WDTR may_MD contain_VB all_ABN D06 22 the_ATI elements_NNS of_IN fear_NN can_MD D06 23 arise_VB suddenly_RB ,_, it_PP3 is_BEZ a_AT good_JJ idea_NN to_TO D06 23 condition_VB a_AT child_NN to_IN some_DTI extent_NN D06 24 against_IN it_PP3 ._. ^ to_TO keep_VB a_AT child_NN of_IN twelve_CD D06 24 or_CC thirteen_CD under_IN the_ATI D06 25 impression_NN that_CS nothing_PN nasty_JJ ever_RB happens_VBZ is_BEZ D06 25 not_XNOT merely_RB dishonest_JJ ,_, it_PP3 D06 26 is_BEZ unwise_JJ ._. ^ as_CS I_PP1A shall_MD suggest_VB in_IN a_AT D06 26 later_JJR chapter_NN there_EX are_BER some_DTI D06 27 situations_NNS which_WDTR occur_VB less_QL frequently_RB than_CS D06 27 they_PP3AS did_DOD once_RB ,_, or_CC at_RB least_RB" D06 28 do_DO not_XNOT now_RN arise_VB until_IN a_AT later_JJR period_NN of_IN D06 28 life_NN ,_, but_CC this_DT is_BEZ no_ATI reason_NN D06 29 for_IN leaving_VBG a_AT child_NN in_IN complete_JJ ignorance_NN to_IN D06 29 the_ATI extent_NN of_IN even_RB lying_VBG D06 30 to_IN it_PP3 when_WRB it_PP3 asks_VBZ questions_NNS ._. ^ a_AP D06 30 little_AP" more_AP honesty_NN ,_, even_CS if_CS" one_CD1 D06 31 refrains_VBZ from_IN going_VBG into_IN too_QL many_AP details_NNS ,_, D06 31 would_MD help_VB many_AP a_AT child_NN to_TO D06 32 make_VB a_AT proper_JJ adjustment_NN to_IN life_NN as_CS it_PP3 D06 32 grows_VBZ up_RP ._. D06 33 ^ let_VB us_PP1OS look_VB at_IN Jesus_NP ._. ^ we_PP1AS do_DO D06 33 not_XNOT ,_, I_PP1A think_VB ,_, see_VB there_RN a_AT life_NN D06 34 without_IN fear_NN ._. ^ there_EX are_BER several_AP instances_NNS D06 34 where_WRB he_PP3A seemed_VBD unable_JJ to_TO D06 35 go_VB on_RP ._. ^ in_IN Gethsemane_NP he_PP3A prayed_VBD that_CS D06 35 the_ATI cup_NN should_MD pass_VB from_IN him_PP3O ._. D06 36 ^ Jesus_NP shows_VBZ us_PP1OS the_ATI way_NN to_TO face_VB life_NN D06 36 ._. ^ to_TO see_VB all_ABN the_ATI latent_JJ D06 37 frightening_JJ possibilities_NNS and_CC yet_RB by_IN facing_VBG D06 37 them_PP3OS and_CC knowing_VBG God_NP is_BEZ D06 38 with_IN us_PP1OS and_CC that_CS ,_, with_IN him_PP3O ,_, there_EX D06 38 is_BEZ nothing_PN that_WPR can_MD finally_RB defeat_VB D06 39 us_PP1OS ._. ^ more_AP than_IN that_DT ,_, that_CS God_NP has_HVZ D06 39 something_PN important_JJ to_TO do_DO with_IN our_PP$ D06 40 lives_NNS and_CC that_CS the_ATI nearer_RBR we_PP1AS get_VB to_IN D06 40 him_PP3O ,_, the_ATI stronger_JJR we_PP1AS become_VB ._. D06 42 *"_*' D06 43 ^ ..._... today_NR D06 44 a_AT wonderful_JJ thought_NN D06 45 in_IN the_ATI dawn_NN was_BEDZ given_VBN ..._... D06 46 and_CC the_ATI thought_NN D06 47 was_BEDZ this_DT :_: D06 48 that_CS a_AT secret_JJ plan_NN D06 49 is_BEZ hid_VBN in_IN my_PP$ hand_NN ;_; D06 50 that_CS my_PP$ hand_NN is_BEZ big_JJ D06 51 big_JJ ,_, D06 52 because_IN of_IN" the_ATI plan_NN D06 53 that_WPR God_NP ,_, D06 54 who_WPR dwells_VBZ in_IN my_PP$ hand_NN ,_, D06 55 knows_VBZ this_DT secret_JJ plan_NN ,_, D06 56 of_IN the_ATI things_NNS he_PP3A will_MD do_DO for_IN the_ATI D06 56 world_NN D06 57 using_VBG my_PP$ hand_NN ._. D06 58 **"_**' D06 60 ^ Toyohiko_NP Kagawa_NP ._. D06 61 ^ prayer_NN ._. D06 62 ^ loving_JJ saviour_NN ,_, who_WPR experienced_VBD all_ABN human_JJ D06 62 emotion_NN ,_, and_CC whose_WP$R D06 63 sensitive_JJ nature_NN knows_VBZ better_RBR than_CS we_PP1AS do_DO ,_, D06 63 what_WDT it_PP3 is_BEZ to_TO be_BE really_RB D06 64 afraid_JJ ,_, help_VB us_PP1OS to_TO know_VB that_CS when_WRB we_PP1AS D06 64 face_VB life_NN boldly_RB ,_, many_AP of_IN the_ATI D06 65 shadows_NNS are_BER seen_VBN to_TO be_BE allies_NNS and_CC not_XNOT D06 65 enemies_NNS and_CC that_CS ,_, come_VB what_WDT may_MD ,_, D06 66 we_PP1AS are_BER never_RB alone_JJ when_WRB we_PP1AS are_BER with_IN D06 66 thee_PP2 ._. D06 67 ^ amen_UH ._. D06 68 ^ chapter_NN five_CD ._. D06 69 ^ tiredness_NN ._. D06 70 ^ most_AP people_NNS would_MD probably_RB regard_VB tiredness_NN D06 70 as_IN a_AT purely_RB D06 71 physical_JJ thing_NN ._. ^ the_ATI cure_NN for_IN which_WDTR is_BEZ D06 71 sleep_NN ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ only_RB partly_RB D06 72 true_JJ ._. ^ many_AP people_NNS wake_VB up_RP tired_JJ of_IN a_AT D06 72 morning_NN and_CC no_ATI amount_NN of_IN rest_NN D06 73 seems_VBZ to_TO make_VB any_DTI difference_NN ._. ^ sleep_NN ,_, to_TO D06 73 be_BE effective_JJ ,_, must_MD be_BE of_IN that_DT D06 74 child-like_JJ quality_NN which_WDTR comes_VBZ from_IN innocence_NN ._. ^ D06 74 to_IN others_APS ,_, the_ATI long_JJ D06 75 hours_NNS of_IN the_ATI night_NN bring_VB only_RB a_AT disturbed_JJ D06 75 tossing_NN and_CC turning_NN which_WDTR D06 76 causes_VBZ them_PP3OS to_TO wake_VB feeling_VBG worse_JJR than_CS D06 76 when_WRB they_PP3AS went_VBD to_IN bed_NN ._. D06 77 ^ we_PP1AS may_MD begin_VB to_TO understand_VB this_DT a_RB D06 77 little_RB" better_RBR when_WRB we_PP1AS realize_VB D06 78 that_DT tiredness_NN itself_PPL is_BEZ largely_RB in_IN the_ATI mind_NN D06 78 ._. ^ very_QL few_AP people_NNS ,_, under_IN D06 79 normal_JJ conditions_NNS ,_, work_VB themselves_PPLS to_IN a_AT D06 79 standstill_NN ._. ^ the_ATI mind_NN tires_VBZ D06 80 first_RB and_CC conveys_VBZ the_ATI impression_NN of_IN tiredness_NN D06 80 to_IN the_ATI body_NN ._. D06 81 ^ this_DT can_MD be_BE proved_VBN by_IN noting_VBG the_ATI effect_NN D06 81 of_IN a_AT new_JJ stimulus_NN on_IN D06 82 somebody_PN who_WPR feels_VBZ thoroughly_RB tired_JJ ._. ^ suppose_VB D06 82 a_AT mother_NN has_HVZ news_NN late_RB D06 83 at_IN night_NN that_CS her_PP$ child_NN is_BEZ in_IN danger_NN ._. ^ D06 83 she_PP3A will_MD undertake_VB a_AT journey_NN D06 84 which_WDTR ,_, an_AT hour_NN before_RI ,_, she_PP3A would_MD have_HV D06 84 declared_VBN impossible_JJ ._. ^ even_RB more_QL D06 85 simply_RB ,_, test_VB your_PP$ own_AP reactions_NNS to_IN different_JJ D06 85 situations_NNS ._. ^ there_EX are_BER D06 86 some_DTI which_WDTR bring_VB on_RP an_AT almost_RB immediate_JJ D06 86 feeling_NN of_IN tiredness_NN *-_*- such_IN as_IN" D06 87 when_WRB your_PP$ wife_NN mentions_VBZ the_ATI washing-up_NN *-_*- D06 87 while_CS others_APS ,_, if_CS they_PP3AS refer_VB D06 88 to_IN something_PN you_PP2 like_VB doing_VBG ,_, bring_VB a_AT D06 88 veritable_JJ surge_NN of_IN energy_NN ._. ^ many_AP D06 89 a_AT girl_NN who_WPR is_BEZ *'_*' too_QL tired_JJ to_TO help_VB mum_NN D06 89 **'_**' will_MD later_RBR jump_VB up_RP with_IN no_ATI D06 90 apparent_JJ tiredness_NN at_IN all_ABN when_WRB her_PP$ boy_NN D06 90 friend_NN calls_VBZ and_CC go_VB for_IN a_AT long_JJ D06 91 walk_NN ._. ^ nor_CC is_BEZ she_PP3A necessarily_RB being_BEG D06 91 deceitful_JJ ._. ^ she_PP3A really_RB did_DOD feel_VB D06 92 tired_JJ until_CS the_ATI mind_NN got_VBD the_ATI necessary_JJ D06 92 injection_NN of_IN a_AT fresh_JJ *-_*- and_CC an_AT D06 93 attractive_JJ *-_*- interest_NN !_! D06 94 ^ tiredness_NN has_HVZ ,_, therefore_RB ,_, as_QL much_AP to_TO D06 94 do_DO with_IN our_PP$ mental_JJ state_NN as_CS D06 95 with_IN our_PP$ physical_JJ exhaustion_NN ._. ^ a_AT disturbed_JJ D06 95 mind_NN can_MD bring_VB the_ATI D06 96 healthiest_JJT body_NN to_IN a_AT sense_NN of_IN fatigue_NN ._. ^ D06 96 they_PP3AS wonder_VB why_WRB they_PP3AS get_VB no_ATI D06 97 rest_NN at_IN night_NN ,_, even_CS if_CS" they_PP3AS do_DO sleep_VB ._. D06 97 ^ they_PP3AS drag_VB themselves_PPLS around_RP and_CC D06 98 can_MD become_VB a_AT burden_NN to_IN their_PP$ families_NNS and_CC D06 98 their_PP$ friends_NNS ._. D06 99 ^ any_DTI mental_JJ confusion_NN can_MD cause_VB this_DT and_CC D06 99 the_ATI best_JJT way_NN is_BEZ probably_RB D06 100 to_TO seek_VB advice_NN ._. ^ as_CS we_PP1AS are_BER unable_JJ to_TO D06 100 cure_VB our_PP$ own_AP bodies_NNS if_CS the_ATI cause_NN D06 101 of_IN our_PP$ pain_NN is_BEZ too_QL deep_RB seated_VBN ,_, so_RB D06 101 we_PP1AS are_BER unable_JJ to_TO cure_VB our_PP$ own_AP D06 102 minds_NNS ,_, if_CS the_ATI trouble_NN is_BEZ a_AT complicated_JJ D06 102 one_CD1 involving_VBG careful_JJ and_CC D06 103 patient_JJ treatment_NN ._. ^ one_CD1 of_IN the_ATI greatest_JJT D06 103 steps_NNS forward_RB that_WPR has_HVZ been_BEN D06 104 made_VBN this_DT century_NN is_BEZ the_ATI way_NN in_IN which_WDTR D06 104 illness_NN of_IN the_ATI mind_NN is_BEZ no_RB longer_RBR D06 105 feared_VBN or_CC shunned_VBN ,_, and_CC is_BEZ in_IN fact_NN no_RB D06 105 differently_RB regarded_VBN than_IN D06 106 physical_JJ illness_NN ._. D06 107 ^ there_EX is_BEZ ,_, nevertheless_RB ,_, a_AT great_JJ deal_NN D06 107 of_IN tiredness_NN which_WDTR comes_VBZ D06 108 from_IN no_ATI major_JJ complication_NN but_CC results_VBZ from_IN D06 108 an_AT inability_NN to_TO deal_VB with_IN D06 109 life_NN ,_, especially_RB under_IN the_ATI diverse_JJ pattern_NN D06 109 which_WDTR is_BEZ the_ATI twentieth_OD D06 110 century_NN ._. ^ in_IN the_ATI days_NNS when_WRB most_AP people_NNS D06 110 were_BED born_VBN ,_, lived_VBN and_CC died_VBN D06 111 within_IN the_ATI boundaries_NNS of_IN the_ATI village_NN ,_, it_PP3 D06 111 was_BEDZ not_XNOT difficult_JJ for_IN anybody_PN D06 112 to_TO live_VB a_AT day_NN at_IN a_AT time_NN ._. ^ even_RB those_DTS D06 112 who_WPR held_VBD a_AT high_JJ and_CC responsible_JJ D06 113 office_NN lived_VBD in_IN far_RB greater_JJR simplicity_NN than_IN D06 113 their_PP$ successors_NNS ._. ^ when_WRB D06 114 news_NN from_IN the_ATI continent_NN took_VBD days_NNS ,_, from_IN D06 114 America_NP weeks_NNS ,_, from_IN the_ATI far_JJ D06 115 east_NR ,_, months_NNS ,_, even_RB a_AT Prime_NPT Minister_NPT could_MD D06 115 go_VB to_IN sleep_NN in_IN blissful_JJ D06 116 ignorance_NN of_IN what_WDT might_MD be_BE happening_VBG at_IN the_ATI D06 116 other_AP end_NN of_IN England_NP ,_, D06 117 whereas_CS today_NR ,_, everybody_PN ,_, let_RB alone_RB" the_ATI D06 117 Prime_NPT Minister_NPT ,_, knows_VBZ of_IN D06 118 happenings_NNS the_ATI other_AP side_NN of_IN the_ATI world_NN ,_, D06 118 within_IN minutes_NNS of_IN their_PP$ taking_VBG D06 119 place_NN ._. D06 120 ^ in_IN other_AP ways_NNS ,_, too_RB ,_, life_NN for_IN the_ATI D06 120 ordinary_JJ individual_NN has_HVZ become_VBN D06 121 so_QL complex_JJ that_CS it_PP3 taxes_VBZ the_ATI mind_NN ._. ^ two_CD D06 121 hundred_CD years_NNS ago_RB ,_, men_NNS lived_VBD D06 122 and_CC worked_VBD in_IN one_CD1 place_NN ,_, their_PP$ lives_NNS D06 122 were_BED of_IN one_CD1 piece_NN ._. ^ now_RN a_AT man_NN may_MD D06 123 live_VB twenty_CD ,_, thirty_CD even_RB sixty_CD miles_NNS from_IN D06 123 his_PP$ work_NN ._. ^ the_ATI only_AP D06 124 connexion_NN is_BEZ the_ATI pipeline_NN of_IN the_ATI railway_NN on_IN D06 124 which_WDTR they_PP3AS travel_VB day_NN by_IN D06 125 day_NN ._. ^ in_IN many_AP cases_NNS ,_, their_PP$ homes_NRS know_VB D06 125 little_AP of_IN their_PP$ place_NN of_IN work_NN D06 126 and_CC their_PP$ associates_NNS at_IN the_ATI office_NN or_CC works_NN D06 126 wonder_VB what_WDT they_PP3AS are_BER D06 127 possibly_RB like_IN in_IN the_ATI surroundings_NNS of_IN their_PP$ D06 127 homes_NRS ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ easy_JJ ,_, D06 128 desperately_RB easy_JJ ,_, to_TO lead_VB a_AT *'_*' double_JJ **'_**' D06 128 life_NN without_IN ever_RB deliberately_RB D06 129 planning_VBG to_TO do_DO so_PN or_CC in_IN fact_NN being_BEG D06 129 conscious_JJ of_IN what_WDT is_BEZ going_VBG on_RP ._. ^ it_PP3 D06 130 is_BEZ easier_JJR to_TO live_VB life_NN in_IN compartments_NNS but_CC D06 130 over_IN the_ATI years_NNS it_PP3 builds_VBZ D06 131 up_RP ,_, and_CC to_TO do_DO so_PN inevitably_RB builds_VBZ up_RP D06 131 tensions_NNS which_WDTR need_VB to_TO be_BE D06 132 handled_VBN correctly_RB ._. D06 133 ^ can_MD we_PP1AS then_RN frame_VB some_DTI *'_*' rules_NNS **'_**' D06 133 which_WDTR may_MD enable_VB us_PP1OS to_TO live_VB D06 134 life_NN as_QL fully_RB as_CS possible_JJ ,_, without_IN having_HVG D06 134 our_PP$ energy_NN sapped_VBN by_IN D06 135 unnecessary_JJ weariness_NN ._. D06 136 ^ (_( a_ZZ )_) ._. ^ makes_VBZ for_IN a_AT decrease_NN in_IN D06 136 tiredness_NN ._. ^ we_PP1AS have_HV a_AT D06 137 saying_NN ^ *'_*' my_PP$ head_NN will_MD never_RB save_VB my_PP$ D06 137 feet_NNS **'_**' ._. ^ time_NN after_IN time_NN we_PP1AS D06 138 forget_VB something_PN and_CC have_HV to_TO go_VB back_RP upstairs_RN D06 138 or_CC down_RP to_IN the_ATI shops_NNS ._. D06 139 ^ if_CS we_PP1AS ever_RB stopped_VBD to_TO consider_VB how_WRB much_AP D06 139 energy_NN *-_*- and_CC time_NN *-_*- we_PP1AS lose_VB D06 140 this_DT way_NN in_IN the_ATI course_NN of_IN a_AT day_NN we_PP1AS D06 140 would_MD be_BE staggered_VBN ._. ^ some_DTI of_IN it_PP3 is_BEZ D06 141 inevitable_JJ ,_, and_CC we_PP1AS do_DO not_XNOT want_VB to_TO D06 141 become_VB too_QL pernickety_JJ ._. D06 142 ^ nevertheless_RB ,_, we_PP1AS could_MD all_ABN probably_RB be_BE a_RB D06 142 little_RB" more_QL orderly_JJ for_CS we_PP1AS D06 143 so_QL frequently_RB just_RB muddle_VB through_RP ._. D06 144 ^ the_ATI housewife_NN would_MD find_VB life_NN far_RB less_QL D06 144 tiring_JJ if_CS she_PP3A made_VBD a_AT list_NN ,_, D06 145 followed_VBD a_AT routine_NN of_IN work_NN rather_RB than_CS D06 145 getting_VBG from_IN one_CD1 thing_NN to_IN the_ATI D06 146 next_AP ._. ^ the_ATI business_NN man_NN would_MD find_VB that_CS D06 146 he_PP3A reached_VBD the_ATI end_NN of_IN the_ATI day_NN D06 147 with_IN far_RB less_AP strain_NN if_CS he_PP3A was_BEDZ a_RB little_RB" D06 147 more_QL systematic_JJ ._. ^ to_TO drift_VB D06 148 aimlessly_RB along_RP is_BEZ more_QL wearying_JJ than_IN anything_PN D06 148 else_RB ._. ^ if_CS we_PP1AS would_MD only_RB D06 149 sit_VB down_RP and_CC write_VB out_RP all_ABN the_ATI necessary_JJ D06 149 jobs_NNS waiting_VBG to_TO be_BE done_VBN and_CC D06 150 then_RN work_VB quietly_RB through_IN them_PP3OS ,_, we_PP1AS would_MD D06 150 find_VB life_NN considerably_RB less_QL D06 151 exhausting_JJ *-_*- and_CC in_IN the_ATI end_NN we_PP1AS would_MD do_DO D06 151 more_AP ._. D06 152 ^ there_EX may_MD be_BE some_DTI who_WPR will_MD argue_VB that_CS D06 152 routine_NN destroys_VBZ the_ATI soul_NN ._. D06 153 ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ so_QL easy_JJ ,_, they_PP3AS say_VB ,_, to_TO get_VB D06 153 into_IN a_AT rut_NN ._. ^ save_VB us_PP1OS from_IN the_ATI school_NN D06 154 curriculum_NN and_CC even_RB worse_JJR the_ATI school_NN system_NN D06 154 whereby_WRB for_IN meals_NNS D06 155 everybody_PN knows_VBZ beforehand_RB exactly_RB what_WDT ,_, on_IN D06 155 any_DTI given_JJ day_NN of_IN the_ATI week_NN ,_, D06 156 they_PP3AS are_BER going_VBG to_TO have_HV ._. ^ if_CS *-_*- such_ABL D06 156 a_AT critic_NN may_MD say_VB *-_*- you_PP2 are_BER calling_VBG D06 157 us_PP1OS to_IN adventure_NN ,_, do_DO not_XNOT strangle_VB us_PP1OS D06 157 before_CS we_PP1AS start_VB by_IN putting_VBG us_PP1OS into_IN D06 158 a_AT strait-jacket_NN called_VBN *'_*' order_NN **'_**' ._. D06 159 ^ I_PP1A am_BEM more_RB than_RB" conscious_JJ of_IN this_DT ._. ^ D06 159 how_WRB anybody_PN can_MD go_VB through_IN the_ATI D06 160 same_AP routine_NN day_NN in_RP and_CC day_NN out_RP for_IN forty_CD D06 160 years_NNS I_PP1A find_VB difficult_JJ to_TO D06 161 understand_VB ._. ^ a_AT lot_NN of_IN it_PP3 is_BEZ inevitable_JJ so_CS D06 161 that_CS" industry_NN and_CC commerce_NN D06 162 may_MD be_BE kept_VBN going_VBG *-_*- though_CS if_CS ever_RB it_PP3 D06 162 becomes_VBZ possible_JJ to_TO work_VB out_RP a_AT D06 163 system_NN of_IN *'_*' staggered_JJ **'_**' hours_NNS it_PP3 may_MD D06 163 do_DO an_AT immense_JJ amount_NN of_IN good_NN D06 164 over_IN and_CC above_IN relieving_VBG the_ATI pressure_NN on_IN D06 164 over-crowded_JJ trains_NNS ._. ^ as_CS it_PP3 D06 165 is_BEZ ,_, with_IN so_QL much_AP of_IN our_PP$ life_NN already_RB in_IN D06 165 a_AT predetermined_JJ groove_NN ,_, I_PP1A D06 166 would_MD hardly_RB like_VB to_TO add_VB further_RBR to_IN the_ATI D06 166 dullness_NN which_WDTR it_PP3 engenders_VBZ ._. D06 167 ^ but_CC I_PP1A am_BEM not_XNOT arguing_VBG for_IN this_DT ._. ^ D06 167 I_PP1A know_VB how_WRB much_AP of_IN a_AT drag_NN it_PP3 can_MD D06 168 be_BE and_CC I_PP1A was_BEDZ interested_JJ some_DTI little_JJ while_NN D06 168 ago_RB to_TO hear_VB of_IN a_AT school_NN who_WPR D06 169 tried_VBD a_AT six-day_JJB timetable_NN ._. ^ they_PP3AS only_RB D06 169 worked_VBD ,_, of_RB course_RB" ,_, a_AT five-day_JJB D06 170 week_NN so_CS that_CS" in_IN the_ATI first_OD week_NN Monday_NR to_IN D06 170 Friday_NR were_BED days_NNS one_CD1 to_IN five_CD D06 171 of_IN the_ATI timetable_NN ,_, the_ATI following_JJ Monday_NR was_BEDZ D06 171 day_NN six_CD and_CC Tuesday_NR started_VBD D06 172 day_NN one_CD1 again_RB and_RB so_RB" on_RB" ._. ^ by_IN this_DT D06 172 means_NN they_PP3AS avoided_VBD each_DT week_NN being_BEG D06 173 the_ATI same_AP with_IN a_AT pupil_NN knowing_VBG exactly_RB what_WDT D06 173 the_ATI subject_NN would_MD be_BE on_IN D06 174 Friday_NR afternoon_NN at_IN 3_CD \0p.m_RB ._. ^ it_PP3 was_BEDZ a_RB D06 174 little_RB" complicated_JJ to_TO work_VB ,_, D06 175 of_RB course_RB" ,_, and_CC there_EX had_HVD to_TO be_BE a_AT big_JJ D06 175 notice_NN in_IN the_ATI entrance_NN saying_VBG D06 176 which_WDT day_NN of_IN the_ATI timetable_NN it_PP3 was_BEDZ *-_*- D06 176 but_CC it_PP3 added_VBD immensely_RB to_IN the_ATI D06 177 interest_NN and_CC kept_VBD everybody_PN on_IN their_PP$ toes_NNS ._. D06 178 ^ to_TO have_HV order_NN does_DOZ not_XNOT mean_VB getting_VBG D06 178 into_IN a_AT dull_JJ routine_NN ._. ^ I_PP1A have_HV D06 179 great_JJ sympathy_NN with_IN the_ATI young_JJ wife_NN who_WPR does_DOZ D06 179 not_XNOT always_RB want_VB to_TO do_DO the_ATI D06 180 washing_NN on_IN a_AT Monday_NR ._. ^ I_PP1A would_MD not_XNOT want_VB D06 180 to_TO either_RB ,_, but_CC if_CS she_PP3A wants_VBZ to_TO D06 181 get_VB through_IN the_ATI day_NN without_IN becoming_VBG exhausted_JJ D06 181 ,_, she_PP3A will_MD be_BE well_RB D06 182 advised_VBN to_TO sit_VB down_RP quietly_RB and_CC make_VB a_AT list_NN D06 182 of_IN everything_PN she_PP3A has_HVZ got_VBN D06 183 to_TO do_DO ,_, note_VB the_ATI order_NN in_IN which_WDTR they_PP3AS D06 183 can_MD most_QL conveniently_RB be_BE done_VBN (_( or_CC D06 184 must_MD be_BE done_VBN because_IN of_IN" other_AP predetermined_JJ D06 184 factors_NNS *-_*- you_PP2 must_MD ,_, for_IN D06 185 example_NN ,_, do_DO your_PP$ shopping_NN on_IN the_ATI morning_NN D06 185 of_IN the_ATI early_JJ closing_NN day_NN )_) ._. D06 186 ^ she_PP3A will_MD ,_, in_IN fact_NN ,_, be_BE surprised_JJ at_IN D06 186 what_WDT peace_NN of_IN mind_NN ensues_VBZ ._. D06 187 ^ (_( b_ZZ )_) ._. ^ concentrate_VB on_IN one_CD1 thing_NN at_IN D06 187 a_AT time_NN ._. ^ a_AT list_NN or_CC a_AT plan_NN D06 188 enables_VBZ us_PP1OS to_TO put_VB all_ABN our_PP$ energies_NNS into_IN D06 188 the_ATI particular_JJ matter_NN on_IN hand_NN ._. D07 2 ^ 2_CD ._. D07 3 ^ we_PP1AS turn_VB now_RN to_IN the_ATI consideration_NN of_IN an_AT D07 3 Aggadic_JNP passage_NN ;_; the_ATI D07 4 final_JJ portion_NN of_IN tractate_NN Makkoth_NP ._. ^ the_ATI D07 4 opinion_NN of_IN \0R_NPT Hananiah_NP D07 5 \0b_&FW Gamaliel_NP is_BEZ quoted_VBN in_IN the_ATI Mishnah_NP ._. ^ D07 5 this_DT teacher_NN holds_VBZ that_CS D07 6 one_CD1 who_WPR has_HVZ incurred_VBN the_ATI penalty_NN of_IN D07 6 kareth_&FW *-_*- the_ATI excision_NN of_IN the_ATI D07 7 soul_NN *-_*- obtains_VBZ a_AT remission_NN from_IN this_DT D07 7 punishment_NN if_CS he_PP3A is_BEZ flogged_VBN ._. ^ in_IN D07 8 the_ATI opening_JJ passage_NN of_IN the_ATI Gemara_NP it_PP3 is_BEZ D07 8 stated_VBN in_IN the_ATI name_NN of_IN \0R_NPT D07 9 Johanan_NP that_CS \0R_NPT Hananiah_NP \0b_&FW Gamaliel's_NP$ D07 9 colleagues_NNS disagree_VB with_IN D07 10 him_PP3O and_CC that_DT in_IN their_PP$ view_NN a_AT flogging_NN D07 10 does_DOZ not_XNOT bring_VB remission_NN of_IN the_ATI D07 11 penalty_NN of_IN kareth_&FW ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ discussed_VBN and_CC D07 11 then_RN (_( and_CC we_PP1AS take_VB up_RP D07 12 our_PP$ analysis_NN at_IN this_DT stage_NN )_) \0R_NPT Adda_NP is_BEZ D07 12 quoted_VBN as_CS saying_VBG in_IN the_ATI name_NN D07 13 of_IN Rabh_NP that_CS the_ATI halakhah_&FW ,_, the_ATI law_NN ,_, D07 13 is_BEZ in_IN accordance_NN with_IN \0R_NPT D07 14 Hananiah_NP \0b_&FW Gamaliel_NP ._. D07 15 ^ Rabh_NP Joseph_NP (_( \0d_VBD 333_CD )_) objects_VBZ that_CS D07 15 the_ATI term_NN ,_, used_VBN by_IN Rabh_NP ,_, D07 16 halakhah_&FW ,_, is_BEZ not_XNOT appropriate_JJ here_RN for_CS *'_*' D07 16 who_WP has_HVZ gone_VBN up_RP to_IN heaven_NN D07 17 and_CC returned_VBN to_TO tell_VB us_PP1OS that_CS this_DT is_BEZ so_PN D07 17 ?_? **'_**' (_( \0i.e_RB the_ATI term_NN D07 18 halakhah_&FW can_MD only_RB be_BE used_VBN about_IN some_DTI D07 18 practical_JJ issue_NN where_WRB a_AT D07 19 decision_NN must_MD be_BE reached_VBN ._. ^ but_CC the_ATI question_NN D07 19 whether_CS or_CC not_XNOT a_AT man_NN is_BEZ D07 20 guilty_JJ of_IN kareth_&FW is_BEZ a_AT matter_NN for_IN God_NP and_CC D07 20 there_EX is_BEZ no_ATI point_NN in_IN D07 21 recording_VBG the_ATI actual_JJ ruling_NN *-_*- halakhah_&FW *-_*- D07 21 for_CS this_DT is_BEZ known_VBN only_RB D07 22 to_IN God_NP )_) ._. ^ to_IN this_DT his_PP$ disciple_NN Abaye_NP (_( D07 22 \0c_RB 280-338/39_CD-CD )_) replies_VBZ that_CS D07 23 the_ATI term_NN is_BEZ applicable_JJ even_RB here_RN (_( \0i.e_RB D07 23 it_PP3 is_BEZ permissible_JJ for_IN D07 24 human_JJ teachers_NNS to_TO state_VB that_CS this_DT is_BEZ how_WRB D07 24 God_NP will_MD act_VB )_) ._. ^ as_IN proof_NN of_IN D07 25 this_DT Abaye_NP quotes_VBZ the_ATI saying_NN of_IN \0R_NPT Joshua_NP D07 25 \0b_&FW Levi_NP (_( early_JJ 3rd_OD D07 26 \0cent_NN )_) who_WPR said_VBD that_CS three_CD things_NNS were_BED D07 26 done_VBN by_IN a_AT human_JJ court_NN here_RN D07 27 below_RI and_CC the_ATI heavenly_JJ court_NN agreed_VBD with_IN D07 27 their_PP$ decisions_NNS ._. ^ here_RN ,_, too_RB ,_, D07 28 the_ATI objection_NN can_MD be_BE raised_VBN :_: ^ *'_*' who_WP has_HVZ D07 28 gone_VBN up_RP to_IN heaven_NN and_CC returned_VBN D07 29 to_TO tell_VB us_PP1OS that_CS this_DT is_BEZ so_PN ?_? **'_**' ^ D07 29 but_CC \0R_NPT Joshua_NP \0b_&FW Levi_NP presumably_RB D07 30 argues_VBZ that_CS we_PP1AS arrive_VB at_IN this_DT information_NN D07 30 by_IN interpreting_VBG certain_JJ D07 31 verses_NNS ,_, and_CC ,_, consequently_RB ,_, we_PP1AS ,_, too_RB ,_, D07 31 are_BER justified_VBN in_IN interpreting_VBG the_ATI D07 32 relevant_JJ verses_NNS to_TO yield_VB that_CS \0R_NPT Hananiah_NP D07 32 \0b_&FW Gamaliel_NP is_BEZ correct_JJ D07 33 and_CC that_CS God_NP will_MD act_VB ,_, as_CS it_PP3 were_BED ,_, D07 33 in_IN the_ATI manner_NN stated_VBN by_IN him_PP3O ._. D07 34 ^ we_PP1AS have_HV here_RN an_AT original_JJ saying_NN of_IN Rabh_NP D07 34 ._. ^ to_IN this_DT Rabh_NP Joseph_NP D07 35 raises_VBZ an_AT objection_NN and_CC Abaye_NP replies_VBZ by_IN D07 35 referring_VBG his_PP$ master_NN to_IN the_ATI D07 36 saying_NN of_IN \0R_NPT Joshua_NP \0b_&FW Levi_NP ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ D07 36 probable_JJ that_CS all_ABN this_DT is_BEZ a_AT D07 37 verbatim_JJ report_NN of_IN the_ATI actual_JJ words_NNS used_VBN by_IN D07 37 Rabh_NP Joseph_NP and_CC Abaye_NP and_CC D07 38 that_CS there_EX has_HVZ been_BEN no_ATI re-working_NN of_IN the_ATI D07 38 material_NN by_IN the_ATI redactors_NNS ._. D07 39 ^ the_ATI only_AP difficulty_NN here_RN is_BEZ that_CS if_CS Rabh_NP D07 39 Joseph_NP is_BEZ prepared_VBN to_TO D07 40 disagree_VB with_IN Rabh_NP there_EX is_BEZ no_ATI reason_NN why_WRB D07 40 he_PP3A should_MD not_XNOT disagree_VB with_IN D07 41 \0R_NPT Joshua_NP \0b_&FW Levi_NP ._. ^ but_CC the_ATI meaning_NN of_IN D07 41 Abaye's_NP$ reply_NN is_BEZ probably_RB D07 42 that_CS Rabh's_NP$ opinion_NN is_BEZ no_ATI isolated_JJ case_NN but_CC D07 42 a_AT normal_JJ method_NN of_IN D07 43 interpretation_NN and_CC for_IN this_DT the_ATI example_NN of_IN D07 43 \0R_NPT Joshua_NP \0b_&FW Levi_NP is_BEZ D07 44 quoted_VBN ._. D07 45 ^ the_ATI Gemara_NP now_RN proceeds_VBZ to_TO examine_VB the_ATI D07 45 saying_NN of_IN \0R_NPT Joshua_NP D07 46 \0b_&FW Levi_NP itself_PPL ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ introduced_VBN by_IN D07 46 the_ATI formula_NN ,_, gupha_&FW ,_, D07 47 *'_*' the_ATI main_JJB saying_NN **'_**' (_( \0i.e_RB we_PP1AS have_HV D07 47 referred_VBN to_IN this_DT saying_NN in_IN D07 48 the_ATI course_NN of_IN the_ATI previous_JJ discussion_NN ,_, here_RN D07 48 we_PP1AS deal_VB with_IN the_ATI saying_NN D07 49 itself_PPL )_) ._. ^ the_ATI three_CD enactments_NNS of_IN a_AT D07 49 human_JJ court_NN in_IN which_WDTR the_ATI heavenly_JJ D07 50 court_NN concurred_VBD are_BER given_VBN (_( no_ATI doubt_NN by_IN D07 50 \0R_NPT Joshua_NP \0b_&FW Levi_NP himself_PPL )_) D07 51 as_IN :_: the_ATI reading_NN of_IN the_ATI book_NN of_IN Esther_NP D07 51 on_IN the_ATI festival_NN of_IN Purim_NP ;_; that_CS D07 52 people_NNS should_MD greet_VB each_PPLS other_PPLS" with_IN the_ATI D07 52 divine_JJ name_NN ;_; and_CC that_CS the_ATI D07 53 tithe_NN normally_RB given_VBN to_IN the_ATI Levites_NNPS should_MD D07 53 be_BE brought_VBN to_IN the_ATI Temple_NPL ._. D07 54 ^ for_IN each_DT of_IN these_DTS ,_, proof_NN texts_NNS are_BER D07 54 quoted_VBN ._. ^ for_IN the_ATI reading_NN of_IN the_ATI D07 55 book_NN of_IN Esther_NP the_ATI verse_NN is_BEZ quoted_VBN :_: ^ *'_*' D07 55 they_PP3AS established_VBD it_PP3 and_CC the_ATI D07 56 Jews_NNPS took_VBD it_PP3 upon_IN them_PP3OS **'_**' ._. ^ this_DT D07 56 is_BEZ said_VBN to_TO mean_VB :_: ^ *'_*' they_PP3AS (_( the_ATI D07 57 heavenly_JJ court_NN )_) established_VBD above_RI that_DT which_WDTR D07 57 the_ATI Jews_NNPS took_VBD upon_IN them_PP3OS D07 58 (_( the_ATI reading_NN of_IN the_ATI book_NN of_IN Esther_NP )_) D07 58 down_RP here_RN below_RI ._. **'_**' ^ the_ATI proof_NN D07 59 text_NN for_IN greeting_NN by_IN the_ATI divine_JJ name_NN is_BEZ D07 59 then_RN quoted_VBN ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ the_ATI D07 60 verse_NN :_: ^ *'_*' and_CC behold_VB ,_, Boaz_NP came_VBD from_IN D07 60 Bethlehem_NP and_CC said_VBD to_IN the_ATI D07 61 reapers_NNS ,_, ^ *'_*' the_ATI Lord_NPT be_BE with_IN you_PP2 **'_**' D07 61 ._. ^ a_AT further_JJB proof_NN text_NN is_BEZ then_RN D07 62 quoted_VBN ,_, with_IN the_ATI formula_NN generally_RB used_VBN for_IN D07 62 a_AT second_OD proof_NN text_NN ,_, *'_*' and_CC D07 63 it_PP3 says_VBZ **'_**' ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ the_ATI verse_NN :_: ^ D07 63 *'_*' the_ATI Lord_NPT bless_VB thee_PP2 ,_, thou_PP2 D07 64 mighty_JJ man_NN of_IN valour_NN ._. **'_**' ^ the_ATI question_NN D07 64 is_BEZ then_RN asked_VBN :_: ^ *'_*' what_WDT need_NN is_BEZ D07 65 there_EX for_IN *'_*' and_CC it_PP3 is_BEZ said_VBN **'_**' ?_? **'_**' D07 65 (_( \0i.e_RB why_WRB are_BER two_CD verses_NNS D07 66 needed_VBN ,_, why_WRB does_DOZ not_XNOT the_ATI first_OD one_CD1 D07 66 suffice_VB ?_? )_) ._. ^ to_IN this_DT the_ATI reply_NN is_BEZ D07 67 given_VBN that_CS from_IN the_ATI verse_NN dealing_VBG with_IN Boaz_NP D07 67 there_EX is_BEZ no_ATI proof_NN of_IN D07 68 divine_JJ approval_NN ,_, only_RB that_CS Boaz_NP used_VBD this_DT D07 68 form_NN of_IN greeting_NN ._. ^ but_CC in_IN D07 69 the_ATI second_OD verse_NN it_PP3 is_BEZ the_ATI angel_NN who_WPR D07 69 uses_VBZ this_DT form_NN of_IN greeting_NN and_CC D07 70 hence_RB there_EX is_BEZ evidence_NN of_IN divine_JJ approval_NN ._. ^ D07 70 finally_RB ,_, the_ATI proof_NN text_NN D07 71 for_IN the_ATI bringing_NN of_IN the_ATI tithe_NN to_IN the_ATI D07 71 Temple_NPL is_BEZ quoted_VBN ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ the_ATI D07 72 verse_NN :_: ^ *'_*' bring_VB ye_PP2 the_ATI whole_JJ tithe_NN unto_IN D07 72 the_ATI store_NN house_NN that_CS there_EX D07 73 may_MD be_BE food_NN in_IN my_PP$ house_NN ,_, and_CC try_VB me_PP1O D07 73 herewith_RB ,_, saith_VBZ the_ATI Lord_NPT of_IN D07 74 hosts_NNS ,_, if_CS I_PP1A will_MD not_XNOT open_VB you_PP2 the_ATI D07 74 windows_NNS of_IN heaven_NN and_CC pour_VB you_PP2 out_RP a_AT D07 75 blessing_NN ,_, until_CS there_EX shall_MD be_BE more_AP than_IN D07 75 sufficiency_NN ._. **'_**' ^ the_ATI Gemara_NP D07 76 then_RN asks_VBZ :_: ^ *'_*' what_WDT is_BEZ the_ATI meaning_NN of_IN D07 76 *'_*' more_AP than_IN sufficiency_NN D07 77 **'_**' (_( \0Heb_NNP beli_&FW dai_&FW ?_? **'_**' ^ Rami_NP bar_&FW D07 77 Rabh_NP replies_VBZ :_: ^ *'_*' until_CS your_PP$ D07 78 lips_NNS are_BER worn_VBN out_RP in_IN saying_VBG :_: ^ *'_*' D07 78 sufficient_JJ **'_**' ._. **'_**' D07 79 ^ the_ATI scheme_NN of_IN the_ATI sugya_&FW is_BEZ as_CS follows_VBZ D07 79 :_: D07 81 ^ (_( 1_CD1 )_) ._. ^ the_ATI saying_NN of_IN \0R_NPT Joshua_NP D07 81 \0b_&FW Levi_NP ._. D07 82 ^ (_( 2_CD )_) ._. ^ first_OD proof_NN text_NN and_CC explanation_NN D07 82 ._. D07 83 ^ (_( 3_CD )_) ._. ^ second_OD proof_NN text_NN ._. D07 84 ^ (_( a_ZZ )_) ._. ^ Boaz_NP D07 85 ._. ^ (_( b_ZZ )_) ._. ^ angel_NN D07 86 ._. ^ question_NN :_: ^ why_WRB is_BEZ (_( b_ZZ )_) required_VBN ?_? D07 87 ^ answer_NN :_: ^ because_CS Boaz_NP may_MD not_XNOT have_HV had_HVN D07 87 divine_JJ approval_NN ._. D07 88 ^ (_( 4_CD )_) ._. ^ third_OD proof_NN text_NN ._. D07 89 ^ question_NN :_: ^ what_WDT is_BEZ the_ATI meaning_NN of_IN D07 89 beli_&FW dai_&FW ?_? D07 90 ^ answer_NN :_: ^ by_IN Rami_NP bar_&FW Rabh_NP ._. D07 92 ^ the_ATI first_OD matter_NN to_IN which_WDTR attention_NN should_MD D07 92 be_BE drawn_VBN is_BEZ that_CS the_ATI D07 93 proof_NN texts_NNS are_BER not_XNOT necessarily_RB the_ATI work_NN D07 93 of_IN \0R_NPT Joshua_NP \0b_&FW Levi_NP D07 94 himself_PPL ._. ^ in_IN fact_NN ,_, the_ATI probability_NN is_BEZ D07 94 that_CS they_PP3AS are_BER a_AT later_JJR D07 95 explanation_NN of_IN his_PP$ saying_NN ,_, as_CS we_PP1AS shall_MD D07 95 see_VB ._. ^ this_DT would_MD account_VB for_IN D07 96 Abaye_NP ,_, in_IN the_ATI previous_JJ passage_NN ,_, observing_VBG D07 96 that_CS *'_*' we_PP1AS expound_VB the_ATI D07 97 verses_NNS **'_**' not_XNOT *'_*' he_PP3A expounds_VBZ **'_**' ._. ^ D07 97 and_CC this_DT would_MD imply_VB that_CS the_ATI D07 98 proof_NN texts_NNS were_BED known_VBN by_IN Abaye_NP ._. ^ our_PP$ D07 98 suggestion_NN is_BEZ substantiated_VBN by_IN D07 99 the_ATI fact_NN that_CS the_ATI comment_NN on_IN the_ATI first_OD D07 99 proof_NN text_NN :_: ~ *'_*' they_PP3AS established_VBD D07 100 above_RI that_DT which_WDTR the_ATI Jews_NNPS took_VBD upon_IN D07 100 them_PP3OS down_RP here_RN below_RI **'_**' is_BEZ quoted_VBN D07 101 by_IN Samuel_NP in_IN tractate_NN Megillah_NP to_TO prove_VB that_CS D07 101 the_ATI book_NN of_IN Esther_NP D07 102 was_BEDZ composed_VBN under_IN the_ATI inspiration_NN of_IN the_ATI D07 102 divine_JJ spirit_NN and_CC Samuel_NP D07 103 does_DOZ not_XNOT quote_VB it_PP3 in_IN the_ATI name_NN of_IN \0R_NPT D07 103 Joshua_NP \0b_&FW Levi_NP ._. ^ even_RB more_QL D07 104 significant_JJ is_BEZ the_ATI fact_NN that_CS the_ATI proof_NN D07 104 texts_NNS from_IN Boaz_NP and_CC the_ATI angel_NN D07 105 are_BER quoted_VBN ,_, in_IN support_NN of_IN this_DT very_AP thesis_NN D07 105 that_CS greeting_NN should_MD be_BE D07 106 given_VBN by_IN the_ATI divine_JJ name_NN ,_, in_IN an_AT anonymous_JJ D07 106 Mishnah_NP ._. ^ in_IN addition_NN ,_, D07 107 the_ATI same_AP reason_NN for_IN the_ATI second_OD text_NN is_BEZ D07 107 given_VBN by_IN the_ATI Gemara_NP in_IN a_AT D07 108 comment_NN to_IN the_ATI Mishnah_NP ._. ^ (_( actually_RB ,_, the_ATI D07 108 Mishnah_NP quotes_VBZ two_CD D07 109 further_JJB proof_NN texts_NNS and_CC the_ATI Gemara_NP explains_VBZ D07 109 why_WRB these_DTS ,_, too_RB ,_, are_BER D07 110 necessary_JJ ,_, but_CC a_AT careful_JJ examination_NN of_IN that_DT D07 110 passage_NN makes_VBZ it_PP3 clear_JJ D07 111 that_CS these_DTS are_BER not_XNOT quoted_VBN here_RN because_CS D07 111 they_PP3AS are_BER not_XNOT necessary_JJ to_TO prove_VB D07 112 the_ATI point_NN made_VBN by_IN \0R_NPT Joshua_NP \0b_&FW Levi_NP ._. D07 112 )_) ^ finally_RB ,_, we_PP1AS note_VB that_CS the_ATI D07 113 comment_NN of_IN Rami_NP bar_&FW Rabh_NP is_BEZ quoted_VBN elsewhere_RB D07 113 ._. D07 114 ^ from_IN the_ATI above_JJB it_PP3 follows_VBZ that_CS here_RN ,_, D07 114 once_RB again_RB ,_, we_PP1AS have_HV a_AT good_JJ D07 115 illustration_NN of_IN how_WRB a_AT sugya_&FW has_HVZ been_BEN D07 115 fashioned_VBN from_IN material_NN D07 116 already_RB in_IN the_ATI hands_NNS of_IN the_ATI redactors_NNS ._. ^ D07 116 the_ATI sugya_&FW is_BEZ built_VBN around_IN D07 117 the_ATI saying_NN of_IN \0R_NPT Joshua_NP \0b_&FW Levi_NP ._. ^ the_ATI D07 117 proof_NN text_NN for_IN the_ATI reading_NN D07 118 of_IN the_ATI book_NN of_IN Esther_NP is_BEZ quoted_VBN with_IN the_ATI D07 118 comment_NN given_VBN by_IN Samuel_NP ._. D07 119 ^ (_( this_DT is_BEZ probably_RB to_TO be_BE understood_VBN as_IN a_AT D07 119 well-known_JJ comment_NN on_IN the_ATI D07 120 verse_NN ;_; quoted_VBN by_IN Samuel_NP in_IN support_NN of_IN his_PP$ D07 120 thesis_NN and_CC quoted_VBN by_IN the_ATI D07 121 Gemara_NP in_IN support_NN of_IN \0R_NPT Joshua_NP \0b_&FW Levi's_NP$ D07 121 thesis_NN !_! )_) ^ the_ATI proof_NN D07 122 text_NN of_IN greeting_NN by_IN the_ATI divine_JJ name_NN is_BEZ D07 122 taken_VBN from_IN the_ATI Mishnah_NP ._. D07 123 ^ there_EX is_BEZ no_ATI reference_NN to_IN the_ATI Mishnah_NP here_RN D07 123 because_CS the_ATI Mishnah_NP D07 124 deals_VBZ with_IN the_ATI actual_JJ practice_NN of_IN greeting_NN by_IN D07 124 the_ATI divine_JJ name_NN and_CC D07 125 the_ATI Gemara_NP here_RN quotes_VBZ the_ATI texts_NNS to_TO support_VB D07 125 the_ATI thesis_NN of_IN \0R_NPT D07 126 Joshua_NP \0b_&FW Levi_NP ._. ^ the_ATI question_NN and_CC answer_NN D07 126 with_IN regard_NN to_IN the_ATI need_NN for_IN D07 127 the_ATI text_NN of_IN the_ATI angel_NN are_BER quoted_VBN here_RN in_IN D07 127 the_ATI same_AP words_NNS in_IN which_WDTR they_PP3AS D07 128 are_BER quoted_VBN in_IN the_ATI discussion_NN on_IN the_ATI Mishnah_NP D07 128 ._. ^ this_DT can_MD either_DTX mean_VB D07 129 that_CS both_ABX sugyas_&FW are_BER quoting_VBG a_AT well-known_JJ D07 129 question_NN and_CC answer_NN or_CC D07 130 that_CS our_PP$ sugya_&FW is_BEZ quoting_VBG from_IN the_ATI longer_JJR D07 130 sugya_&FW which_WDTR deals_VBZ D07 131 with_IN all_ABN four_CD texts_NNS quoted_VBN in_IN the_ATI Mishnah_NP D07 131 ._. ^ or_CC it_PP3 is_BEZ possible_JJ that_CS D07 132 our_PP$ sugya_&FW contains_VBZ the_ATI original_JJ question_NN and_CC D07 132 answer_NN and_CC this_DT is_BEZ D07 133 quoted_VBN in_IN the_ATI other_AP sugya_&FW ._. ^ (_( this_DT can_MD D07 133 be_BE supported_VBN by_IN the_ATI use_NN of_IN D07 134 the_ATI expression_NN :_: ~ *'_*' Boaz_NP did_DOD it_PP3 of_IN his_PP$ D07 134 own_AP accord_NN but_CC there_EX was_BEDZ no_ATI D07 135 approval_NN of_IN his_PP$ action_NN in_IN heaven_NN **'_**' in_IN D07 135 both_ABX sugyoth_&FW ._. ^ such_ABL an_AT D07 136 expression_NN appears_VBZ to_TO have_HV been_BEN framed_VBN in_IN D07 136 response_NN to_IN the_ATI particular_JJ D07 137 point_NN at_IN issue_NN here_RN ,_, whether_CS the_ATI heavenly_JJ D07 137 court_NN concurred_VBD in_IN the_ATI D07 138 decision_NN of_IN the_ATI human_JJ court_NN ._. )_) ^ the_ATI proof_NN D07 138 text_NN of_IN bringing_VBG the_ATI tithe_NN to_IN D07 139 the_ATI Temple_NPL is_BEZ then_RN quoted_VBN and_CC the_ATI D07 139 interpretation_NN of_IN the_ATI latter_AP part_NN of_IN D07 140 the_ATI verse_NN by_IN Rami_NP bar_&FW Rabh_NP is_BEZ added_VBN ,_, D07 140 not_XNOT because_CS this_DT is_BEZ at_IN all_ABN D07 141 relevant_JJ to_IN the_ATI discussion_NN but_CC because_CS it_PP3 D07 141 was_BEDZ a_AT familiar_JJ D07 142 interpretation_NN which_WDTR had_HVD become_VBN so_QL well_RB known_VBN D07 142 that_CS it_PP3 was_BEDZ invariably_RB D07 143 quoted_VBN whenever_WRB the_ATI verse_NN itself_PPL was_BEDZ quoted_VBN D07 143 ,_, almost_RB as_CS if_CS" it_PP3 were_BED a_AT D07 144 part_NN of_IN the_ATI verse_NN ._. D07 145 ^ the_ATI Gemara_NP continues_VBZ with_IN a_AT saying_NN of_IN D07 145 the_ATI Palestinian_JNP D07 146 teacher_NN ,_, \0R_NPT Eleazar_NP (_( 3rd_OD \0cent_NN )_) :_: ^ *'_*' D07 146 the_ATI holy_JJ spirit_NN manifested_VBD D07 147 itself_PPL in_IN three_CD places_NNS :_: the_ATI court_NN of_IN Shem_NP D07 147 ,_, the_ATI court_NN of_IN Samuel_NP of_IN D07 148 Ramah_NP ,_, and_CC the_ATI court_NN of_IN Solomon_NP ._. **'_**' ^ D07 148 the_ATI place_NN of_IN this_DT saying_NN here_RN is_BEZ D07 149 obvious_JJ ,_, it_PP3 follows_VBZ naturally_RB on_IN the_ATI saying_NN D07 149 of_IN \0R_NPT Joshua_NP \0b_&FW Levi_NP D07 150 which_WDTR deals_VBZ with_IN a_AT similar_JJ theme_NN ._. ^ this_DT D07 150 is_BEZ not_XNOT ,_, of_RB course_RB" ,_, to_TO say_VB that_CS D07 151 originally_RB the_ATI saying_NN of_IN \0R_NPT Eleazar_NP was_BEDZ in_IN D07 151 any_DTI way_NN connected_VBN with_IN D07 152 that_DT of_IN \0R_NPT Joshua_NP \0b_&FW Levi_NP ,_, only_RB that_CS D07 152 the_ATI two_CD are_BER placed_VBN into_IN D07 153 juxtaposition_NN by_IN the_ATI Gemara_NP ._. ^ a_AT proof_NN text_NN D07 153 is_BEZ then_RN quoted_VBN for_IN each_DT D07 154 of_IN the_ATI three_CD cases_NNS mentioned_VBN by_IN \0R_NPT Eleazar_NP D07 154 ._. ^ Judah_NP said_VBD *'_*' it_PP3 is_BEZ from_IN D07 155 me_PP1O **'_**' ,_, admitting_VBG that_CS Tamar_NP was_BEDZ with_IN D07 155 child_NN from_IN him_PP3O ._. ^ but_CC how_WRB could_MD he_PP3A D07 156 have_HV known_VBN this_DT ,_, perhaps_RB she_PP3A had_HVD consorted_VBN D07 156 with_IN some_DTI other_AP man_NN ?_? ^ but_CC D07 157 the_ATI meaning_NN of_IN the_ATI verse_NN is_BEZ that_CS a_AT D07 157 heavenly_JJ voice_NN said_VBD :_: ~ *'_*' it_PP3 is_BEZ from_IN D07 158 me_PP1O **'_**' *-_*- in_IN the_ATI words_NNS of_IN the_ATI Gemara_NP D07 158 ,_, the_ATI voice_NN stated_VBD ,_, *'_*' these_DTS D07 159 secret_JJ matters_NNS have_HV proceeded_VBN from_IN me_PP1O **'_**' ._. D07 159 ^ this_DT proves_VBZ ,_, according_IN to_IN" D07 160 the_ATI Gemara_NP ,_, that_CS the_ATI holy_JJ spirit_NN manifested_VBD D07 160 itself_PPL in_IN the_ATI court_NN of_IN D07 161 Shem_NP which_WDTR flourished_VBD in_IN the_ATI days_NNS of_IN Judah_NP D07 161 ._. ^ of_IN Samuel_NP it_PP3 is_BEZ said_VBN that_CS D07 162 when_WRB he_PP3A asked_VBD the_ATI people_NNS to_TO bear_VB witness_NN D07 162 that_CS he_PP3A had_HVD not_XNOT taken_VBN D07 163 anything_PN of_IN theirs_PP$$ the_ATI people_NNS said_VBD that_CS D07 163 they_PP3AS were_BED witnesses_NNS ._. ^ but_CC the_ATI D07 164 verse_NN reads_VBZ :_: ~ *'_*' and_CC he_PP3A said_VBD :_: ~ *'_*' D07 164 witness_VB **'_**' instead_RB of_IN *'_*' and_CC they_PP3AS D07 165 said_VBD **'_**' ._. ^ the_ATI Gemara_NP interprets_VBZ this_DT to_TO D07 165 mean_VB that_CS it_PP3 was_BEDZ a_AT D07 166 heavenly_JJ voice_NN which_WDTR proclaimed_VBD :_: ^ *'_*' witness_VB D07 166 ._. **'_**' ^ finally_RB ,_, the_ATI famous_JJ D07 167 case_NN of_IN the_ATI two_CD harlots_NNS is_BEZ quoted_VBN ._. ^ D07 167 how_WRB did_DOD Solomon_NP know_VB which_WDT was_BEDZ the_ATI D07 168 true_JJ mother_NN ,_, perhaps_RB she_PP3A was_BEDZ acting_VBG D07 168 craftily_RB ?_? ^ but_CC it_PP3 was_BEDZ a_AT heavenly_JJ D07 169 voice_NN which_WDTR said_VBD :_: ^ *'_*' she_PP3A is_BEZ his_PP$ D07 169 mother_NN ._. **'_**' D07 170 ^ Raba_NP objects_VBZ that_CS there_EX is_BEZ no_ATI proof_NN D07 170 from_IN the_ATI texts_NNS quoted_VBN ._. ^ for_IN D07 171 Judah_NP may_MD have_HV known_VBN that_CS Tamar_NP was_BEDZ with_IN D07 171 child_NN from_IN him_PP3O because_CS he_PP3A D07 172 counted_VBD the_ATI days_NNS and_CC months_NNS from_IN the_ATI time_NN D07 172 he_PP3A had_HVD been_BEN with_IN her_PP3O and_CC D07 173 found_VBD them_PP3OS to_TO coincide_VB with_IN the_ATI time_NN of_IN D07 173 her_PP$ pregnancy_NN and_CC we_PP1AS do_DO not_XNOT D07 174 presume_VB that_DT which_WDTR we_PP1AS do_DO not_XNOT see_VB (_( D07 174 \0i.e_RB we_PP1AS do_DO not_XNOT assume_VB that_CS D07 175 another_DT man_NN may_MD have_HV consorted_VBN with_IN her_PP3O at_IN D07 175 the_ATI same_AP time_NN )_) ._. ^ with_IN D07 176 regard_NN to_IN Samuel_NP the_ATI singular_JJ form_NN may_MD have_HV D07 176 been_BEN used_VBN because_CS the_ATI D07 177 whole_JJ people_NNS of_IN Israel_NP are_BER referred_VBN to_IN in_IN D07 177 the_ATI singular_NN ,_, as_CS they_PP3AS are_BER in_IN D07 178 another_DT verse_NN ._. ^ as_IN for_IN" Solomon_NP he_PP3A knew_VBD D07 178 that_CS she_PP3A was_BEDZ the_ATI mother_NN because_CS D07 179 she_PP3A loved_VBD the_ATI child_NN sufficiently_RB to_TO give_VB D07 179 him_PP3O up_RP rather_RB than_CS see_VB him_PP3O D07 180 killed_VBN ._. ^ but_CC ,_, says_VBZ Raba_NP ,_, there_EX is_BEZ no_ATI D07 180 real_JJ proof_NN from_IN the_ATI verses_NNS and_CC D07 181 \0R_NPT Eleazar's_NP$ saying_NN is_BEZ based_VBN on_IN a_AT D07 181 tradition_NN ._. D08 2 ^ it_PP3 follows_VBZ that_CS the_ATI application_NN of_IN the_ATI D08 2 one_CD1 passage_NN to_IN the_ATI D08 3 healing_NN miracles_NNS is_BEZ likely_JJ to_TO be_BE as_QL arbitrary_JJ D08 3 and_CC unprecedented_JJ as_CS the_ATI D08 4 application_NN of_IN the_ATI other_AP to_IN the_ATI *'_*' messianic_JJ D08 4 secret_NN **'_**' ._. ^ in_IN fact_NN the_ATI D08 5 application_NN of_IN \0Isa_NP 53.4_CD to_IN healing_NN miracles_NNS D08 5 is_BEZ not_XNOT really_RB D08 6 appropriate_JJ ._. ^ it_PP3 only_RB becomes_VBZ possible_JJ if_CS D08 6 the_ATI verbs_NNS have_HV the_ATI meaning_NN D08 7 *'_*' take_NC away_NC **'_**' ,_, which_WDTR is_BEZ certainly_RB D08 7 not_XNOT the_ATI meaning_NN of_IN the_ATI Hebrew_NNP they_PP3AS D08 8 translate_VB ,_, and_CC contrary_JJ to_IN the_ATI intention_NN of_IN D08 8 the_ATI original_JJ context_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 D08 9 does_DOZ not_XNOT mean_VB that_CS Jesus_NP cured_VBD diseases_NNS ,_, D08 9 but_CC that_CS he_PP3A bore_VBD them_PP3OS D08 10 himself_PPL ._. ^ we_PP1AS have_HV previously_RB decided_VBN that_CS D08 10 the_ATI proper_JJ Christian_JNP D08 11 understanding_NN of_IN this_DT verse_NN is_BEZ the_ATI atoning_JJ D08 11 efficacy_NN of_IN the_ATI passion_NN ._. D08 12 ^ but_CC because_CS it_PP3 is_BEZ a_AT literal_JJ translation_NN of_IN D08 12 the_ATI Hebrew_NNP ,_, it_PP3 is_BEZ D08 13 necessary_JJ to_TO see_VB a_AT real_JJ reference_NN to_IN the_ATI D08 13 diseases_NNS of_IN the_ATI people_NNS who_WPR D08 14 came_VBD to_IN Jesus_NP ,_, when_WRB the_ATI verse_NN is_BEZ D08 14 selected_VBN for_IN a_AT particular_JJ purpose_NN in_IN D08 15 isolation_NN from_IN the_ATI whole_JJ context_NN ._. ^ as_IN such_ABL D08 15 ,_, it_PP3 may_MD have_HV been_BEN used_VBN to_TO D08 16 relate_VB Christ's_NP$ healing_NN miracles_NNS to_IN his_PP$ total_JJ D08 16 work_NN of_IN redemption_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 D08 17 thus_RB widens_VBZ the_ATI scope_NN of_IN the_ATI great_JJ passion_NN D08 17 prophecy_NN from_IN the_ATI strict_JJ D08 18 passion_NN apologetic_NN to_IN the_ATI whole_NN of_IN our_PP$ D08 18 Lord's_NPT$ ministry_NN ._. ^ the_ATI healings_NNS D08 19 are_BER as_QL much_RB a_AT part_NN of_IN his_PP$ messianic_JJ work_NN D08 19 as_IN the_ATI passion_NN itself_PPL ._. ^ it_PP3 D08 20 was_BEDZ prophesied_VBN that_CS the_ATI Lord's_NPT$ servant_NN would_MD D08 20 bear_VB our_PP$ diseases_NNS ,_, and_CC D08 21 Jesus_NP both_ABX removed_VBD men's_NNS$ diseases_NNS by_IN his_PP$ D08 21 miracles_NNS and_CC himself_PPL suffered_VBD D08 22 their_PP$ pains_NNS on_IN the_ATI cross_NN ._. ^ these_DTS were_BED D08 22 not_XNOT the_ATI acts_NNS of_IN a_AT wonder-worker_NN ,_, D08 23 but_CC should_MD have_HV been_BEN recognized_VBN as_IN the_ATI D08 23 proper_JJ work_NN of_IN the_ATI Christ_NP ,_, even_CS D08 24 if_CS" he_PP3A was_BEDZ only_RB Messias_&FW incognitus_&FW ._. D08 25 ^ when_WRB Matthew_NP incorporates_VBZ this_DT quotation_NN in_IN D08 25 its_PP$ present_JJ D08 26 context_NN ,_, he_PP3A loses_VBZ sight_NN of_IN the_ATI connection_NN D08 26 with_IN the_ATI cross_NN ._. ^ all_ABN that_WPR he_PP3A D08 27 is_BEZ interested_JJ in_IN is_BEZ the_ATI fact_NN that_CS the_ATI D08 27 work_NN of_IN healing_NN can_MD receive_VB D08 28 warrant_NN from_IN scripture_NN ._. ^ the_ATI purpose_NN is_BEZ D08 28 pictorial_JJ rather_RB than_CS D08 29 apologetic_JJ ._. ^ the_ATI details_NNS of_IN the_ATI life_NN of_IN D08 29 Jesus_NP are_BER already_RB present_JJ in_IN D08 30 the_ATI revelation_NN given_VBN to_IN the_ATI prophets_NNS ._. ^ but_CC D08 30 Matthew_NP scarcely_RB realizes_VBZ D08 31 that_CS his_PP$ use_NN of_IN the_ATI verse_NN accords_VBZ ill_RB D08 31 with_IN its_PP$ real_JJ meaning_NN ._. D08 32 ^ our_PP$ Lord's_NPT$ use_NN of_IN parables_NNS ._. D08 33 ^ the_ATI effect_NN of_IN the_ATI two_CD quotations_NNS which_WDTR D08 33 we_PP1AS have_HV so_QL far_RB studied_VBN D08 34 in_IN this_DT section_NN is_BEZ to_TO prove_VB that_CS when_WRB D08 34 Jesus_NP did_DOD acts_NNS of_IN healing_NN he_PP3A was_BEDZ D08 35 acting_VBG as_IN the_ATI Messiah_NP ._. ^ this_DT raises_VBZ the_ATI D08 35 question_NN whether_CS people_NNS can_MD be_BE D08 36 held_VBN culpable_JJ for_IN failing_VBG to_TO recognize_VB this_DT ._. ^ D08 36 this_DT aspect_NN of_IN the_ATI D08 37 matter_NN appears_VBZ in_IN a_AT further_JJB pair_NN of_IN texts_NNS D08 37 which_WDTR are_BER concerned_VBN with_IN our_PP$ D08 38 Lord's_NPT$ use_NN of_IN parables_NNS ._. ^ the_ATI analysis_NN will_MD D08 38 show_VB that_CS the_ATI early_JJ Church_NPL D08 39 not_XNOT unnaturally_RB adopted_VBD the_ATI position_NN that_CS D08 39 failure_NN to_TO see_VB the_ATI messianic_JJ D08 40 character_NN of_IN his_PP$ work_NN was_BEDZ really_RB caused_VBN by_IN D08 40 the_ATI people's_NNS$ own_AP blindness_NN ._. D08 41 ^ there_EX was_BEDZ a_AT fundamental_JJ refusal_NN to_TO understand_VB D08 41 and_CC to_TO believe_VB ._. D08 42 ^ we_PP1AS begin_VB by_IN observing_VBG how_WRB Matthew_NP D08 42 precisely_RB repeats_VBZ with_IN regard_NN D08 43 to_IN the_ATI parables_NNS the_ATI procedure_NN he_PP3A had_HVD D08 43 used_VBN for_IN healings_NNS and_CC exorcisms_NNS ._. D08 44 ^ he_PP3A takes_VBZ two_CD virtually_RB equivalent_JJ Marcan_JNP D08 44 summaries_NNS ,_, abbreviates_VBZ them_PP3OS D08 45 to_TO make_VB one_CD1 point_VB each_DT ,_, and_CC adds_VBZ what_WDT D08 45 he_PP3A thinks_VBZ to_TO be_BE the_ATI appropriate_JJ D08 46 testimony_NN in_IN each_DT case_NN ._. ^ the_ATI matter_NN is_BEZ D08 46 further_RBR complicated_VBN ,_, however_RB ,_, D08 47 by_IN the_ATI fact_NN that_CS the_ATI earlier_JJR passage_NN about_IN D08 47 parables_NNS already_RB contains_VBZ D08 48 the_ATI quotation_NN material_NN (_( \0i.e_RB \0Isa_NP 6.9_CD \0f_RB D08 48 )_) in_IN the_ATI Marcan_JNP D08 49 original_NN ;_; and_CC this_DT is_BEZ a_AT quotation_NN which_WDTR D08 49 has_HVZ wide_JJ ramifications_NNS D08 50 throughout_IN the_ATI new_JJ testament_NN ._. D08 51 ^ the_ATI first_OD summary_NN is_BEZ Mark_NP 4.10-12_CD-CD ._. ^ D08 51 it_PP3 is_BEZ a_AT short_JJ paragraph_NN on_IN D08 52 the_ATI reason_NN for_IN parables_NNS ,_, largely_RB based_VBN on_IN D08 52 \0Isa_NP 6.9_CD \0f_RB ,_, which_WDTR Mark_NP D08 53 has_HVZ inserted_VBN here_RN to_TO *'_*' mark_VB time_NN **'_**' D08 53 between_IN the_ATI parable_NN of_IN the_ATI sower_NN D08 54 and_CC its_PP$ interpretation_NN ._. ^ Matthew_NP does_DOZ not_XNOT D08 54 add_VB a_AT new_JJ quotation_NN ,_, but_CC on_IN D08 55 the_ATI other_AP hand_NN abbreviates_VBZ the_ATI Marcan_JNP version_NN D08 55 still_RB further_RBR ,_, when_WRB he_PP3A D08 56 rewrites_VBZ this_DT in_IN \0Matt_NP 13.10-16_CD-CD ._. ^ his_PP$ D08 56 improvements_NNS consist_VB in_IN D08 57 (_( a_ZZ )_) the_ATI insertion_NN of_IN the_ATI proverbial_JJ saying_NN D08 57 about_IN ~ *'_*' whosoever_WPA D08 58 hath_HVZ ,_, to_IN him_PP3O shall_MD be_BE given_VBN **'_**' ,_, D08 58 \0etc_RB ,_, from_IN Mark_NP 4.25_CD ;_; and_CC (_( b_ZZ )_) D08 59 the_ATI addition_NN of_IN a_AT Q_ZZ saying_NN about_IN the_ATI D08 59 blessedness_NN of_IN the_ATI disciples_NNS ,_, D08 60 which_WDTR has_HVZ a_AT closely_RB similar_JJ vocabulary_NN to_IN D08 60 that_DT of_IN the_ATI Isaiah_NP allusion_NN ._. D08 61 ^ these_DTS improvements_NNS have_HV the_ATI sole_JJB motive_NN of_IN D08 61 enhancing_VBG the_ATI superiority_NN D08 62 of_IN the_ATI disciples_NNS ,_, who_WPR have_HV the_ATI secret_JJ D08 62 knowledge_NN which_WDTR others_APS fail_VB to_TO D08 63 perceive_VB ._. ^ the_ATI inserted_JJ verse_NN properly_RB denotes_VBZ D08 63 a_AT warning_NN against_IN D08 64 taking_VBG spiritual_JJ privilege_NN for_CS granted_VBN ._. ^ it_PP3 D08 64 retains_VBZ this_DT in_IN its_PP$ Marcan_JNP D08 65 context_NN (_( Mark_NP 4.21-5_CD-CD ,_, otherwise_RB omitted_VBN by_IN D08 65 Matthew_NP )_) ,_, and_CC even_RB more_QL D08 66 clearly_RB in_IN its_PP$ Q_ZZ version_NN at_IN the_ATI end_NN of_IN D08 66 the_ATI parable_NN of_IN the_ATI talents_NNS D08 67 (_( \0Matt_NP 25.29_CD =_&FO Luke_NP 19.26_CD )_) ._. ^ but_CC here_RN D08 67 it_PP3 actually_RB increases_VBZ the_ATI D08 68 sense_NN of_IN privilege_NN ,_, which_WDTR directly_RB contradicts_VBZ D08 68 our_PP$ Lord's_NPT$ intention_NN !_! D08 69 ^ the_ATI added_JJ Q_ZZ saying_NN on_IN the_ATI blessedness_NN of_IN D08 69 the_ATI disciples_NNS is_BEZ really_RB D08 70 concerned_VBN with_IN the_ATI blessedness_NN of_IN the_ATI present_JJ D08 70 generation_NN ,_, when_WRB the_ATI D08 71 kingdom_NN of_IN God_NP is_BEZ breaking_VBG in_RP ,_, by_IN contrast_NN D08 71 with_IN the_ATI unfulfilled_JJ hopes_NNS D08 72 of_IN previous_JJ generations_NNS ._. ^ but_CC Matthew_NP has_HVZ D08 72 made_VBN it_PP3 underline_VB the_ATI good_JJ D08 73 fortune_NN of_IN the_ATI disciples_NNS as_IN a_AT privileged_JJ D08 73 e*?2lite_NN ._. D08 74 ^ the_ATI second_OD summary_NN is_BEZ Mark's_NP$ conclusion_NN to_IN D08 74 the_ATI chapter_NN (_( Mark_NP D08 75 4.33_CD \0f_RB )_) ._. ^ in_IN \0Matt_NP 13.34_CD Matthew_NP takes_VBZ D08 75 over_RP the_ATI first_OD of_IN these_DTS two_CD D08 76 verses_NNS ,_, which_WDTR says_VBZ that_CS Jesus_NP gave_VBD all_ABN D08 76 his_PP$ teaching_NN in_IN the_ATI form_NN of_IN D08 77 parables_NNS ._. ^ but_CC he_PP3A suppresses_VBZ the_ATI other_AP ,_, D08 77 which_WDTR tells_VBZ how_WRB Jesus_NP D08 78 afterwards_RB interpreted_VBD them_PP3OS to_IN the_ATI disciples_NNS D08 78 privately_RB ._. ^ instead_RB he_PP3A D08 79 inserts_VBZ from_IN his_PP$ own_AP stock_NN the_ATI D08 79 formula-quotation_NN of_IN \0Ps_NP 78.2_CD :_: ^ *'_*' I_PP1A D08 80 will_MD open_VB my_PP$ mouth_NN in_IN parables_NNS ;_; I_PP1A will_MD D08 80 utter_VB things_NNS hidden_VBN from_IN the_ATI D08 81 foundation_NN (_( of_IN the_ATI world_NN )_) ._. **'_**' ^ these_DTS D08 81 changes_NNS thus_RB cut_VB out_RP any_DTI further_JJB D08 82 mention_NN of_IN the_ATI privilege_NN of_IN the_ATI disciples_NNS ,_, D08 82 which_WDTR had_HVD been_BEN specifically_RB D08 83 developed_VBN in_IN the_ATI former_AP summary_NN ,_, and_CC place_VB D08 83 the_ATI emphasis_NN solely_RB on_IN the_ATI D08 84 intentional_JJ obscurity_NN of_IN Jesus'_NP$ public_JJ teaching_NN ._. ^ D08 84 we_PP1AS shall_MD see_VB that_CS in_IN D08 85 both_ABX cases_NNS Matthew's_NP$ interpretation_NN of_IN the_ATI D08 85 material_NN is_BEZ the_ATI end_NN of_IN a_AT D08 86 process_NN which_WDTR reflects_VBZ changing_JJ conditions_NNS in_IN D08 86 the_ATI Church_NPL ._. ^ as_CS the_ATI D08 87 second_OD is_BEZ much_RB the_ATI simpler_JJR one_CD1 of_IN the_ATI D08 87 two_CD ,_, it_PP3 will_MD be_BE best_JJT to_TO consider_VB D08 88 it_PP3 first_RB ._. D08 90 ^ the_ATI keyword_NN for_IN Matthew_NP is_BEZ wen_&FW D08 90 parabolai*?21s_&FW ._. ^ as_CS the_ATI D08 91 whole_NN of_IN the_ATI first_OD line_NN is_BEZ identical_JJ with_IN D08 91 the_ATI Septuagint_NP ,_, it_PP3 probably_RB D08 92 represents_VBZ the_ATI final_JJ stage_NN of_IN the_ATI adaptation_NN D08 92 of_IN the_ATI text_NN ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ to_TO D08 93 make_VB it_PP3 specifically_RB applicable_JJ to_IN the_ATI use_NN of_IN D08 93 parables_NNS ._. ^ for_IN earlier_JJR D08 94 stages_NNS we_PP1AS have_HV to_TO look_VB at_IN the_ATI second_OD D08 94 line_NN ,_, which_WDTR is_BEZ an_AT independent_JJ D08 95 rendering_NN of_IN the_ATI Hebrew_JNP text_NN ._. ^ this_DT was_BEDZ D08 95 not_XNOT necessarily_RB concerned_VBN with_IN D08 96 parables_NNS at_IN all_ABN ._. ^ the_ATI most_QL notable_JJ feature_NN D08 96 of_IN it_PP3 is_BEZ the_ATI translation_NN D08 97 kekrumme*?2na_&FW (_( =_&FO things_NNS kept_VBN hidden_JJ )_) for_IN D08 98 **[HEBREW.QUOTATION**]_&FW D08 99 (_( =_&FO riddles_NNS )_) ._. ^ this_DT directly_RB contradicts_VBZ D08 99 what_WDT is_BEZ said_VBN in_IN \0Ps_NP 78.3_CD \0f_RB ,_, D08 100 that_CS these_DTS things_NNS have_HV been_BEN handed_VBN down_RP D08 100 from_IN the_ATI fathers_NNS ,_, and_CC *'_*' we_PP1AS D08 101 will_MD not_XNOT hide_VB them_PP3OS **'_**' from_IN succeeding_JJ D08 101 generations_NNS ._. ^ thus_RB this_DT version_NN D08 102 disregards_VBZ the_ATI context_NN ,_, presumably_RB intentionally_RB D08 102 ._. D08 103 ^ nevertheless_RB there_EX is_BEZ evidence_NN that_CS this_DT D08 103 psalm_NN was_BEDZ used_VBN by_IN at_IN any_DTI D08 104 rate_NN one_CD1 circle_NN in_IN the_ATI Church_NPL with_IN closer_JJR D08 104 attention_NN to_IN its_PP$ meaning_NN ._. D08 105 ^ in_IN John_NP 6.31_CD our_PP$ Lord's_NPT$ opponents_NNS quote_VB D08 105 \0v_NN 24_CD :_: ^ *'_*' he_PP3A gave_VBD them_PP3OS D08 106 bread_NN out_RP of_IN heaven_NN to_TO eat_VB ._. **'_**' ^ the_ATI D08 106 objection_NN is_BEZ that_CS Jesus'_NP$ claim_NN to_TO D08 107 be_BE the_ATI Messiah_NP is_BEZ invalidated_VBN by_IN his_PP$ D08 107 failure_NN to_TO repeat_VB the_ATI miracle_NN of_IN D08 108 the_ATI manna_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ evident_JJ that_CS the_ATI D08 108 feeding_NN of_IN the_ATI multitude_NN is_BEZ held_VBN by_IN D08 109 John_NP to_TO be_BE a_AT proper_JJ repetition_NN of_IN this_DT D08 109 miracle_NN ._. ^ but_CC the_ATI teaching_NN D08 110 shows_VBZ that_CS the_ATI miracle_NN is_BEZ fulfilled_VBN more_QL D08 110 truly_RB at_IN a_AT much_RB deeper_JJR level_NN ._. D08 111 ^ this_DT implies_VBZ an_AT interpretation_NN of_IN the_ATI whole_JJ D08 111 psalm_NN in_IN terms_NNS of_IN our_PP$ D08 112 Lord's_NPT$ redeeming_JJ work_NN ._. ^ the_ATI psalm_NN is_BEZ a_AT D08 112 poetical_JJ narrative_NN of_IN the_ATI acts_NNS D08 113 of_IN God_NP in_IN redemption_NN ._. ^ the_ATI elaborate_JJ opening_JJ D08 113 verses_NNS ,_, speaking_VBG darkly_RB D08 114 of_IN a_AT mystery_NN from_IN the_ATI foundation_NN of_IN the_ATI D08 114 world_NN ,_, are_BER intended_VBN to_TO show_VB D08 115 that_CS such_ABL acts_NNS are_BER always_RB true_JJ of_IN God_NP ._. ^ D08 115 the_ATI whole_JJ thing_NN is_BEZ thus_RB an_AT D08 116 expression_NN of_IN faith_NN ,_, that_CS he_PP3A who_WPR acted_VBD D08 116 in_IN this_DT way_NN can_MD do_DO so_PN again_RB ._. D08 117 ^ in_IN the_ATI same_AP way_NN ,_, those_DTS who_WPR try_VB to_TO D08 117 figure_VB out_RP eschatological_JJ D08 118 programmes_NNS can_MD expect_VB the_ATI same_AP acts_NNS to_TO be_BE D08 118 repeated_VBN ._. ^ this_DT was_BEDZ perhaps_RB D08 119 too_QL naively_RB imagined_VBN by_IN some_DTI ._. ^ but_CC if_CS D08 119 the_ATI Jews_NNPS objected_VBN that_CS Jesus_NP had_HVD D08 120 failed_VBN to_TO perform_VB the_ATI repetition_NN of_IN acts_NNS of_IN D08 120 redemption_NN expected_VBN in_IN the_ATI D08 121 eschatological_JJ programme_NN ,_, the_ATI Church_NPL could_MD reply_VB D08 121 that_CS he_PP3A had_HVD indeed_RB D08 122 fulfilled_VBN it_PP3 ,_, though_CS in_IN a_AT mystery_NN ._. ^ this_DT D08 122 is_BEZ an_AT apologetic_JJ motive_NN for_IN D08 123 the_ATI feeding_NN miracles_NNS ._. ^ and_CC it_PP3 also_RB shows_VBZ D08 123 how_WRB Jesus_NP was_BEDZ truly_RB acting_VBG as_IN D08 124 the_ATI Messiah_NP in_IN the_ATI time_NN before_IN his_PP$ D08 124 crucifixion_NN ._. D08 125 ^ we_PP1AS have_HV now_RN arrived_VBN at_IN an_AT intelligible_JJ D08 125 reason_NN for_IN D08 126 kekrumme*?2na_&FW as_IN a_AT rendering_NN of_IN D08 127 **[HEBREW.QUOTATION**]_&FW ._. D08 128 ^ these_DTS *'_*' riddles_NNS **'_**' are_BER the_ATI righteous_JJ D08 128 acts_NNS of_IN God_NP in_IN redemption_NN ,_, as_CS D08 129 the_ATI psalm_NN itself_PPL implies_VBZ ._. ^ the_ATI works_NNS of_IN D08 129 Jesus_NP *-_*- primarily_RB his_PP$ atoning_JJ D08 130 death_NN ,_, but_CC also_RB ,_, at_IN this_DT stage_NN in_IN the_ATI D08 130 apologetic_NN ,_, the_ATI rest_NN of_IN the_ATI D08 131 ministry_NN *-_*- are_BER the_ATI final_JJ expression_NN of_IN D08 131 these_DTS acts_NNS of_IN redemption_NN ._. ^ but_CC D08 132 if_CS it_PP3 be_BE objected_VBN that_CS his_PP$ works_NNS bore_VBD D08 132 little_AP relation_NN to_IN the_ATI way_NN in_IN D08 133 which_WDTR this_DT was_BEDZ expected_VBN ,_, then_RN it_PP3 invited_VBD D08 133 the_ATI apologist_NN to_TO place_VB the_ATI D08 134 emphasis_NN on_IN the_ATI hiddenness_NN of_IN God's_NP$ ways_NNS ._. ^ D08 134 to_TO say_VB that_CS Jesus'_NP$ D08 135 works_NNS were_BED genuinely_RB messianic_JJ ,_, but_CC took_VBD D08 135 the_ATI form_NN of_IN D08 136 **[HEBREW.QUOTATION**]_&FW ,_, D08 137 so_CS that_CS" they_PP3AS could_MD only_RB be_BE perceived_VBN as_IN D08 137 such_ABL by_IN the_ATI elect_JJ ,_, solves_VBZ the_ATI D08 138 whole_JJ problem_NN ._. D08 139 ^ such_ABL is_BEZ the_ATI application_NN of_IN \0Ps_NP 78_CD D08 139 considered_VBN as_IN a_AT whole_NN ._. ^ the_ATI D08 140 selection_NN of_IN \0v_NN 2_CD as_IN a_AT pesher_&FW quotation_NN D08 140 narrows_VBZ the_ATI application_NN D08 141 to_IN the_ATI teaching_NN of_IN Jesus_NP ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ the_ATI D08 141 full_JJ and_CC final_JJ revelation_NN D08 142 (_( \0cf_VB \0Heb_NP 1.2a_CD )_) ._. ^ in_IN the_ATI first_OD line_NN D08 143 **[HEBREW.QUOTATION**]_&FW D08 144 has_HVZ a_AT roughly_RB equivalent_JJ meaning_NN to_IN D08 145 **[HEBREW.QUOTATION**]_&FW D08 146 in_IN the_ATI second_OD ._. ^ to_TO apply_VB it_PP3 to_IN the_ATI D08 146 parabolic_JJ method_NN is_BEZ a_AT further_JJB D08 147 refinement_NN ,_, effected_VBN with_IN the_ATI aid_NN of_IN the_ATI D08 147 Septuagint_NP rendering_NN ._. D08 148 ^ finally_RB Matthew_NP inserts_VBZ the_ATI resultant_JJ text_NN D08 148 into_IN his_PP$ parables_NNS chapter_NN D08 149 for_IN its_PP$ *'_*' pictorial_JJ **'_**' value_NN ,_, just_RB as_CS D08 149 he_PP3A used_VBD \0Isa_NP 53.4_CD at_IN 8.17_CD ._. D08 150 ^ these_DTS stages_NNS of_IN development_NN reflect_VB the_ATI D08 150 Church's_NPL$ changing_JJ D08 151 outlook_NN ._. ^ to_TO begin_VB with_RI ,_, the_ATI resurrection_NN D08 151 is_BEZ held_VBN to_TO be_BE the_ATI revelation_NN D08 152 of_IN the_ATI mystery_NN of_IN redemption_NN ,_, the_ATI open_JJ D08 152 demonstration_NN of_IN God's_NP$ saving_JJ D08 153 activity_NN to_IN which_WDTR all_ABN previous_JJ sacred_JJ history_NN D08 153 has_HVZ been_BEN leading_VBG ._. ^ this_DT D08 154 idea_NN is_BEZ commonly_RB met_VBN with_IN in_IN the_ATI Pauline_JNP D08 154 epistles_NNS ,_, \0e.g_RB 1_CD1 D08 155 \0Cor_NP 2.7_CD ,_, where_WRB it_PP3 characteristically_RB refers_VBZ D08 155 principally_RB to_IN the_ATI D08 156 cross_NN ._. ^ secondly_RB the_ATI teaching_NN of_IN Jesus_NP is_BEZ D08 156 held_VBN to_TO be_BE an_AT essential_JJ part_NN D08 157 of_IN the_ATI revelation_NN ,_, though_CS its_PP$ true_JJ D08 157 significance_NN was_BEDZ known_VBN only_RB to_IN the_ATI D08 158 *'_*' elect_JJ **'_**' ._. ^ thus_RB the_ATI construction_NN put_VBN D08 158 upon_IN the_ATI teaching_NN in_IN the_ATI light_NN D08 159 of_IN the_ATI resurrection_NN faith_NN is_BEZ read_VBN back_RP as_CS D08 159 if_CS" that_DT was_BEDZ its_PP$ recognized_JJ D08 160 meaning_NN all_RB along_RP ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ exactly_RB parallel_JJ D08 160 to_IN the_ATI attitude_NN adopted_VBN D08 161 to_IN the_ATI healing_NN miracles_NNS ._. ^ it_PP3 was_BEDZ a_AT D08 161 natural_JJ position_NN to_TO take_VB ,_, once_CS the_ATI D08 162 teacher_NN himself_PPL had_HVD withdrawn_VBN ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ D08 162 similar_JJ to_IN the_ATI position_NN of_IN the_ATI D08 163 Qumran_NP covenanters_NNS ,_, who_WPR preserved_VBD a_AT tradition_NN D08 163 of_IN biblical_JJ exegesis_NN ,_, D08 164 derived_VBN from_IN their_PP$ founder_NN ,_, which_WDTR they_PP3AS D08 164 regarded_VBD as_IN a_AT secret_NN revealed_VBN D08 165 to_IN the_ATI e*?2lite_NN ._. ^ the_ATI third_OD and_CC final_JJ D08 165 stage_NN is_BEZ the_ATI claim_NN that_CS D08 166 this_DT method_NN was_BEDZ a_AT deliberate_JJ policy_NN on_IN the_ATI D08 166 part_NN of_IN Jesus_NP ,_, to_TO prevent_VB D08 167 the_ATI mystery_NN from_IN being_BEG revealed_VBN to_IN any_DTI but_IN D08 167 the_ATI few_AP who_WPR are_BER chosen_VBN ._. ^ it_PP3 D08 168 is_BEZ probable_JJ that_CS this_DT idea_NN of_IN a_AT policy_NN of_IN D08 168 concealment_NN on_IN the_ATI part_NN of_IN D08 169 our_PP$ Lord_NPT corresponds_VBZ with_IN an_AT actual_JJ impression_NN D08 169 given_VBN by_IN his_PP$ anxiety_NN to_TO D08 170 prevent_VB his_PP$ own_AP radical_JJ reinterpretation_NN of_IN the_ATI D08 170 kingdom_NN of_IN God_NP from_IN D08 171 being_BEG confused_VBN with_IN popular_JJ expectations_NNS ._. ^ D08 171 the_ATI special_JJ Marcan_JNP nuance_NN D08 172 in_IN connection_NN with_IN this_DT is_BEZ the_ATI impression_NN D08 172 that_CS even_RB the_ATI inner_JJB group_NN of_IN D08 173 disciples_NNS were_BED themselves_PPLS equally_RB mystified_VBN by_IN D08 173 the_ATI parabolic_JJ method_NN D08 174 (_( Mark_NP 8.17_CD )_) ._. ^ a_AT concomitant_NN of_IN the_ATI D08 174 final_JJ stage_NN is_BEZ the_ATI sect-type_JJB D08 175 doctrine_NN of_IN the_ATI Church_NPL ._. ^ the_ATI Church_NPL is_BEZ D08 175 a_AT privileged_JJ e*?2lite_NN ,_, D08 176 having_HVG access_NN to_IN knowledge_NN denied_VBN to_IN those_DTS D08 176 outside_IN its_PP$ ranks_NNS ._. D08 177 ^ Isaiah_NP 6.9_CD \0f_RB ._. D08 178 ^ we_PP1AS now_RN turn_VB to_IN the_ATI earlier_JJR paragraph_NN D08 178 on_IN parables_NNS ,_, and_CC look_VB D08 179 first_RB at_IN the_ATI material_NN as_CS it_PP3 stands_VBZ in_IN D08 179 Mark_NP 4.10-13_CD-CD ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ clear_JJ that_CS D08 180 we_PP1AS have_HV here_RN an_AT original_JJ saying_NN built_VBN on_IN D08 180 \0Isa_NP 6.9_CD \0f_RB ,_, sandwiched_VBN D08 181 between_IN Marcan_JNP editorial_JJ matter_NN which_WDTR considerably_RB D08 181 alters_VBZ the_ATI sense_NN of_IN D08 182 it_PP3 ._. ^ the_ATI nucleus_NN consists_VBZ of_IN \0vv_NNS 11_CD D08 182 \0f_RB ,_, which_WDTR is_BEZ a_AT perfect_JJ D08 183 expression_NN of_IN the_ATI doctrine_NN of_IN the_ATI e*?2lite_NN ._. ^ D08 183 the_ATI mystery_NN of_IN the_ATI D08 184 kingdom_NN is_BEZ given_VBN to_IN the_ATI disciples_NNS ,_, but_CC D08 184 to_IN outsiders_NNS all_ABN things_NNS are_BER D08 185 *'_*' in_IN parables_NNS **'_**' ._. ^ the_ATI purpose_NN is_BEZ to_TO D08 185 sift_VB the_ATI people_NNS ,_, for_CS (_( it_PP3 is_BEZ D08 186 assumed_VBN )_) the_ATI elect_JJ perceive_VB the_ATI mystery_NN ,_, D08 186 but_CC the_ATI rejected_JJ are_BER blind_JJ to_IN D08 187 it_PP3 ._. ^ if_CS wen_&FW parabolai*?21s_&FW represents_VBZ D08 188 **[HEBREW.QUOTATION**]_&FW D08 189 (_( collective_JJ )_) ,_, as_CS it_PP3 actually_RB does_DOZ in_IN D08 189 the_ATI Septuagint_NP of_IN \0Ps_NP 78.2_CD ,_, D08 190 then_RN the_ATI original_JJ saying_NN was_BEDZ probably_RB more_QL D08 190 general_JJ in_IN intention_NN ,_, and_CC D08 191 it_PP3 is_BEZ Mark_NP who_WPR has_HVZ narrowed_VBN it_PP3 down_RP to_IN D08 191 parables_NNS in_IN the_ATI technical_JJ D08 192 sense_NN ._. D09 2 ^ faith_NN can_MD not_XNOT stand_VB unless_CS it_PP3 has_HVZ nothing_PN D09 2 to_TO stand_VB on_IN ._. ^ every_AT moment_NN D09 3 is_BEZ strain_NN and_CC crisis_NN ._. ^ that_DT may_MD be_BE natural_JJ D09 3 to_IN the_ATI reformer_NN in_IN a_AT D09 4 decadent_JJ atmosphere_NN (_( if_CS Danish_JNP religion_NN was_BEDZ D09 4 decadent_JJ )_) ,_, but_CC it_PP3 has_HVZ the_ATI D09 5 true_JJ Jansenist_JNP touch_NN ,_, as_CS defined_VBN by_IN D09 5 Sainte-Beuve_NP in_IN the_ATI famous_JJ phrase_NN ,_, D09 6 ^ *'_*' it_PP3 forgot_VBD God_NP the_ATI father_NN ._. **'_**' ^ D09 6 after_IN all_ABN ,_, the_ATI world_NN created_VBN by_IN God_NP D09 7 was_BEDZ pronounced_VBN good_JJ by_IN him_PP3O ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ D09 7 corrected_VBN but_CC not_XNOT superseded_VBN by_IN the_ATI D09 8 religion_NN of_IN redemption_NN *-_*- the_ATI kingdom_NN of_IN the_ATI D09 8 son_NN ._. D09 9 ^ no_ATI doubt_NN there_EX are_BER fierce_JJ and_CC dangerous_JJ D09 9 factors_NNS working_VBG under_IN the_ATI D09 10 surface_NN of_IN our_PP$ souls_NNS ,_, but_CC we_PP1AS need_MD not_XNOT D09 10 (_( indeed_RB we_PP1AS can_MD not_XNOT )_) be_BE always_RB D09 11 living_VBG under_IN the_ATI surface_NN ._. D09 12 ^ we_PP1AS get_VB a_AT clear_JJ result_NN of_IN his_PP$ system_NN D09 12 when_WRB he_PP3A speaks_VBZ of_IN children_NNS ._. D09 13 ^ as_CS their_PP$ life_NN has_HVZ no_ATI strain_NN they_PP3AS can_MD D09 13 not_XNOT be_BE real_JJ Christians_NNPS and_CC D09 14 Kierkegaard_NP has_HVZ to_TO deal_VB (_( rather_RB shame-facedly_RB )_) D09 14 with_IN the_ATI gospel_NN texts_NNS D09 15 on_IN the_ATI subject_NN (_( unscientific_JJ postscript_NN ,_, \0p_NN D09 15 524_CD )_) ._. D09 16 ^ Kant_NP and_CC the_ATI utilitarians_NNS ._. D09 17 ^ most_AP people_NNS would_MD agree_VB that_CS Immanuel_NP Kant_NP D09 17 was_BEDZ a_AT great_JJ thinker_NN D09 18 and_CC also_RB that_CS he_PP3A was_BEDZ hard_JJ to_TO understand_VB ._. D09 19 ^ there_EX are_BER many_AP ways_NNS of_IN being_BEG hard_JJ to_TO D09 19 understand_VB ._. ^ one_CD1 is_BEZ due_JJ to_IN D09 20 style_NN ._. ^ not_XNOT knowing_VBG German_NNP ,_, I_PP1A can_MD D09 20 hardly_RB assess_VB this_DT ._. ^ it_PP3 would_MD seem_VB D09 21 that_CS he_PP3A can_MD be_BE quite_RB lucid_JJ when_WRB he_PP3A D09 21 wants_VBZ ,_, and_CC can_MD strike_VB out_RP effective_JJ D09 22 phrases_NNS like_IN ~ *'_*' perceptions_NNS without_IN conceptions_NNS D09 22 are_BER blind_JJ ,_, and_CC D09 23 conceptions_NNS without_IN perceptions_NNS are_BER empty_JJ ,_, **'_**' D09 23 or_CC ~ *'_*' so_RB act_VB that_CS your_PP$ D09 24 action_NN may_MD be_BE a_AT general_JJ law_NN ._. **'_**' ^ on_IN D09 24 the_ATI other_AP hand_NN ,_, he_PP3A is_BEZ one_CD1 of_IN the_ATI D09 25 philosophers_NNS whose_WP$R work_NN has_HVZ been_BEN subjected_VBN D09 25 to_IN higher_JJR criticism_NN ,_, and_CC D09 26 the_ATI division_NN into_IN earlier_JJR and_CC later_JJR strata_NNS D09 26 recalls_VBZ the_ATI Q_ZZ and_CC M_ZZ and_CC L_ZZ D09 27 of_IN new_JJ testament_NN sources_NNS ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ partly_RB D09 27 owing_IN to_IN" the_ATI fact_NN that_CS he_PP3A D09 28 was_BEDZ thinking_VBG ,_, while_CS he_PP3A was_BEDZ writing_VBG ,_, D09 28 and_CC did_DOD not_XNOT always_RB trouble_VB to_TO turn_VB D09 29 and_CC revise_VB page_NN 100_CD in_IN the_ATI light_NN of_IN what_WDT D09 29 he_PP3A had_HVD said_VBN on_IN page_NN 200_CD ._. ^ but_CC D09 30 we_PP1AS must_MD also_RB take_VB into_IN account_NN a_AT feature_NN D09 30 of_IN his_PP$ mind_NN that_WPR may_MD be_BE D09 31 called_VBN dualism_NN ._. ^ he_PP3A tells_VBZ us_PP1OS himself_PPL D09 31 that_CS his_PP$ method_NN of_IN thinking_VBG was_BEDZ D09 32 to_TO take_VB a_AT point_NN of_IN view_NN and_CC work_VB it_PP3 out_RP D09 32 to_IN its_PP$ logical_JJ conclusion_NN and_CC D09 33 then_RN to_TO do_DO the_ATI same_AP with_IN the_ATI opposite_JJ D09 33 point_NN of_IN view_NN ._. ^ they_PP3AS sometimes_RB D09 34 lie_VB down_RP side_NN by_IN side_NN ,_, like_IN the_ATI lion_NN and_CC D09 34 the_ATI lamb_NN ,_, but_CC not_XNOT to_TO live_VB in_IN D09 35 peace_NN together_RB ._. D09 36 ^ two_CD famous_JJ examples_NNS present_VB themselves_PPLS in_IN D09 36 the_ATI critique_NN of_IN pure_JJ D09 37 reason_NN ,_, where_WRB he_PP3A is_BEZ analysing_VBG the_ATI fact_NN D09 37 of_IN knowledge_NN ._. ^ first_RB of_IN all_ABN ,_, D09 38 the_ATI case_NN of_IN the_ATI senses_NNS and_CC the_ATI D09 38 understanding_NN ._. ^ they_PP3AS seem_VB to_TO have_HV no_ATI D09 39 common_JJ root_NN ._. ^ the_ATI first_OD is_BEZ passive_JJ ,_, the_ATI D09 39 second_OD active_JJ ._. ^ the_ATI first_OD D09 40 deals_VBZ with_IN the_ATI outward_JJB and_CC the_ATI second_OD with_IN D09 40 the_ATI inner_JJB world_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ D09 41 said_VBN that_CS they_PP3AS are_BER inseparable_JJ but_CC it_PP3 is_BEZ D09 41 not_XNOT clear_JJ why_WRB (_( for_IN example_NN )_) D09 42 my_PP$ sensation_NN of_IN colour_NN and_CC my_PP$ thought_NN of_IN D09 42 substance_NN should_MD combine_VB into_IN D09 43 the_ATI amalgam_NN we_PP1AS call_VB *'_*' seeing_VBG a_AT thing_NN D09 43 **'_**' ._. ^ we_PP1AS may_MD say_VB (_( without_IN going_VBG D09 44 into_IN technicalities_NNS )_) that_CS Kant_NP took_VBD his_PP$ D09 44 account_NN of_IN the_ATI senses_NNS from_IN D09 45 Hume_NP ,_, and_CC his_PP$ account_NN of_IN the_ATI understanding_NN D09 45 from_IN Leibniz_NP ,_, and_CC it_PP3 can_MD D09 46 hardly_RB be_BE said_VBN that_CS he_PP3A reconciled_VBD them_PP3OS ._. D09 47 ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ the_ATI same_AP with_IN the_ATI distinction_NN D09 47 between_IN phenomena_NNS (_( things_NNS as_CS D09 48 they_PP3AS appear_VB to_IN us_PP1OS )_) and_CC things_NNS in_IN D09 48 themselves_PPLS (_( as_CS they_PP3AS really_RB are_BER )_) ._. ^ D09 48 we_PP1AS D09 49 are_BER told_VBN there_EX is_BEZ a_AT deep_JJ gulf_NN between_IN D09 49 the_ATI two_CD ._. ^ phenomena_NNS fall_VB within_IN D09 50 my_PP$ experience_NN ._. ^ things_NNS in_IN themselves_PPLS are_BER D09 50 unknowable_JJ ,_, but_CC in_IN that_DT case_NN D09 51 how_WRB do_DO I_PP1A know_VB of_IN their_PP$ existence_NN ?_? ^ and_CC D09 51 what_WDT of_IN the_ATI knowing_JJ self_NN which_WDTR ,_, D09 52 in_IN his_PP$ view_NN ,_, seems_VBZ to_TO belong_VB to_IN both_ABX D09 52 worlds_NNS ?_? ^ we_PP1AS must_MD keep_VB this_DT D09 53 dualism_NN in_IN mind_NN when_WRB we_PP1AS come_VB to_TO consider_VB D09 53 what_WDT Kant_NP says_VBZ about_IN the_ATI D09 54 relation_NN of_IN goodness_NN and_CC happiness_NN ._. D09 55 ^ most_AP people_NNS know_VB Heine's_NP$ brilliant_JJ jest_NN D09 55 about_IN the_ATI contrast_NN D09 56 between_IN two_CD critiques_NNS *-_*- that_DT of_IN pure_JJ reason_NN D09 56 ,_, in_IN which_WDTR he_PP3A deals_VBZ with_IN D09 57 thought_NN ,_, and_CC that_DT of_IN the_ATI practical_JJ reason_NN ,_, D09 57 in_IN which_WDTR he_PP3A deals_VBZ with_IN D09 58 action_NN ._. ^ in_IN the_ATI first_OD he_PP3A had_HVD shown_VBN D09 58 himself_PPL a_AT revolutionary_NN ._. ^ *'_*' the_ATI D09 59 inhabitants_NNS of_IN Koenigsburg_NP set_VBD their_PP$ watches_NNS D09 59 by_IN him_PP3O when_WRB they_PP3AS saw_VBD this_DT D09 60 mild_JJ ,_, inoffensive_JJ man_NN take_VB his_PP$ regular_JJ walk_NN D09 60 ._. **'_**' ^ had_HVD they_PP3AS known_VBN ,_, they_PP3AS D09 61 would_MD have_HV been_BEN more_QL frightened_JJ of_IN him_PP3O than_CS D09 61 of_IN Robespierre_NP ._. D09 62 ^ Robespierre_NP only_RB killed_VBD a_AT king_NN ._. ^ Kant_NP D09 62 killed_VBD a_AT God_NP *-_*- the_ATI God_NP of_IN the_ATI D09 63 Deists_NNPS (_( that_DT is_BEZ ,_, the_ATI God_NP whose_WP$R D09 63 existence_NN can_MD be_BE proved_VBN by_IN reason_NN )_) ._. D09 64 ^ then_RN he_PP3A describes_VBZ Kant_NP looking_VBG up_RP from_IN D09 64 his_PP$ triumphant_JJ dialectic_NN and_CC D09 65 his_PP$ eye_NN lights_VBZ upon_IN his_PP$ faithful_JJ servant_NN ,_, D09 65 Lampe_NP ._. ^ he_PP3A must_MD be_BE left_VBN with_IN D09 66 something_PN to_TO live_VB by_IN ._. ^ so_RB in_IN the_ATI second_OD D09 66 critique_NN Kant_NP reinstates_VBZ God_NP ,_, D09 67 freedom_NN and_CC immortality_NN as_IN the_ATI object_NN ,_, not_XNOT D09 67 of_IN proof_NN ,_, but_CC of_IN belief_NN ._. D09 68 ^ put_VBN less_QL picturesquely_RB ,_, this_DT means_VBZ that_CS D09 68 the_ATI critique_NN of_IN pure_JJ D09 69 reason_NN hedges_NNS in_IN knowledge_NN so_QL strictly_RB that_CS D09 69 it_PP3 can_MD deal_VB with_IN things_NNS D09 70 only_RB as_CS they_PP3AS appear_VB to_IN us_PP1OS in_IN sense_NN D09 70 experience_NN ._. ^ but_CC when_WRB we_PP1AS take_VB up_RP D09 71 the_ATI second_OD critique_NN which_WDTR deals_VBZ with_IN morality_NN D09 71 ,_, we_PP1AS find_VB that_CS the_ATI moral_JJ D09 72 good_NN is_BEZ permanent_JJ and_CC unchanging_JJ in_IN which_WDTR D09 72 we_PP1AS have_HV to_TO believe_VB to_TO make_VB D09 73 sense_NN of_IN duty_NN ._. ^ as_CS Kant_NP says_VBZ with_IN a_AT D09 73 regal_JJ gesture_NN ,_, ^ *'_*' I_PP1A abolish_VB D09 74 knowledge_NN to_TO make_VB room_NN for_IN belief_NN ._. **'_**' D09 75 ^ so_RB we_PP1AS have_HV got_VBN back_RP to_IN the_ATI existence_NN D09 75 of_IN God_NP ,_, but_CC the_ATI God_NP of_IN the_ATI D09 76 moral_JJ law_NN ._. ^ moral_JJ duty_NN (_( he_PP3A argues_VBZ )_) D09 76 is_BEZ distinguished_VBN from_IN other_AP D09 77 purposive_JJ action_NN by_IN its_PP$ absolute_JJ obligation_NN *-_*- D09 77 what_WDT Kant_NP calls_VBZ the_ATI D09 78 categorical_JJ imperative_NN ._. ^ all_ABN other_AP imperatives_NNS D09 78 are_BER conditional_JJ ._. ^ *'_*' if_CS D09 79 you_PP2 want_VB to_TO be_BE a_AT musician_NN ,_, you_PP2 must_MD D09 79 practice_VB so_QL many_AP hours_NNS a_AT D09 80 day_NN **'_**' ._. ^ but_CC conscience_NN does_DOZ not_XNOT say_VB ,_, ^ D09 80 *'_*' if_CS you_PP2 want_VB to_TO be_BE good_JJ ,_, you_PP2 D09 81 must_MD abstain_VB from_IN committing_VBG murder_NN ._. **'_**' ^ D09 81 it_PP3 says_VBZ ,_, ^ *'_*' thou_PP2 shalt_MD do_DO D09 82 no_ATI murder_NN ._. **'_**' ^ the_ATI moral_JJ command_NN is_BEZ D09 82 unconditional_JJ ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ not_XNOT based_VBN on_IN D09 83 desire_NN which_WDTR is_BEZ selfish_JJ ._. ^ duty_NN is_BEZ not_XNOT D09 83 concerned_VBN with_IN consequence_NN :_: D09 84 happiness_NN is_BEZ concerned_VBN with_IN nothing_PN else_RB ._. D09 85 ^ here_RN we_PP1AS have_HV a_AT sharp_JJ dualism_NN ._. ^ the_ATI D09 85 soul_NN of_IN man_NN is_BEZ free_JJ only_RB when_WRB D09 86 it_PP3 accepts_VBZ the_ATI moral_JJ law_NN as_CS good_JJ in_IN D09 86 itself_PPL and_CC does_DOZ not_XNOT get_VB entangled_VBN D09 87 with_IN selfish_JJ desires_NNS ._. ^ he_PP3A does_DOZ not_XNOT go_VB D09 87 quite_RB so_QL far_RB as_CS to_TO say_VB that_CS if_CS I_PP1A D09 88 take_VB pleasure_NN in_IN a_AT good_JJ action_NN it_PP3 makes_VBZ D09 88 that_DT action_NN bad_JJ ,_, but_CC he_PP3A does_DOZ D09 89 say_VB that_CS its_PP$ goodness_NN has_HVZ no_ATI connection_NN with_IN D09 89 my_PP$ feelings_NNS ._. ^ Kant_NP finds_VBZ D09 90 it_PP3 rather_RB difficult_JJ to_TO answer_VB the_ATI question_NN :_: D09 90 have_HV I_PP1A any_DTI motive_NN at_IN all_ABN D09 91 when_WRB I_PP1A obey_VB the_ATI moral_JJ law_NN ?_? ^ I_PP1A do_DO D09 91 not_XNOT desire_VB anything_PN for_IN myself_PPL or_CC for_IN D09 92 others_APS ._. ^ I_PP1A am_BEM not_XNOT concerned_VBN with_IN any_DTI D09 92 consequence_NN that_WPR may_MD follow_VB ._. ^ I_PP1A D09 93 may_MD say_VB that_CS I_PP1A *'_*' respect_VB **'_**' it_PP3 but_CC D09 93 I_PP1A show_VB that_DT respect_NN simply_RB by_IN D09 94 obeying_VBG a_AT law_NN which_WDTR ,_, because_CS it_PP3 is_BEZ D09 94 always_RB binding_JJ on_IN all_ABN ,_, must_MD have_HV D09 95 God_NP for_IN its_PP$ giver_NN ._. D09 96 ^ so_QL far_RB Kant_NP has_HVZ not_XNOT got_VBN much_RB beyond_IN D09 96 the_ATI Stoic_JNP position_NN ._. ^ but_CC D09 97 after_IN all_ABN ,_, he_PP3A had_HVD been_BEN brought_VBN up_RP D09 97 under_IN Christian_JNP influences_NNS ,_, and_CC he_PP3A D09 98 goes_VBZ a_AT step_NN further_RBR ._. ^ to_TO do_DO my_PP$ duty_NN D09 98 is_BEZ to_TO will_VB the_ATI supreme_JJ good_NN ._. ^ I_PP1A D09 99 can_MD not_XNOT will_VB what_WDT is_BEZ impossible_JJ and_CC D09 99 therefore_RB there_EX must_MD be_BE a_AT God_NP who_WPR D09 100 is_BEZ able_JJ and_CC willing_JJ to_TO bring_VB about_RP the_ATI D09 100 supreme_JJ good_NN *-_*- which_WDTR includes_VBZ D09 101 happiness_NN ._. ^ \0A_NP \0E_NP Taylor_NP has_HVZ said_VBN that_CS D09 101 what_WDT distinguishes_VBZ D09 102 religion_NN from_IN morality_NN is_BEZ that_CS the_ATI former_AP D09 102 says_VBZ ,_, ^ *'_*' what_WDT ought_MD to_TO be_BE ,_, D09 103 exists_VBZ ._. **'_**' ^ Kant_NP makes_VBZ a_AT move_NN in_IN that_DT D09 103 direction_NN ._. D09 104 ^ there_EX is_BEZ another_DT point_NN at_IN which_WDTR he_PP3A D09 104 swerves_VBZ from_IN the_ATI strict_JJ Stoic_JNP D09 105 creed_NN ._. ^ he_PP3A accepts_VBZ a_AT belief_NN in_IN immortality_NN D09 105 not_XNOT so_QL much_RB as_IN a_AT system_NN of_IN D09 106 rewards_NNS and_CC penalties_NNS as_IN the_ATI possibility_NN of_IN D09 106 endless_JJ moral_JJ progress_NN ._. D09 107 ^ his_PP$ rather_RB curious_JJ argument_NN runs_VBZ as_CS follows_VBZ D09 107 :_: ^ *'_*' what_WDT the_ATI law_NN commands_VBZ D09 108 must_MD be_BE possible_JJ ._. **'_**' ^ *'_*' I_PP1A must_MD ;_; D09 108 therefore_RB I_PP1A can_MD ._. **'_**' ^ *'_*' this_DT proves_VBZ D09 109 human_JJ freedom_NN ._. ^ but_CC the_ATI law_NN commands_VBZ that_CS D09 109 I_PP1A shall_MD be_BE absolutely_RB good_JJ ._. D09 110 ^ now_RN goodness_NN is_BEZ a_AT process_NN of_IN becoming_VBG D09 110 which_WDTR never_RB ends_VBZ ,_, and_CC therefore_RB D09 111 needs_VBZ an_AT endless_JJ period_NN **'_**' *-_*- in_IN which_WDTR D09 111 not_XNOT to_TO attain_VB its_PP$ goal_NN !_! D09 112 ^ but_CC will_MD this_DT process_NN go_VB on_RP after_IN death_NN D09 112 as_CS it_PP3 does_DOZ here_RN on_IN earth_NN ,_, D09 113 where_WRB the_ATI just_JJ are_BER never_RB perfectly_RB happy_JJ and_CC D09 113 where_WRB evils_NNS are_BER D09 114 constantly_RB clouding_VBG and_CC obstructing_VBG the_ATI good_JJ D09 114 will_NN ,_, which_WDTR Kant_NP calls_VBZ D09 115 *'_*' the_ATI brightest_JJT jewel_NN of_IN the_ATI soul_NN **'_**' ?_? ^ D09 115 I_PP1A suppose_VB he_PP3A might_MD have_HV D09 116 answered_VBN ,_, yes_UH ,_, survival_NN after_IN death_NN and_CC D09 116 unending_JJ improvement_NN need_MD not_XNOT D09 117 mean_VB perfect_JJ happiness_NN there_RN any_RB more_RBR than_CS D09 117 here_RN ._. ^ but_CC after_IN seventeen_CD D09 118 centuries_NNS of_IN Christian_JNP teaching_NN about_IN heaven_NN it_PP3 D09 118 was_BEDZ difficult_JJ to_TO D09 119 contemplate_VB so_QL bleak_JJ a_AT prospect_NN ._. ^ so_RB now_RN D09 119 he_PP3A introduces_VBZ a_AT new_JJ moral_JJ D09 120 intuition_NN ._. ^ *'_*' that_CS goodness_NN and_CC happiness_NN D09 120 ought_MD to_TO go_VB together_RB ,_, and_CC D09 121 the_ATI existence_NN of_IN God_NP proves_VBZ that_CS they_PP3AS D09 121 shall_MD ._. **'_**' D09 122 ^ so_RB he_PP3A seems_VBZ to_TO have_HV overcome_VBN the_ATI D09 122 dualism_NN of_IN happiness_NN and_CC duty_NN D09 123 but_CC at_IN a_AT cost_NN ._. ^ he_PP3A has_HVZ been_BEN violently_RB D09 123 attacked_VBN for_IN reviving_VBG at_IN this_DT D09 124 point_NN the_ATI very_AP desire_NN for_IN rewards_NNS ,_, which_WDTR D09 124 he_PP3A had_HVD banished_VBN so_QL haughtily_RB D09 125 from_IN his_PP$ ethics_NN ._. ^ Professor_NPT Webb_NP defends_VBZ D09 125 him_PP3O against_IN this_DT charge_NN by_IN D09 126 saying_VBG that_CS the_ATI desire_NN is_BEZ not_XNOT selfish_JJ but_CC D09 126 a_AT matter_NN of_IN justice_NN *-_*- that_CS D09 127 all_ABN good_JJ men_NNS should_MD be_BE rewarded_VBN (_( whether_CS D09 127 it_PP3 includes_VBZ myself_PPL or_CC not_XNOT )_) ._. D09 128 ^ this_DT may_MD or_CC may_MD not_XNOT be_BE a_AT sufficient_JJ D09 128 answer_NN ,_, but_CC it_PP3 hardly_RB meets_VBZ the_ATI D09 129 problem_NN ^ *'_*' does_DOZ Kant_NP regard_VB happiness_NN as_IN a_AT D09 129 good_JJ thing_NN or_CC not_XNOT ?_? **'_**' ^ the_ATI D09 130 answer_NN would_MD seem_VB to_TO be_BE that_CS it_PP3 is_BEZ a_AT D09 130 bad_JJ thing_NN before_IN death_NN and_CC a_AT good_JJ D09 131 thing_NN after_RI ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ not_XNOT perhaps_RB as_QL D09 131 absurd_JJ as_CS it_PP3 sounds_VBZ and_CC might_MD be_BE D09 132 worked_VBN into_IN a_AT theory_NN that_CS life_NN here_RN is_BEZ a_AT D09 132 probation_NN ,_, in_IN which_WDTR we_PP1AS prove_VB D09 133 ourselves_PPLS worthy_JJ or_CC unworthy_JJ of_IN happiness_NN in_IN D09 133 the_ATI next_AP ._. D09 134 ^ but_CC in_IN this_DT life_NN is_BEZ it_PP3 not_XNOT lawful_JJ D09 134 to_TO seek_VB the_ATI happiness_NN of_IN D09 135 others_APS ?_? ^ on_IN stern_JJ Kantian_JNP grounds_NNS ,_, no_UH ._. ^ D09 135 our_PP$ only_AP desire_NN for_IN others_APS D09 136 should_MD be_BE that_CS they_PP3AS observe_VB the_ATI moral_JJ law_NN D09 136 ._. ^ thus_RB ,_, the_ATI evil_NN of_IN cruelty_NN D09 137 consists_VBZ in_IN its_PP$ effect_NN on_IN the_ATI disposition_NN of_IN D09 137 the_ATI doer_NN and_CC not_XNOT in_IN the_ATI D09 138 sufferings_NNS of_IN the_ATI victim_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ surely_RB D09 138 the_ATI height_NN of_IN pedantry_NN to_TO deny_VB D09 139 that_CS at_RB least_RB" one_CD1 of_IN the_ATI consequences_NNS D09 139 which_WDTR result_VB from_IN breaking_VBG the_ATI D09 140 law_NN of_IN human_JJ kindness_NN is_BEZ the_ATI increase_NN of_IN D09 140 human_JJ unhappiness_NN ._. D09 141 ^ the_ATI utilitarians_NNS defended_VBD pleasure_NN against_IN D09 141 Kant_NP ._. ^ I_PP1A do_DO not_XNOT D09 142 propose_VB to_TO say_VB more_AP than_IN a_AT word_NN about_IN Jeremy_NP D09 142 Bentham_NP ._. ^ as_IN a_AT reformer_NN D09 143 of_IN law_NN and_CC political_JJ institutions_NNS he_PP3A was_BEDZ D09 143 effective_JJ ,_, largely_RB because_CS D09 144 they_PP3AS demand_VB an_AT appeal_NN to_IN the_ATI kind_NN of_IN D09 144 external_JJ obedience_NN which_WDTR can_MD be_BE D09 145 regulated_VBN by_IN external_JJ rewards_NNS and_CC punishments_NNS ._. ^ D09 145 but_CC ,_, when_WRB he_PP3A tries_VBZ to_TO D09 146 open_VB the_ATI secrets_NNS of_IN the_ATI human_JJ heart_NN ,_, he_PP3A D09 146 appears_VBZ as_IN the_ATI pedant_NN ,_, which_WDTR D09 147 for_IN all_ABN his_PP$ good_JJ nature_NN he_PP3A really_RB was_BEDZ ._. D09 147 ^ he_PP3A seems_VBZ to_TO have_HV accepted_VBN the_ATI D09 148 syllogism_NN :_: D09 149 ^ I_PP1A only_RB do_DO what_WDT I_PP1A desire_VB ._. D09 150 ^ I_PP1A only_RB desire_VB what_WDT gives_VBZ me_PP1O the_ATI D09 150 greater_JJR pleasure_NN ._. D09 151 ^ therefore_RB ,_, whatever_WDT I_PP1A do_DO ,_, I_PP1A do_DO D09 151 because_CS it_PP3 gives_VBZ me_PP1O the_ATI greater_JJR D09 152 pleasure_NN ._. D09 153 ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ natural_JJ to_TO ask_VB *-_*- if_CS everyone_PN D09 153 does_DOZ what_WDT gives_VBZ him_PP3O the_ATI D09 154 greatest_JJT pleasure_NN and_CC can_MD not_XNOT do_DO anything_PN D09 154 else_RB ,_, what_WDT is_BEZ wrong_JJ and_CC why_WRB D09 155 is_BEZ the_ATI moralist_NN needed_VBN to_TO tell_VB us_PP1OS what_WDT D09 155 we_PP1AS ought_MD to_TO do_DO ?_? ^ what_WDT is_BEZ the_ATI D09 156 greatest_JJT pleasure_NN ?_? ^ on_IN what_WDT scale_NN is_BEZ it_PP3 D09 156 measured_VBN ?_? ^ am_BEM I_PP1A the_ATI best_JJT judge_NN D09 157 of_IN it_PP3 ?_? ^ and_RB so_RB" on_RB" ._. ^ but_CC apart_IN from_IN" D09 157 all_ABN that_DT ,_, one_CD1 is_BEZ surprised_JJ at_IN the_ATI D09 158 poverty_NN of_IN his_PP$ psychology_NN ._. ^ Bentham_NP would_MD D09 158 have_HV done_VBN well_RB to_TO consider_VB D09 159 the_ATI romantic_JJ movement_NN which_WDTR he_PP3A so_QL much_RB D09 159 despised_VBD ._. D09 160 ^ we_PP1AS only_RB do_DO what_WDT we_PP1AS want_VB !_! ^ D09 160 struggles_NNS of_IN martyrs_NNS ,_, doubts_NNS of_IN lovers_NNS ,_, D09 161 fight_NN against_IN temptation_NN ,_, changing_JJ moods_NNS of_IN D09 161 the_ATI voluptuary_NN ,_, earnest_JJ D09 162 struggling_NN after_IN the_ATI true_JJ end_NN of_IN life_NN *-_*- D09 162 was_BEDZ all_ABN this_DT world_NN of_IN feeling_NN D09 163 completely_RB closed_VBN to_IN him_PP3O ?_? ^ as_CS though_CS" ~ *'_*' D09 163 what_WDT do_DO I_PP1A want_VB ?_? **'_**' were_BED not_XNOT D09 164 the_ATI question_NN of_IN questions_NNS !_! D09 165 ^ that_DT world_NN was_BEDZ not_XNOT wholly_RB closed_VBN to_IN D09 165 John_NP Stuart_NP Mill_NP ._. ^ brought_VBN up_RP D09 166 in_IN the_ATI straitest_JJT sect_NN of_IN the_ATI Benthamites_NNPS ,_, D09 166 he_PP3A literally_RB collapsed_VBD after_IN D09 167 a_AT diet_NN of_IN *'_*' push-pin_NN as_QL good_JJ as_IN poetry_NN D09 167 **'_**' and_CC *'_*' forty-three_CD motives_NNS D09 168 for_IN obeying_VBG the_ATI law_NN **'_**' ._. ^ he_PP3A recovered_VBD D09 168 into_IN a_AT brighter_JJR world_NN of_IN poetry_NN D09 169 and_CC music_NN ._. ^ but_CC he_PP3A still_RB called_VBD himself_PPL D09 169 a_AT utilitarian_NN ._. D09 170 ^ this_DT was_BEDZ not_XNOT merely_RB loyalty_NN to_IN his_PP$ D09 170 upbringing_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 was_BEDZ the_ATI result_NN D09 171 of_IN his_PP$ abiding_JJ dislike_NN for_IN any_DTI system_NN which_WDTR D09 171 relied_VBD upon_IN pure_JJ D09 172 intuition_NN ._. ^ wherever_WRB he_PP3A sensed_VBD it_PP3 ,_, there_RN D09 172 was_BEDZ the_ATI enemy_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 relied_VBD D09 173 upon_IN an_AT obscure_JJ feeling_NN ,_, which_WDTR was_BEDZ not_XNOT D09 173 accountable_JJ to_IN reason_NN ._. ^ for_IN D09 174 Mill_NP ,_, life_NN must_MD be_BE made_VBN up_RP of_IN clear-cut_JJ D09 174 ends_NNS ,_, and_CC of_IN means_NNS leading_VBG D09 175 straight_RB to_IN them_PP3OS ._. ^ the_ATI kind_NN of_IN good_NN D09 175 preached_VBN by_IN Kant_NP and_CC Coleridge_NP D09 176 seemed_VBD to_IN him_PP3O vague_JJ and_CC undefined_JJ ._. ^ but_CC D09 176 everyone_PN knew_VBD what_WDT pleasure_NN D09 177 was_BEDZ ._. ^ here_RN was_BEDZ a_AT goal_NN with_IN no_ATI mystical_JJ D09 177 nonsense_NN about_IN it_PP3 ._. D10 2 ^ there_EX are_BER ,_, of_RB course_RB" ,_, those_DTS who_WPR D10 2 regard_VB the_ATI Church_NPL as_IN Christ's_NP$ D10 3 body_NN ,_, not_XNOT metaphorically_RB ,_, but_CC metaphysically_RB D10 3 and_CC ontologically_RB ,_, and_CC D10 4 see_VB it_PP3 as_IN an_AT extension_NN of_IN the_ATI incarnation_NN ,_, D10 4 and_CC would_MD not_XNOT think_VB any_DTI D10 5 description_NN of_IN the_ATI Church_NPL complete_JJ in_IN which_WDTR D10 5 the_ATI phrase_NN *'_*' body_NN of_IN D10 6 Christ_NP **'_**' did_DOD not_XNOT occur_VB ;_; and_CC no_ATI doubt_NN D10 6 the_ATI sentence_NN under_IN consideration_NN D10 7 was_BEDZ framed_VBN thus_RB ,_, with_IN biblical_JJ language_NN D10 7 used_VBN in_IN this_DT oddly_RB unbiblical_JJ D10 8 way_NN ,_, in_TO order_TO" to_TO" leave_VB it_PP3 open_JJ to_IN D10 8 such_ABL persons_NNS to_TO expound_VB what_WDT is_BEZ D10 9 said_VBN ,_, not_XNOT of_IN evangelism_NN ,_, whereby_WRB Christ_NP D10 9 calls_VBZ men_NNS out_RP of_IN the_ATI world_NN to_IN D10 10 himself_PPL ,_, but_CC of_IN the_ATI Church_NPL as_CS D10 10 supernaturalizing_VBG society_NN ,_, or_CC as_CS linking_VBG D10 11 men_NNS to_IN Christ_NP through_IN its_PP$ sacraments_NNS ,_, or_CC D10 11 else_RB of_IN Christ_NP as_CS in_IN some_DTI D10 12 sense_NN continuing_VBG his_PP$ work_NN of_IN redemption_NN by_IN D10 12 endlessly_RB offering_VBG himself_PPL D10 13 to_IN God_NP in_IN organic_JJ union_NN with_IN his_PP$ members_NNS ._. ^ D10 13 but_CC all_ABN these_DTS are_BER minority_NN D10 14 views_NNS in_IN the_ATI Church_NPL of_IN England_NP ,_, of_IN D10 14 dubious_JJ biblical_JJ credentials_NNS ,_, and_CC D10 15 scarcely_RB a_AT century_NN old_JJ ;_; they_PP3AS can_MD hardly_RB D10 15 be_BE said_VBN to_TO be_BE rooted_VBN in_IN D10 16 Anglican_JNP tradition_NN ,_, and_CC they_PP3AS are_BER certainly_RB D10 16 not_XNOT countenanced_VBN in_IN any_DTI D10 17 official_JJ formulary_NN of_IN the_ATI Church_NPL of_IN England_NP ._. ^ D10 17 as_IN such_ABL ,_, they_PP3AS have_HV D10 18 surely_RB no_ATI right_NN thus_RB to_TO deflect_VB the_ATI wording_NN D10 18 of_IN the_ATI catechism_NN from_IN the_ATI D10 19 biblical_JJ norm_NN of_IN usage_NN ._. D10 20 ^ (_( 2_CD )_) ._. ^ the_ATI section_NN (_( 14-17_CD-CD )_) D10 20 introduced_VBN by_IN the_ATI question_NN :_: ~ *'_*' what_WDT D10 21 orders_NNS of_IN ministries_NNS are_BER there_EX in_IN the_ATI D10 21 Church_NPL ?_? **'_**' ought_MD to_TO be_BE dropped_VBN ._. D10 22 ^ in_IN the_ATI first_OD place_NN ,_, the_ATI question_NN presumably_RB D10 22 refers_VBZ to_IN the_ATI Church_NPL D10 23 universal_JJ on_IN earth_NN ,_, but_CC it_PP3 is_BEZ answered_VBN by_IN D10 23 a_AT description_NN of_IN bishops_NNS ,_, D10 24 priests_NNS ,_, and_CC deacons_NNS ,_, and_CC their_PP$ work_NN in_IN D10 24 the_ATI Church_NPL of_IN England_NP ._. ^ this_DT D10 25 is_BEZ odd_JJ :_: is_BEZ the_ATI Church_NPL of_IN England_NP ,_, D10 25 then_RN ,_, to_TO be_BE identified_VBN with_IN the_ATI D10 26 Church_NPL universal_JJ ?_? ^ and_CC furthermore_RB :_: it_PP3 is_BEZ D10 26 essential_JJ for_IN the_ATI D10 27 catechumen_NN to_TO be_BE instructed_VBN in_IN the_ATI precise_JJ D10 27 functions_NNS of_IN bishops_NNS ,_, D10 28 priests_NNS ,_, and_CC deacons_NNS in_IN the_ATI Church_NPL of_IN D10 28 England_NP set-up_NN before_CS he_PP3A be_BE D10 29 admitted_VBN to_IN the_ATI Lord's_NPT$ table_NN ?_? ^ such_ABL D10 29 instruction_NN could_MD only_RB be_BE held_VBN D10 30 essential_JJ if_CS this_DT organizational_JJ structure_NN were_BED D10 30 itself_PPL essential_JJ to_IN D10 31 the_ATI being_NN of_IN the_ATI Church_NPL ,_, as_IN such_ABL ,_, so_CS D10 31 that_CS" where_WRB this_DT threefold_JJ D10 32 ministry_NN could_MD not_XNOT be_BE recognized_VBN the_ATI Church_NPL D10 32 must_MD be_BE judged_VBN D10 33 non-existent_JJ ,_, and_CC the_ATI conclusion_NN drawn_VBN that_CS D10 33 there_EX are_BER no_ATI valid_JJ or_CC D10 34 efficacious_JJ Eucharists_NPS there_RN ._. ^ knowledge_NN about_IN D10 34 the_ATI threefold_JJ ministry_NN D10 35 would_MD then_RN be_BE *'_*' saving_JJ knowledge_NN **'_**' in_IN D10 35 the_ATI strict_JJ sense_NN ,_, for_IN valid_JJ D10 36 sacraments_NNS are_BER generally_RB necessary_JJ to_IN salvation_NN ;_; D10 36 but_CC is_BEZ this_DT the_ATI D10 37 historic_JJ Anglican_JNP view_NN ?_? ^ can_MD it_PP3 be_BE proved_VBN D10 37 by_IN scripture_NN ,_, which_WDTR D10 38 *'_*' containeth_VBZ all_ABN things_NNS necessary_JJ to_IN salvation_NN D10 38 **'_**' ?_? ^ the_ATI answer_NN is_BEZ no_UH D10 39 in_IN both_ABX cases_NNS ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ true_JJ that_CS a_AT D10 39 vocal_JJ minority_NN in_IN the_ATI Church_NPL of_IN D10 40 England_NP today_NR holds_VBZ this_DT opinion_NN in_IN some_DTI form_NN D10 40 ,_, but_CC it_PP3 does_DOZ not_XNOT seem_VB D10 41 right_JJ to_TO give_VB space_NN in_IN the_ATI revised_JJ catechism_NN D10 41 to_IN a_AT matter_NN whose_WP$R D10 42 presence_NN there_RN could_MD only_RB be_BE justified_VBN if_CS this_DT D10 42 minority_NN view_NN were_BED D10 43 accepted_VBN as_CS being_BEG scriptural_JJ and_CC normatively_RB D10 43 Anglican_JNP ._. D10 44 ^ this_DT section_NN leaves_VBZ the_ATI impression_NN that_CS D10 44 the_ATI ministry_NN is_BEZ the_ATI D10 45 Church_NPL for_IN all_ABN practical_JJ purposes_NNS ,_, and_CC this_DT D10 45 impression_NN is_BEZ strengthened_VBN D10 46 when_WRB ,_, at_IN a_AT later_JJR stage_NN ,_, we_PP1AS read_VB that_CS D10 46 *'_*' the_ATI Church's_NPL$ ministry_NN in_IN D10 47 marriage_NN is_BEZ to_TO bless_VB the_ATI man_NN and_CC the_ATI D10 47 woman_NN in_IN their_PP$ wedding_NN ,_, so_CS D10 48 that_CS" they_PP3AS may_MD together_RB receive_VB the_ATI grace_NN D10 48 of_IN God_NP ..._... **'_**' (_( 53_CD )_) ._. ^ certainly_RB D10 49 not_XNOT !_! ^ this_DT is_BEZ Roman_JNP doctrine_NN ,_, not_XNOT D10 49 the_ATI doctrine_NN of_IN the_ATI Church_NPL of_IN D10 50 England_NP ._. ^ the_ATI Church_NPL is_BEZ the_ATI fellowship_NN of_IN D10 50 the_ATI faithful_JJ ,_, not_XNOT just_RB the_ATI D10 51 minister_NN ;_; and_CC the_ATI Church's_NPL$ ministry_NN in_IN D10 51 marriage_NN is_BEZ to_TO pray_VB for_IN D10 52 and_CC with_IN the_ATI marrying_JJ couple_NN *-_*- a_AT ministry_NN D10 52 of_IN which_WDTR the_ATI officiant's_NN$ D10 53 pronouncement_NN of_IN blessing_NN is_BEZ only_RB one_CD1 small_JJ D10 53 part_NN ._. ^ here_RN ,_, too_RB ,_, a_AT change_NN D10 54 of_IN wording_NN is_BEZ imperative_JJ ;_; unless_CS ,_, indeed_RB ,_, D10 54 question_NN 53_CD be_BE deleted_VBN D10 55 altogether_RB ,_, which_WDTR we_PP1AS ourselves_PPLS would_MD favour_VB D10 55 (_( see_VB below_RI )_) ._. D10 56 ^ (_( 3_CD )_) ._. ^ baptism_NN is_BEZ defined_VBN (_( 38_CD )_) D10 56 as_IN *'_*' the_ATI sacrament_NN in_IN which_WDTR ,_, D10 57 through_IN the_ATI action_NN of_IN the_ATI holy_JJ spirit_NN ,_, D10 57 we_PP1AS are_BER christened_VBN or_CC made_VBN D10 58 Christ's_NP$ **'_**' ._. ^ this_DT definition_NN is_BEZ not_XNOT D10 58 very_QL satisfactory_JJ ._. ^ in_IN the_ATI first_OD D10 59 place_NN ,_, it_PP3 has_HVZ no_ATI clear_JJ meaning_NN (_( which_WDTR D10 59 fact_NN alone_RB makes_VBZ it_PP3 unfit_JJ to_TO D10 60 stand_VB in_IN a_AT catechism_NN )_) ._. ^ in_IN the_ATI second_OD D10 60 place_NN ,_, it_PP3 most_QL naturally_RB implies_VBZ D10 61 that_CS there_EX is_BEZ a_AT peculiar_JJ grace_NN received_VBN in_IN D10 61 baptism_NN ex_&FW opere_&FW D10 62 operato_&FW ._. ^ but_CC it_PP3 is_BEZ not_XNOT historic_JJ D10 62 Anglican_JNP teaching_NN (_( think_VB of_IN the_ATI D10 63 Gorham_NP judgment_NN )_) ,_, nor_CC ,_, we_PP1AS think_VB ,_, is_BEZ D10 63 it_PP3 unanimous_JJ present-day_JJB Anglican_JNP D10 64 opinion_NN ,_, that_CS the_ATI grace_NN exhibited_VBN in_IN baptism_NN D10 64 is_BEZ always_RB received_VBN in_IN the_ATI D10 65 rite_NN itself_PPL ,_, and_CC never_RB before_RI or_CC after_RI ._. ^ D10 65 in_IN the_ATI answer_NN to_IN question_NN 42_CD ,_, D10 66 however_RB ,_, we_PP1AS are_BER told_VBN that_CS ~ *'_*' D10 66 confirmation_NN is_BEZ the_ATI ministry_NN by_IN which_WDTR ,_, D10 67 through_IN prayer_NN with_IN the_ATI laying_NN on_RP of_IN hands_NNS D10 67 by_IN the_ATI bishop_NN ,_, the_ATI holy_JJ D10 68 spirit_NN is_BEZ received_VBN to_TO complete_VB what_WDT he_PP3A D10 68 began_VBD in_IN baptism_NN ..._... **'_**' ;_; D10 69 which_WDTR form_NN of_IN words_NNS (_( based_VBN ,_, it_PP3 seems_VBZ D10 69 ,_, on_IN the_ATI audacious_JJ assertion_NN in_IN D10 70 the_ATI Scottish_JNP prayer_NN book_NN that_CS ~ *'_*' confirmation_NN D10 70 is_BEZ an_AT apostolic_JJ and_CC D10 71 sacramental_JJ rite_NN by_IN which_WDTR the_ATI holy_JJ spirit_NN D10 71 is_BEZ given_VBN to_TO complete_VB our_PP$ D10 72 baptism_NN **'_**' )_) seems_VBZ to_TO force_VB us_PP1OS to_TO D10 72 interpret_VB answer_NN 38_CD of_IN some_DTI sort_NN of_IN D10 73 baptismal_JJ regeneration_NN ._. ^ yet_RB it_PP3 is_BEZ a_AT very_QL D10 73 odd_JJ sort_NN of_IN regeneration_NN ,_, D10 74 for_CS it_PP3 is_BEZ only_RB a_AT partial_JJ initiation_NN into_IN D10 74 Christ_NP and_CC his_PP$ Church_NPL ,_, D10 75 needing_VBG the_ATI further_JJB grace_NN given_VBN in_IN D10 75 confirmation_NN (_( also_RB ex_&FW opere_&FW D10 76 operato_&FW ?_? )_) to_TO perfect_VB it_PP3 ._. ^ such_ABL a_AT D10 76 concept_NN has_HVZ breath-taking_JJ D10 77 implications_NNS ._. ^ it_PP3 implies_VBZ that_CS every_AT baptized_JJ D10 77 Christian_NNP throughout_IN the_ATI D10 78 universal_JJ Church_NPL whose_WP$R ecclesiastical_JJ system_NN does_DOZ D10 78 not_XNOT make_VB available_JJ D10 79 to_IN him_PP3O episcopal_JJ confirmation_NN misses_VBZ some_DTI D10 79 grace_NN ,_, forfeits_VBZ some_DTI D10 80 blessing_NN ,_, foregoes_VBZ some_DTI degree_NN of_IN union_NN with_IN D10 80 Christ_NP ._. ^ on_IN this_DT view_NN ,_, as_CS D10 81 Professor_NPT \0G_NP \0W_NP \0H_NP Lampe_NP has_HVZ pointed_VBN out_RP D10 81 ,_, *'_*' Christian_JNP baptism_NN D10 82 would_MD be_BE reduced_VBN to_IN the_ATI level_NN of_IN the_ATI D10 82 baptism_NN of_IN John_NP ,_, a_AT preparatory_JJ D10 83 cleansing_NN in_IN expectation_NN of_IN a_AT future_JJB baptism_NN D10 83 with_IN holy_JJ spirit_NN ;_; D10 84 confirmation_NN would_MD become_VB ,_, not_XNOT merely_RB a_AT D10 84 sacrament_NN in_IN the_ATI fullest_JJT sense_NN D10 85 (_( which_WDTR the_ATI Anglican_JNP articles_NNS deny_VB )_) ,_, but_CC D10 85 the_ATI great_JJ sacrament_NN without_IN D10 86 whose_WP$R reception_NN no_ATI man_NN could_MD call_VB himself_PPL a_AT D10 86 Christian_NNP ..._... **'_**' (_( the_ATI D10 87 seal_NN of_IN the_ATI spirit_NN ,_, 1951_CD ,_, \0p_NN 13_CD )_) ._. ^ D10 87 Lampe_NP calls_VBZ these_DTS D10 88 *'_*' monstrous_JJ conclusions_NNS **'_**' ._. ^ we_PP1AS agree_VB ._. ^ D10 88 are_BER they_PP3AS historic_JJ Anglican_JNP D10 89 teaching_NN ?_? ^ can_MD they_PP3AS be_BE proved_VBN by_IN scripture_NN D10 89 ?_? ^ again_RB ,_, the_ATI answer_NN in_IN both_ABX D10 90 cases_NNS is_BEZ no_UH ._. ^ we_PP1AS know_VB ,_, certainly_RB ,_, D10 90 that_CS this_DT view_NN (_( the_ATI *'_*' Mason-Dix_NP D10 91 line_NN **'_**' )_) has_HVZ been_BEN argued_VBN at_IN various_JJ D10 91 times_NNS during_IN the_ATI past_JJB hundred_CD D10 92 years_NNS by_IN a_AT small_JJ band_NN of_IN very_QL able_JJ men_NNS ,_, D10 92 that_CS it_PP3 has_HVZ a_AT certain_JJ D10 93 following_NN today_NR ,_, and_CC that_CS it_PP3 has_HVZ actually_RB D10 93 been_BEN embodied_VBN in_IN the_ATI D10 94 proposed_JJ new_JJ confirmation_NN rite_NN ._. ^ but_CC most_AP D10 94 Anglicans_NNPS ,_, we_PP1AS think_VB ,_, still_RB D10 95 hold_VB to_IN the_ATI historic_JJ view_NN expressed_VBN in_IN the_ATI D10 95 structure_NN of_IN the_ATI 1662_CD D10 96 confirmation_NN service_NN *-_*- namely_RB ,_, that_DT confirmation_NN D10 96 is_BEZ simply_RB a_AT domestic_JJ D10 97 institution_NN whereby_WRB the_ATI Anglican_JNP community_NN ,_, D10 97 acting_VBG through_IN the_ATI bishop_NN D10 98 as_IN its_PP$ appointed_JJ representative_NN ,_, welcomes_VBZ into_IN D10 98 adult_JJ fellowship_NN ,_, on_IN D10 99 the_ATI basis_NN of_IN a_AT personal_JJ profession_NN of_IN faith_NN D10 99 ,_, those_DTS who_WPR in_IN baptism_NN were_BED D10 100 originally_RB received_VBN ,_, normally_RB as_IN infants_NNS ,_, D10 100 with_IN the_ATI status_NN of_IN sponsored_JJ D10 101 members_NNS ._. ^ the_ATI congregation_NN prays_VBZ that_CS the_ATI D10 101 spirit_NN may_MD strengthen_VB the_ATI D10 102 confirmees_NNS for_IN the_ATI new_JJ responsibilities_NNS which_WDTR D10 102 their_PP$ increased_JJ status_NN D10 103 in_IN the_ATI Church_NPL brings_VBZ ._. ^ but_CC this_DT is_BEZ D10 103 not_XNOT in_IN the_ATI least_AP to_TO imply_VB that_CS in_IN D10 104 the_ATI sight_NN of_IN God_NP the_ATI blessings_NNS of_IN the_ATI D10 104 spirit_NN which_WDTR their_PP$ baptism_NN D10 105 signified_VBD *-_*- *'_*' union_NN with_IN Christ_NP in_IN his_PP$ D10 105 death_NN and_CC resurrection_NN ,_, the_ATI D10 106 forgiveness_NN of_IN sins_NNS ,_, and_CC a_AT new_JJ birth_NN into_IN D10 106 God's_NP$ family_NN ,_, the_ATI Church_NPL D10 107 **'_**' (_( 40_CD )_) *-_*- are_BER necessarily_RB incomplete_JJ D10 107 till_CS confirmation_NN has_HVZ taken_VBN place_NN ._. D10 108 ^ here_RN again_RB ,_, then_RN ,_, we_PP1AS must_MD protest_VB D10 108 against_IN the_ATI intrusion_NN into_IN the_ATI new_JJ D10 109 catechism_NN ,_, which_WDTR the_ATI whole_JJ Church_NPL ,_, it_PP3 D10 109 is_BEZ hoped_VBN ,_, will_MD use_VB ,_, of_IN a_AT D10 110 minority_NN opinion_NN which_WDTR most_AP Anglican_JNP clergy_NNS in_IN D10 110 their_PP$ teaching_NN of_IN D10 111 confirmation_NN candidates_NNS would_MD wish_VB to_TO ignore_VB ,_, D10 111 or_CC indeed_RB repudiate_VB ._. D10 112 ^ (_( 4_CD )_) ._. ^ at_IN this_DT point_NN ,_, however_RB ,_, D10 112 we_PP1AS would_MD make_VB a_AT more_QL radical_JJ D10 113 criticism_NN ._. ^ the_ATI passages_NNS dealing_VBG with_IN the_ATI D10 113 five_CD *'_*' other_AP ministries_NNS of_IN D10 114 grace_NN **'_**' (_( *'_*' confirmation_NN ,_, holy_JJ order_NN ,_, D10 114 holy_JJ matrimony_NN ,_, the_ATI ministry_NN of_IN D10 115 absolution_NN ,_, and_CC the_ATI ministry_NN of_IN healing_NN **'_**' D10 115 )_) ought_MD ,_, we_PP1AS suggest_VB ,_, to_TO be_BE D10 116 dropped_VBN entirely_RB ._. ^ for_CS the_ATI assumption_NN behind_IN D10 116 the_ATI phrase_NN *'_*' other_AP D10 117 ministries_NNS of_IN grace_NN **'_**' evidently_RB is_BEZ that_CS in_IN D10 117 each_DT of_IN these_DTS five_CD cases_NNS D10 118 (_( though_CS ,_, one_CD1 would_MD gather_VB ,_, in_IN no_ATI other_AP D10 118 case_NN )_) the_ATI activity_NN of_IN the_ATI D10 119 officiant_NN confers_VBZ some_DTI special_JJ gift_NN of_IN God_NP D10 119 which_WDTR would_MD not_XNOT otherwise_RB D10 120 be_BE received_VBN ._. ^ we_PP1AS saw_VBD earlier_RBR how_WRB D10 120 clearly_RB this_DT comes_VBZ out_RP in_IN the_ATI D10 121 tell-tale_JJB wording_NN of_IN the_ATI statement_NN about_IN D10 121 matrimony_NN ;_; and_CC the_ATI assumption_NN D10 122 appears_VBZ again_RB when_WRB absolution_NN is_BEZ defined_VBN as_IN D10 122 the_ATI ministry_NN whereby_WRB D10 123 penitents_NNS who_WPR have_HV made_VBN *'_*' free_JJ confession_NN D10 123 **'_**' of_IN their_PP$ sins_NNS in_IN the_ATI D10 124 minister's_NN$ presence_NN *'_*' receive_VB through_IN him_PP3O (_( D10 124 sic_RB )_) the_ATI forgiveness_NN D10 125 of_IN God_NP **'_**' ._. ^ (_( this_DT ,_, of_RB course_RB" ,_, as_CS D10 125 it_PP3 stands_VBZ ,_, is_BEZ simply_RB not_XNOT historic_JJ D10 126 Anglican_JNP teaching_NN ,_, but_CC a_AT well-known_JJ party_NN line_NN D10 126 ._. ^ to_TO express_VB the_ATI D10 127 Anglican_JNP view_NN of_IN absolution_NN ,_, as_CS witnessed_VBN to_IN D10 127 by_IN the_ATI prayer_NN book_NN ,_, the_ATI D10 128 last_AP words_NNS would_MD have_HV to_TO read_VB :_: *'_*' receive_VB D10 128 through_IN him_PP3O assurance_NN of_IN D10 129 the_ATI forgiveness_NN of_IN God_NP **'_**' *-_*- rather_ABL a_AT D10 129 different_JJ thing_NN ._. )_) D10 130 ^ but_CC the_ATI assumption_NN that_CS these_DTS five_CD types_NNS D10 130 of_IN ministerial_JJ action_NN D10 131 each_DT convey_VB a_AT special_JJ grace_NN ex_&FW opere_&FW operato_&FW D10 131 is_BEZ without_IN D10 132 warrant_NN in_IN Anglican_JNP theology_NN *-_*- not_XNOT to_TO D10 132 mention_VB the_ATI Bible_NP !_! ^ we_PP1AS might_MD ,_, D10 133 perhaps_RB ,_, be_BE told_VBN that_DT no_ATI such_ABL assumption_NN D10 133 is_BEZ implied_VBN ,_, and_CC all_ABN that_WPR D10 134 *'_*' ministries_NNS of_IN grace_NN **'_**' means_VBZ in_IN this_DT D10 134 context_NN is_BEZ that_CS God_NP blesses_VBZ his_PP$ D10 135 faithful_JJ people_NNS through_IN each_DT of_IN these_DTS D10 135 ministerial_JJ functions_NNS ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ D10 136 an_AT undoubted_JJ truth_NN ;_; but_CC if_CS nothing_PN more_AP than_IN D10 136 this_DT is_BEZ intended_VBN ,_, we_PP1AS D10 137 should_MD at_RB once_RB" have_HV to_TO ask_VB why_WRB ,_, in_IN that_DT D10 137 case_NN ,_, only_RB these_DTS five_CD receive_VB D10 138 mention_NN ?_? ^ why_WRB is_BEZ healing_NN specified_VBN when_WRB D10 138 the_ATI visitation_NN of_IN the_ATI sick_JJ is_BEZ D10 139 not_XNOT ?_? ^ why_WRB is_BEZ absolution_NN spoken_VBN of_IN while_CS D10 139 the_ATI preaching_NN of_IN the_ATI word_NN is_BEZ D10 140 left_VBN out_RP ?_? ^ whichever_WDT way_NN we_PP1AS look_VB at_IN D10 140 it_PP3 ,_, neither_DTX the_ATI articles_NNS ,_, nor_CC the_ATI D10 141 prayer_NN book_NN ,_, nor_CC the_ATI Bible_NP ,_, can_MD justify_VB D10 141 the_ATI selection_NN of_IN just_RB these_DTS D10 142 five_CD activities_NNS ,_, and_CC no_ATI more_AP ,_, as_IN the_ATI D10 142 Church's_NPL$ *'_*' other_AP ministries_NNS of_IN D10 143 grace_NN **'_**' ._. ^ the_ATI selection_NN is_BEZ inherently_RB D10 143 arbitrary_JJ and_CC untheological_JJ ._. D10 144 ^ this_DT idea_NN behind_IN it_PP3 is_BEZ presumably_RB that_CS the_ATI D10 144 catechism_NN ought_MD to_TO mention_VB D10 145 one_CD1 ministerial_JJ action_NN in_IN the_ATI Church_NPL of_IN D10 145 England_NP to_TO correspond_VB with_IN D10 146 each_DT of_IN Rome's_NP$ seven_CD sacraments_NNS ;_; but_CC there_EX D10 146 is_BEZ no_ATI obvious_JJ reason_NN why_WRB it_PP3 D10 147 should_MD ._. ^ the_ATI habit_NN of_IN mind_NN which_WDTR takes_VBZ D10 147 its_PP$ cue_NN from_IN Rome_NP and_CC aims_VBZ to_TO D10 148 keep_VB step_NN with_IN Rome_NP wherever_WRB possible_JJ is_BEZ D10 148 found_VBN in_IN the_ATI Church_NPL of_IN D10 149 England_NP ,_, but_CC it_PP3 is_BEZ not_XNOT authentically_RB D10 149 Anglican_JNP ._. ^ we_PP1AS ask_VB again_RB :_: can_MD it_PP3 D10 150 be_BE held_VBN that_CS the_ATI knowledge_NN of_IN these_DTS five_CD D10 150 *'_*' ministries_NNS of_IN grace_NN **'_**' is_BEZ D10 151 in_IN any_DTI way_NN essential_JJ to_IN salvation_NN ?_? ^ can_MD D10 151 the_ATI things_NNS that_WPR are_BER said_VBN ,_, in_RB D10 152 particular_RB" ,_, about_IN confirmation_NN ,_, and_CC matrimony_NN ,_, D10 152 and_CC absolution_NN ,_, be_BE D10 153 proved_VBN from_IN scripture_NN ?_? ^ can_MD any_DTI warrant_NN or_CC D10 153 sanction_NN for_IN them_PP3OS be_BE found_VBN D10 154 in_IN existing_JJ Anglican_JNP formularies_NNS ,_, or_CC in_IN the_ATI D10 154 main_JJB stream_NN of_IN the_ATI D10 155 Anglican_JNP theological_JJ tradition_NN ?_? ^ if_CS not_XNOT (_( D10 155 and_CC we_PP1AS think_VB that_CS the_ATI answer_NN D10 156 to_IN all_ABN three_CD questions_NNS is_BEZ no_UH )_) ,_, then_RN D10 156 they_PP3AS can_MD have_HV no_ATI rightful_JJ place_NN in_IN D10 157 a_AT catechism_NN for_IN the_ATI Church_NPL of_IN England_NP ._. D10 158 ^ so_PN much_AP for_IN the_ATI new_JJ material_NN ._. ^ but_CC to_TO D10 158 complete_VB our_PP$ survey_NN we_PP1AS D10 159 should_MD also_RB note_VB what_WDT has_HVZ been_BEN omitted_VBN of_IN D10 159 the_ATI old_JJ material_NN ._. ^ here_RN are_BER D10 160 the_ATI more_QL important_JJ deletions_NNS ._. D10 161 ^ (_( 1_CD1 )_) ._. ^ the_ATI reference_NN to_IN the_ATI world_NN D10 161 ,_, the_ATI flesh_NN ,_, and_CC the_ATI devil_NN in_IN D10 162 the_ATI first_OD baptismal_JJ vow_NN has_HVZ been_BEN replaced_VBN D10 162 by_IN a_AT weak_JJ general_JJ reference_NN D10 163 to_IN *'_*' wrong_NN **'_**' and_CC *'_*' evil_NN ._. **'_**' ^ (_( D10 163 we_PP1AS gather_VB ,_, however_RB ,_, that_CS the_ATI devil_NN ,_, D10 163 at_RB D10 164 least_RB" ,_, is_BEZ soon_RB to_TO be_BE restored_VBN to_IN his_PP$ D10 164 rightful_JJ place_NN as_IN an_AT object_NN of_IN D10 165 specific_JJ renunciation_NN ._. )_) D10 166 ^ (_( 2_CD )_) ._. ^ the_ATI assertion_NN of_IN original_JJ sin_NN D10 166 (_( *'_*' being_BEG by_IN nature_NN born_VBN in_IN D10 167 sin_NN ,_, and_CC the_ATI children_NNS of_IN wrath_NN **'_**' )_) D10 167 has_HVZ been_BEN dropped_VBN entirely_RB ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ D10 168 disturbing_JJ ,_, for_CS the_ATI new_JJ catechism_NN now_RN says_VBZ D10 168 nothing_PN positive_JJ at_IN all_ABN D10 169 about_IN man's_NN$ lost_JJ condition_NN by_IN nature_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 D10 169 is_BEZ true_JJ that_CS the_ATI biblical_JJ D10 170 doctrine_NN of_IN original_JJ sin_NN (_( under_IN its_PP$ D10 170 ecclesiastical_JJ name_NN of_IN D10 171 Augustinianism_NNP )_) is_BEZ having_HVG a_AT raw_JJ deal_NN in_IN D10 171 Anglican_JNP liturgical_JJ circles_NNS D10 172 these_DTS days_NNS ;_; but_CC it_PP3 is_BEZ there_RN in_IN the_ATI D10 172 Bible_NP ,_, and_CC it_PP3 ought_MD to_TO appear_VB in_IN an_AT D10 173 unexpurgated_JJ form_NN in_IN the_ATI catechism_NN ._. ^ for_CS the_ATI D10 173 catechism_NN exists_VBZ to_TO teach_VB D10 174 the_ATI gospel_NN of_IN God's_NP$ grace_NN ,_, and_CC you_PP2 can_MD D10 174 not_XNOT understand_VB grace_NN till_CS you_PP2 D10 175 have_HV first_RB understood_VBN sin_NN ._. D10 176 ^ (_( 3_CD )_) ._. ^ the_ATI sanction_NN of_IN the_ATI second_OD D10 176 commandment_NN has_HVZ also_RB gone_VBN ,_, so_CS D10 177 that_CS" the_ATI new_JJ catechism_NN now_RN contains_VBZ no_ATI D10 177 mention_NN of_IN God's_NP$ penal_JJ wrath_NN D10 178 against_IN sin_NN ._. D10 179 ^ (_( 4_CD )_) ._. ^ the_ATI description_NN of_IN the_ATI Church_NPL D10 179 as_IN God's_NP$ *'_*' elect_JJ people_NNS **'_**' *-_*- D10 180 the_ATI covenant_NN community_NN *-_*- has_HVZ gone_VBN ._. ^ the_ATI D10 180 thought_NN of_IN the_ATI covenant_NN D10 181 relationship_NN seems_VBZ to_TO be_BE completely_RB absent_JJ from_IN D10 181 the_ATI wording_NN of_IN the_ATI D10 182 revised_JJ catechism_NN ._. D10 183 ^ (_( 5_CD )_) ._. ^ the_ATI conception_NN of_IN a_AT sacrament_NN D10 183 as_IN a_AT visible_JJ word_NN of_IN God_NP ,_, D10 184 summoning_VBG its_PP$ recipients_NNS to_IN *'_*' faith_NN ,_, D10 184 whereby_WRB they_PP3AS stedfastly_RB believe_VB D10 185 the_ATI promises_NNS of_IN God_NP made_VBN to_IN them_PP3OS in_IN D10 185 that_DT sacrament_NN **'_**' ,_, has_HVZ vanished_VBN D10 186 too_RB ._. D10 187 ^ (_( 6_CD )_) ._. ^ so_PN has_HVZ the_ATI demand_NN that_CS D10 187 those_DTS who_WPR come_VB to_IN the_ATI Lord's_NPT$ supper_NN D10 188 should_MD first_RB examine_VB themselves_PPLS ._. D11 2 ^ Bible_NP study_NN *-_*- Zechariah_NP ._. D11 3 ^ \0F_NP \0B_NP Hole_NP ._. D11 4 ^ (_( chapters_NNS 7_CD :_: 1-11_CD-CD :_: 17_CD )_) ._. D11 5 ^ in_IN the_ATI first_OD verse_NN of_IN chapter_NN 7_CD ,_, we_PP1AS D11 5 find_VB another_DT date_NN D11 6 given_VBN ;_; almost_RB two_CD years_NNS later_RBR than_IN that_DT D11 6 of_IN the_ATI visions_NNS just_RB recorded_VBN ,_, D11 7 and_CC the_ATI prophecies_NNS of_IN Haggai_NP ._. ^ these_DTS fresh_JJ D11 7 prophecies_NNS were_BED occasioned_VBN D11 8 by_IN the_ATI arrival_NN of_IN certain_JJ men_NNS with_IN questions_NNS D11 8 as_IN to_IN" the_ATI observance_NN of_IN D11 9 fasts_NNS ,_, and_CC we_PP1AS notice_VB that_CS we_PP1AS pass_VB D11 9 from_IN the_ATI record_NN of_IN visions_NNS to_IN a_AT D11 10 series_NN of_IN plain_JJ declarations_NNS of_IN God's_NP$ message_NN D11 10 ._. ^ we_PP1AS now_RN find_VB repeated_VBN D11 11 not_XNOT ,_, ~ *'_*' I_PP1A lifted_VBD up_RP mine_PP$$ eyes_NNS ,_, D11 11 **'_**' but_CC rather_RB ,_, ~ *'_*' the_ATI word_NN of_IN the_ATI D11 12 Lord_NPT came_VBD ._. **'_**' D11 13 ^ the_ATI question_NN raised_VBN by_IN these_DTS men_NNS D11 13 concerned_VBD a_AT fast_NN in_IN the_ATI fifth_OD D11 14 month_NN ,_, which_WDTR had_HVD been_BEN observed_VBN for_IN many_AP D11 14 years_NNS ._. ^ from_IN Jeremiah_NP 52_CD :_: 12_CD ,_, D11 15 we_PP1AS learn_VB that_CS it_PP3 was_BEDZ in_IN that_DT month_NN D11 15 the_ATI Babylonian_JNP army_NN had_HVD burned_VBN D11 16 Solomon's_NP$ magnificent_JJ temple_NN ,_, and_CC wrecked_VBN D11 16 Jerusalem_NP ._. ^ now_RN once_RB more_RBR D11 17 the_ATI house_NN of_IN the_ATI Lord_NPT was_BEDZ being_BEG built_VBN D11 17 ,_, if_CS not_XNOT entirely_RB finished_VBN ,_, so_RB D11 18 was_BEDZ it_PP3 suitable_JJ that_CS they_PP3AS should_MD still_RB D11 18 observe_VB the_ATI fast_NN ?_? ^ a_AT very_QL D11 19 natural_JJ question_NN !_! D11 20 ^ the_ATI answer_NN of_IN God_NP through_IN Zechariah_NP linked_VBD D11 20 with_IN this_DT fast_NN another_DT D11 21 in_IN the_ATI seventh_OD month_NN ,_, which_WDTR apparently_RB was_BEDZ D11 21 in_IN memory_NN of_IN the_ATI murder_NN of_IN D11 22 Gedaliah_NP and_CC others_APS ,_, and_CC the_ATI flight_NN of_IN D11 22 the_ATI remnant_NN ,_, left_VBN in_IN the_ATI land_NN ,_, D11 23 into_IN Egypt_NP ,_, as_CS recorded_VBN in_IN 2_CD Kings_NP 25_CD :_: D11 23 25_CD ,_, 26_CD ._. ^ these_DTS tragedies_NNS were_BED D11 24 commemorated_VBN with_IN fasting_NN and_CC tears_NNS ,_, during_IN D11 24 the_ATI seventy_CD years_NNS D11 25 captivity_NN ._. ^ as_QL far_RB as_CS we_PP1AS can_MD discern_VB ,_, D11 25 no_ATI direct_JJ answer_NN was_BEDZ given_VBN to_IN D11 26 the_ATI question_NN they_PP3AS raised_VBD :_: instead_RB another_DT D11 26 question_NN was_BEDZ raised_VBN with_IN D11 27 them_PP3OS ._. ^ did_DOD they_PP3AS have_HV Jehovah_NP before_IN D11 27 their_PP$ minds_NNS in_IN their_PP$ observances_NNS D11 28 or_CC only_RB themselves_PPLS ?_? ^ and_CC when_WRB the_ATI fast_NN D11 28 was_BEDZ over_RP ,_, did_DOD they_PP3AS return_VB to_IN D11 29 their_PP$ eating_NN and_CC drinking_NN just_RB enjoying_VBG D11 29 themselves_PPLS ?_? ^ did_DOD they_PP3AS really_RB D11 30 fast_VB ,_, enquired_VBD the_ATI Lord_NPT ,_, *'_*' unto_IN me_PP1O ,_, D11 30 even_RB to_IN me_PP1O ?_? **'_**' D11 31 ^ here_RN is_BEZ deeply_RB important_JJ instruction_NN for_IN D11 31 ourselves_PPLS ._. ^ we_PP1AS may_MD put_VB D11 32 it_PP3 thus_RB :_: ^ in_IN our_PP$ observances_NNS and_CC service_NN D11 32 a_AT right_JJ motive_NN is_BEZ everything_PN ._. D11 33 ^ we_PP1AS may_MD diligently_RB observe_VB the_ATI Lord's_NPT$ D11 33 supper_NN on_IN the_ATI first_OD day_NN of_IN the_ATI D11 34 week_NN ,_, diligently_RB preach_VB the_ATI gospel_NN ,_, or_CC D11 34 minister_VB to_IN the_ATI saints_NNS ;_; but_CC are_BER D11 35 we_PP1AS doing_VBG it_PP3 with_IN God_NP himself_PPL ,_, revealed_VBN D11 35 in_IN Christ_NP ,_, before_IN us_PP1OS ,_, or_CC are_BER we_PP1AS D11 36 just_RB pursuing_VBG an_AT agreeable_JJ ritual_NN and_CC D11 36 maintaining_VBG our_PP$ own_AP reputations_NNS D11 37 in_IN it_PP3 all_ABN ?_? ^ a_AT searching_JJ question_NN ,_, which_WDTR D11 37 the_ATI writer_NN had_HVD better_RBR ask_VB D11 38 himself_PPL as_CC well_CC" as_CC" the_ATI readers_NNS ask_VB D11 38 themselves_PPLS ._. D11 39 ^ if_CS the_ATI people_NNS had_HVD kept_VBN the_ATI Lord_NPT D11 39 before_IN them_PP3OS and_CC observed_VBN his_PP$ D11 40 words_NNS through_IN the_ATI former_AP prophets_NNS ,_, things_NNS D11 40 would_MD have_HV been_BEN far_RB D11 41 otherwise_RB ._. ^ and_CC what_WDT was_BEDZ his_PP$ word_NN now_RN D11 41 through_IN Zechariah_NP ,_, but_CC just_RB what_WDT D11 42 it_PP3 had_HVD been_BEN through_IN them_PP3OS ._. ^ take_VB D11 42 Isaiah's_NP$ first_OD chapter_NN as_IN an_AT example_NN ._. D11 43 ^ he_PP3A accused_VBD the_ATI people_NNS of_IN moral_JJ corruption_NN D11 43 ,_, whilst_CS maintaining_VBG D11 44 ceremonial_JJ exactitude_NN ._. ^ in_IN verses_NNS 11-14_CD-CD ,_, D11 44 of_IN our_PP$ chapter_NN the_ATI men_NNS who_WPR D11 45 enquired_VBD are_BER reminded_VBN of_IN this_DT ,_, and_CC are_BER D11 45 plainly_RB challenged_VBN as_IN to_IN" the_ATI D11 46 present_JJ attitude_NN of_IN themselves_PPLS and_CC the_ATI people_NNS D11 46 of_IN their_PP$ day_NN ,_, as_CS we_PP1AS see_VB D11 47 in_IN verses_NNS 8-10_CD-CD ._. ^ the_ATI moral_JJ evils_NNS that_WPR D11 47 had_HVD wrecked_VBN the_ATI nation_NN were_BED D11 48 still_RB working_VBG amongst_IN the_ATI people_NNS that_WPR had_HVD D11 48 returned_VBN to_IN the_ATI land_NN ._. ^ a_AT D11 49 remnant_NN may_MD return_VB but_CC the_ATI inveterate_JJ tendency_NN D11 49 to_TO develop_VB the_ATI old_JJ D11 50 evils_NNS remains_VBZ ._. ^ let_VB us_PP1OS never_RB forget_VB that_DT D11 50 ._. D11 51 ^ but_CC having_HVG exposed_VBN the_ATI sinful_JJ state_NN of_IN D11 51 the_ATI people_NNS ,_, another_DT word_NN D11 52 from_IN the_ATI Lord_NPT came_VBD in_IN which_WDTR the_ATI purposes_NNS D11 52 of_IN his_PP$ mercy_NN were_BED revealed_VBN ,_, D11 53 as_CS we_PP1AS see_VB in_IN chapter_NN 8_CD ._. ^ in_IN this_DT D11 53 remarkable_JJ chapter_NN there_EX are_BER things_NNS D11 54 specially_RB addressed_VBN to_IN the_ATI remnant_NN then_RN back_RP D11 54 in_IN the_ATI land_NN *-_*- verses_NNS D11 55 9-17_CD-CD ,_, for_IN instance_NN *-_*- yet_RB the_ATI main_JJB D11 55 drift_NN of_IN it_PP3 goes_VBZ far_RB beyond_IN anything_PN D11 56 that_WPR was_BEDZ realized_VBN in_IN their_PP$ history_NN ,_, D11 56 between_IN the_ATI rebuilding_NN as_CS D11 57 permitted_VBN by_IN Cyrus_NP ,_, and_CC the_ATI destruction_NN under_IN D11 57 the_ATI Romans_NNPS ;_; so_RB it_PP3 looks_VBZ D11 58 on_RP to_IN the_ATI end_NN of_IN the_ATI age_NN and_CC the_ATI D11 58 second_OD coming_NN of_IN Christ_NP ._. D11 59 ^ in_IN that_DT age_NN Jerusalem_NP will_MD indeed_RB have_HV D11 59 Jehovah_NP dwelling_NN in_IN her_PP$ D11 60 midst_NN and_CC be_BE called_VBN *'_*' a_AT city_NN of_IN truth_NN ._. D11 60 **'_**' ^ once_RB indeed_RB he_PP3A who_WPR was_BEDZ the_ATI D11 61 *'_*' truth_NN **'_**' as_CC well_CC" as_CC" the_ATI *'_*' way_NN ,_, D11 61 **'_**' and_CC the_ATI *'_*' life_NN ,_, **'_**' was_BEDZ in_IN her_PP$ D11 62 midst_NN ,_, only_RB to_TO be_BE rejected_VBN and_CC crucified_VBN ,_, D11 62 while_CS Pilate_NP ,_, who_WPR sanctioned_VBD D11 63 that_DT act_NN of_IN rejection_NN ,_, asked_VBD satirically_RB ,_, ^ D11 63 *'_*' what_WDT is_BEZ truth_NN ?_? **'_**' ^ no_UH ,_, D11 64 Jerusalem_NP has_HVZ never_RB yet_RB been_BEN worthy_JJ of_IN that_DT D11 64 designation_NN ;_; but_CC she_PP3A will_MD D11 65 be_BE in_IN a_AT coming_JJ age_NN ._. ^ and_CC then_RN human_JJ life_NN D11 65 will_MD be_BE greatly_RB prolonged_VBN ,_, D11 66 and_CC young_JJ life_NN be_BE abundant_JJ and_CC free_JJ ._. ^ our_PP$ D11 66 modern_JJ streets_NNS with_IN D11 67 fast-moving_JJ motor_NN traffic_NN are_BER hardly_RB a_AT playground_NN D11 67 for_IN children_NNS ._. D11 68 ^ verses_NNS 6-8_CD-CD ,_, also_RB look_VB on_RP to_IN the_ATI D11 68 time_NN of_IN the_ATI end_NN ._. ^ what_WDT had_HVD come_VBN D11 69 to_TO pass_VB in_IN the_ATI return_NN of_IN the_ATI remnant_NN was_BEDZ D11 69 indeed_RB wonderful_JJ in_IN their_PP$ D11 70 eyes_NNS ,_, but_CC what_WDT is_BEZ here_RN predicted_VBN would_MD D11 70 be_BE more_QL wonderful_JJ still_RB ,_, when_WRB D11 71 God_NP would_MD gather_VB from_IN the_ATI west_NR as_CC well_CC" as_CC" D11 71 the_ATI east_NR ,_, to_TO dwell_VB as_IN his_PP$ D11 72 people_NN ,_, so_CS that_CS" he_PP3A would_MD be_BE their_PP$ God_NP D11 72 *'_*' in_IN truth_NN and_CC righteousness_NN ._. **'_**' D11 73 ^ in_IN Christ_NP truth_NN and_CC righteousness_NN have_HV indeed_RB D11 73 been_BEN revealed_VBN and_CC D11 74 established_VBN ,_, but_CC never_RB yet_RB has_HVZ God_NP dwelt_VBN D11 74 in_IN Jerusalem_NP on_IN that_DT basis_NN ._. D11 75 ^ the_ATI day_NN is_BEZ coming_VBG when_WRB he_PP3A will_MD do_DO so_PN D11 75 ._. D11 76 ^ in_IN verses_NNS 9-16_CD-CD ,_, there_EX is_BEZ a_AT special_JJ D11 76 appeal_NN to_IN the_ATI remnant_NN of_IN the_ATI D11 77 people_NNS then_RN in_IN the_ATI land_NN ._. ^ they_PP3AS are_BER D11 77 reminded_VBN of_IN the_ATI words_NNS spoken_VBN to_IN D11 78 them_PP3OS earlier_RBR ,_, when_WRB the_ATI foundation_NN of_IN the_ATI D11 78 temple_NN was_BEDZ laid_VBN ,_, and_CC how_WRB the_ATI D11 79 adversity_NN that_WPR had_HVD marked_VBN their_PP$ doings_NNS had_HVD D11 79 been_BEN turned_VBN into_IN a_AT time_NN of_IN D11 80 prosperity_NN ._. ^ God_NP was_BEDZ now_RN bestowing_VBG much_AP D11 80 favour_NN and_CC prosperity_NN upon_IN D11 81 them_PP3OS ,_, but_CC they_PP3AS are_BER reminded_VBN that_CS he_PP3A D11 81 called_VBD for_IN suitable_JJ behaviour_NN on_IN D11 82 their_PP$ part_NN ._. ^ truth_NN ,_, honesty_NN and_CC righteous_JJ D11 82 judgment_NN was_BEDZ what_WDT was_BEDZ D11 83 expected_VBN of_IN them_PP3OS ._. ^ again_RB the_ATI stress_NN is_BEZ D11 83 on_IN the_ATI moral_JJ qualities_NNS that_WPR are_BER D11 84 according_VBG to_IN God_NP ,_, and_CC not_XNOT on_IN ceremonial_JJ D11 84 observances_NNS ._. D11 85 ^ a_AT further_JJB word_NN from_IN the_ATI Lord_NPT is_BEZ now_RN D11 85 given_VBN ,_, and_CC in_IN verse_NN 19_CD four_CD D11 86 fasts_NNS are_BER mentioned_VBN ._. ^ besides_IN the_ATI two_CD D11 86 mentioned_VBN in_IN the_ATI previous_JJ D11 87 chapter_NN we_PP1AS now_RN have_HV the_ATI one_CD1 in_IN the_ATI D11 87 fourth_OD month_NN ,_, for_CS in_IN that_DT month_NN D11 88 famine_NN prevailed_VBD and_CC Jerusalem_NP was_BEDZ broken_VBN up_RP D11 88 ,_, according_IN to_IN" Jeremiah_NP D11 89 52_CD :_: 6_CD ,_, and_CC it_PP3 was_BEDZ in_IN the_ATI tenth_OD D11 89 month_NN that_CS the_ATI city_NN was_BEDZ surrounded_VBN by_IN D11 90 Nebuchadnezzar's_NP$ army_NN ,_, as_CS verse_NN 4_CD of_IN that_DT D11 90 same_AP chapter_NN records_NNS ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ D11 91 now_RN revealed_VBN that_CS the_ATI day_NN would_MD come_VB when_WRB D11 91 these_DTS four_CD fasts_NNS would_MD be_BE D11 92 turned_VBN into_IN feasts_NNS of_IN rejoicing_NN ._. ^ therefore_RB D11 92 they_PP3AS were_BED to_TO love_VB truth_NN D11 93 and_CC peace_NN ._. ^ these_DTS predictions_NNS of_IN future_JJB D11 93 blessing_NN were_BED to_TO have_HV a_AT D11 94 present_JJ effect_NN upon_IN the_ATI people_NNS ._. D11 95 ^ and_CC all_ABN that_WPR we_PP1AS know_VB of_IN future_JJB D11 95 blessing_NN should_MD have_HV a_AT present_JJ D11 96 effect_NN or_CC good_NN upon_IN ourselves_PPLS ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ D11 96 worthy_JJ of_IN note_NN that_DT truth_NN D11 97 precedes_VBZ peace_NN ,_, as_IN cause_NN and_CC effect_NN ._. ^ D11 97 error_NN produces_VBZ strife_NN just_RB as_QL D11 98 certainly_RB as_CS truth_NN produces_VBZ peace_NN ._. ^ in_IN the_ATI D11 98 remaining_JJ verse_NN of_IN our_PP$ D11 99 chapter_NN we_PP1AS find_VB predictions_NNS of_IN the_ATI happy_JJ D11 99 state_NN of_IN things_NNS that_WPR will_MD D11 100 prevail_VB when_WRB truth_NN at_RB last_RB" prevails_VBZ in_IN D11 100 Jerusalem_NP ,_, and_CC peace_NN fills_VBZ the_ATI D11 101 scene_NN ._. ^ in_IN that_DT coming_JJ day_NN the_ATI house_NN of_IN D11 101 the_ATI Lord_NPT will_MD indeed_RB be_BE ,_, D11 102 *'_*' an_AT house_NN of_IN prayer_NN for_IN all_ABN people_NNS **'_**' D11 102 (_( \0Isa_NP 56_CD :_: 7_CD )_) ._. ^ there_EX will_MD D11 103 be_BE many_AP who_WPR desire_VB to_TO seek_VB the_ATI Lord_NPT in_IN D11 103 prayer_NN ,_, and_CC they_PP3AS will_MD recognize_VB D11 104 where_WRB God_NP is_BEZ to_TO be_BE found_VBN in_IN that_DT day_NN ._. ^ D11 104 all_RB through_IN the_ATI centuries_NNS the_ATI D11 105 name_NN ,_, *'_*' Jew_NC ,_, **'_**' has_HVZ had_HVN a_AT measure_NN D11 105 of_IN reproach_NN attaching_NN to_IN it_PP3 ._. ^ it_PP3 D11 106 will_MD not_XNOT be_BE so_PN then_RN ,_, for_CS they_PP3AS will_MD D11 106 recognize_VB that_CS at_RB last_RB" God_NP is_BEZ with_IN D11 107 his_PP$ ancient_JJ people_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ obvious_JJ that_CS D11 107 this_DT prediction_NN has_HVZ never_RB yet_RB D11 108 been_BEN fulfilled_VBN ,_, and_CC looks_VBZ on_RP to_IN a_AT future_JJB D11 108 day_NN ._. D11 109 ^ the_ATI word_NN of_IN the_ATI Lord_NPT that_WPR opens_VBZ D11 109 chapter_NN 9_CD is_BEZ spoken_VBN of_IN as_IN a_AT D11 110 *'_*' burden_NN ,_, **'_**' since_CS it_PP3 starts_VBZ with_IN D11 110 solemn_JJ words_NNS of_IN judgment_NN on_IN peoples_NNS D11 111 that_WPR surrounded_VBD the_ATI land_NN of_IN Israel_NP ._. ^ some_DTI D11 111 of_IN these_DTS judgments_NNS took_VBD D11 112 place_NN soon_RB after_CS the_ATI predictions_NNS were_BED uttered_VBN D11 112 ;_; that_DT upon_IN Tyre_NP ,_, for_IN D11 113 instance_NN ,_, and_CC upon_IN the_ATI cities_NNS of_IN the_ATI D11 113 Philistines_NPS ._. ^ Darby's_NP$ new_JJ D11 114 translation_NN tells_VBZ us_PP1OS that_CS an_AT alternate_JJ D11 114 rendering_NN to_IN *'_*' bastard_NC ,_, **'_**' is_BEZ D11 115 one_CD1 *'_*' of_IN a_AT foreign_JJ race_NN ._. **'_**' ^ but_CC D11 115 even_RB so_RB there_EX will_MD apparently_RB be_BE a_AT D11 116 remainder_NN ,_, or_CC a_AT remnant_NN ,_, who_WPR will_MD be_BE for_IN D11 116 God_NP and_CC belong_VB to_IN him_PP3O ._. D11 117 ^ moreover_RB ,_, however_WRB powerful_JJ oppressors_NNS may_MD D11 117 appear_VB to_TO be_BE ,_, God_NP will_MD D11 118 encamp_VB about_IN his_PP$ house_NN in_IN protecting_JJ mercy_NN ._. ^ D11 118 and_CC how_WRB will_MD this_DT be_BE D11 119 brought_VBN to_TO pass_VB ?_? D11 120 ^ verses_NNS 9_CD and_CC 10_CD answer_VB this_DT question_NN ,_, D11 120 for_CS in_IN these_DTS two_CD verses_NNS the_ATI D11 121 two_CD advents_NNS of_IN the_ATI Lord_NPT Jesus_NP are_BER brought_VBN D11 121 before_IN us_PP1OS ._. ^ the_ATI coming_NN of_IN D11 122 the_ATI King_NPT will_MD settle_VB everything_PN ,_, but_CC we_PP1AS D11 122 can_MD imagine_VB how_WRB the_ATI reader_NN of_IN D11 123 Zechariah's_NP$ day_NN might_MD pause_VB at_IN this_DT ninth_OD D11 123 verse_NN in_IN amazement_NN ,_, feeling_VBG D11 124 that_CS in_IN the_ATI presence_NN of_IN powerful_JJ D11 124 outside_JJB foes_NNS ,_, and_CC the_ATI inward_JJB D11 125 defection_NN so_QL plainly_RB manifested_VBN amongst_IN the_ATI D11 125 Jews_NNPS ,_, some_DTI great_JJ and_CC D11 126 majestic_JJ and_CC powerful_JJ deliverer_NN was_BEDZ needful_JJ ,_, D11 126 and_CC the_ATI King_NPT is_BEZ announced_VBN D11 127 as_CS lowly_JJ in_IN his_PP$ person_NN and_CC in_IN his_PP$ approach_NN D11 127 ._. ^ true_JJ ,_, he_PP3A is_BEZ to_TO have_HV D11 128 salvation_NN ,_, but_CC this_DT was_BEDZ not_XNOT the_ATI kind_NN of_IN D11 128 King_NPT that_WPR was_BEDZ popularly_RB D11 129 expected_VBN ._. D11 130 ^ the_ATI spirit_NN of_IN God_NP ,_, who_WPR inspired_VBD this_DT D11 130 prophecy_NN knew_VBD very_QL well_RB that_CS D11 131 there_EX was_BEDZ a_AT deeper_JJR question_NN to_TO be_BE settled_VBN D11 131 before_CS there_EX could_MD be_BE the_ATI D11 132 intervention_NN in_IN power_NN that_WPR was_BEDZ so_QL ardently_RB D11 132 desired_VBN ._. ^ first_RB must_MD come_VB D11 133 the_ATI bearing_NN of_IN the_ATI full_JJ penalty_NN of_IN human_JJ D11 133 sin_NN ,_, and_CC hence_RB the_ATI divinely_RB D11 134 reached_VBN settlement_NN of_IN that_DT dreadful_JJ matter_NN ,_, D11 134 and_CC ,_, that_DT accomplished_VBN ,_, D11 135 there_EX could_MD be_BE emancipation_NN from_IN sin's_NN$ power_NN ._. ^ D11 135 this_DT had_HVD been_BEN set_VBN forth_RP D11 136 typically_RB in_IN Exodus_NP 12_CD and_CC 14_CD ._. ^ first_RB the_ATI D11 136 blood_NN of_IN the_ATI lambs_NNS in_IN Egypt_NP ,_, D11 137 and_CC then_RN deliverance_NN by_IN the_ATI overthrow_NN of_IN Egypt_NP D11 137 ._. ^ the_ATI latter_AP is_BEZ more_QL D11 138 spectacular_JJ ,_, but_CC the_ATI former_AP a_AT far_RB deeper_JJR D11 138 thing_NN ._. D11 139 ^ in_IN the_ATI gospels_NNS we_PP1AS see_VB how_WRB the_ATI more_QL D11 139 spectacular_JJ filled_VBD the_ATI minds_NNS D11 140 of_IN the_ATI disciples_NNS ._. ^ even_RB when_WRB they_PP3AS acted_VBD D11 140 and_CC played_VBD their_PP$ part_NN in_IN the_ATI D11 141 fulfilment_NN of_IN verse_NN 9_CD ,_, they_PP3AS did_DOD not_XNOT D11 141 realize_VB they_PP3AS were_BED doing_VBG it_PP3 ._. ^ this_DT D11 142 we_PP1AS are_BER plainly_RB told_VBN in_IN John_NP 12_CD :_: 16_CD ._. ^ D11 142 only_RB when_WRB Jesus_NP was_BEDZ glorified_VBN and_CC D11 143 the_ATI holy_JJ spirit_NN was_BEDZ given_VBN did_DOD they_PP3AS D11 143 realize_VB the_ATI true_JJ significance_NN of_IN D11 144 what_WDT they_PP3AS had_HVD done_VBN ._. ^ again_RB ,_, in_IN Acts_NP D11 144 1_CD1 :_: 6_CD ,_, we_PP1AS see_VB how_WRB the_ATI coming_NN of_IN D11 144 the_ATI D11 145 kingdom_NN in_IN power_NN filled_VBD their_PP$ thoughts_NNS before_CS D11 145 the_ATI spirit_NN was_BEDZ given_VBN ._. D11 146 ^ the_ATI coming_NN of_IN the_ATI King_NPT in_IN lowly_JJ grace_NN D11 146 was_BEDZ but_RI little_RB understood_VBN or_CC D11 147 anticipated_VBN by_IN the_ATI great_JJ majority_NN ._. D11 148 ^ but_CC the_ATI Messiah_NP will_MD come_VB in_IN power_NN and_CC D11 148 have_HV dominion_NN over_IN all_ABN the_ATI D11 149 earth_NN ,_, as_CS verse_NN 10_CD declares_VBZ ._. ^ the_ATI way_NN D11 149 his_PP$ widespread_JJ kingship_NN is_BEZ D11 150 stated_VBN here_RN agrees_VBZ exactly_RB with_IN the_ATI inspired_JJ D11 150 statement_NN through_IN David_NP D11 151 centuries_NNS before_RI ,_, written_VBN in_IN psalm_NN 72_CD :_: 8_CD D11 151 ._. ^ when_WRB David_NP forsaw_VBD D11 152 this_DT by_IN the_ATI spirit_NN ,_, every_AT desire_NN of_IN his_PP$ D11 152 heart_NN was_BEDZ satisfied_VBN ,_, and_CC he_PP3A D11 153 had_HVD nothing_PN left_VBN to_TO pray_VB for_IN ,_, as_CS the_ATI D11 153 last_AP verse_NN of_IN the_ATI psalm_NN tells_VBZ us_PP1OS ._. D11 154 ^ what_WDT our_PP$ prophet_NN tells_VBZ us_PP1OS is_BEZ that_CS the_ATI D11 154 days_NNS of_IN warfare_NN will_MD be_BE over_RP *-_*- D11 155 chariot_NN and_CC battle_NN bow_NN cut_VBN off_RP ,_, and_CC peace_NN D11 155 imposed_VBN upon_IN the_ATI nations_NNS ._. D11 156 ^ verse_NN 11_CD appears_VBZ to_TO be_BE a_AT word_NN specially_RB D11 156 addressed_VBN to_IN the_ATI sons_NNS of_IN D11 157 Israel_NP ,_, for_IN Ephraim_NP is_BEZ addressed_VBN in_IN verse_NN D11 157 13_CD ,_, as_CC well_CC" as_CC" Judah_NP ._. ^ they_PP3AS D11 158 have_HV all_ABN been_BEN like_IN prisoners_NNS ,_, entrapped_VBN in_IN D11 158 a_AT waterless_JJ pit_NN ,_, waiting_VBG D11 159 and_CC hoping_VBG for_IN deliverance_NN ._. ^ when_WRB Messiah_NP D11 159 comes_VBZ in_IN power_NN deliverance_NN D11 160 will_MD reach_VB them_PP3OS ,_, but_CC only_RB through_IN *'_*' the_ATI D11 160 blood_NN of_IN thy_PP$ covenant_NN ._. **'_**' D11 161 ^ here_RN we_PP1AS see_VB an_AT allusion_NN to_IN that_DT new_JJ D11 161 covenant_NN of_IN grace_NN ,_, predicted_VBN in_IN D11 162 Jeremiah_NP 31_CD :_: 31_CD ,_, illuminated_VBN for_IN us_PP1OS by_IN D11 162 the_ATI words_NNS of_IN the_ATI Lord_NPT Jesus_NP at_IN D11 163 the_ATI institution_NN of_IN his_PP$ supper_NN ,_, when_WRB he_PP3A D11 163 spoke_VBD of_IN ,_, *'_*' my_PP$ blood_NN of_IN the_ATI new_JJ D11 164 testament_NN **'_**' (_( \0Matt_NP 26_CD :_: 28_CD )_) ._. ^ on_IN D11 164 that_DT basis_NN only_RB will_MD the_ATI D11 165 deliverance_NN and_CC the_ATI blessing_NN be_BE brought_VBN in_RP D11 165 and_CC firmly_RB established_VBN ._. D11 166 ^ when_WRB Zechariah_NP wrote_VBD these_DTS things_NNS ,_, Greece_NP D11 166 ,_, mentioned_VBN in_IN verse_NN 13_CD ,_, D11 167 was_BEDZ hardly_RB a_AT power_NN to_TO be_BE reckoned_VBN with_IN ,_, D11 167 though_CS not_XNOT long_RB after_RI ,_, under_IN D11 168 Alexander_NP the_ATI great_JJ ,_, it_PP3 was_BEDZ destined_VBN to_TO D11 168 overthrow_VB the_ATI Persian_JNP power_NN ._. D11 169 ^ we_PP1AS may_MD see_VB therefore_RB in_IN the_ATI closing_JJ D11 169 verses_NNS of_IN this_DT chapter_NN D11 170 predictions_NNS which_WDTR had_HVD a_AT partial_JJ fulfilment_NN D11 170 not_XNOT long_RB after_CS the_ATI prophecy_NN D11 171 was_BEDZ given_VBN ,_, though_CS in_IN their_PP$ fulness_NN they_PP3AS D11 171 look_VB on_RP to_IN the_ATI end_NN D11 172 of_IN the_ATI age_NN ._. D11 173 ^ the_ATI same_AP thing_NN may_MD be_BE said_VBN of_IN the_ATI D11 173 predictions_NNS that_WPR fill_VB chapter_NN D11 174 10_CD ,_, though_CS it_PP3 opens_VBZ with_IN solemn_JJ words_NNS D11 174 concerning_IN the_ATI evils_NNS that_WPR still_RB D11 175 were_BED practiced_VBN among_IN the_ATI people_NNS ._. ^ the_ATI *'_*' D11 175 rain_NN **'_**' of_IN blessing_NN D11 176 would_MD descend_VB from_IN God_NP ,_, and_CC not_XNOT proceed_VB D11 176 from_IN the_ATI *'_*' idols_NNS ,_, **'_**' or_CC D11 177 *'_*' teraphim_&FW ,_, **'_**' little_JJ images_NNS by_IN which_WDTR D11 177 men_NNS sought_VBD to_TO probe_VB into_IN future_JJB D11 178 events_NNS ._. ^ all_ABN that_WPR came_VBD from_IN this_DT source_NN D11 178 was_BEDZ but_RI vanity_NN ,_, and_CC the_ATI D11 179 *'_*' shepherds_NNS **'_**' of_IN the_ATI people_NNS ,_, who_WPR D11 179 dealt_VBD with_IN such_ABL things_NNS would_MD have_HV D11 180 the_ATI anger_NN of_IN God_NP against_IN them_PP3OS ,_, for_CS God_NP D11 180 was_BEDZ going_VBG to_TO take_VB up_RP the_ATI house_NN D11 181 of_IN Judah_NP and_CC use_VB them_PP3OS in_IN the_ATI execution_NN D11 181 of_IN judgment_NN in_IN some_DTI directions_NNS ._. D12 2 ^ had_HVD the_ATI passing_NN away_RP of_IN one_CD1 generation_NN in_IN D12 2 death_NN been_BEN normal_JJ ,_, could_MD D12 3 it_PP3 at_IN the_ATI same_AP time_NN have_HV been_BEN listed_VBN D12 3 with_IN *'_*' vanity_NN of_IN vanities_NNS **'_**' ?_? D12 4 ^ when_WRB Adam_NP by_IN his_PP$ disobedience_NN let_VBD sin_NN into_IN D12 4 the_ATI world_NN and_CC death_NN by_IN D12 5 sin_NN ,_, man_NN made_VBN in_IN the_ATI image_NN of_IN God_NP D12 5 became_VBD *'_*' subject_JJ to_IN vanity_NN D12 6 **'_**' (_( \0Rom_NP 8_CD :_: 20_CD )_) ,_, not_XNOT willingly_RB D12 6 certainly_RB ,_, and_CC in_IN hope_NN most_QL blessedly_RB ,_, D12 7 but_CC subject_JJ to_IN vanity_NN nevertheless_RB ._. ^ the_ATI doom_NN D12 7 pronounced_VBN in_IN Genesis_NP D12 8 3_CD :_: 19_CD ~ *'_*' dust_NN thou_PP2 art_BER and_CC unto_IN dust_NN D12 8 shalt_MD thou_PP2 return_VB **'_**' is_BEZ D12 9 seen_VBN by_IN Ecclesiastes_NP as_IN something_PN that_WPR reduced_VBD D12 9 man_NN to_IN the_ATI level_NN of_IN the_ATI D12 10 beast_NN of_IN the_ATI field_NN ._. ^ he_PP3A comments_VBZ *'_*' as_CS D12 10 the_ATI one_CD1 dieth_VBZ ,_, so_RB dieth_VBZ the_ATI D12 11 other_AP **'_**' (_( 3_CD :_: 19_CD )_) ._. ^ if_CS the_ATI coming_NN D12 11 of_IN death_NN has_HVZ necessitated_VBN the_ATI D12 12 successive_JJ passing_NN and_CC coming_NN of_IN the_ATI generations_NNS D12 12 of_IN men_NNS ,_, then_RN the_ATI D12 13 question_NN arises_VBZ ,_, what_WDT would_MD have_HV been_BEN the_ATI D12 13 state_NN of_IN things_NNS had_HVD Adam_NP D12 14 remained_VBN unfallen_JJ ?_? D12 15 ^ now_RN we_PP1AS readily_RB admit_VB that_CS from_IN one_CD1 D12 15 point_NN of_IN view_NN ,_, this_DT argument_NN D12 16 based_VBN upon_IN what_WDT might_MD have_HV happened_VBN but_CC D12 16 which_WDTR did_DOD not_XNOT ,_, is_BEZ often_RB D12 17 futile_JJ ,_, and_CC we_PP1AS are_BER well_RB advised_VBN to_TO face_VB D12 17 things_NNS as_CS they_PP3AS are_BER ._. ^ if_CS ,_, D12 18 however_RB ,_, we_PP1AS approach_VB such_ABL a_AT question_NN with_IN D12 18 a_AT chastened_JJ spirit_NN ,_, D12 19 admitting_VBG all_ABN the_ATI time_NN that_CS what_WDT we_PP1AS say_VB D12 19 may_MD nevertheless_RB be_BE very_QL wide_JJ D12 20 of_IN the_ATI mark_NN ,_, some_DTI light_NN upon_IN the_ATI vexed_JJ D12 20 state_NN of_IN affairs_NNS that_WPR now_RN D12 21 obtain_VB may_MD repay_VB our_PP$ modest_JJ inquiry_NN ._. D12 22 ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ categorically_RB stated_VBN that_CS God_NP made_VBD D12 22 man_NN upright_JJ ,_, but_CC that_CS D12 23 men_NNS have_HV sought_VBN out_RP many_AP inventions_NNS (_( D12 23 \0Eccles_NP 7_CD :_: 29_CD )_) ,_, so_CS that_CS" we_PP1AS can_MD D12 24 go_VB behind_IN the_ATI record_NN of_IN the_ATI fall_NN in_IN Eden_NP D12 24 with_IN this_DT fact_NN in_IN mind_NN ._. ^ the_ATI D12 25 unfallen_JJ Adam_NP was_BEDZ commanded_VBN by_IN his_PP$ creator_NN D12 25 to_TO *'_*' be_BE fruitful_JJ ,_, and_CC D12 26 multiply_VB ,_, and_CC replenish_VB the_ATI earth_NN **'_**' (_( D12 26 \0Gen_NP 1_CD1 :_: 28_CD )_) ,_, yet_CC it_PP3 is_BEZ very_QL D12 27 evident_JJ that_CS ,_, if_CS time_NN went_VBD on_RP and_CC the_ATI D12 27 population_NN of_IN the_ATI earth_NN D12 28 continued_VBD to_TO increase_VB ,_, nations_NNS and_CC rulers_NNS D12 28 would_MD soon_RB be_BE facing_VBG a_AT most_QL D12 29 serious_JJ problem_NN of_IN feeding_VBG and_CC supporting_VBG these_DTS D12 29 teeming_JJ millions_CDS ._. D12 30 ^ only_RB by_IN the_ATI sad_JJ fact_NN now_RN that_CS *'_*' one_CD1 D12 30 generation_NN **'_**' passes_VBZ ,_, can_MD the_ATI D12 31 earth_NN continue_VB to_TO support_VB *'_*' the_ATI generations_NNS D12 31 **'_**' that_WPR come_VB ._. ^ it_PP3 appears_VBZ D12 32 therefore_RB that_CS had_HVD man_NN not_XNOT fallen_VBN and_CC death_NN D12 32 not_XNOT intervened_VBN ,_, the_ATI D12 33 succeeding_JJ generations_NNS that_WPR would_MD have_HV made_VBN up_RP D12 33 the_ATI number_NN of_IN the_ATI elect_JJ D12 34 seed_NN would_MD have_HV appeared_VBN without_IN break_NN ,_, and_CC D12 34 that_CS the_ATI earth_NN would_MD have_HV D12 35 provided_VBN abundant_JJ accommodation_NN for_IN them_PP3OS all_ABN ._. D12 35 ^ there_EX would_MD then_RN have_HV D12 36 not_XNOT been_BEN necessary_JJ the_ATI thousands_CDS of_IN years_NNS D12 36 which_WDTR the_ATI ages_NNS span_VB ,_, and_CC D12 37 none_PN of_IN the_ATI *'_*' tares_NNS **'_**' would_MD have_HV D12 37 challenged_VBN the_ATI true_JJ seed_NN and_CC D12 38 occupied_VBN so_QL much_AP of_IN their_PP$ territory_NN ._. D12 39 ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ safe_JJ to_TO say_VB ,_, however_RB ,_, that_CS D12 39 no_ATI inheritance_NN set_VBN aside_RP for_IN D12 40 those_DTS predestinated_VBN by_IN divine_JJ grace_NN ,_, ever_RB D12 40 has_HVZ written_VBN across_IN it_PP3 *'_*' with_NC D12 41 vacant_NC possession_NC ._. **'_**' ^ in_IN every_AT case_NN a_AT D12 41 usurper_NN has_HVZ to_TO be_BE D12 42 dispossessed_VBN before_CS the_ATI true_JJ heirs_NNS can_MD take_VB D12 42 possession_NN ;_; see_VB D12 43 Deuteronomy_NP two_CD for_IN this_DT in_IN type_NN ._. ^ the_ATI D12 43 multiplication_NN of_IN man_NN after_IN the_ATI D12 44 fall_NN ,_, was_BEDZ not_XNOT made_VBN up_RP entirely_RB by_IN the_ATI D12 44 true_JJ seed_NN ;_; Satan_NP sowed_VBD his_PP$ D12 45 tares_NNS ,_, and_CC those_DTS tares_NNS outnumbered_VBD the_ATI D12 45 true_JJ seed_NN so_QL disproportionately_RB D12 46 that_CS by_IN the_ATI time_NN that_CS Noah_NP was_BEDZ grown_VBN to_IN D12 46 manhood_NN *'_*' all_ABN flesh_NN **'_**' with_IN D12 47 the_ATI exception_NN of_IN one_CD1 family_NN of_IN eight_CD souls_NNS D12 47 (_( 1_CD1 \0Pet_NP 3_CD :_: 20_CD )_) had_HVD so_RB D12 48 corrupted_VBN his_PP$ way_NN upon_IN the_ATI earth_NN ,_, that_CS D12 48 they_PP3AS were_BED completely_RB destroyed_VBN D12 49 from_IN the_ATI earth_NN (_( \0Gen_NP 6_CD :_: 13_CD )_) ,_, *'_*' D12 49 everything_PN that_WPR is_BEZ in_IN the_ATI earth_NN shall_MD D12 50 die_VB **'_**' was_BEDZ the_ATI verdict_NN (_( \0Gen_NP 6_CD :_: 17_CD D12 50 )_) and_CC ~ *'_*' Noah_NP only_RB remained_VBD alive_JJ ,_, D12 51 and_CC they_PP3AS that_WPR were_BED with_IN him_PP3O in_IN the_ATI D12 51 Ark_NP **'_**' (_( \0Gen_NP 7_CD :_: 23_CD )_) ._. D12 52 ^ again_RB ,_, upon_IN emerging_VBG on_RP to_IN dry_JJ land_NN ,_, D12 52 Noah_NP is_BEZ commanded_VBN ,_, as_CS was_BEDZ D12 53 Adam_NP before_IN him_PP3O ,_, ^ *'_*' be_BE fruitful_JJ ,_, and_CC D12 53 multiply_VB ,_, and_CC replenish_VB the_ATI D12 54 earth_NN **'_**' (_( \0Gen_NP 9_CD :_: 1_CD1 )_) ._. ^ this_DT D12 54 increase_NN in_IN number_NN however_RB was_BEDZ not_XNOT D12 55 limited_VBN to_IN the_ATI true_JJ seed_NN ,_, for_CS we_PP1AS read_VB D12 55 the_ATI Midianites_NNPS and_CC the_ATI D12 56 Amalekites_NNPS came_VBD *'_*' as_IN grasshoppers_NNS for_IN D12 56 multitude_NN **'_**' (_( Judges_NP 6_CD :_: 5,7_CD :_: 12_CD )_) D12 57 whereas_CS Israel_NP were_BED greatly_RB impoverished_VBN ._. ^ the_ATI D12 57 *'_*' multitude_NN **'_**' of_IN the_ATI D12 58 Canaanites_NNPS (_( Judges_NP 4_CD :_: 7_CD )_) ;_; of_IN the_ATI D12 58 Syrians_NNPS (_( 1_CD1 Kings_NP 20_CD :_: 13_CD )_) ;_; of_IN the_ATI D12 59 Ethiopians_NNPS (_( 2_CD \0Chron_NP 14_CD :_: 11_CD )_) ;_; of_IN D12 59 the_ATI children_NNS of_IN Moab_NP and_CC of_IN Ammon_NP (_( 2_CD D12 60 \0Chron_NP 20_CD :_: 2_CD )_) ;_; of_IN the_ATI Assyrians_NNPS (_( 2_CD D12 60 \0Chron_NP 32_CD :_: 7_CD )_) ;_; of_IN Babylon_NP (_( \0Isa_NP D12 61 13_CD :_: 4_CD )_) ;_; of_IN the_ATI nations_NNS (_( \0Isa_NP 29_CD :_: D12 61 7_CD )_) ;_; of_IN Egypt_NP ,_, of_IN Elam_NP ,_, of_IN Meshech_NP D12 61 and_CC D12 62 Tubal_NP and_CC of_IN Gog_NP ;_; and_CC finally_RB the_ATI D12 62 multitudes_NNS in_IN the_ATI valley_NN of_IN decision_NN D12 63 (_( Joel_NP 3_CD :_: 14_CD )_) ,_, indicate_VB something_PN of_IN D12 63 the_ATI menace_NN to_IN the_ATI true_JJ seed_NN in_IN the_ATI D12 64 earth_NN that_CS the_ATI multiplying_NN of_IN these_DTS nations_NNS D12 64 must_MD have_HV been_BEN ._. ^ the_ATI D12 65 picture_NN before_IN the_ATI mind_NN is_BEZ a_AT field_NN of_IN D12 65 wheat_NN ,_, smothered_VBN by_IN the_ATI growth_NN D12 66 of_IN charlock_NN and_CC poppy_NN ._. ^ the_ATI passages_NNS which_WDTR D12 66 speak_VB of_IN Israel_NP being_BEG a_AT D12 67 multitude_NN are_BER well_RB known_VBN ,_, two_CD passages_NNS ,_, D12 67 namely_RB Genesis_NP 28_CD :_: 3_CD and_CC 48_CD :_: 4_CD D12 68 need_VB to_TO be_BE corrected_VBN in_IN the_ATI \0A.V_NN for_IN the_ATI D12 68 word_NN there_RN translated_VBN D12 69 *'_*' multitude_NC **'_**' is_BEZ the_ATI Hebrew_JNP word_NN gahal_&FW D12 69 meaning_VBG *'_*' a_AT called_JJ out_RP D12 70 assembly_NN **'_**' ,_, or_CC as_CS Stephen_NP says_VBZ *'_*' the_ATI D12 70 church_NN in_IN the_ATI wilderness_NN D12 71 **'_**' (_( Acts_NP 7_CD :_: 38_CD )_) ,_, and_CC has_HVZ no_ATI D12 71 connexion_NN with_IN the_ATI question_NN of_IN number_NN ._. D12 72 ^ while_CS the_ATI promise_NN was_BEDZ made_VBN to_IN Abraham_NP D12 72 that_CS his_PP$ seed_NN should_MD be_BE D12 73 like_IN the_ATI stars_NNS ,_, the_ATI dust_NN and_CC the_ATI sand_NN D12 73 that_WPR can_MD not_XNOT be_BE numbered_VBN ,_, we_PP1AS know_VB D12 74 that_CS the_ATI Lord_NPT had_HVD said_VBN of_IN them_PP3OS ~ *'_*' D12 74 ye_PP2 were_BED the_ATI fewest_AP of_IN all_ABN D12 75 people_NNS **'_**' (_( \0Deut_NP 7_CD :_: 7_CD )_) although_CS from_IN D12 75 being_BEG *'_*' three_CD score_NN and_CC ten_CD D12 76 persons_NNS **'_**' they_PP3AS had_HVD become_VBN by_IN the_ATI time_NN D12 76 Moses_NP wrote_VBD *'_*' as_IN the_ATI stars_NNS of_IN D12 77 heaven_NN for_IN multitude_NN **'_**' (_( \0Deut_NP 10_CD :_: 22_CD )_) D12 77 ._. ^ at_IN the_ATI time_NN of_IN the_ATI end_NN of_IN D12 78 the_ATI millennium_NN the_ATI evil_JJ seed_NNS are_BER so_QL D12 78 numerous_JJ that_CS they_PP3AS are_BER likened_VBN in_IN D12 79 number_NN to_IN *'_*' the_ATI sand_NN of_IN the_ATI sea_NN **'_**' ,_, D12 79 and_CC went_VBD up_RP on_IN *'_*' the_ATI breadth_NN of_IN D12 80 the_ATI earth_NN **'_**' (_( \0Rev_NP 20_CD :_: 8,9_CD )_) ._. ^ at_RB D12 80 last_RB" ,_, however_RB ,_, the_ATI nations_NNS of_IN the_ATI D12 81 earth_NN will_MD become_VB so_RB decimated_VBN by_IN war_NN ,_, D12 81 famine_NN and_CC self_NN destruction_NN D12 82 that_CS Zechariah_NP speaks_VBZ of_IN *'_*' every_AT one_CD1 that_WPR D12 82 is_BEZ left_VBN of_IN all_ABN the_ATI D12 83 nations_NNS which_WDTR come_VB against_IN Jerusalem_NP **'_**' (_( D12 83 Zech_NP 14_CD :_: 16_CD )_) !_! ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ thus_RB that_CS D12 84 Israel_NP ,_, as_IN the_ATI vehicle_NN of_IN the_ATI true_JJ seed_NN D12 84 on_IN earth_NN ,_, come_VB into_IN their_PP$ own_AP ,_, D12 85 for_CS then_RN ~ *'_*' Israel_NP shall_MD blossom_VB ,_, and_CC bud_VB D12 85 ,_, and_CC fill_VB the_ATI face_NN of_IN the_ATI D12 86 world_NN with_IN fruit_NN **'_**' (_( \0Isa_NP 27_CD :_: 6_CD )_) ;_; D12 86 it_PP3 is_BEZ then_RN that_CS they_PP3AS *'_*' enlarge_VB the_ATI D12 87 place_NN of_IN their_PP$ tent_NN **'_**' and_CC their_PP$ seed_NN *'_*' D12 87 shall_MD inherit_VB the_ATI gentiles_NNS D12 88 **'_**' (_( \0Isa_NP 54_CD :_: 3_CD )_) even_RB as_CS their_PP$ D12 88 fathers_NNS in_IN small_JJ yet_CC typical_JJ measure_NN D12 89 *'_*' inherited_VBD **'_**' the_ATI land_NN held_VBN by_IN the_ATI D12 89 Amorite_NNP (_( \0Deut_NP 2_CD :_: 31_CD )_) ._. D12 90 ^ coming_VBG back_RP from_IN this_DT survey_NN to_IN the_ATI time_NN D12 90 of_IN Adam_NP ,_, and_CC supposing_VBG ,_, D12 91 for_IN the_ATI sake_NN of_IN argument_NN ,_, that_CS Adam_NP did_DOD D12 91 not_XNOT fall_NN ,_, that_CS neither_DTX sin_NN nor_CC D12 92 death_NN were_BED factors_NNS in_IN the_ATI purpose_NN ,_, and_CC D12 92 that_CS consequently_RB redemption_NN by_IN D12 93 the_ATI shedding_NN of_IN blood_NN would_MD be_BE unknown_JJ and_CC D12 93 unnecessary_JJ ,_, let_VB us_PP1OS think_VB D12 94 further_RBR along_IN this_DT line_NN ._. ^ Hebrews_NP 2_CD :_: 14_CD D12 94 makes_VBZ it_PP3 clear_JJ that_CS the_ATI saviour_NN D12 95 took_VBD part_NN in_IN flesh_NN and_CC blood_NN in_CS order_CS" D12 95 that_CS" he_PP3A might_MD be_BE the_ATI D12 96 kinsman-redeemer_NN of_IN all_ABN the_ATI seed_NN ,_, but_CC John_NP D12 96 1_CD1 :_: 14_CD reveals_VBZ that_CS he_PP3A was_BEDZ D12 97 made_VBN flesh_NN so_CS that_CS" of_IN his_PP$ fulness_NN we_PP1AS D12 97 all_ABN might_MD receive_VB ,_, and_CC that_DT as_IN D12 98 the_ATI word_NN made_VBN flesh_NN revealed_VBN to_IN man_NN the_ATI D12 98 Father_NPT (_( John_NP 1_CD1 :_: 18_CD )_) ._. ^ is_BEZ it_PP3 D12 99 something_PN that_WPR is_BEZ impossible_JJ of_IN belief_NN that_CS ,_, D12 99 had_HVD there_EX been_BEN no_ATI sin_NN ,_, D12 100 even_RB then_RN God_NP would_MD still_RB have_HV been_BEN manifest_JJ D12 100 in_IN the_ATI flesh_NN ?_? ^ was_BEDZ the_ATI D12 101 virgin_NN birth_NN that_WPR took_VBD place_NN about_RB 4,000_CD D12 101 years_NNS after_IN the_ATI creation_NN of_IN D12 102 man_NN ,_, but_RI the_ATI postponement_NN of_IN a_AT most_QL D12 102 glorious_JJ and_CC miraculous_JJ event_NN ,_, D12 103 that_WPR had_HVD it_PP3 not_XNOT been_BEN for_IN sin_NN ,_, would_MD D12 103 have_HV taken_VBN place_NN in_IN the_ATI garden_NN of_IN D12 104 Eden_NP before_CS any_DTI other_AP children_NNS were_BED born_VBN ?_? ^ D12 104 was_BEDZ it_PP3 this_DT that_WPR lies_VBZ D12 105 behind_IN the_ATI mystery_NN of_IN the_ATI temptation_NN and_CC the_ATI D12 105 fall_NN ,_, with_IN its_PP$ close_JJ D12 106 connexion_NN with_IN the_ATI two_CD seeds_NNS ,_, the_ATI immediate_JJ D12 106 reference_NN to_IN childbirth_NN ,_, D12 107 and_CC the_ATI birth_NN of_IN Cain_NP who_WPR turned_VBD out_RP to_TO D12 107 be_BE *'_*' of_IN the_ATI wicked_JJ one_CD1 **'_**' ?_? ^ we_PP1AS D12 108 ask_VB these_DTS questions_NNS ,_, we_PP1AS may_MD entertain_VB our_PP$ D12 108 theories_NNS ,_, but_CC questions_NNS and_CC D12 109 theories_NNS they_PP3AS must_MD remain_VB ._. D12 110 ^ had_HVD the_ATI coming_NN in_RP of_IN death_NN not_XNOT made_VBN D12 110 the_ATI successive_JJ generations_NNS D12 111 follow_VB the_ATI death_NN of_IN those_DTS that_WPR preceded_VBD D12 111 them_PP3OS ,_, the_ATI full_JJ tale_NN of_IN those_DTS D12 112 chosen_VBN either_DTX before_IN or_CC since_IN the_ATI overthrow_NN D12 112 of_IN the_ATI world_NN would_MD have_HV D12 113 been_BEN early_RB reached_VBN ,_, and_CC the_ATI translation_NN from_IN D12 113 Adam_NP to_IN Christ_NP effected_VBN D12 114 and_CC the_ATI different_JJ spheres_NNS of_IN predestinated_JJ glory_NN D12 114 entered_VBN ._. ^ as_CS it_PP3 is_BEZ ,_, D12 115 the_ATI evil_JJ seed_NNS jostle_VB the_ATI true_JJ heirs_NNS for_IN D12 115 room_NN and_CC many_AP times_NNS overrun_VB D12 116 them_PP3OS and_CC keep_VB them_PP3OS down_RP both_ABX in_IN number_NN D12 116 and_CC in_IN possessions_NNS ._. ^ the_ATI very_AP D12 117 character_NN of_IN this_DT age_NN turns_VBZ the_ATI true_JJ heirs_NNS D12 117 into_IN pilgrims_NNS and_CC strangers_NNS D12 118 yet_CC it_PP3 still_RB stands_VBZ written_VBN ~ *'_*' the_ATI meek_JJ D12 118 shall_MD inherit_VB the_ATI earth_NN **'_**' and_CC D12 119 that_DT not_XNOT only_RB in_IN the_ATI sermon_NN on_IN the_ATI mount_NN D12 119 ,_, but_CC in_IN psalm_NN thirty-seven_CD D12 120 where_WRB the_ATI believer_NN is_BEZ told_VBN to_TO fret_VB not_XNOT D12 120 because_IN of_IN" evil_NN doers_NNS ..._... for_CS D12 121 yet_RB a_AT little_JJ while_NN and_CC the_ATI wicked_JJ shall_MD D12 121 not_XNOT be_BE (_( \0Ps_NP 37_CD :_: 9,10_CD )_) ._. ^ as_IN a_AT D12 122 consequence_NN of_IN what_WDT actually_RB occurred_VBD in_IN Genesis_NP D12 122 three_CD ,_, Christ_NP ,_, the_ATI D12 123 true_JJ seed_NN ,_, is_BEZ revealed_VBN as_IN the_ATI D12 123 kinsman-redeemer_NN ,_, and_CC resurrection_NN now_RN D12 124 becomes_VBZ the_ATI gate_NN to_IN glory_NN ._. ^ doubtless_RB all_ABN D12 124 has_HVZ been_BEN overruled_VBN by_IN divine_JJ D12 125 love_NN ._. ^ the_ATI rugged_JJ pathway_NN that_WPR we_PP1AS have_HV D12 125 been_BEN called_VBN upon_IN to_TO walk_VB ,_, the_ATI D12 126 attacks_NNS and_CC the_ATI snares_NNS of_IN the_ATI evil_JJ one_CD1 ,_, D12 126 all_ABN contribute_VB to_IN that_DT D12 127 essential_JJ experience_NN which_WDTR arising_VBG out_RP of_IN D12 127 patience_NN ,_, ultimately_RB leads_VBZ D12 128 to_IN a_AT hope_NN that_WPR maketh_VBZ not_XNOT ashamed_JJ (_( \0Rom_NP D12 128 5_CD :_: 4,5_CD )_) ._. D12 129 ^ the_ATI scripture_NN speaks_VBZ more_RB than_RB" once_RB of_IN D12 129 a_AT *'_*' book_NN of_IN life_NN **'_**' ,_, Paul_NP D12 130 speaks_VBZ of_IN it_PP3 saying_VBG ,_, ~ *'_*' my_PP$ fellow_JJB D12 130 labourers_NNS ,_, whose_WP$R names_NNS are_BER in_IN the_ATI D12 131 book_NN of_IN life_NN **'_**' (_( \0Phil_NP 4_CD :_: 3_CD )_) ,_, D12 131 showing_VBG that_CS those_DTS called_VBN during_IN his_PP$ D12 132 prison_NN ministry_NN have_HV their_PP$ names_NNS therein_RB ._. ^ D12 132 in_IN Revelation_NP 3_CD :_: 5_CD the_ATI D12 133 divine_JJ promise_NN strengthens_VBZ the_ATI overcomer_NN in_IN his_PP$ D12 133 fight_NN by_IN assuring_VBG him_PP3O D12 134 that_CS ~ *'_*' I_PP1A will_MD not_XNOT blot_VB out_RP his_PP$ name_NN D12 134 out_RP of_IN the_ATI book_NN of_IN life_NN **'_**' and_CC D12 135 the_ATI reader_NN may_MD find_VB his_PP$ mind_NN turning_VBG to_IN D12 135 Revelation_NP 22_CD :_: 19_CD where_WRB we_PP1AS read_VB D12 136 in_IN the_ATI \0A.V_NN ~ *'_*' God_NP shall_MD take_VB away_RP his_PP$ D12 136 part_NN out_RP of_IN the_ATI book_NN of_IN D12 137 life_NN **'_**' whereas_CS the_ATI \0R.V_NN reads_VBZ *'_*' from_IN D12 137 the_ATI tree_NN of_IN life_NN **'_**' with_IN D12 138 the_ATI critical_JJ texts_NNS ._. ^ those_DTS *'_*' whose_WP$R D12 138 names_NNS are_BER not_XNOT written_VBN in_IN the_ATI book_NN D12 139 of_IN life_NN **'_**' will_MD worship_VB the_ATI beast_NN (_( \0Rev_NP D12 139 13_CD :_: 8_CD )_) ,_, even_RB as_CS Revelation_NP D12 140 17_CD :_: 8_CD reveals_VBZ ._. ^ at_IN the_ATI great_JJ white_JJ D12 140 throne_NN the_ATI book_NN of_IN life_NN is_BEZ brought_VBN D12 141 forward_RB ,_, and_CC to_TO keep_VB close_RB to_IN the_ATI wording_NN D12 141 of_IN the_ATI inspired_JJ original_NN we_PP1AS D12 142 read_VB ^ *'_*' and_CC if_CS any_DTI one_CD1 was_BEDZ not_XNOT D12 142 found_VBN written_VBN in_IN the_ATI book_NN of_IN life_NN ,_, D12 143 he_PP3A was_BEDZ cast_VBN into_IN the_ATI lake_NN of_IN fire_NN **'_**' D12 143 (_( \0Rev_NP 10_CD :_: 15_CD )_) ._. ^ the_ATI D12 144 prominence_NN given_VBN to_IN the_ATI book_NN of_IN life_NN in_IN D12 144 the_ATI Revelation_NP may_MD be_BE because_CS D12 145 the_ATI emergence_NN of_IN the_ATI true_JJ seed_NN is_BEZ imminent_JJ D12 145 ._. ^ it_PP3 refers_VBZ particularly_RB to_IN D12 146 the_ATI overcomer_NN ._. ^ see_VB millennial_JJ studies_NNS in_IN D12 146 \0Vol_NN 39_CD ._. ^ the_ATI true_JJ D12 147 seed_NN whose_WP$R names_NNS are_BER in_IN that_DT book_NN will_MD D12 147 never_RB apostatize_VB ;_; the_ATI false_JJ D12 148 seed_NN whose_WP$R names_NNS were_BED never_RB in_IN that_DT book_NN D12 148 will_MD follow_VB their_PP$ own_AP course_NN ._. D12 149 ^ some_DTI of_IN the_ATI true_JJ seed_NN will_MD miss_VB the_ATI D12 149 glory_NN of_IN the_ATI millennial_JJ kingdom_NN D12 150 and_CC other_AP spheres_NNS of_IN blessing_NN ,_, and_CC will_MD D12 150 not_XNOT emerge_VB until_CS the_ATI great_JJ D12 151 white_JJ throne_NN is_BEZ set_VBN up_RP ,_, but_CC even_RB there_RN ,_, D12 151 it_PP3 is_BEZ revealed_VBN that_CS some_DTI will_MD D12 152 be_BE found_VBN written_VBN ,_, and_CC pass_VB on_RP into_IN life_NN D12 152 that_WPR is_BEZ life_NN indeed_RB ._. D12 153 ^ a_AT prayerful_JJ reading_NN of_IN psalm_NN 139_CD would_MD be_BE D12 153 extremely_RB helpful_JJ at_IN D12 154 this_DT point_NN ,_, of_IN which_WDTR the_ATI following_NN is_BEZ a_AT D12 154 quotation_NN :_: D12 156 ^ *'_*' my_PP$ substance_NN was_BEDZ not_XNOT hid_VBN from_IN D12 156 thee_PP2 ,_, when_WRB I_PP1A was_BEDZ made_VBN in_IN D12 157 secret_NN ,_, and_CC curiously_RB wrought_VBN in_IN the_ATI lower_JJR D12 157 parts_NNS of_IN the_ATI earth_NN ._. D12 158 ^ *'_*' thine_PP$ eyes_NNS did_DOD see_VB my_PP$ substance_NN ,_, D12 158 yet_RB being_BEG unperfect_JJ ;_; and_CC D12 159 in_IN thy_PP$ book_NN all_ABN my_PP$ members_NNS were_BED written_VBN D12 159 ,_, which_WDTR in_IN continuance_NN were_BED D12 160 fashioned_VBN when_WRB as_RB yet_RB" there_EX was_BEDZ none_PN of_IN D12 160 them_PP3OS **'_**' (_( \0Ps_NP 139_CD :_: 15,16_CD )_) ._. D12 162 ^ the_ATI conflict_NN between_IN the_ATI two_CD seeds_NNS arose_VBD D12 162 out_RP of_IN the_ATI disobedience_NN D12 163 of_IN man_NN in_IN relation_NN to_IN the_ATI knowledge_NN of_IN good_JJ D12 163 and_CC evil_JJ (_( \0Gen_NP 3_CD )_) ._. ^ when_WRB D12 164 writing_VBG to_IN the_ATI believers_NNS at_IN Rome_NP ,_, the_ATI D12 164 apostle_NN Paul_NP said_VBD concerning_IN D12 165 some_DTI that_CS ~ *'_*' by_IN good_JJ words_NNS and_CC fair_JJ D12 165 speeches_NNS they_PP3AS deceived_VBD the_ATI heart_NN D12 166 of_IN the_ATI simple_JJ **'_**' (_( \0Rom_NP 16_CD :_: 18_CD )_) ._. ^ D12 166 he_PP3A then_RN went_VBD on_RP to_TO speak_VB of_IN their_PP$ D12 167 *'_*' obedience_NN **'_**' saying_VBG that_CS he_PP3A would_MD have_HV D12 167 them_PP3OS wise_JJ unto_IN that_DT which_WDTR is_BEZ D12 168 good_JJ and_CC simple_JJ concerning_IN evil_NN ._. ^ now_RN this_DT D12 168 word_NN *'_*' simple_NC D12 169 **'_**' akeraios_&FW occurs_VBZ in_IN the_ATI proverb_NN *'_*' wise_JJ D12 169 as_IN serpents_NNS ,_, and_CC harmless_JJ D12 170 as_IN doves_NNS **'_**' (_( \0Matt_NP 10_CD :_: 16_CD )_) ,_, where_WRB D12 170 it_PP3 is_BEZ evident_JJ that_CS the_ATI simplicity_NN D12 171 inculcated_VBN by_IN the_ATI apostle_NN is_BEZ in_IN marked_JJ D12 171 contrast_NN to_IN the_ATI subtlety_NN of_IN the_ATI D12 172 serpent_NN ._. ^ these_DTS words_NNS occur_VB just_RB before_IN the_ATI D12 172 concluding_JJ section_NN which_WDTR D12 173 deals_VBZ with_IN the_ATI revelation_NN of_IN the_ATI mystery_NN D12 173 which_WDTR had_HVD been_BEN kept_VBN in_IN D12 174 silence_NN (_( \0Rom_NP 16_CD :_: 25-27_CD-CD )_) ._. ^ this_DT D12 174 mystery_NN we_PP1AS have_HV shown_VBN elsewhere_RB D12 175 refers_VBZ to_IN the_ATI relationship_NN that_WPR exists_VBZ between_IN D12 175 Adam_NP ,_, his_PP$ fall_NN and_CC his_PP$ D12 176 seed_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ therefore_RB no_ATI surprise_NN to_IN D12 176 us_PP1OS to_TO find_VB in_IN Romans_NNPS 16_CD :_: 20_CD D12 177 immediately_RB following_IN these_DTS words_NNS that_WPR remind_VB D12 177 us_PP1OS of_IN the_ATI fall_NN ,_, a_AT most_QL D12 178 definite_JJ reference_NN to_IN Genesis_NP three_CD ._. D13 2 ^ Christ_NP Church_NPL ._. D13 3 ^ Coventry_NP ._. D13 4 ^ a_AT further_JJB article_NN by_IN the_ATI vicar_NN ,_, the_ATI D13 4 \0Rev_NPT Robin_NP \0H_NP Blandford_NP ._. D13 5 ^ roughly_RB four_CD years_NNS ago_RB I_PP1A had_HVD the_ATI D13 5 privilege_NN of_IN writing_VBG for_IN D13 6 Church_NPL and_CC people_NNS the_ATI story_NN of_IN how_WRB our_PP$ D13 6 church_NN ,_, which_WDTR had_HVD been_BEN D13 7 destroyed_VBN in_IN the_ATI war_NN ,_, was_BEDZ rebuilt_VBN on_IN a_AT D13 7 new_JJ site_NN here_RN in_IN Coventry_NP ,_, D13 8 where_WRB it_PP3 was_BEDZ more_RBR needed_VBN ._. D13 9 ^ I_PP1A have_HV been_BEN asked_VBN to_TO say_VB something_PN D13 9 about_IN the_ATI subsequent_JJ life_NN and_CC D13 10 work_NN of_IN the_ATI church_NN since_IN then_RN ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ D13 10 a_AT temptation_NN to_IN any_DTI Vicar_NPT ,_, but_CC D13 11 the_ATI devil_NN sees_VBZ to_IN it_PP3 that_CS we_PP1AS are_BER D13 11 kept_VBN humble_JJ ,_, even_RB when_WRB full_JJ of_IN joy_NN D13 12 because_IN of_IN" the_ATI work_NN of_IN God_NP in_IN our_PP$ midst_NN D13 12 ._. D13 13 ^ I_PP1A outlined_VBD in_IN my_PP$ previous_JJ article_NN our_PP$ D13 13 lay_JJB workers_NNS scheme_NN ._. ^ the_ATI D13 14 parish_NN was_BEDZ divided_VBN up_RP into_IN groups_NNS of_IN fifty_CD D13 14 houses_NNS ._. ^ every_AT lay_JJB worker_NN D13 15 had_HVD the_ATI oversight_NN of_IN and_CC responsibility_NN for_IN D13 15 one_CD1 such_ABL group_NN of_IN fifty_CD D13 16 houses_NNS ._. D13 17 ^ there_EX are_BER two_CD thousand_CD houses_NNS in_IN our_PP$ D13 17 parish_NN ,_, so_CS that_DT meant_VBD forty_CD D13 18 lay_JJB workers_NNS were_BED needed_VBN ._. ^ these_DTS were_BED D13 18 forthcoming_JJ from_IN the_ATI congregation_NN D13 19 that_WPR had_HVD survived_VBN the_ATI destruction_NN of_IN the_ATI D13 19 church_NN and_CC had_HVD worshipped_VBN for_IN D13 20 fourteen_CD years_NNS in_IN a_AT small_JJ mission_NN church_NN lent_VBN D13 20 us_PP1OS by_IN the_ATI Cathedral_NPL ._. D13 21 ^ they_PP3AS were_BED all_ABN keen_JJ Christian_JNP men_NNS and_CC D13 21 women_NNS but_CC they_PP3AS consented_VBD to_TO take_VB D13 22 a_AT fourteen-week_JJB course_NN after_IN which_WDTR they_PP3AS D13 22 were_BED commissioned_VBN by_IN the_ATI D13 23 Bishop_NPT ._. D13 24 ^ we_PP1AS covered_VBD the_ATI new_JJ parish_NN ,_, calling_VBG D13 24 on_IN every_AT house_NN ,_, distributing_VBG a_AT D13 25 free_JJ magazine_NN and_CC asking_VBG particulars_NNS of_IN every_AT D13 25 household_NN for_IN a_AT card_NN D13 26 index_NN system_NN ._. ^ later_RBR another_DT visit_NN at_IN every_AT D13 26 house_NN yielded_VBD a_AT crop_NN of_IN D13 27 orders_NNS for_IN the_ATI magazine_NN resulting_VBG in_IN an_AT D13 27 overall_JJB monthly_JJ figure_NN now_RN of_IN D13 28 one_CD1 thousand_CD two_CD hundred_CD and_CC fifty_CD copies_NNS in_IN D13 28 a_AT parish_NN of_IN two_CD thousand_CD D13 29 houses_NNS (_( I_PP1A have_HV a_AT wonderful_JJ magazine_NN editor_NN D13 29 !_! )_) ._. D13 30 ^ these_DTS lay_JJB workers_NNS are_BER like_IN the_ATI veins_NNS D13 30 in_IN a_AT human_JJ body_NN ,_, they_PP3AS bring_VB D13 31 life_NN to_IN every_AT part_NN of_IN the_ATI parish_NN where_WRB D13 31 they_PP3AS gain_VB access_NN and_CC their_PP$ D13 32 regular_JJ monthly_JJ visit_NN keeps_VBZ them_PP3OS and_CC the_ATI D13 32 Vicar_NPT in_IN touch_NN with_IN all_ABN sorts_NNS D13 33 of_IN cases_NNS ,_, and_CC with_IN every_AT need_NN as_CS it_PP3 D13 33 crops_VBZ up_RP ._. D13 34 ^ what_WDT of_IN the_ATI work_NN of_IN the_ATI Church_NPL ?_? ^ D13 34 I_PP1A think_VB it_PP3 is_BEZ only_RB fair_JJ to_IN D13 35 ourselves_PPLS to_TO say_VB here_RN that_CS ,_, as_CS our_PP$ parish_NN D13 35 was_BEDZ formed_VBN by_IN areas_NNS taken_VBN D13 36 out_RP of_IN two_CD other_AP parishes_NNS ,_, most_AP of_IN those_DTS D13 36 people_NNS who_WPR were_BED likely_JJ to_TO D13 37 attend_VB a_AT place_NN of_IN worship_NN were_BED already_RB doing_VBG D13 37 so_PN ,_, and_CC unless_CS some_DTI D13 38 reason_NN existed_VBD for_IN their_PP$ changing_VBG we_PP1AS had_HVD D13 38 only_RB the_ATI sub-soil_NN to_TO work_VB on_IN ._. D13 39 ^ there_EX was_BEDZ also_RB a_AT live_JJ baptist_NN Church_NPL D13 39 within_IN the_ATI parish_NN ._. D13 40 ^ beginning_VBG with_IN the_ATI Sunday_NR congregations_NNS we_PP1AS D13 40 worshipped_VBD for_IN two_CD D13 41 years_NNS in_IN the_ATI new_JJ Church_NPL Hall_NPL while_CS the_ATI D13 41 new_JJ Church_NPL was_BEDZ being_BEG built_VBN ._. D13 42 ^ the_ATI hall_NN ,_, seating_VBG about_RB 100_CD (_( when_WRB set_VBN D13 42 out_RP as_IN a_AT church_NN with_IN choir_NN D13 43 stalls_NNS )_) ,_, was_BEDZ generally_RB nearly_RB full_JJ ,_, but_CC D13 43 I_PP1A rather_RB dreaded_VBD the_ATI day_NN when_WRB D13 44 that_DT number_NN had_HVD to_TO sit_VB in_IN the_ATI church_NN ,_, D13 44 the_ATI body_NN of_IN which_WDTR holds_VBZ three_CD D13 45 hundred_CD and_CC thirty_CD ._. ^ that_DT day_NN came_VBD after_IN D13 45 two_CD years_NNS and_CC now_RN ,_, after_IN D13 46 worshipping_VBG in_IN it_PP3 for_IN a_AT further_JJB two_CD years_NNS D13 46 ,_, we_PP1AS have_HV a_AT morning_NN D13 47 congregation_NN of_IN about_RB one_CD1 hundred_CD and_CC fifty_CD D13 47 including_IN the_ATI *'_*' children's_NNS$ D13 48 church_NN **'_**' which_WDTR leaves_VBZ during_IN the_ATI service_NN D13 48 ,_, and_CC an_AT evening_NN congregation_NN D13 49 of_IN about_RB two_CD hundred_CD ._. ^ this_DT evening_NN D13 49 congregation_NN contains_VBZ a_AT high_JJ D13 50 percentage_NN of_IN young_JJ people_NNS and_CC is_BEZ a_AT very_QL D13 50 cheering_JJ sight_NN ._. ^ there_EX is_BEZ D13 51 hymn-singing_NN for_IN young_JJ people_NNS after_IN the_ATI service_NN D13 51 to_IN which_WDTR forty_CD or_CC D13 52 fifty_CD stay_VB ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ carefully_RB planned_VBN with_IN D13 52 some_DTI special_JJ item_NN every_AT D13 53 Sunday_NR and_CC organized_VBN by_IN two_CD young_JJ day_NN School_NPL D13 53 teachers_NNS in_IN turn_NN ._. D13 54 ^ Sunday_NR School_NPL and_CC Bible_NP classes_NNS number_VB D13 54 about_RB three_CD hundred_CD ._. D13 55 ^ every_AT available_JJ space_NN in_IN the_ATI hall_NN and_CC all_ABN D13 55 ten_CD classrooms_NNS are_BER filled_VBN D13 56 and_CC now_RN two_CD primary_JJ classes_NNS have_HV to_TO use_VB D13 56 the_ATI church_NN as_RB well_RB" ._. ^ a_AT girls'_NNS$ D13 57 Bible_NP class_NN numbers_VBZ about_RB fifty_CD and_CC divides_VBZ D13 57 into_IN four_CD groups_NNS ._. ^ the_ATI D13 58 boys'_NNS$ Bible_NP class_NN is_BEZ not_XNOT much_AP less_AP and_CC D13 58 divides_VBZ into_IN two_CD groups_NNS ._. D13 59 ^ mid-week_NN activities_NNS ._. D13 60 ^ weekday_NN organizations_NNS form_VB an_AT important_JJ part_NN D13 60 of_IN the_ATI work_NN of_IN D13 61 every_AT church_NN and_CC we_PP1AS try_VB to_TO meet_VB the_ATI D13 61 needs_NNS of_IN every_AT age_NN group_NN and_CC stage_NN D13 62 of_IN Christian_JNP development_NN ._. ^ for_IN women_NNS we_PP1AS D13 62 have_HV a_AT devotional_JJ meeting_NN on_IN D13 63 Wednesday_NR afternoons_NNS and_CC a_AT women's_NNS$ guild_NN on_IN D13 63 alternate_JJ Thursday_NR D13 64 evenings_NNS ,_, and_CC the_ATI young_JJ wives'_NNS$ fellowship_NN D13 64 on_IN alternate_JJ Sunday_NR D13 65 afternoons_NNS ._. D13 66 ^ men_NNS are_BER not_XNOT numerous_JJ yet_RB in_IN our_PP$ D13 66 recently_RB formed_JJ \0C.E.M.S_NP D13 67 branch_NN but_CC we_PP1AS do_DO have_HV an_AT entirely_RB Christian_JNP D13 67 programme_NN and_CC at_IN the_ATI D13 68 moment_NN are_BER studying_VBG the_ATI 39_CD articles_NNS ._. ^ a_AT D13 68 mixed_JJ Bible_NP study_NN and_CC D13 69 discussion_NN group_NN meets_VBZ every_AT Tuesday_NR in_IN the_ATI D13 69 vicarage_NN and_CC other_AP men_NNS D13 70 attend_VB this_DT ._. ^ our_PP$ uniformed_JJ organization_NN for_IN D13 70 children_NNS is_BEZ campaigners_NNS ,_, D13 71 which_WDTR proves_VBZ very_QL effective_JJ and_CC efficient_JJ ,_, D13 71 numbers_NNS in_IN all_ABN clans_NNS D13 72 exceeding_VBG a_AT hundred_CD ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ greatly_RB to_IN D13 72 the_ATI credit_NN of_IN the_ATI Chiefs_NPTS that_CS D13 73 the_ATI elder_JJR boys_NNS and_CC girls_NNS go_VB on_RP into_IN the_ATI D13 73 craftsmen_NNS clans_NNS in_IN good_JJ D13 74 numbers_NNS ._. ^ many_AP keen_JJ Christians_NNPS have_HV emerged_VBN D13 74 from_IN this_DT organization_NN ._. D13 75 ^ teenagers_NNS of_IN both_ABX sexes_NNS are_BER also_RB provided_VBN D13 75 for_IN by_IN a_AT young_JJ people's_NNS$ D13 76 fellowship_NN with_IN an_AT attendance_NN of_IN about_RB forty_CD in_IN D13 76 term_NN time_NN and_CC fifty_CD or_CC D13 77 more_AP in_IN the_ATI vacations_NNS ._. ^ from_IN the_ATI very_QL D13 77 first_OD we_PP1AS have_HV based_VBN this_DT on_IN the_ATI D13 78 principle_NN *'_*' Christ_NP first_RB and_CC no_ATI apologies_NNS D13 78 **'_**' ._. ^ the_ATI result_NN has_HVZ been_BEN D13 79 many_AP conversions_NNS and_CC a_AT deep_JJ Christian_JNP work_NN ._. ^ D13 79 the_ATI admirably_RB D13 80 run_VBN local_JJ youth_NN for_IN Christ_NP has_HVZ been_BEN a_AT D13 80 great_JJ blessing_NN in_IN this_DT too_RB ._. D13 81 ^ for_IN recreation_NN they_PP3AS have_HV games_NNS (_( badminton_NN D13 81 ,_, table_NN tennis_NN ,_, D13 82 skittles_NNS ,_, \0etc_RB )_) on_IN all_ABN available_JJ Saturdays_NRS D13 82 ._. ^ these_DTS are_BER for_IN members_NNS D13 83 only_RB except_CS that_CS" visitors_NNS may_MD be_BE invited_VBN for_IN D13 83 three_CD occasions_NNS ._. ^ if_CS D13 84 after_IN that_DT they_PP3AS do_DO not_XNOT join_VB the_ATI young_JJ D13 84 people's_NNS$ fellowship_NN I_PP1A should_MD D13 85 have_HV to_TO tell_VB them_PP3OS that_CS it_PP3 is_BEZ a_AT D13 85 condition_NN of_IN coming_VBG ._. ^ in_IN two_CD years_NNS I_PP1A D13 86 may_MD have_HV had_HVN to_TO do_DO so_PN once_RB ._. D13 87 ^ a_AT not_XNOT overlarge_JJ but_CC very_QL much_RB alive_JJ D13 87 prayer_NN meeting_NN is_BEZ held_VBN every_AT D13 88 Friday_NR ._. D13 89 ^ in_IN the_ATI four_CD years_NNS we_PP1AS have_HV been_BEN here_RN D13 89 we_PP1AS have_HV had_HVN the_ATI great_JJ joy_NN of_IN D13 90 seeing_VBG two_CD of_IN our_PP$ young_JJ men_NNS reach_VB the_ATI D13 90 ministry_NN ,_, both_ABX of_IN them_PP3OS D13 91 outstanding_JJ men_NNS ._. ^ a_AT further_JJB two_CD are_BER in_IN D13 91 training_VBG now_RN and_CC three_CD more_AP D13 92 have_HV applied_VBN for_IN interviews_NNS with_IN \0C.A.C.T.M_NP or_CC D13 92 already_RB D13 93 attended_VBN ._. ^ at_RB least_RB" one_CD1 other_AP is_BEZ reaching_VBG D13 93 that_DT point_NN ._. D13 94 ^ at_IN a_AT recent_JJ service_NN in_IN a_AT nearby_JJB church_NN D13 94 we_PP1AS had_HVD the_ATI further_JJB joy_NN of_IN D13 95 having_HVG three_CD of_IN our_PP$ congregation_NN admitted_VBN into_IN D13 95 the_ATI order_NN of_IN lay_JJB D13 96 readers_NNS at_IN the_ATI same_AP service_NN ._. ^ these_DTS ,_, too_RB D13 96 ,_, are_BER men_NNS of_IN exceptional_JJ D13 97 calibre_NN ._. ^ this_DT brings_VBZ our_PP$ available_JJ lay_JJB D13 97 readers_NNS up_RP to_IN five_CD ._. D13 98 ^ not_XNOT all_ABN these_DTS young_JJ men_NNS have_HV been_BEN D13 98 the_ATI product_NN of_IN our_PP$ own_AP church_NN D13 99 but_CC some_DTI have_HV come_VBN from_IN outside_RP at_IN various_JJ D13 99 stages_NNS in_IN their_PP$ Christian_JNP D13 100 growth_NN and_CC have_HV made_VBN this_DT their_PP$ spiritual_JJ D13 100 home_NR ._. ^ we_PP1AS thank_VB God_NP for_IN this_DT D13 101 great_JJ gift_NN ._. D13 102 ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ also_RB something_PN for_IN which_WDTR we_PP1AS D13 102 can_MD praise_VB God_NP that_CS a_AT D13 103 congregation_NN of_IN strongly_RB evangelical_JJ tradition_NN ,_, D13 103 plus_IN one_CD1 from_IN the_ATI area_NN D13 104 where_WRB we_PP1AS now_RN are_BER ,_, have_HV merged_VBN together_RB D13 104 well_RB with_IN scarcely_RB a_AT note_NN of_IN D13 105 discord_NN ._. D13 106 ^ we_PP1AS are_BER indeed_RB privileged_JJ to_TO have_HV such_ABL D13 106 wonderful_JJ buildings_NNS ._. ^ a_AT D13 107 modern_JJ church_NN ,_, the_ATI surprise_NN and_CC admiration_NN of_IN D13 107 all_ABN who_WPR see_VB it_PP3 ,_, a_AT D13 108 beautiful_JJ hall_NN (_( hardly_RB the_ATI word_NN to_TO describe_VB D13 108 many_AP church_NN halls_NNS !_! )_) with_IN D13 109 ten_CD classrooms_NNS alongside_RI ,_, adjustable_JJ to_IN four_CD D13 109 by_IN moving_JJ screens_NNS ,_, a_AT D13 110 caretaker's_NN$ house_NN and_CC vicarage_NN ,_, all_ABN in_IN one_CD1 D13 110 short_JJ road_NN ._. ^ we_PP1AS can_MD D13 111 thankfully_RB say_VB they_PP3AS are_BER the_ATI best_JJT in_IN the_ATI D13 111 diocese_NN ,_, if_CS not_XNOT very_QL much_RB D13 112 further_RBR afield_RB ,_, and_CC a_AT great_JJ help_NN in_IN the_ATI D13 112 administration_NN of_IN the_ATI work_NN D13 113 that_WPR they_PP3AS house_VB ._. ^ dowdy_JJ buildings_NNS do_DO D13 113 not_XNOT glorify_VB God_NP nor_CC attract_VB D13 114 people_NNS to_TO come_VB ._. D13 115 ^ is_BEZ all_ABN this_DT expensive_JJ to_TO run_VB and_CC keep_VB D13 115 up_RP ?_? ^ yes_UH ,_, it_PP3 is_BEZ ._. ^ we_PP1AS D13 116 compute_VB that_CS we_PP1AS have_HV got_VBN to_TO have_HV a_AT D13 116 monthly_JJ income_NN of_IN *+170_NNU ._. ^ we_PP1AS are_BER D13 117 like_IN a_AT man_NN on_IN a_AT bicycle_NN ;_; we_PP1AS have_HV to_TO D13 117 keep_VB moving_VBG or_CC we_PP1AS can_MD not_XNOT keep_VB D13 118 going_VBG :_: a_AT challenge_NN and_CC incentive_NN to_TO maintain_VB D13 118 a_AT spiritual_JJ church_NN life_NN ._. D13 119 ^ from_IN the_ATI warden_NN of_IN Mabledon_NP ._. D13 120 ^ glancing_VBG over_RP the_ATI past_JJB year_NN ,_, one_CD1 is_BEZ D13 120 impressed_VBN by_IN the_ATI wide_JJ range_NN D13 121 of_IN Christian_JNP interests_NNS represented_VBN by_IN those_DTS D13 121 coming_VBG to_TO stay_VB for_IN longer_JJR D13 122 or_CC shorter_JJR periods_NNS ._. ^ there_EX have_HV been_BEN D13 122 houseparties_NNS for_IN the_ATI training_NN and_CC D13 123 building-up_NN of_IN young_JJ Christians_NNPS in_IN the_ATI service_NN D13 123 of_IN Christ_NP :_: missionary_JJ D13 124 societies_NNS have_HV brought_VBN their_PP$ home_NR staffs_NNS or_CC D13 124 council_NN members_NNS for_IN D13 125 fellowship_NN in_IN prayer_NN and_CC for_IN the_ATI discussion_NN of_IN D13 125 mutual_JJ problems_NNS and_CC D13 126 opportunities_NNS :_: parishes_NNS have_HV allowed_VBN themselves_PPLS D13 126 to_TO be_BE bereft_VBN of_IN clergy_NNS D13 127 and_CC some_DTI of_IN the_ATI Sunday_NR congregation_NN in_CS order_CS" D13 127 that_CS" a_AT quiet_JJ parish_NN D13 128 weekend_NN might_MD be_BE spent_VBN away_RP from_IN the_ATI usual_JJ D13 128 routine_NN ._. ^ one_CD1 such_ABL group_NN D13 129 recently_RB brought_VBN whole_JJ families_NNS *-_*- father_NN ,_, D13 129 mother_NN ,_, and_CC children_NNS ._. D13 130 ^ two_CD mission_NN fields_NNS ._. D13 132 ^ *'_*' a_AT house-going_JJ parson_NN makes_VBZ a_AT church-going_JJ D13 132 people_NN **'_**' *-_*- so_PN D13 133 I_PP1A learned_VBD at_IN college_NN ,_, and_CC I_PP1A believed_VBD D13 133 it_PP3 was_BEDZ a_AT \0C.P-A.S_NP D13 134 slogan_NN ._. ^ I_PP1A was_BEDZ convinced_VBN it_PP3 was_BEDZ true_JJ D13 134 ,_, and_CC travelling_VBG home_NR from_IN D13 135 central_JJ Africa_NP eight_CD years_NNS ago_RB to_TO work_VB in_IN a_AT D13 135 Liverpool_NP parish_NN I_PP1A D13 136 resolved_VBD that_CS house_NN visiting_NN would_MD have_HV priority_NN D13 136 ._. ^ I_PP1A was_BEDZ also_RB D13 137 convinced_VBN people_NNS were_BED hungry_JJ for_IN the_ATI word_NN D13 137 of_IN God_NP *-_*- ^ *'_*' preach_VB the_ATI D13 138 gospel_NN and_CC you_PP2 will_MD fill_VB the_ATI church_NN **'_**' ._. ^ D13 138 by_IN the_ATI grace_NN of_IN God_NP and_CC his_PP$ D13 139 good_JJ hand_NN upon_IN me_PP1O ,_, for_IN seven_CD and_CC a_AT D13 139 half_ABN years_NNS I_PP1A have_HV acted_VBN on_IN these_DTS D13 140 convictions_NNS only_RB to_TO find_VB that_CS neither_DTX seems_VBZ D13 140 to_TO apply_VB in_IN this_DT part_NN of_IN D13 141 the_ATI mission_NN field_NN ._. ^ nevertheless_RB visiting_VBG and_CC D13 141 the_ATI scripture_NN message_NN D13 142 will_MD always_RB be_BE my_PP$ priorities_NNS ,_, but_CC let_VB D13 142 ordinands_NNS and_CC young_JJ clergy_NNS be_BE D13 143 saved_VBN from_IN false_JJ optimism_NN !_! ^ whilst_CS not_XNOT D13 143 regretting_VBG acting_VBG on_IN a_AT false_JJ D13 144 assumption_NN ,_, I_PP1A wonder_VB why_WRB there_EX is_BEZ such_ABL D13 144 a_AT small_JJ response_NN in_IN this_DT part_NN D13 145 of_IN Liverpool_NP to_IN the_ATI same_AP gospel_NN which_WDTR D13 145 brought_VBD Africans_NNPS flocking_VBG to_IN our_PP$ D13 146 mission_NN churches_NNS and_CC preaching_NN places_NNS ,_, not_XNOT D13 146 only_RB to_TO hear_VB but_CC to_TO D13 147 receive_VB ?_? ^ some_DTI say_VB it_PP3 is_BEZ because_CS Africa_NP D13 147 was_BEDZ pre-Christian_JNP ,_, whereas_CS D13 148 Liverpool_NP is_BEZ post-Christian_JNP ._. ^ *'_*' all_ABN have_HV D13 148 sinned_VBN and_CC come_VBN short_RB of_IN the_ATI D13 149 glory_NN of_IN God_NP **'_**' *-_*- it_PP3 was_BEDZ generally_RB D13 149 unnecessary_JJ to_TO persuade_VB Africans_NNPS of_IN D13 150 this_DT truth_NN ,_, they_PP3AS were_BED only_RB too_QL conscious_JJ D13 150 of_IN their_PP$ need_NN ._. ^ in_IN twenty-two_CD D13 151 years_NNS I_PP1A never_RB heard_VBD one_CD1 claim_VB to_TO be_BE as_QL D13 151 good_JJ as_IN ,_, or_CC better_JJR than_IN ,_, his_PP$ D13 152 neighbours_NNS ._. ^ I_PP1A hesitate_VB to_TO say_VB my_PP$ D13 152 parishioners_NNS are_BER not_XNOT conscious_JJ D13 153 of_IN sin_NN ,_, but_CC generally_RB they_PP3AS are_BER satisfied_JJ D13 153 to_TO be_BE better_JJR than_IN their_PP$ D13 154 neighbours_NNS (_( or_CC to_TO think_VB they_PP3AS are_BER !_! )_) ^ D13 154 they_PP3AS are_BER not_XNOT conscious_JJ of_IN a_AT D13 155 need_NN for_IN the_ATI saviour_NN ,_, and_CC never_RB flock_VB to_IN D13 155 church_NN ._. ^ I_PP1A would_MD readily_RB D13 156 agree_VB that_CS our_PP$ African_JNP brethren_NNS had_HVD not_XNOT D13 156 such_ABL counter-attractions_NNS as_IN D13 157 the_ATI week-end_NN caravan_NN ,_, the_ATI car_NN ,_, amusements_NNS D13 157 ,_, \0T.V_NN ,_, and_CC Sunday_NR work_NN D13 158 at_IN double_JJ pay_NN ,_, but_CC to_IN them_PP3OS the_ATI village_NN D13 158 dances_NNS ,_, beer_NN orgies_NNS ,_, and_CC D13 159 cultivation_NN (_( by_IN which_WDTR they_PP3AS lived_VBD )_) were_BED D13 159 just_RB as_QL important_JJ ._. D13 160 ^ some_DTI contrasts_NNS might_MD enable_VB us_PP1OS to_TO draw_VB D13 160 a_AT conclusion_NN ._. D13 161 ^ revealing_JJ contrasts_NNS ._. D13 162 ^ our_PP$ African_JNP village_NN teachers_NNS were_BED primarily_RB D13 162 evangelists_NNS and_CC D13 163 through_IN their_PP$ ministry_NN *'_*' enquirers_NNS **'_**' into_IN D13 163 the_ATI Christian_JNP faith_NN were_BED D13 164 enrolled_VBN and_CC instructed_VBN ._. ^ those_DTS determined_JJ to_TO D13 164 go_VB forward_RB for_IN baptism_NN D13 165 were_BED admitted_VBN to_IN the_ATI *'_*' catechumenate_NN **'_**' ._. ^ D13 165 a_AT minimum_NN of_IN two_CD years_NNS was_BEDZ D13 166 considered_VBN necessary_JJ for_IN regular_JJ instruction_NN and_CC D13 166 testing_NN before_CS D13 167 candidates_NNS were_BED accepted_VBN into_IN a_AT baptism_NN class_NN D13 167 ._. ^ the_ATI pastor_NN had_HVD to_TO be_BE D13 168 satisfied_VBN (_( as_QL far_RB as_CS he_PP3A was_BEDZ able_JJ )_) D13 168 that_CS each_DT was_BEDZ a_AT born-again_JJB D13 169 Christian_NNP ._. ^ whether_CS the_ATI baptism_NN took_VBD place_NN D13 169 in_IN the_ATI river_NN ,_, or_CC in_IN the_ATI D13 170 Church_NPL ,_, it_PP3 truly_RB symbolized_VBD the_ATI sinner_NN D13 170 being_BEG buried_VBN with_IN Christ_NP ,_, and_CC D13 171 raised_VBN with_IN him_PP3O to_IN newness_NN of_IN life_NN ._. ^ D13 171 every_AT baptized_JJ person_NN knew_VBD indeed_RB D13 172 that_CS the_ATI washing_NN of_IN water_NN was_BEDZ the_ATI outward_JJB D13 172 sign_NN of_IN the_ATI cleansing_NN from_IN D13 173 sin_NN within_RI ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ sad_JJ to_TO recollect_VB that_CS D13 173 probably_RB less_AP than_IN ten_CD per_NNU D13 174 cent_NNU" of_IN the_ATI original_JJ enquirers_NNS were_BED baptized_VBN D13 174 *-_*- but_CC the_ATI general_JJ leakage_NN D13 175 from_IN the_ATI Church_NPL was_BEDZ before_IN baptism_NN ._. ^ when_WRB D13 175 I_PP1A came_VBD to_IN \0St_NPT Bede's_NP$ D13 176 it_PP3 was_BEDZ a_AT shock_NN to_TO find_VB the_ATI normal_JJ D13 176 request_NN for_IN baptism_NN was_BEDZ ^ *'_*' Mum_NPT says_VBZ D13 177 will_MD you_PP2 do_DO the_ATI baby_NN next_AP Sunday_NR **'_**' ._. ^ D13 177 my_PP$ insistence_NN on_IN personal_JJ D13 178 interviews_NNS with_IN the_ATI parents_NNS and_CC their_PP$ presence_NN D13 178 at_IN the_ATI baptism_NN D13 179 frequently_RB meant_VBD they_PP3AS just_RB went_VBD elsewhere_RB to_TO D13 179 have_HV their_PP$ babies_NNS D13 180 *'_*' done_VBN **'_**' ._. ^ I_PP1A was_BEDZ equally_RB shocked_JJ D13 180 to_TO find_VB the_ATI congregation_NN objecting_VBG D13 181 to_IN baptisms_NNS during_IN morning_NN prayer_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 has_HVZ D13 181 been_BEN a_AT long_JJ hard_JJ struggle_NN D13 182 to_TO make_VB this_DT the_ATI norm_NN ,_, and_CC for_IN parents_NNS D13 182 and_CC godparents_NNS to_TO realize_VB it_PP3 is_BEZ D13 183 such_ABL an_AT important_JJ event_NN ,_, and_CC that_CS very_QL D13 183 particular_JJ preparation_NN is_BEZ D13 184 needed_VBN ._. ^ now_RN ,_, the_ATI whole_JJ congregation_NN will_MD D13 184 say_VB together_RB in_IN sincerity_NN D13 185 ~ *'_*' we_PP1AS receive_VB this_DT child_NN into_IN the_ATI D13 185 congregation_NN of_IN Christ's_NP$ D13 186 flock_NN ..._... **'_**' ,_, and_CC usually_RB parents_NNS are_BER D13 186 appreciative_JJ of_IN our_PP$ methods_NNS ._. D13 187 ^ they_PP3AS are_BER visited_VBN at_RB least_RB" twice_RB before_IN D13 187 the_ATI baptism_NN and_CC monthly_RB for_IN as_QL D13 188 long_RB as_CS possible_JJ ._. ^ even_RB so_RB it_PP3 does_DOZ not_XNOT D13 188 bring_VB them_PP3OS to_IN Church_NPL *-_*- we_PP1AS still_RB D13 189 have_HV a_AT long_JJ way_NN to_TO go_VB to_TO reach_VB our_PP$ D13 189 African_JNP Church_NPL standard_NN ._. D14 2 ^ a_AT defence_NN of_IN the_ATI true_JJ faith_NN ._. D14 3 ^ by_IN Brother_NPT Roberts_NP ._. D14 4 ^ \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP reproduces_VBZ the_ATI argument_NN of_IN D14 4 personal_JJ identity_NN D14 5 amid_IN atomic_JJ change_NN ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ sufficiently_RB D14 5 answered_VBN on_IN page_NN 34_CD of_IN D14 6 twelve_CD lectures_NNS ._. ^ a_AT remark_NN or_CC two_CD ,_, however_RB D14 6 ,_, is_BEZ called_VBN for_IN here_RN ._. D14 7 ^ he_PP3A bases_VBZ the_ATI argument_NN on_IN a_AT fallacy_NN to_TO D14 7 begin_VB with_RI ._. ^ he_PP3A says_VBZ that_CS D14 8 during_IN the_ATI change_NN of_IN a_AT man's_NN$ substance_NN from_IN D14 8 waste_NN and_CC nutrition_NN ,_, D14 9 *'_*' his_PP$ personality_NN undergoes_VBZ no_ATI corresponding_JJ D14 9 change_NN ._. **'_**' ^ this_DT is_BEZ D14 10 not_XNOT true_JJ ._. ^ a_AT man_NN of_IN forty_CD feels_VBZ himself_PPL D14 10 a_AT very_QL different_JJ person_NN from_IN D14 11 what_WDT he_PP3A was_BEDZ at_IN ten_CD ._. ^ an_AT entire_JJB change_NN D14 11 in_IN the_ATI nature_NN of_IN his_PP$ D14 12 consciousness_NN takes_VBZ place_NN in_IN the_ATI interval_NN ._. ^ D14 12 it_PP3 is_BEZ a_AT matter_NN of_IN D14 13 universal_JJ experience_NN ,_, that_CS as_CS years_NNS roll_VB by_RP D14 13 ,_, the_ATI ideas_NNS change_VB ,_, the_ATI D14 14 tastes_NNS change_VB ,_, the_ATI character_NN changes_VBZ ,_, the_ATI D14 14 voice_NN changes_VBZ ,_, the_ATI personal_JJ D14 15 physique_NN changes_VBZ *-_*- everything_PN changes_VBZ ;_; and_CC D14 15 the_ATI nature_NN of_IN these_DTS changes_NNS D14 16 depends_VBZ upon_IN circumstances_NNS ._. ^ why_WRB ?_? ^ because_CS D14 16 the_ATI new_JJ material_NN introduced_VBN D14 17 into_IN the_ATI system_NN in_IN the_ATI process_NN of_IN nutrition_NN D14 17 ,_, is_BEZ directed_VBN into_IN new_JJ D14 18 shapes_NNS and_CC forms_NNS ,_, according_IN to_IN" the_ATI D14 18 activities_NNS by_IN which_WDTR its_PP$ absorption_NN D14 19 is_BEZ guided_VBN and_CC determined_VBN ._. ^ if_CS a_AT man_NN D14 19 goes_VBZ to_IN sea_NN ,_, his_PP$ muscles_NNS and_CC vital_JJ D14 20 organs_NNS ,_, and_CC the_ATI bony_JJ framework_NN are_BER in_IN D14 20 continual_JJ occupation_NN ,_, and_CC the_ATI D14 21 nutritive_JJ elements_NNS are_BER consequently_RB more_QL largely_RB D14 21 made_VBN use_NN of_IN ,_, in_IN D14 22 building_VBG up_RP the_ATI mechanical_JJ parts_NNS of_IN his_PP$ D14 22 being_NN ,_, than_CS if_CS he_PP3A stayed_VBD at_IN D14 23 home_NR ._. ^ send_VB him_PP3O to_IN college_NN ,_, and_CC you_PP2 D14 23 will_MD see_VB a_AT different_JJ result_NN ._. D14 24 ^ activity_NN of_IN brain_NN is_BEZ brought_VBN into_IN play_NN ,_, D14 24 to_IN the_ATI neglect_NN of_IN the_ATI bodily_JJ D14 25 functions_NNS ;_; and_CC the_ATI consequence_NN is_BEZ ,_, the_ATI D14 25 brain_NN monopolises_VBZ the_ATI nutritive_JJ D14 26 supply_NN ,_, and_CC is_BEZ developed_VBN to_IN the_ATI detriment_NN D14 26 of_IN the_ATI merely_RB physical_JJ D14 27 powers_NNS ,_, the_ATI result_NN of_IN which_WDTR is_BEZ ,_, that_CS D14 27 the_ATI man_NN is_BEZ more_QL feeble_JJ as_IN a_AT whole_NN D14 28 than_IN his_PP$ sea-faring_JJ Brother_NPT ,_, and_CC has_HVZ his_PP$ D14 28 mind_NN very_QL differently_RB D14 29 constituted_VBN from_IN what_WDT it_PP3 would_MD have_HV been_BEN D14 29 had_HVD he_PP3A been_BEN brought_VBN up_RP at_IN the_ATI D14 30 plough_NN ._. ^ \0Mr_NPT Barnett's_NP$ assumption_NN ,_, therefore_RB D14 30 ,_, that_CS the_ATI personality_NN D14 31 undergoes_VBZ no_ATI change_NN with_IN the_ATI progress_NN of_IN D14 31 material_JJ substitution_NN ,_, is_BEZ D14 32 wrong_JJ ._. ^ it_PP3 undergoes_VBZ many_AP changes_NNS ,_, but_CC D14 32 of_RB course_RB" he_PP3A feels_VBZ himself_PPL the_ATI D14 33 same_AP individual_NN ,_, because_CS the_ATI impressions_NNS D14 33 originally_RB constituting_VBG his_PP$ D14 34 individuality_NN are_BER perpetuated_VBN ,_, though_CS modified_VBN ._. D14 34 ^ but_CC let_VB a_AT *'_*' stroke_NN D14 35 **'_**' affect_VB the_ATI brain_NN throughout_RI ,_, and_CC D14 35 obliterate_VB original_JJ impressions_NNS (_( of_IN D14 36 which_WDTR there_EX have_HV been_BEN cases_NNS )_) ,_, the_ATI D14 36 person's_NN$ individuality_NN vanishes_VBZ ._. ^ he_PP3A D14 37 forgets_VBZ who_WP he_PP3A was_BEDZ ,_, and_CC what_WDT he_PP3A D14 37 knew_VBD ,_, and_CC begins_VBZ the_ATI formation_NN of_IN a_AT D14 38 new_JJ individuality_NN by_IN means_IN" of_IN" new_JJ impressions_NNS D14 38 ,_, should_MD his_PP$ power_NN to_TO D14 39 receive_VB new_JJ impressions_NNS not_XNOT have_HV been_BEN D14 39 destroyed_VBN by_IN the_ATI calamity_NN ._. ^ a_AT D14 40 case_NN of_IN this_DT sort_NN is_BEZ within_IN the_ATI writer's_NN$ D14 40 experience_NN ,_, where_WRB there_EX was_BEDZ a_AT D14 41 complete_JJ lapse_NN of_IN memory_NN ,_, necessitating_VBG the_ATI D14 41 re-formation_NN of_IN D14 42 acquaintance_NN with_IN friends_NNS ,_, places_NNS ,_, habits_NNS D14 42 and_CC everything_PN ._. ^ after_IN a_AT D14 43 while_NN ,_, the_ATI second_OD education_NN as_QL quickly_RB D14 43 disappeared_VBD as_IN the_ATI first_OD ,_, and_CC D14 44 the_ATI old_JJ memories_NNS returned_VBN ._. ^ on_IN \0Mr_NPT D14 44 Barnett's_NP$ theory_NN ,_, this_DT was_BEDZ D14 45 inexplicable_JJ ._. ^ on_IN the_ATI theory_NN that_CS the_ATI brain_NN D14 45 *'_*' thinks_VBZ by_IN virtue_NN of_IN its_PP$ D14 46 organization_NN ,_, **'_**' it_PP3 is_BEZ susceptible_JJ of_IN D14 46 explanation_NN ._. D14 47 ^ \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP denies_VBZ the_ATI transmissibility_NN of_IN D14 47 qualities_NNS ._. ^ he_PP3A feels_VBZ D14 48 himself_PPL compelled_VBN to_TO do_DO this_DT ,_, to_TO save_VB his_PP$ D14 48 argument_NN on_IN continuous_JJ D14 49 identity_NN ;_; but_CC in_IN yielding_VBG to_IN theoretical_JJ D14 49 exigency_NN ,_, he_PP3A convicts_VBZ himself_PPL D14 50 of_IN either_DTX ignorance_NN or_CC recklessness_NN ._. ^ the_ATI D14 50 very_AP argument_NN he_PP3A relies_VBZ upon_IN D14 51 disproves_VBZ his_PP$ denial_NN ._. ^ he_PP3A says_VBZ the_ATI body_NN D14 51 *'_*' changes_VBZ throughout_RI several_AP D14 52 times_NNS in_IN a_AT man's_NN$ life_NN ,_, and_CC at_IN seventy_CD D14 52 does_DOZ not_XNOT contain_VB a_AT single_JJ D14 53 particle_NN of_IN the_ATI matter_NN which_WDTR composed_VBD it_PP3 D14 53 at_IN seven_CD ._. **'_**' ^ now_RN ,_, in_IN view_NN D14 54 of_IN this_DT ,_, how_WRB does_DOZ \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP deal_VB with_IN D14 54 the_ATI fact_NN that_CS a_AT person_NN of_IN D14 55 dark_JJ complexion_NN ,_, eating_VBG the_ATI same_AP food_NN as_IN a_AT D14 55 person_NN of_IN light_JJ D14 56 complexion_NN ,_, will_MD be_BE dark_JJ complexioned_JJ till_IN D14 56 death_NN ?_? ^ take_VB the_ATI colour_NN D14 57 of_IN the_ATI eye_NN and_CC the_ATI colour_NN of_IN the_ATI hair_NN ;_; D14 57 how_WRB does_DOZ he_PP3A account_VB for_IN the_ATI D14 58 permanence_NN of_IN these_DTS organic_JJ qualities_NNS ,_, except_CS D14 58 that_CS" the_ATI original_JJ D14 59 quality_NN is_BEZ taken_VBN up_RP by_IN the_ATI succeeding_JJ atoms_NNS D14 59 of_IN nutrition_NN ?_? ^ \0Mr_NPT D14 60 Barnett's_NP$ answer_NN is_BEZ *'_*' they_PP3AS assume_VB similar_JJ D14 60 qualities_NNS of_IN their_PP$ own_AP ._. **'_**' D14 61 ^ do_DO they_PP3AS pick_VB up_RP nothing_PN from_IN their_PP$ D14 61 predecessors_NNS ?_? ^ if_CS they_PP3AS do_DO not_XNOT ,_, how_WRB D14 62 is_BEZ it_PP3 that_CS the_ATI same_AP flour_NN and_CC mutton_NN D14 62 eaten_VBN at_IN the_ATI same_AP table_NN will_MD turn_VB D14 63 to_IN four_CD different_JJ conditions_NNS as_IN regards_IN" colour_NN D14 63 and_CC organic_JJ quality_NN ,_, in_IN D14 64 four_CD different_JJ persons_NNS ?_? ^ is_BEZ it_PP3 not_XNOT the_ATI D14 64 existing_JJ organism_NN that_WPR D14 65 determines_VBZ the_ATI use_NN and_CC quality_NN of_IN the_ATI new_JJ D14 65 material_NN introduced_VBN ?_? and_CC how_WRB D14 66 could_MD this_DT be_BE ,_, except_CS on_IN the_ATI principle_NN of_IN D14 66 transmission_NN of_IN quality_NN ?_? D14 67 ^ \0Mr_NPT Barnett's_NP$ answer_NN to_IN this_DT ,_, finally_RB D14 67 surrenders_VBZ the_ATI whole_JJ case_NN D14 68 against_IN himself_PPL ._. ^ he_PP3A says_VBZ *'_*' they_PP3AS enter_VB D14 68 into_IN the_ATI same_AP relation_NN to_IN the_ATI D14 69 laws_NNS of_IN life_NN as_IN those_DTS which_WDTR the_ATI old_JJ D14 69 have_HV quitted_VBN ._. **'_**' ^ precisely_RB ,_, and_CC D14 70 this_DT applied_VBN to_IN the_ATI brain_NN ,_, explains_VBZ D14 70 continuous_JJ identity_NN amid_IN atomic_JJ D14 71 change_NN ._. ^ whatever_WDT impressions_NNS or_CC qualities_NNS D14 71 result_VB from_IN the_ATI original_JJ D14 72 organization_NN of_IN the_ATI brain_NN ,_, are_BER inherited_VBN by_IN D14 72 the_ATI new_JJ material_NN ,_, taken_VBN up_RP D14 73 by_IN them_PP3OS ,_, transmitted_VBN to_IN successors_NNS and_RB so_RB" D14 73 on_RB" ad_&FW infinitum_&FW ._. D14 74 ^ but_CC destroy_VB the_ATI brain_NN altogether_RB ,_, and_CC you_PP2 D14 74 destroy_VB the_ATI process_NN as_QL D14 75 much_RB as_CS you_PP2 destroy_VB the_ATI sight_NN of_IN the_ATI eye_NN D14 75 and_CC the_ATI hearing_NN of_IN the_ATI ear_NN ._. D14 76 ^ \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP can_MD *'_*' detect_VB nothing_PN but_IN D14 76 unintelligible_JJ nonsense_NN D14 77 **'_**' in_IN the_ATI proposition_NN that_CS *'_*' mind_NN is_BEZ D14 77 the_ATI product_NN of_IN the_ATI living_JJ brain_NN ,_, and_CC D14 78 personal_JJ identity_NN the_ATI sum_NN of_IN its_PP$ impressions_NNS D14 78 ._. **'_**' ^ his_PP$ objection_NN to_IN it_PP3 D14 79 is_BEZ that_CS if_CS mind_NN be_BE the_ATI product_NN of_IN the_ATI D14 79 brain_NN ,_, it_PP3 would_MD be_BE subject_JJ like_IN D14 80 the_ATI brain_NN to_IN the_ATI law_NN of_IN atomic_JJ change_NN ._. ^ D14 80 and_CC so_PN it_PP3 is_BEZ ,_, as_CS \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP D14 81 will_MD discover_VB ,_, if_CS he_PP3A reflects_VBZ but_RI a_AT D14 81 moment_NN ._. ^ is_BEZ it_PP3 not_XNOT a_AT fact_NN ,_, that_CS D14 82 unless_CS we_PP1AS renew_VB our_PP$ knowledge_NN ,_, the_ATI lapse_NN D14 82 of_IN time_NN will_MD weaken_VB and_CC in_IN D14 83 the_ATI end_NN destroy_VB it_PP3 ?_? ^ is_BEZ there_EX no_ATI such_ABL D14 83 thing_NN as_IN *'_*' getting_VBG out_RP of_IN D14 84 use_NN ,_, **'_**' and_CC forgetting_VBG what_WDT one_CD1 has_HVZ D14 84 learnt_VBN ?_? ^ the_ATI very_AP power_NN of_IN D14 85 education_NN lies_VBZ in_IN the_ATI fact_NN that_CS \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP D14 85 denies_VBZ ,_, \0viz_RB ,_, that_CS the_ATI D14 86 mind_NN is_BEZ *'_*' subject_JJ to_IN the_ATI law_NN of_IN atomic_JJ D14 86 change_NN ,_, **'_**' and_CC depends_VBZ for_IN the_ATI D14 87 form_NN of_IN its_PP$ development_NN upon_IN the_ATI forces_NNS D14 87 brought_VBN to_TO bear_VB in_IN its_PP$ D14 88 guidance_NN ._. D14 89 ^ \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP struggles_VBZ in_RB vain_RB" against_IN D14 89 the_ATI proposition_NN that_CS if_CS D14 90 the_ATI mind_NN be_BE immaterial_JJ ,_, its_PP$ functions_NNS ought_MD D14 90 to_TO be_BE unaffected_JJ by_IN the_ATI D14 91 condition_NN of_IN the_ATI body_NN ._. ^ he_PP3A suggests_VBZ that_CS D14 91 it_PP3 is_BEZ associated_VBN with_IN the_ATI D14 92 material_JJ elements_NNS of_IN his_PP$ being_NN on_IN the_ATI common_JJ D14 92 basis_NN of_IN life_NN ,_, which_WDTR D14 93 unites_VBZ and_CC affinitises_VBZ all_ABN parts_NNS ._. ^ animal_JJ D14 93 and_CC vegetable_JJ substances_NNS are_BER D14 94 amalgamated_VBN on_IN this_DT basis_NN ,_, and_CC why_WRB not_XNOT a_AT D14 94 third_OD ,_, argues_VBZ \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP *-_*- D14 95 the_ATI immaterial_JJ and_CC immortal_JJ ?_? ^ the_ATI answer_NN is_BEZ D14 95 ,_, nothing_PN is_BEZ impossible_JJ ;_; D14 96 but_CC if_CS this_DT is_BEZ the_ATI principle_NN on_IN which_WDTR D14 96 the_ATI mind_NN is_BEZ developed_VBN in_IN the_ATI D14 97 body_NN ,_, obviously_RB the_ATI inversion_NN of_IN the_ATI D14 97 principle_NN must_MD be_BE fatal_JJ to_IN it_PP3 ._. D14 98 ^ if_CS life_NN gives_VBZ ,_, death_NN must_MD take_VB away_RP ._. ^ D14 98 when_WRB *'_*' the_ATI principle_NN of_IN life_NN D14 99 **'_**' is_BEZ withdrawn_VBN ,_, the_ATI *'_*' animal_JJ and_CC D14 99 vegetable_JJ **'_**' elements_NNS of_IN man's_NN$ being_BEG D14 100 are_BER destroyed_VBN ,_, and_CC any_DTI third_OD element_NN D14 100 depending_VBG upon_IN *'_*' the_ATI principle_NN of_IN D14 101 life_NN **'_**' for_IN its_PP$ basis_NN ,_, must_MD perish_VB also_RB D14 101 ._. ^ \0Mr_NPT Barnett's_NP$ argument_NN D14 102 recoils_VBZ upon_IN himself_PPL ._. ^ to_TO evade_VB the_ATI recoil_NN D14 102 ,_, he_PP3A dogmatises_VBZ on_IN *'_*' the_ATI D14 103 principle_NN of_IN life_NN ._. **'_**' ^ he_PP3A says_VBZ life_NN D14 103 is_BEZ not_XNOT the_ATI result_NN of_IN D14 104 organisation_NN ,_, but_CC a_AT principle_NN that_WPR operates_VBZ D14 104 through_IN organisation_NN ._. D14 105 ^ upon_IN this_DT ,_, we_PP1AS have_HV to_TO ask_VB if_CS the_ATI D14 105 life_NN of_IN a_AT dog_NN is_BEZ not_XNOT in_IN the_ATI same_AP D14 106 category_NN ?_? ^ \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP can_MD not_XNOT exclude_VB it_PP3 D14 106 ._. ^ a_AT dog_NN is_BEZ as_QL much_RB God's_NP$ D14 107 handiwork_NN as_IN a_AT man_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 depends_VBZ upon_IN the_ATI D14 107 same_AP laws_NNS of_IN respiration_NN and_CC D14 108 deglutition_NN as_IN those_DTS which_WDTR govern_VB human_JJ D14 108 existence_NN ._. ^ the_ATI Bible_NP says_VBZ men_NNS D14 109 and_CC beasts_NNS are_BER identical_JJ in_IN the_ATI mode_NN of_IN D14 109 life_NN and_CC death_NN (_( \0Eccles_NP 3_CD ._. D14 110 19-20_CD-CD )_) ._. ^ what_WDT then_RN would_MD \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP D14 110 do_DO with_IN his_PP$ definition_NN as_CS D14 111 applied_VBN to_IN a_AT dog_NN ?_? ^ *'_*' life_NN is_BEZ not_XNOT D14 111 the_ATI result_NN of_IN organization_NN :_: D14 112 organization_NN is_BEZ the_ATI medium_NN through_IN which_WDTR life_NN D14 112 is_BEZ manifested_VBN ._. **'_**' ^ has_HVZ D14 113 the_ATI dog_NN an_AT immortal_JJ principle_NN of_IN life_NN that_WPR D14 113 was_BEDZ antecedent_JJ to_IN its_PP$ D14 114 organization_NN ,_, and_CC which_WDTR only_RB manifests_VBZ itself_PPL D14 114 through_IN its_PP$ doggish_JJ D14 115 body_NN ?_? ^ if_CS so_PN ,_, whose_WP$ principle_NN of_IN life_NN D14 115 was_BEDZ it_PP3 before_CS the_ATI dog_NN came_VBD ?_? ^ was_BEDZ D14 116 it_PP3 the_ATI dog's_NN$ ?_? ^ if_CS \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP will_MD D14 116 admit_VB that_CS the_ATI primitive_JJ D14 117 life-power_NN in_IN all_ABN cases_NNS is_BEZ God's_NP$ ,_, we_PP1AS D14 117 might_MD agree_VB with_IN him_PP3O ;_; but_CC in_IN D14 118 admitting_VBG this_DT ,_, he_PP3A must_MD abandon_VB the_ATI idea_NN D14 118 that_CS human_JJ lives_NNS are_BER separate_JJ D14 119 entities_NNS or_CC *'_*' souls_NNS ,_, **'_**' which_WDTR may_MD be_BE D14 119 disembodied_VBN and_CC live_VB as_IN conscious_JJ D14 120 beings_NNS still_RB ._. ^ all_ABN human_JJ life_NN ,_, and_CC all_ABN D14 120 beast_NN and_CC all_ABN insect_NN life_NN ,_, are_BER D14 121 but_RI inspirations_NNS from_IN the_ATI eternal_JJ universal_JJ D14 121 fountain_NN of_IN life_NN ,_, of_IN which_WDTR D14 122 the_ATI God_NP revealed_VBN to_IN Israel_NP is_BEZ the_ATI focal_JJ D14 122 centre_NN and_CC controller_NN ._. ^ but_CC D14 123 \0Mr_NPT Barnett's_NP$ Platonism_NNP ,_, deeply_RB tinctured_VBN D14 123 with_IN the_ATI spirit_NN of_IN Greek_JNP D14 124 mythology_NN ,_, teaching_VBG the_ATI existence_NN of_IN so_QL many_AP D14 124 separate_JJ independent_JJ D14 125 immortal_JJ intelligences_NNS ,_, prevents_VBZ him_PP3O from_IN D14 125 seeing_VBG this_DT ._. ^ he_PP3A insists_VBZ D14 126 upon_IN three_CD separable_JJ compounds_NNS as_CS constituting_VBG D14 126 the_ATI unity_NN of_IN a_AT human_JJ D14 127 being_NN ._. ^ if_CS he_PP3A would_MD define_VB them_PP3OS ,_, the_ATI D14 127 argument_NN might_MD be_BE made_VBN more_QL D14 128 serviceable_JJ ._. ^ *'_*' body_NN ,_, soul_NN and_CC spirit_NN **'_**' D14 128 are_BER his_PP$ words_NNS ,_, quoting_VBG from_IN D14 129 Paul_NP ._. ^ we_PP1AS submit_VB to_IN \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP that_CS D14 129 these_DTS words_NNS describe_VB aspects_NNS of_IN D14 130 human_JJ existence_NN only_RB while_CS a_AT man_NN is_BEZ alive_JJ ._. ^ D14 130 this_DT is_BEZ shown_VBN by_IN the_ATI D14 131 fact_NN that_CS they_PP3AS were_BED addressed_VBN to_IN and_CC D14 131 spoken_VBN of_IN living_JJ men_NNS ,_, and_CC that_CS D14 132 the_ATI three_CD aspects_NNS expressed_VBN are_BER only_RB D14 132 presented_VBN in_IN life_NN ._. ^ is_BEZ there_EX a_AT D14 133 *'_*' body_NN **'_**' when_WRB man_NN is_BEZ dissolved_VBN in_IN D14 133 the_ATI grave_NN ?_? ^ is_BEZ there_EX a_AT *'_*' soul_NN **'_**' to_IN D14 134 that_DT body_NN when_WRB all_ABN soul_NN is_BEZ evaporated_VBN ?_? ^ D14 134 is_BEZ there_EX a_AT spirit_NN to_IN it_PP3 when_WRB D14 135 it_PP3 no_RB longer_RBR exists_VBZ to_TO be_BE animated_VBN by_IN a_AT D14 135 spirit_NN ?_? ^ it_PP3 would_MD be_BE curious_JJ D14 136 to_TO know_VB what_WDT \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP understands_VBZ by_IN *'_*' D14 136 soul_NN **'_**' as_CS distinct_JJ from_IN D14 137 *'_*' spirit_NN **'_**' and_CC vice_RB versa_RB" ._. ^ from_IN a_AT D14 137 common-sense_NN point_NN of_IN D14 138 view_NN the_ATI matter_NN is_BEZ plain_JJ ._. ^ a_AT man_NN in_IN D14 138 life_NN presents_VBZ three_CD aspects_NNS D14 139 cognisant_JJ to_IN the_ATI understanding_NN ._. ^ there_EX is_BEZ (_( D14 139 1_CD1 )_) the_ATI body_NN ,_, which_WDTR is_BEZ the_ATI D14 140 basis_NN of_IN (_( 2_CD )_) the_ATI life_NN ,_, which_WDTR develops_VBZ D14 140 (_( 3_CD )_) the_ATI spirit_NN ,_, or_CC mind_NN ._. ^ a_AT dead_JJ D14 141 man_NN is_BEZ a_AT body_NN simply_RB ;_; an_AT idiot_NN is_BEZ a_AT D14 141 body_NN with_IN soul_NN or_CC life_NN ;_; a_AT living_JJ D14 142 man_NN with_IN full_JJ possession_NN of_IN mental_JJ faculties_NNS D14 142 presents_VBZ the_ATI combination_NN D14 143 of_IN *'_*' body_NN ,_, soul_NN ,_, and_CC spirit_NN ._. **'_**' ^ D14 143 when_WRB death_NN comes_VBZ ,_, it_PP3 destroys_VBZ this_DT D14 144 combination_NN ._. ^ the_ATI body_NN returns_VBZ to_IN the_ATI dust_NN D14 144 ,_, the_ATI life_NN returns_VBZ to_IN God_NP ,_, D14 145 and_CC the_ATI spirit_NN disappears_VBZ ._. ^ the_ATI resurrection_NN D14 145 will_MD put_VB all_ABN three_CD D14 146 together_RB again_RB on_IN the_ATI glorious_JJ basis_NN of_IN D14 146 incorruptibility_NN ._. D14 147 ^ \0Mr_NPT Barnett's_NP$ review_NN of_IN scripture_NN arguments_NNS D14 147 on_IN mortality_NN ._. D14 148 ^ \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP next_RB attempts_VBZ to_TO follow_VB the_ATI D14 148 scriptural_JJ D14 149 argument_NN ._. ^ he_PP3A begins_VBZ by_IN observing_VBG that_CS *'_*' D14 149 it_PP3 is_BEZ a_AT waste_NN of_IN words_NNS to_TO D14 150 argue_VB against_IN the_ATI received_JJ doctrine_NN of_IN man's_NN$ D14 150 immortality_NN ,_, as_CS if_CS" that_DT D14 151 doctrine_NN implied_VBD that_CS man_NN is_BEZ not_XNOT mortal_JJ ._. D14 151 **'_**' ^ he_PP3A illustrates_VBZ his_PP$ D14 152 meaning_NN by_IN saying_VBG that_CS the_ATI dead_JJ are_BER dead_JJ D14 152 in_IN some_DTI respects_NNS and_CC alive_JJ in_IN D14 153 others_APS ._. ^ if_CS \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP would_MD define_VB his_PP$ D14 153 terms_NNS ,_, it_PP3 would_MD be_BE easier_JJR D14 154 to_TO follow_VB him_PP3O ._. ^ what_WDT does_DOZ he_PP3A mean_VB by_IN D14 154 *'_*' death_NN ?_? **'_**' ^ has_HVZ it_PP3 no_ATI inverse_JJ D14 155 reference_NN to_IN *'_*' life_NN ?_? **'_**' ^ do_DO we_PP1AS not_XNOT D14 155 derive_VB our_PP$ idea_NN of_IN death_NN from_IN D14 156 acquaintance_NN with_IN life_NN ._. ^ life_NN is_BEZ a_AT positive_JJ D14 156 phenomenon_NN ,_, and_CC (_( in_IN D14 157 relation_NN to_IN us_PP1OS )_) has_HVZ a_AT beginning_NN ;_; and_CC D14 157 the_ATI word_NN *'_*' death_NC **'_**' has_HVZ become_VBN D14 158 current_JJ to_TO express_VB the_ATI cessation_NN of_IN that_DT D14 158 phenomenon_NN ,_, with_IN which_WDTR ,_, D14 159 unfortunately_RB ,_, we_PP1AS are_BER familiar_JJ ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ D14 159 true_JJ the_ATI word_NN is_BEZ used_VBN with_IN D14 160 reference_NN to_IN a_AT variety_NN of_IN things_NNS ,_, but_CC this_DT D14 160 only_RB arises_VBZ from_IN the_ATI fact_NN D14 161 that_CS there_EX is_BEZ a_AT variety_NN of_IN life_NN ._. ^ D14 161 vegetable_JJ life_NN gives_VBZ rise_NN to_IN its_PP$ use_NN D14 162 when_WRB a_AT plant_NN dies_VBZ ._. ^ metaphorical_JJ life_NN ,_, as_IN D14 162 the_ATI prosperity_NN of_IN an_AT D14 163 institution_NN ,_, occasions_VBZ its_PP$ use_NN ,_, when_WRB D14 163 prosperity_NN departs_VBZ and_CC the_ATI D14 164 institution_NN dies_VBZ ._. ^ to_IN whatever_WDT thing_NN it_PP3 D14 164 applies_VBZ ,_, it_PP3 expresses_VBZ the_ATI D14 165 opposite_NN of_IN the_ATI life_NN pertaining_VBG to_IN it_PP3 ,_, or_CC D14 165 that_WPR may_MD be_BE conceived_VBN as_CS D14 166 pertaining_VBG to_IN it_PP3 ._. ^ on_IN this_DT obvious_JJ and_CC D14 166 universal_JJ principle_NN ,_, the_ATI death_NN D14 167 of_IN a_AT human_JJ being_NN must_MD have_HV inverse_JJ reference_NN D14 167 to_IN the_ATI life_NN of_IN a_AT human_JJ D14 168 being_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 can_MD not_XNOT be_BE said_VBN that_CS a_AT D14 168 human_JJ being_NN is_BEZ dead_JJ ,_, unless_CS his_PP$ life_NN D14 169 as_IN a_AT human_JJ being_NN has_HVZ ceased_VBN ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ D14 169 vain_JJ ,_, therefore_RB ,_, for_IN \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP D14 170 to_TO get_VB away_RP from_IN the_ATI inconsistency_NN of_IN a_AT man_NN D14 170 being_BEG dead_JJ and_CC alive_JJ at_IN D14 171 the_ATI same_AP time_NN ._. ^ if_CS a_AT human_JJ being_NN D14 171 continues_VBZ to_TO live_VB after_IN death_NN ,_, he_PP3A is_BEZ D14 172 not_XNOT dead_JJ ._. ^ it_PP3 would_MD not_XNOT suit_VB the_ATI D14 172 theory_NN to_TO say_VB that_CS the_ATI body_NN is_BEZ dead_JJ ,_, D14 173 because_CS according_IN to_IN" the_ATI theory_NN the_ATI body_NN is_BEZ D14 173 never_RB alive_JJ ,_, but_CC only_RB D14 174 inhabited_VBN by_IN the_ATI real_JJ invisible_JJ man_NN ,_, on_IN D14 174 whose_WP$R withdrawal_NN the_ATI body_NN D14 175 crumbles_VBZ ._. D14 176 ^ \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP contends_VBZ for_IN the_ATI *'_*' D14 176 elasticity_NN **'_**' of_IN the_ATI terms_NNS D14 177 *'_*' life_NC **'_**' and_CC *'_*' death_NC ._. **'_**' ^ D14 177 unfortunately_RB ,_, he_PP3A does_DOZ not_XNOT define_VB what_WDT D14 177 he_PP3A D14 178 means_VBZ ._. ^ the_ATI only_AP elasticity_NN about_IN them_PP3OS D14 178 is_BEZ that_DT already_RB indicated_VBN ,_, D14 179 \0viz_RB ,_, their_PP$ applications_NNS to_IN different_JJ kinds_NNS D14 179 of_IN life_NN and_CC death_NN ._. ^ on_IN D14 180 this_DT principle_NN ,_, the_ATI scriptures_NNS quoted_VBN by_IN D14 180 \0Mr_NPT Barnett_NP are_BER perfectly_RB D14 181 intelligible_JJ without_IN involving_VBG that_DT violation_NN of_IN D14 181 first_OD principles_NNS on_IN D14 182 the_ATI subject_NN which_WDTR he_PP3A wishes_VBZ to_TO found_VB upon_IN D14 182 them_PP3OS ._. D15 3 ^ grace_NN ,_, mercy_NN and_CC peace_NN ._. D15 5 ^ *'_*' grace_NN ,_, mercy_NN and_CC peace_NN ,_, from_IN God_NP D15 5 our_PP$ Father_NPT and_CC Jesus_NP Christ_NP our_PP$ D15 6 Lord_NPT ._. **'_**' 1_CD1 Timothy_NP 1.2_CD ._. D15 7 ^ greetings_NNS expressed_VBN in_IN *'_*' words_NNS which_WDTR D15 7 the_ATI holy_JJ ghost_NN D15 8 teacheth_VBZ **'_**' come_VB to_IN the_ATI reverent_JJ reader_NN D15 8 today_NR with_IN the_ATI same_AP warmth_NN D15 9 and_CC unction_NN as_CS when_WRB Timothy_NP held_VBD in_IN his_PP$ D15 9 hands_NNS the_ATI precious_JJ parchment_NN D15 10 upon_IN which_WDTR the_ATI message_NN was_BEDZ first_RB written_VBN ._. D15 10 ^ under_IN the_ATI gracious_JJ tuition_NN D15 11 of_IN the_ATI eternal_JJ spirit_NN ,_, the_ATI writer_NN framed_VBD D15 11 his_PP$ prayerful_JJ desire_NN for_IN the_ATI D15 12 reader's_NN$ spiritual_JJ good_NN ._. ^ wisdom_NN far_RB greater_JJR D15 12 than_IN that_DT of_IN the_ATI most_QL D15 13 devoted_JJ apostle_NN ordained_VBD that_CS the_ATI encouragement_NN D15 13 first_RB enjoyed_VBN by_IN D15 14 Timothy_NP should_MD subsequently_RB be_BE shared_VBN by_IN the_ATI D15 14 people_NNS of_IN God_NP of_IN every_AT D15 15 race_NN and_CC in_IN every_AT age_NN ._. D15 16 ^ grace_NN is_BEZ the_ATI fountain_NN from_IN which_WDTR every_AT D15 16 blessing_NN springs_VBZ ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ D15 17 the_ATI free_JJ ,_, unmerited_JJ favour_NN of_IN God_NP bestowed_VBN D15 17 upon_IN the_ATI guilty_JJ sinner_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 D15 18 is_BEZ manifested_VBN in_IN the_ATI perfect_JJ provision_NN made_VBN D15 18 for_IN the_ATI expiation_NN of_IN the_ATI D15 19 sinner's_NN$ guilt_NN by_IN the_ATI atoning_JJ blood_NN of_IN the_ATI D15 19 redeemer_NN ,_, the_ATI Lord's_NPT$ D15 20 anointed_JJ ._. D15 21 ^ mercy_NN is_BEZ extended_VBN to_TO relieve_VB the_ATI guilty_JJ D15 21 of_IN the_ATI miserable_JJ D15 22 consequences_NNS of_IN their_PP$ guilt_NN before_IN God_NP ._. ^ *'_*' D15 22 according_IN to_IN" his_PP$ mercy_NN he_PP3A D15 23 saved_VBD us_PP1OS by_IN the_ATI washing_NN of_IN regeneration_NN D15 23 and_CC renewing_NN of_IN the_ATI holy_JJ D15 24 ghost_NN ,_, which_WDTR he_PP3A shed_VBD on_IN us_PP1OS abundantly_RB D15 24 through_IN Jesus_NP Christ_NP our_PP$ D15 25 saviour_NN ._. **'_**' ^ by_IN nature_NN afar_RB off_RP ,_, D15 25 alienated_VBN and_CC separated_VBN from_IN God_NP ,_, D15 26 spiritually_RB destitute_JJ and_CC dead_JJ in_IN trespasses_NNS and_CC D15 26 sins_NNS ,_, the_ATI redeemed_JJ D15 27 soul_NN is_BEZ *'_*' a_AT debtor_NN to_IN mercy_NN alone_RB **'_**' ,_, D15 27 born_VBN of_IN the_ATI spirit_NN ,_, called_VBN from_IN D15 28 nature's_NN$ darkness_NN into_IN God's_NP$ marvellous_JJ light_NN ,_, D15 28 translated_VBN into_IN the_ATI D15 29 kingdom_NN of_IN his_PP$ dear_JJ son_NN ,_, and_CC in_IN everything_PN D15 29 enriched_VBN by_IN him_PP3O ._. D15 30 ^ peace_NN with_IN God_NP could_MD be_BE secured_VBN for_IN the_ATI D15 30 guilty_JJ only_RB by_IN *'_*' God_NP ,_, who_WPR D15 31 hath_HVZ reconciled_VBN us_PP1OS to_IN himself_PPL by_IN Jesus_NP D15 31 Christ_NP **'_**' ._. ^ no_ATI man_NN ever_RB made_VBD D15 32 his_PP$ own_AP peace_NN with_IN God_NP ._. ^ the_ATI divinely_RB D15 32 appointed_VBN mediator_NN himself_PPL D15 33 declares_VBZ that_CS ,_, ~ *'_*' no_ATI man_NN cometh_VBZ unto_IN D15 33 the_ATI Father_NPT but_CC by_IN me_PP1O ._. **'_**' D15 34 ^ he_PP3A is_BEZ the_ATI prince_NN of_IN peace_NN ._. ^ he_PP3A D15 34 speaks_VBZ peace_NN to_IN his_PP$ people_NNS ._. ^ *'_*' he_PP3A is_BEZ D15 35 our_PP$ peace_NN ._. **'_**' D15 36 ^ grace_NN is_BEZ the_ATI source_NN ,_, mercy_NN is_BEZ the_ATI D15 36 stream_NN ,_, and_CC peace_NN is_BEZ the_ATI D15 37 experience_NN of_IN the_ATI blessing_NN of_IN the_ATI Lord_NPT ,_, D15 37 which_WDTR maketh_VBZ rich_JJ ._. ^ while_CS we_PP1AS D15 38 borrow_VB the_ATI apostolic_JJ greeting_NN ,_, we_PP1AS also_RB D15 38 express_VB the_ATI earnest_JJ desire_NN and_CC D15 39 prayer_NN of_IN members_NNS and_CC friends_NNS of_IN the_ATI D15 39 trinitarian_JJ Bible_NP society_NN that_CS D15 40 the_ATI scriptures_NNS distributed_VBN during_IN the_ATI year_NN may_MD D15 40 be_BE the_ATI means_NN of_IN D15 41 revealing_VBG to_IN those_DTS who_WPR read_VB them_PP3OS *-_*- *'_*' D15 41 grace_NN ,_, mercy_NN and_CC peace_NN ,_, from_IN God_NP D15 42 our_PP$ Father_NPT and_CC Jesus_NP Christ_NP our_PP$ Lord_NPT ._. D15 42 **'_**' D15 44 ^ the_ATI authorised_JJ version_NN still_RB supreme_JJ ._. D15 46 ^ the_ATI cover_NN of_IN this_DT quarterly_JJ record_NN is_BEZ D15 46 designed_VBN as_IN a_AT small_JJ D15 47 tribute_NN to_IN the_ATI authorised_JJ version_NN ,_, which_WDTR D15 47 has_HVZ now_RN reached_VBN its_PP$ 350th_OD D15 48 anniversary_NN and_CC remains_VBZ peerless_JJ among_IN the_ATI D15 48 English_JNP translations_NNS of_IN the_ATI D15 49 Bible_NP ._. ^ the_ATI design_NN draws_VBZ attention_NN to_IN D15 49 several_AP important_JJ aspects_NNS of_IN D15 50 this_DT enduring_JJ and_CC excellent_JJ work_NN ,_, including_IN D15 50 Hampton_NP Court_NPL Palace_NPL ,_, its_PP$ D15 51 birthplace_NN ,_, and_CC \0Dr_NPT Reynolds_NP ,_, the_ATI puritan_JJ D15 51 minister_NN ,_, who_WPR first_RB D15 52 suggested_VBD that_CS a_AT new_JJ translation_NN should_MD be_BE D15 52 undertaken_VBN ._. D15 53 ^ with_IN God's_NP$ gracious_JJ blessing_NN ,_, the_ATI D15 53 translator_NN in_IN his_PP$ study_NN ,_, the_ATI D15 54 printer_NN with_IN his_PP$ press_NN and_CC the_ATI preacher_NN in_IN D15 54 the_ATI pulpit_NN have_HV all_ABN helped_VBN D15 55 to_TO make_VB the_ATI word_NN of_IN God_NP available_JJ to_IN D15 55 English_NNP speaking_JJ people_NNS D15 56 throughout_IN the_ATI world_NN ._. ^ incomparable_JJ in_IN its_PP$ D15 56 faithfulness_NN ,_, majestic_JJ in_IN D15 57 its_PP$ language_NN ,_, and_CC inexhaustible_JJ in_IN its_PP$ D15 57 spiritual_JJ fruitfulness_NN ,_, this_DT D15 58 time_NN honoured_VBN version_NN continues_VBZ to_TO reveal_VB to_IN D15 58 millions_CDS the_ATI matchless_JJ D15 59 grace_NN of_IN him_PP3O whose_WP$R name_NN is_BEZ the_ATI word_NN of_IN D15 59 God_NP ,_, and_CC who_WPR is_BEZ crowned_VBN D15 60 with_IN glory_NN and_CC honour_NN ._. D15 61 ^ commemoration_NN editions_NNS ._. D15 62 ^ the_ATI society_NN is_BEZ publishing_VBG two_CD commemoration_NN D15 62 editions_NNS of_IN the_ATI D15 63 authorised_JJ version_NN and_CC these_DTS should_MD be_BE available_JJ D15 63 in_IN January_NR ._. ^ an_AT D15 64 appropriate_JJ device_NN representing_VBG the_ATI open_JJ book_NN D15 64 surmounted_VBN by_IN a_AT crown_NN D15 65 and_CC the_ATI dates_NNS 1611-1961_CD-CD will_MD be_BE blocked_VBN D15 65 in_IN gold_NN on_IN the_ATI front_JJB cover_NN ._. D15 66 ^ the_ATI editions_NNS will_MD be_BE supplied_VBN in_IN excellently_RB D15 66 designed_JJ paper_NN jackets_NNS ,_, D15 67 including_IN the_ATI following_JJ brief_JJ tribute_NN :_: *-_*- D15 68 ^ *'_*' in_IN presenting_VBG this_DT commemoration_NN edition_NN D15 68 the_ATI society_NN pays_VBZ D15 69 tribute_NN to_IN the_ATI excellence_NN of_IN this_DT version_NN D15 69 which_WDTR is_BEZ an_AT inestimable_JJ part_NN D15 70 of_IN our_PP$ protestant_JJ heritage_NN ,_, has_HVZ been_BEN the_ATI D15 70 means_NN of_IN spiritual_JJ enrichment_NN D15 71 to_IN millions_CDS of_IN readers_NNS for_IN 350_CD years_NNS and_CC D15 71 remains_VBZ peerless_JJ among_IN the_ATI D15 72 English_JNP translations_NNS of_IN the_ATI Bible_NP ._. **'_**' D15 73 ^ the_ATI commemoration_NN editions_NNS will_MD be_BE in_IN royal_JJ D15 73 brevier_NN type_NN (_( 6_CD D15 74 3/4_CD *?8_NNU x_IN 4_CD 3/4_CD *?8_NNU )_) at_IN 8_CD \0s_NNU 6_CD D15 74 \0d_NNU and_CC royal_JJ Ruby_NP type_NN (_( 5_CD 1/2_CD *?8_NNU x_IN D15 74 3_CD D15 75 3/4_CD *?8_NNU )_) at_IN 6_CD \0s_NNU each_DT ._. ^ copies_NNS may_MD D15 75 be_BE ordered_VBN by_IN post_NN and_CC particulars_NNS D15 76 of_IN reduced_JJ prices_NNS for_IN Sunday_NR School_NPL and_CC D15 76 congregational_JJ orders_NNS will_MD be_BE D15 77 sent_VBN on_IN request_NN ._. D15 79 ^ make_VB the_ATI paper_NN speak_VB ._. D15 81 ^ this_DT caption_NN ,_, which_WDTR appears_VBZ on_IN the_ATI D15 81 letter-head_NN of_IN one_CD1 of_IN our_PP$ D15 82 correspondents_NNS in_IN south_NR India_NP ,_, simply_RB and_CC D15 82 clearly_RB defines_VBZ the_ATI chief_JJB D15 83 object_NN of_IN the_ATI \0T.B.S_NP in_IN sending_VBG out_RP the_ATI D15 83 scriptures_NNS ._. ^ the_ATI D15 84 following_JJ paragraphs_NNS from_IN recent_JJ letters_NNS of_IN D15 84 application_NN and_CC thanks_NNS D15 85 will_MD indicate_VB that_CS *'_*' the_ATI paper_NN speaks_VBZ **'_**' D15 85 in_IN places_NNS where_WRB the_ATI ministry_NN D15 86 of_IN the_ATI spoken_JJ word_NN is_BEZ not_XNOT always_RB possible_JJ D15 86 ._. D15 87 ^ in_IN hospital_NN in_IN south_NR India_NP ._. D15 88 ^ *'_*' I_PP1A am_BEM indeed_RB very_QL grateful_JJ to_IN you_PP2 D15 88 for_IN the_ATI lovely_JJ copies_NNS of_IN the_ATI D15 89 holy_JJ Bible_NP ,_, new_JJ testaments_NNS and_CC gospels_NNS D15 89 posted_VBN to_IN me_PP1O in_IN October_NR ,_, 1960_CD ._. D15 90 ^ *'_*' I_PP1A wanted_VBD to_TO go_VB to_IN some_DTI far_JJ off_JJ" D15 90 places_NNS as_IN Jamshedpur_NP ,_, Calcutta_NP D15 91 and_CC Rewa_NP and_CC preach_VB the_ATI gospel_NN in_IN September_NR D15 91 ,_, but_CC on_IN the_ATI way_NN I_PP1A had_HVD a_AT D15 92 sudden_JJ illness_NN and_CC had_HVD to_TO get_VB admitted_VBN to_IN D15 92 the_ATI government_NN Hospital_NPL in_IN D15 93 Cuttack_NP ._. ^ though_CS my_PP$ stay_NN was_BEDZ long_JJ and_CC D15 93 painful_JJ ,_, the_ATI treatment_NN was_BEDZ D15 94 successful_JJ ._. ^ three_CD Christian_JNP surgeons_NNS were_BED D15 94 working_VBG in_IN the_ATI ward_NN where_WRB I_PP1A D15 95 stayed_VBD ,_, and_CC a_AT big_JJ medical_JJ college_NN is_BEZ D15 95 attached_VBN to_IN this_DT hospital_NN ._. ^ many_AP D15 96 Hindu_JNP surgeons_NNS and_CC medical_JJ students_NNS and_CC some_DTI D15 96 of_IN the_ATI officers_NNS who_WPR were_BED D15 97 in_IN the_ATI hospital_NN as_IN patients_NNS each_DT received_VBD a_AT D15 97 copy_NN of_IN the_ATI holy_JJ Bible_NP or_CC D15 98 new_JJ testament_NN ._. D15 99 ^ *'_*' an_AT engineer_NN who_WPR received_VBD a_AT copy_NN of_IN D15 99 the_ATI holy_JJ Bible_NP ,_, said_VBD with_IN a_AT D15 100 happy_JJ smile_NN ,_, ^ *'_*' just_RB this_DT morning_NN I_PP1A D15 100 requested_VBD a_AT Christian_JNP friend_NN of_IN D15 101 mine_PP$$ to_TO give_VB me_PP1O a_AT copy_NN of_IN the_ATI holy_JJ D15 101 Bible_NP to_TO read_VB ._. ^ he_PP3A did_DOD not_XNOT have_HV a_AT D15 102 copy_NN ._. ^ God_NP gave_VBD it_PP3 through_IN you_PP2 ._. **'_**' ^ D15 102 another_DT medical_JJ student_NN came_VBD and_CC D15 103 said_VBD ,_, ^ *'_*' Sir_NPT ,_, I_PP1A want_VB a_AT copy_NN of_IN D15 103 the_ATI new_JJ testament_NN ._. **'_**' ^ I_PP1A asked_VBD ,_, D15 104 ^ *'_*' Brother_NPT ,_, how_WRB do_DO you_PP2 know_VB I_PP1A have_HV D15 104 the_ATI copies_NNS ?_? **'_**' ^ he_PP3A said_VBD he_PP3A had_HVD D15 104 seen_VBN D15 105 his_PP$ friends_NNS reading_VBG in_IN the_ATI medical_JJ hostel_NN D15 105 and_CC he_PP3A was_BEDZ also_RB *'_*' tempted_VBN D15 106 **'_**' to_TO get_VB a_AT copy_NN from_IN me_PP1O and_CC read_VB it_PP3 D15 106 ._. ^ I_PP1A gave_VBD him_PP3O a_AT holy_JJ Bible_NP ._. ^ he_PP3A D15 106 used_VBD D15 107 to_TO come_VB every_AT day_NN and_CC talk_NN to_IN me_PP1O for_IN a_AP D15 107 few_AP" minutes_NNS ._. D15 108 ^ *'_*' a_AT Hindu_JNP patient_NN awaiting_VBG an_AT operation_NN D15 108 received_VBD a_AT small_JJ booklet_NN D15 109 and_CC his_PP$ remark_NN was_BEDZ ,_, *'_*' this_DT will_MD keep_VB D15 109 me_PP1O **'_**' ._. ^ I_PP1A could_MD not_XNOT give_VB every_AT D15 110 medical_JJ student_NN a_AT copy_NN of_IN the_ATI holy_JJ Bible_NP D15 110 for_CS there_EX are_BER many_AP students_NNS ._. D15 111 ^ I_PP1A had_HVD to_TO contact_VB them_PP3OS ,_, explain_VB a_AP D15 111 little_AP" and_CC then_RN present_VB the_ATI D15 112 scriptures_NNS ._. ^ my_PP$ bane_NN was_BEDZ a_AT boon_NN and_CC I_PP1A D15 112 learnt_VBD to_TO carry_VB my_PP$ cross_NN D15 113 cheerfully_RB ._. D15 114 ^ *'_*' may_MD the_ATI master_NN of_IN the_ATI vineyard_NN bless_VB D15 114 the_ATI seed_NN sown_VBN for_IN his_PP$ D15 115 glory_NN ,_, and_CC may_MD souls_NNS be_BE saved_VBN and_CC added_VBN D15 115 to_IN the_ATI fold_NN ._. ^ may_MD the_ATI Lord_NPT D15 116 bless_VB you_PP2 abundantly_RB as_CS you_PP2 supply_VB the_ATI D15 116 seeds_NNS to_IN farmers_NNS in_IN India_NP D15 117 working_VBG in_IN his_PP$ vineyard_NN and_CC supply_VB all_ABN your_PP$ D15 117 need_NN for_IN his_PP$ glory_NN ._. D15 118 ^ *'_*' please_UH pray_VB for_IN me_PP1O ,_, as_CS I_PP1A am_BEM D15 118 anxious_JJ to_TO work_VB in_IN unreached_JJ areas_NNS ._. D15 119 ^ my_PP$ health_NN is_BEZ weak_JJ and_CC resources_NNS poor_JJ but_CC D15 119 the_ATI Lord_NPT used_VBD me_PP1O in_IN 8_CD D15 120 provinces_NNS of_IN India_NP and_CC about_RB 200_CD towns_NNS and_CC D15 120 villages_NNS during_IN the_ATI past_JJB 16_CD D15 121 years_NNS ,_, in_IN my_PP$ life_NN of_IN faith_NN ._. ^ I_PP1A can_MD D15 121 do_DO all_ABN things_NNS through_IN him_PP3O who_WPR D15 122 strengthens_VBZ me_PP1O ._. D15 123 ^ *'_*' the_ATI Lord_NPT bless_VB thee_PP2 and_CC keep_VB thee_PP2 D15 123 ._. **'_**' D15 124 ^ the_ATI Corinth_NP of_IN India_NP ._. D15 125 ^ *'_*' we_PP1AS thank_VB you_PP2 for_IN helping_VBG us_PP1OS D15 125 with_IN Bibles_NPS and_CC portions_NNS ._. ^ all_ABN D15 126 the_ATI packets_NNS reached_VBD us_PP1OS in_IN good_JJ condition_NN ._. D15 126 ^ really_RB this_DT supply_NN was_BEDZ a_AT D15 127 very_QL great_JJ help_NN in_IN our_PP$ work_NN here_RN in_IN India_NP D15 127 ._. ^ from_IN November_NR 1st_OD to_IN 16th_OD D15 128 we_PP1AS distributed_VBD literature_NN in_IN an_AT important_JJ D15 128 Hindu_JNP city_NN where_WRB many_AP D15 129 thousands_CDS of_IN people_NNS gather_VB for_IN pilgrimage_NN ._. ^ D15 129 the_ATI name_NN of_IN that_DT city_NN is_BEZ D15 130 Madura_NP and_CC it_PP3 is_BEZ known_VBN as_IN the_ATI Corinth_NP of_IN D15 130 India_NP ._. ^ every_AT street_NN in_IN that_DT D15 131 city_NN is_BEZ filled_VBN with_IN idols_NNS ._. ^ the_ATI Lord_NPT D15 131 blessed_VBD us_PP1OS richly_RB ._. ^ we_PP1AS could_MD D15 132 distribute_VB several_AP thousands_CDS of_IN scripture_NN leaflets_NNS D15 132 and_CC gospels_NNS and_CC D15 133 quite_ABL a_AP few_AP" Bibles_NPS ._. ^ we_PP1AS are_BER praying_VBG D15 133 that_CS there_EX may_MD be_BE fruit_NN unto_IN D15 134 eternal_JJ life_NN ._. ^ also_RB last_AP month_NN the_ATI Lord_NPT D15 134 enabled_VBD us_PP1OS to_TO go_VB into_IN some_DTI of_IN D15 135 the_ATI villages_NNS where_WRB the_ATI gospel_NN has_HVZ not_XNOT D15 135 been_BEN preached_VBN so_QL far_RB ._. ^ many_AP D15 136 attended_VBD and_CC heard_VBD the_ATI word_NN of_IN God_NP ,_, and_CC D15 136 received_VBD the_ATI scriptures_NNS ._. D15 137 ^ prayer_NN is_BEZ requested_VBN for_IN all_ABN these_DTS efforts_NNS D15 137 so_CS that_CS" in_IN due_JJ time_NN souls_NNS D15 138 may_MD be_BE brought_VBN to_IN the_ATI Lord_NPT Jesus_NP Christ_NP ._. D15 139 ^ *'_*' often_RB we_PP1AS remembered_VBD the_ATI work_NN of_IN D15 139 the_ATI trinitarian_JJ Bible_NP society_NN D15 140 in_IN prayer_NN ,_, and_CC certainly_RB we_PP1AS shall_MD continue_VB D15 140 to_TO do_DO so_PN ._. D15 141 ^ *'_*' your_PP$ earnest_JJ prayers_NNS are_BER solicited_VBN for_IN D15 141 the_ATI humble_JJ work_NN we_PP1AS do_DO D15 142 for_IN the_ATI Lord_NPT in_IN India_NP ._. **'_**' D15 143 ^ people_NNS are_BER hungry_JJ ._. D15 144 ^ *'_*' the_ATI idea_NN of_IN distributing_VBG the_ATI D15 144 scriptures_NNS to_IN a_AT considerable_JJ D15 145 extent_NN occurred_VBD to_IN me_PP1O early_RB in_IN January_NR ._. ^ D15 145 we_PP1AS started_VBD the_ATI distribution_NN D15 146 and_CC we_PP1AS found_VBD that_CS there_EX were_BED people_NNS who_WPR D15 146 were_BED interested_JJ ,_, and_CC in_IN a_AT D15 147 short_JJ time_NN we_PP1AS had_HVD a_AT band_NN of_IN thirty_CD young_JJ D15 147 men_NNS ._. ^ after_IN their_PP$ work_NN in_IN the_ATI D15 148 various_JJ factories_NNS and_CC government_NN offices_NNS at_IN D15 148 Bangalore_NP they_PP3AS help_VB me_PP1O D15 149 with_IN the_ATI distribution_NN work_NN ._. ^ our_PP$ numbers_NNS D15 149 have_HV since_RI doubled_VBN ._. D15 150 ^ *'_*' Christ_NP has_HVZ wrought_VBN a_AT finished_JJ ,_, full_JJ D15 150 and_CC perfect_JJ salvation_NN for_IN D15 151 me_PP1O by_IN his_PP$ death_NN and_CC resurrection_NN ,_, but_CC D15 151 most_AP of_IN the_ATI people_NNS are_BER ignorant_JJ D15 152 of_IN it_PP3 ._. ^ one_CD1 of_IN the_ATI best_JJT ways_NNS to_TO get_VB D15 152 the_ATI gospel_NN message_NN into_IN the_ATI minds_NNS D15 153 and_CC hearts_NNS of_IN sinners_NNS is_BEZ through_IN religious_JJ D15 153 literature_NN ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ a_AT work_NN D15 154 every_AT Christian_NNP can_MD do_DO ._. ^ its_PP$ importance_NN can_MD D15 154 not_XNOT be_BE D15 155 over-estimated_VBN ._. ^ one_CD1 need_MD not_XNOT be_BE an_AT D15 155 evangelist_NN or_CC a_AT minister_NN or_CC a_AT D15 156 missionary_NN in_TO order_TO" to_TO" be_BE able_JJ to_TO engage_VB D15 156 in_IN this_DT work_NN ._. ^ one_CD1 can_MD do_DO it_PP3 D15 157 right_RB where_WRB he_PP3A is_BEZ ._. ^ only_RB a_AT small_JJ D15 157 percentage_NN of_IN Christians_NNPS can_MD be_BE D15 158 full-time_JJB pastors_NNS ,_, evangelists_NNS or_CC teachers_NNS ,_, D15 158 but_CC every_AT believer_NN can_MD be_BE D15 159 a_AT faithful_JJ distributor_NN of_IN the_ATI gospel_NN ._. D15 160 ^ *'_*' India's_NP$ door_NN may_MD soon_RB be_BE closed_VBN to_IN D15 160 foreign_JJ missionaries_NNS ._. ^ the_ATI D15 161 desperate_JJ need_NN is_BEZ to_TO sow_VB millions_CDS of_IN gospel_NN D15 161 tracts_NNS on_IN India's_NP$ soil_NN ,_, D15 162 now_RN ,_, so_CS that_CS" they_PP3AS will_MD in_IN months_NNS and_CC D15 162 years_NNS ahead_RB bear_VB a_AT spiritual_JJ D15 163 harvest_NN ._. ^ our_PP$ hearts_NNS must_MD burn_VB for_IN the_ATI D15 163 need_NN of_IN an_AT abundant_JJ supply_NN of_IN D15 164 the_ATI scriptures_NNS ._. ^ God's_NP$ seal_NN is_BEZ on_IN the_ATI D15 164 world-wide_JJ distribution_NN of_IN his_PP$ D15 165 printed_JJ word_NN ._. ^ hundreds_CDS and_CC thousands_CDS have_HV D15 165 found_VBN God_NP through_IN the_ATI D15 166 silent_JJ ministry_NN of_IN the_ATI printed_JJ gospel_NN ._. D15 167 ^ *'_*' everywhere_RB people_NNS are_BER hungry_JJ for_IN the_ATI D15 167 living_JJ and_CC true_JJ bread_NN ._. D15 168 ^ *'_*' the_ATI printed_JJ page_NN can_MD go_VB anywhere_RB ._. ^ D15 168 it_PP3 knows_VBZ no_ATI fear_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 never_RB D15 169 tires_VBZ ,_, and_CC never_RB dies_VBZ ._. ^ it_PP3 can_MD travel_VB D15 169 at_IN little_AP expense_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 can_MD run_VB D15 170 up_RP and_CC down_RP like_IN an_AT angel_NN of_IN God_NP ,_, D15 170 blessing_VBG all_ABN ,_, giving_VBG to_IN all_ABN ,_, asking_VBG D15 171 no_ATI gift_NN in_IN return_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 can_MD talk_VB to_IN D15 171 one_CD1 as_CS to_IN the_ATI multitude_NN ;_; and_CC to_IN the_ATI D15 172 multitude_NN as_QL well_RB as_IN one_CD1 ._. ^ it_PP3 requires_VBZ D15 172 no_ATI public_JJ room_NN to_TO tell_VB its_PP$ D15 173 story_NN in_IN ,_, but_CC can_MD speak_VB in_IN the_ATI kitchen_NN D15 173 or_CC the_ATI shop_NN ,_, the_ATI parlour_NN or_CC the_ATI D15 174 study_NN ,_, in_IN the_ATI railway_NN carriage_NN or_CC in_IN the_ATI D15 174 bus_NN ,_, on_IN the_ATI broad_JJ highway_NN or_CC D15 175 on_IN the_ATI footpath_NN through_IN the_ATI fields_NNS ._. ^ it_PP3 D15 175 is_BEZ not_XNOT hindered_VBN by_IN scoffs_NNS ,_, D15 176 jeers_NNS ,_, or_CC taunts_NNS ._. ^ though_CS it_PP3 will_MD not_XNOT D15 176 always_RB answer_VB questions_NNS ,_, it_PP3 will_MD D15 177 tell_VB its_PP$ story_NN twice_RB ,_, or_CC thrice_RB or_CC four_CD D15 177 times_NNS over_RP ,_, if_CS one_CD1 wishes_VBZ ._. ^ it_PP3 D15 178 is_BEZ in_RB short_RB" the_ATI teacher_NN of_IN all_ABN classes_NNS D15 178 and_CC the_ATI benefactor_NN of_IN all_ABN D15 179 lands_NNS ._. D15 180 ^ *'_*' I_PP1A chanced_VBD to_TO come_VB across_IN a_AP few_AP" D15 180 of_IN your_PP$ scripture_NN portions_NNS ._. ^ may_MD D15 181 I_PP1A kindly_RB request_VB you_PP2 to_TO send_VB me_PP1O quite_ABL D15 181 a_AT number_NN and_CC to_TO keep_VB my_PP$ name_NN in_IN D15 182 your_PP$ mailing_NN list_NN and_CC send_VB me_PP1O packets_NNS D15 182 whenever_WRB you_PP2 can_MD ?_? D15 183 ^ *'_*' we_PP1AS also_RB request_VB you_PP2 to_TO remember_VB D15 183 us_PP1OS and_CC our_PP$ work_NN in_IN your_PP$ D15 184 prayers_NNS ._. **'_**' D15 186 ^ news_NN from_IN Nepal_NP ._. D15 188 ^ a_AT recent_JJ report_NN gives_VBZ the_ATI encouraging_JJ news_NN D15 188 that_CS all_ABN copies_NNS of_IN D15 189 the_ATI first_OD and_CC second_OD editions_NNS of_IN the_ATI Nepali_JNP D15 189 gospel_NN have_HV been_BEN sold_VBN and_CC D15 190 that_CS the_ATI third_OD edition_NN recently_RB printed_VBN by_IN D15 190 the_ATI \0T.B.S_NP is_BEZ being_BEG D15 191 rapidly_RB distributed_VBN ._. ^ more_AP than_IN 7,750_CD copies_NNS D15 191 had_HVD been_BEN sold_VBN up_RP to_IN D15 192 September_NR and_CC most_AP of_IN these_DTS had_HVD been_BEN taken_VBN D15 192 into_IN Nepal_NP ._. ^ the_ATI \0Rev_NPT D15 193 \0R_NP \0T_NP Cunningham_NP warmly_RB acknowledges_VBZ the_ATI help_NN D15 193 given_VBN by_IN the_ATI D15 194 society_NN and_CC trusts_VBZ that_DT many_AP of_IN the_ATI Lord's_NPT$ D15 194 people_NNS will_MD join_VB in_IN prayer_NN D15 195 for_IN God's_NP$ blessing_NN upon_IN these_DTS copies_NNS of_IN his_PP$ D15 195 word_NN ,_, that_CS they_PP3AS may_MD be_BE D15 196 fruitfully_RB used_VBN to_IN his_PP$ glory_NN ._. D15 197 ^ regular_JJ consignments_NNS of_IN these_DTS gospels_NNS have_HV D15 197 been_BEN sent_VBN from_IN London_NP D15 198 and_CC have_HV safely_RB reached_VBN their_PP$ destination_NN ._. D15 199 ^ the_ATI following_JJ article_NN in_IN our_PP$ series_NN D15 199 entitled_VBN *'_*' the_ATI force_NN of_IN D15 200 truth_NN **'_**' is_BEZ based_VBN on_IN a_AT letter_NN from_IN D15 200 \0Mrs_NPT \0R_NP \0T_NP Cunningham_NP ,_, D15 201 printed_VBN in_IN the_ATI October_NR issue_NN of_IN the_ATI magazine_NN D15 201 of_IN the_ATI independent_JJ board_NN D15 202 for_IN Presbyterian_JNP missions_NNS ._. D16 2 ^ *'_*' well_UH ,_, tell_VB me_PP1O ,_, what_WDT is_BEZ the_ATI D16 2 Pope's_NPT$ business_NN ?_? **'_**' D16 3 ^ religion_NN and_CC politics_NN ._. D16 4 ^ it_PP3 's_BEZ no_RB good_JJ talking_VBG as_CS though_CS" D16 4 religion_NN and_CC politics_NN were_BED two_CD D16 5 separate_JJ things_NNS ,_, like_IN sport_NN and_CC music_NN ._. ^ if_CS D16 5 the_ATI captain_NN of_IN the_ATI Arsenal_NP D16 6 starts_VBZ telling_JJ Sir_NPT Malcolm_NP Sargent_NP how_WRB to_TO D16 6 conduct_VB an_AT orchestra_NN he_PP3A 'll_MD D16 7 be_BE told_VBN to_TO mind_VB his_PP$ own_AP business_NN ._. ^ Sir_NPT D16 7 Malcolm_NP Sargent_NP will_MD be_BE told_VBN D16 8 the_ATI same_AP thing_NN if_CS he_PP3A tries_VBZ to_TO tell_VB the_ATI D16 8 captain_NN of_IN the_ATI Arsenal_NP how_WRB to_TO D16 9 score_VB goals_NNS ._. ^ sport_NN has_HVZ nothing_PN to_TO do_DO D16 9 with_IN music_NN ._. ^ so_RB everyone_PN knows_VBZ D16 10 where_WRB he_PP3A is_BEZ ._. D16 11 ^ what_WDT about_IN religion_NN and_CC politics_NN ?_? ^ they_PP3AS D16 11 are_BER not_XNOT in_IN two_CD watertight_JJ D16 12 compartments_NNS ._. ^ think_VB of_IN the_ATI number_NN of_IN laws_NNS D16 12 that_WPR have_HV just_RB as_QL much_AP to_TO D16 13 do_DO with_IN a_AT man's_NN$ soul_NN as_CS with_IN his_PP$ body_NN ._. ^ D16 13 if_CS the_ATI government_NN tells_VBZ you_PP2 to_TO D16 14 send_VB your_PP$ children_NNS to_IN a_AT school_NN where_WRB they_PP3AS D16 14 'll_MD be_BE taught_VBN there_EX 's_BEZ no_ATI D16 15 God_NP *-_*- is_BEZ that_DT religion_NN or_CC politics_NN ?_? ^ if_CS D16 15 the_ATI government_NN tells_VBZ you_PP2 to_TO D16 16 kill_VB off_RP your_PP$ mother_NN because_CS she_PP3A is_BEZ D16 16 suffering_VBG from_IN an_AT incurable_JJ D16 17 disease_NN *-_*- is_BEZ that_DT religion_NN or_CC politics_NN ?_? ^ D16 17 if_CS the_ATI state_NN decides_VBZ that_CS it_PP3 D16 18 is_BEZ legal_JJ for_IN your_PP$ wife_NN to_TO run_VB off_RP with_IN D16 18 another_DT man_NN and_CC leave_VB your_PP$ D16 19 children_NNS without_IN a_AT mother_NN *-_*- is_BEZ that_DT religion_NN D16 19 or_CC politics_NN ?_? D16 20 ^ do_DO you_PP2 see_VB the_ATI point_NN ?_? ^ there_EX are_BER so_QL D16 20 many_AP things_NNS which_WDTR are_BER the_ATI D16 21 business_NN of_IN the_ATI Church_NPL and_CC of_IN the_ATI state_NN ._. ^ D16 21 if_CS they_PP3AS do_DO n't_XNOT agree_VB on_IN what_WDT D16 22 is_BEZ right_JJ there_EX is_BEZ bound_VBN to_TO be_BE conflict_NN ._. D16 23 ^ keep_VB religion_NN out_RP ._. D16 24 ^ there_EX are_BER some_DTI things_NNS the_ATI government_NN D16 24 does_DOZ where_WRB religion_NN simply_RB D16 25 need_MD not_XNOT enter_VB in_RP ._. ^ the_ATI Church_NPL has_HVZ no_ATI D16 25 views_NNS on_IN drains_NNS ,_, gas-works_NNS or_CC D16 26 brick-laying_NN ._. ^ on_IN the_ATI other_AP hand_NN the_ATI state_NN D16 26 has_HVZ no_ATI views_NNS on_IN vestments_NNS ,_, D16 27 hymns_NNS and_CC prayers_NNS ._. ^ so_RB you_PP2 will_MD n't_XNOT D16 27 find_VB the_ATI Church_NPL fighting_VBG the_ATI state_NN D16 28 over_IN the_ATI right_JJ size_NN of_IN drain_NN pipes_NNS and_CC D16 28 you_PP2 will_MD n't_XNOT find_VB the_ATI state_NN D16 29 fighting_VBG the_ATI Church_NPL over_IN the_ATI right_JJ tune_NN for_IN D16 29 hymns_NNS ._. D16 30 ^ that_DT 's_BEZ fine_JJ ._. ^ but_CC there_EX are_BER more_QL D16 30 important_JJ things_NNS in_IN life_NN than_IN D16 31 drain_NN pipes_NNS and_CC hymns_NNS ._. ^ it_PP3 's_BEZ all_RB very_QL D16 31 well_JJ to_TO say_VB that_CS if_CS the_ATI Church_NPL D16 32 sticks_VBZ to_IN religion_NN there_EX 's_BEZ no_ATI reason_NN why_WRB D16 32 it_PP3 should_MD ever_RB fall_VB out_RP with_IN D16 33 a_AT political_JJ party_NN ._. ^ the_ATI point_NN is_BEZ ,_, what_WDT D16 33 is_BEZ religion_NN ?_? ^ another_DT point_NN is_BEZ ,_, D16 34 what_WDT are_BER politics_NNS ?_? D16 35 ^ politics_NN means_VBZ the_ATI way_NN to_TO rule_VB a_AT country_NN D16 35 ._. ^ but_CC a_AT country_NN is_BEZ made_VBN D16 36 up_RP of_IN people_NNS ._. ^ and_CC people_NNS are_BER both_ABX body_NN D16 36 and_CC soul_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 seems_VBZ pretty_RB D16 37 obvious_JJ that_CS it_PP3 is_BEZ the_ATI job_NN of_IN a_AT D16 37 government_NN to_TO look_VB after_IN the_ATI needs_NNS of_IN D16 38 the_ATI people_NNS ._. ^ it_PP3 should_MD see_VB that_CS there_EX D16 38 's_BEZ work_NN for_IN the_ATI unemployed_JJ ,_, food_NN D16 39 for_IN the_ATI hungry_JJ ,_, houses_NNS for_IN families_NNS ,_, D16 39 education_NN for_IN the_ATI children_NNS ,_, D16 40 hospitals_NNS for_IN the_ATI sick_JJ ._. D16 41 ^ it_PP3 seems_VBZ to_TO be_BE obvious_JJ ._. ^ but_CC really_RB D16 41 it_PP3 is_BEZ n't_XNOT obvious_JJ at_IN all_ABN ._. ^ the_ATI D16 42 government_NN ,_, after_IN all_ABN ,_, is_BEZ really_RB the_ATI D16 42 servant_NN of_IN the_ATI people_NNS ._. D16 43 ^ the_ATI heart_NN of_IN the_ATI matter_NN ._. D16 44 ^ that_DT brings_VBZ us_PP1OS to_IN the_ATI heart_NN of_IN the_ATI D16 44 matter_NN ._. ^ there_EX is_BEZ something_PN D16 45 very_QL simple_JJ which_WDTR nearly_RB everyone_PN in_IN modern_JJ D16 45 times_NNS has_HVZ forgotten_VBN ._. ^ this_DT D16 46 is_BEZ it_PP3 ._. ^ the_ATI most_QL important_JJ thing_NN in_IN the_ATI D16 46 world_NN is_BEZ the_ATI family_NN ._. ^ we_PP1AS are_BER D16 47 always_RB talking_VBG about_IN the_ATI Church_NPL and_CC state_NN ._. ^ D16 47 but_CC there_EX would_MD n't_XNOT be_BE any_DTI D16 48 need_NN either_DTX for_IN Church_NPL or_CC for_IN state_NN if_CS D16 48 there_EX were_BED no_ATI families_NNS ._. ^ so_RB D16 49 priests_NNS and_CC politicians_NNS before_CS they_PP3AS start_VB to_TO D16 49 talk_VB about_IN their_PP$ rights_NNS D16 50 must_MD remember_VB that_CS the_ATI most_QL important_JJ rights_NNS D16 50 in_IN the_ATI world_NN are_BER the_ATI D16 51 rights_NNS of_IN families_NNS ._. D16 52 ^ so_RB what_WDT seems_VBZ obvious_JJ is_BEZ n't_XNOT so_QL D16 52 obvious_JJ after_IN all_ABN ._. ^ it_PP3 's_BEZ not_XNOT for_IN D16 53 the_ATI government_NN to_TO decide_VB how_WRB it_PP3 's_BEZ going_VBG D16 53 to_TO house_VB people_NNS and_CC educate_VB D16 54 children_NNS ._. ^ it_PP3 's_BEZ for_IN families_NNS to_TO decide_VB D16 54 what_WDT kind_NN of_IN houses_NNS they_PP3AS want_VB D16 55 and_CC what_WDT kind_NN of_IN education_NN is_BEZ best_JJT for_IN D16 55 their_PP$ children_NNS ._. ^ this_DT is_BEZ what_WDT D16 56 the_ATI modern_JJ state_NN usually_RB forgets_VBZ ._. ^ the_ATI D16 56 catholic_JJ Church_NPL always_RB D16 57 remembers_VBZ ._. ^ hence_RB all_ABN the_ATI quarrels_NNS between_IN D16 57 the_ATI Church_NPL and_CC state_NN ._. D16 58 ^ here_RN 's_BEZ a_AT true_JJ story_NN of_IN a_AT man_NN we_PP1AS D16 58 'll_MD call_VB John_NP Williamson_NP ,_, because_CS D16 59 that_DT 's_BEZ not_XNOT his_PP$ name_NN ._. D16 60 ^ John_NP was_BEDZ a_AT civil_JJ servant_NN of_IN the_ATI old_JJ D16 60 school_NN ._. ^ he_PP3A had_HVD worked_VBN hard_JJ D16 61 and_CC passed_VBN examinations_NNS ._. ^ he_PP3A was_BEDZ anxious_JJ D16 61 to_TO get_VB on_RP ._. ^ now_RN civil_JJ D16 62 servants_NNS ,_, as_CS the_ATI name_NN suggests_VBZ ,_, are_BER D16 62 supposed_VBN to_TO be_BE servants_NNS of_IN the_ATI D16 63 public_NN ._. ^ they_PP3AS are_BER supposed_VBN to_TO do_DO what_WDT D16 63 they_PP3AS are_BER told_VBN ._. ^ it_PP3 does_DOZ n't_XNOT D16 64 matter_VB to_IN them_PP3OS which_WDT party_NN is_BEZ in_IN power_NN ._. D16 64 ^ they_PP3AS have_HV to_TO get_VB on_RP with_IN the_ATI D16 65 job_NN without_IN playing_VBG politics_NN ._. ^ John_NP had_HVD a_AT D16 65 wife_NN and_CC four_CD children_NNS ._. ^ he_PP3A D16 66 knew_VBD if_CS he_PP3A wanted_VBD to_TO rise_VB to_TO be_BE head_NN D16 66 of_IN his_PP$ department_NN the_ATI less_AP he_PP3A had_HVD D16 67 to_TO say_VB the_ATI better_JJR would_MD be_BE his_PP$ chances_NNS ._. ^ D16 67 so_RB he_PP3A never_RB wrote_VBD to_IN the_ATI D16 68 papers_NNS ._. ^ he_PP3A never_RB went_VBD to_IN political_JJ D16 68 meetings_NNS ._. ^ he_PP3A kept_VBD himself_PPL to_IN D16 69 himself_PPL ._. D16 70 ^ his_PP$ friends_NNS used_VBD to_TO try_VB to_TO persuade_VB D16 70 him_PP3O to_TO join_VB their_PP$ parties_NNS ._. D16 71 ^ but_CC John_NP always_RB had_HVD his_PP$ answer_NN ._. D16 72 ^ *'_*' it_PP3 's_BEZ all_RB very_QL well_JJ for_IN you_PP2 D16 72 fellows_NNS ,_, **'_**' he_PP3A used_VBD to_TO say_VB ,_, *'_*' you_PP2 D16 73 can_MD have_HV any_DTI politics_NN you_PP2 like_VB ._. ^ you_PP2 D16 73 will_MD n't_XNOT lose_VB your_PP$ jobs_NNS for_IN speaking_VBG D16 74 out_RP of_IN turn_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 's_BEZ different_JJ with_IN me_PP1O D16 74 ._. ^ when_WRB I_PP1A say_VB the_ATI wrong_JJ thing_NN ,_, if_CS D16 75 I_PP1A do_DO n't_XNOT lose_VB my_PP$ job_NN at_RB least_RB" they_PP3AS D16 75 'll_MD pass_VB me_PP1O by_RP when_WRB I_PP1A 'm_BEM looking_VBG for_IN D16 76 promotion_NN ._. ^ my_PP$ motto_NN is_BEZ *-_*- ^ civil_JJ servants_NNS D16 76 should_MD be_BE seen_VBN and_CC not_XNOT D16 77 heard_VBN ._. **'_**' D16 78 ^ leave_VB politics_NN alone_JJ ._. D16 79 ^ so_RB John's_NP$ rule_NN of_IN life_NN was_BEDZ to_TO leave_VB D16 79 politics_NN alone_JJ ._. ^ but_CC D16 80 politics_NN simply_RB would_MD n't_XNOT leave_VB John_NP alone_JJ ._. ^ D16 80 every_AT couple_NN of_IN weeks_NNS D16 81 there_EX would_MD be_BE some_DTI new_JJ law_NN passed_VBN to_TO make_VB D16 81 life_NN more_QL difficult_JJ ._. ^ more_AP D16 82 and_CC more_AP permits_NNS required_VBN ._. ^ more_AP and_CC more_AP D16 82 forms_NNS to_TO be_BE filled_VBN in_RP ._. ^ but_CC D16 83 he_PP3A did_DOD n't_XNOT let_VB this_DT get_VB him_PP3O down_RP ._. ^ D16 83 he_PP3A naturally_RB felt_VBD a_AT bit_NN annoyed_JJ when_WRB D16 84 he_PP3A could_MD n't_XNOT build_VB a_AT chicken-house_NN in_IN his_PP$ D16 84 back_JJB garden_NN without_IN having_HVG to_TO D16 85 write_VB a_AT dozen_CD letters_NNS ._. ^ but_CC he_PP3A was_BEDZ D16 85 n't_XNOT going_VBG to_TO break_VB his_PP$ heart_NN over_IN D16 86 a_AP few_AP" chickens_NNS ._. D16 87 ^ but_CC ,_, of_RB course_RB" ,_, when_WRB he_PP3A had_HVD a_AP D16 87 few_AP" friends_NNS round_RP for_IN a_AT drink_NN he_PP3A D16 88 used_VBD to_TO have_HV his_PP$ grouse_NN ._. ^ after_IN all_ABN ,_, D16 88 he_PP3A was_BEDZ thoroughly_RB English_JNP ._. ^ in_IN D16 89 his_PP$ view_NN politicians_NNS were_BED making_VBG life_NN far_RB D16 89 too_QL difficult_JJ ._. ^ in_IN fact_NN ,_, he_PP3A D16 90 went_VBD so_QL far_RB as_CS to_TO say_VB that_CS if_CS he_PP3A were_BED D16 90 n't_XNOT a_AT civil_JJ servant_NN he_PP3A 'd_MD go_VB into_IN D16 91 politics_NN and_CC tell_VB them_PP3OS a_AT thing_NN or_CC two_CD ._. D16 92 ^ but_CC one_CD1 day_NN he_PP3A changed_VBD his_PP$ mind_NN ._. ^ D16 92 he_PP3A had_HVD put_VBN up_RP with_IN it_PP3 when_WRB they_PP3AS D16 93 were_BED telling_VBG him_PP3O what_WDT to_TO do_DO about_IN house_NN D16 93 repairs_NNS ,_, petrol_NN and_CC chickens_NNS ._. D16 94 ^ but_CC now_RN they_PP3AS started_VBD messing_VBG about_RP with_IN D16 94 his_PP$ children_NNS ._. D16 95 ^ *'_*' this_DT **'_**' ,_, said_VBD John_NP ,_, *'_*' is_BEZ D16 95 the_ATI end_NN ._. ^ I_PP1A do_DO n't_XNOT mind_VB them_PP3OS D16 95 telling_VBG me_PP1O D16 96 how_WRB to_TO feed_VB my_PP$ chickens_NNS ._. ^ but_CC they_PP3AS D16 96 are_BER not_XNOT going_VBG to_TO tell_VB me_PP1O how_WRB to_TO D16 97 bring_VB up_RP my_PP$ children_NNS ._. **'_**' D16 98 ^ when_WRB you_PP2 come_VB right_RB down_RP to_IN it_PP3 ,_, John_NP D16 98 began_VBD to_TO think_VB ,_, politicians_NNS D16 99 are_BER trying_VBG to_TO take_VB the_ATI place_NN of_IN parents_NNS ._. D16 99 ^ he_PP3A did_DOD n't_XNOT mind_VB when_WRB they_PP3AS D16 100 interfered_VBD with_IN parents_NNS who_WPR would_MD n't_XNOT do_DO D16 100 their_PP$ job_NN ._. ^ every_AT Christmas_NP he_PP3A D16 101 sent_VBD a_AT subscription_NN to_IN the_ATI royal_JJ society_NN for_IN D16 101 the_ATI prevention_NN of_IN cruelty_NN D16 102 to_IN children_NNS ._. ^ some_DTI men_NNS and_CC women_NNS did_DOD D16 102 n't_XNOT deserve_VB to_TO have_HV children_NNS ._. D16 103 ^ what_WDT was_BEDZ getting_VBG him_PP3O down_RP in_IN a_AT big_JJ D16 103 way_NN was_BEDZ being_BEG told_VBN what_WDT to_TO do_DO D16 104 about_IN his_PP$ own_AP children_NNS ._. ^ and_CC who_WP was_BEDZ D16 104 telling_VBG him_PP3O anyway_RB ?_? ^ civil_JJ D16 105 servants_NNS like_IN himself_PPL ._. ^ as_QL often_RB as_CS not_XNOT D16 105 they_PP3AS were_BED not_XNOT even_RB married_VBN ._. D16 106 ^ education_NN ._. D16 107 ^ what_WDT brought_VBD things_NNS to_IN a_AT head_NN ?_? ^ it_PP3 D16 107 happened_VBD this_DT way_NN ._. ^ although_CS D16 108 John_NP was_BEDZ n't_XNOT a_AT catholic_NN ,_, his_PP$ wife_NN and_CC D16 108 children_NNS were_BED ._. ^ Marie_NP ,_, his_PP$ eldest_JJT D16 109 girl_NN ,_, won_VBD a_AT scholarship_NN ._. ^ so_RB ,_, of_RB D16 109 course_RB" ,_, he_PP3A put_VBD her_PP$ name_NN down_RP for_IN the_ATI D16 110 convent_NN of_IN the_ATI sacred_JJ heart_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 's_BEZ true_JJ D16 110 that_CS the_ATI convent_NN was_BEDZ in_IN the_ATI D16 111 next_AP town_NN ,_, three_CD miles_NNS away_RP ._. ^ but_CC Marie_NP D16 111 was_BEDZ a_AT big_JJ ,_, strong_JJ girl_NN ._. D16 112 ^ half-an-hour's_NN$ journey_NN would_MD n't_XNOT do_DO her_PP3O D16 112 any_DTI harm_NN ._. D16 113 ^ but_CC what_WDT happened_VBD ?_? ^ he_PP3A had_HVD a_AT letter_NN D16 113 from_IN the_ATI local_JJ education_NN D16 114 authority_NN telling_VBG him_PP3O that_CS Marie_NP could_MD not_XNOT D16 114 go_VB to_IN the_ATI convent_NN School_NPL ._. D16 115 ^ she_PP3A would_MD have_HV to_TO go_VB to_IN the_ATI municipal_JJ D16 115 high_JJ School_NPL ._. ^ he_PP3A wrote_VBD back_RP ,_, D16 116 thinking_VBG there_EX had_HVD been_BEN some_DTI mistake_NN ._. ^ D16 116 he_PP3A pointed_VBD out_RP that_CS although_CS he_PP3A D16 117 was_BEDZ n't_XNOT a_AT catholic_NN he_PP3A 'd_HVD promised_VBN to_TO D16 117 bring_VB the_ATI children_NNS up_RP catholics_NNS ._. D16 118 ^ so_RB ,_, of_RB course_RB" ,_, his_PP$ girl_NN must_MD go_VB to_IN D16 118 the_ATI convent_NN ._. ^ back_RP came_VBD the_ATI reply_NN D16 119 by_IN return_NN of_IN post_NN ._. ^ high_JJ School_NPL or_CC nothing_PN D16 119 ._. ^ if_CS he_PP3A did_DOD n't_XNOT send_VB her_PP3O on_IN D16 120 the_ATI first_OD day_NN of_IN term_NN they_PP3AS would_MD prosecute_VB D16 120 ._. D16 121 ^ that_DT 's_BEZ why_WRB John_NP started_VBD meddling_VBG in_IN D16 121 politics_NN ._. ^ here_RN 's_BEZ a_AT simple_JJ D16 122 question_NN for_IN anyone_PN to_TO answer_VB :_: ^ who_WP was_BEDZ D16 122 doing_VBG the_ATI meddling_NN ?_? ^ was_BEDZ John_NP D16 123 meddling_VBG in_IN government_NN affairs_NNS or_CC was_BEDZ the_ATI D16 123 government_NN meddling_NN in_IN his_PP$ D16 124 family_NN affairs_NNS ?_? ^ if_CS you_PP2 can_MD answer_VB that_DT D16 124 question_NN *-_*- and_CC it_PP3 's_BEZ not_XNOT a_AT very_QL D16 125 hard_JJ one_CD1 *-_*- you_PP2 will_MD be_BE able_JJ to_TO answer_VB D16 125 the_ATI question_NN *-_*- ^ why_WRB does_DOZ the_ATI D16 126 Church_NPL meddle_VB in_IN politics_NN ?_? D16 127 ^ the_ATI important_JJ word_NN is_BEZ meddle_NC ._. ^ let_VB D16 127 's_PP1OS finish_VB the_ATI story_NN about_IN John_NP D16 128 and_CC then_RN you_PP2 'll_MD see_VB why_WRB ._. D16 129 ^ the_ATI priest_NN meddles_VBZ ._. D16 130 ^ John_NP could_MD get_VB no_ATI satisfaction_NN from_IN the_ATI D16 130 local_JJ education_NN D16 131 authority_NN so_CS he_PP3A went_VBD to_TO see_VB the_ATI catholic_JJ D16 131 priest_NN ._. D16 132 ^ *'_*' you_PP2 know_VB I_PP1A 'm_BEM not_XNOT a_AT catholic_NN ,_, D16 132 Father_NPT ,_, **'_**' he_PP3A said_VBD ,_, *'_*' but_CC an_AT D16 133 Englishman's_NNP$ word_NN is_BEZ his_PP$ bond_NN ._. ^ I_PP1A gave_VBD D16 133 my_PP$ promise_NN that_CS my_PP$ children_NNS D16 134 would_MD be_BE brought_VBN up_RP catholics_NNS ._. ^ I_PP1A 've_HV D16 134 done_VBN all_ABN I_PP1A can_MD ._. ^ if_CS I_PP1A kick_VB up_RP too_QL D16 135 much_AP fuss_NN ,_, it_PP3 's_BEZ not_XNOT going_VBG to_TO do_DO D16 135 me_PP1O any_DTI good_NN at_IN the_ATI office_NN ._. ^ what_WDT are_BER D16 136 you_PP2 going_VBG to_TO do_DO about_IN it_PP3 ?_? **'_**' D16 137 ^ you_PP2 can_MD guess_VB what_WDT the_ATI priest_NN did_DOD D16 137 about_IN it_PP3 ._. ^ he_PP3A did_DOD plenty_NN ._. ^ he_PP3A D16 138 argued_VBD with_IN the_ATI education_NN officer_NN at_IN the_ATI D16 138 Town_NPL Hall_NPL and_CC lost_VBD ._. ^ then_RN he_PP3A D16 139 organized_VBD a_AT big_JJ protest_NN meeting_NN and_CC invited_VBD D16 139 the_ATI Town_NPL councillors_NNS ._. ^ the_ATI D16 140 whole_JJ case_NN was_BEDZ argued_VBN fairly_RB and_CC above_IN board_NN D16 140 ._. ^ even_RB the_ATI councillors_NNS D16 141 who_WPR had_HVD no_ATI particular_JJ use_NN for_IN the_ATI catholic_JJ D16 141 religion_NN were_BED impressed_VBN ._. D16 142 ^ the_ATI way_NN they_PP3AS looked_VBD at_IN it_PP3 after_CS they_PP3AS D16 142 had_HVD heard_VBN all_ABN the_ATI speeches_NNS was_BEDZ D16 143 that_CS you_PP2 can_MD n't_XNOT kick_VB people_NNS around_RP like_IN D16 143 that_DT ._. ^ if_CS this_DT kid_NN had_HVD won_VBN a_AT D16 144 scholarship_NN ,_, the_ATI parents_NNS had_HVD a_AT right_NN to_TO D16 144 say_VB where_WRB she_PP3A should_MD have_HV her_PP$ D16 145 education_NN ._. D16 146 ^ so_RB Marie_NP is_BEZ at_IN the_ATI sacred_JJ heart_NN convent_NN D16 146 ._. ^ she_PP3A 's_BEZ there_RN because_CS the_ATI D16 147 priest_NN meddled_VBD in_IN politics_NN ._. D16 148 ^ what_WDT is_BEZ the_ATI Church_NPL up_RP to_IN ?_? D16 149 ^ now_RN if_CS you_PP2 can_MD see_VB the_ATI sense_NN of_IN that_DT D16 149 ,_, you_PP2 can_MD see_VB the_ATI sense_NN of_IN D16 150 a_AT lot_NN of_IN things_NNS the_ATI catholic_JJ Church_NPL is_BEZ D16 150 doing_VBG in_IN the_ATI world_NN to-day_NR ._. D16 151 ^ it_PP3 's_BEZ not_XNOT a_AT question_NN of_IN one_CD1 child_NN D16 151 going_VBG to_IN a_AT catholic_JJ school_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 's_BEZ a_AT D16 152 question_NN of_IN millions_CDS of_IN working_JJ men_NNS being_BEG D16 152 able_JJ to_TO worship_VB God_NP in_IN their_PP$ D16 153 own_AP way_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 's_BEZ a_AT question_NN of_IN D16 153 governments_NNS in_IN many_AP parts_NNS of_IN the_ATI world_NN D16 154 kicking_VBG around_RP their_PP$ citizens_NNS ,_, forcing_VBG them_PP3OS D16 154 to_TO join_VB parties_NNS they_PP3AS do_DO n't_XNOT D16 155 agree_VB with_IN ,_, making_VBG them_PP3OS do_DO what_WDT they_PP3AS D16 155 are_BER told_VBN *-_*- or_CC else_RB ..._... ._. D16 156 ^ at_IN this_DT moment_NN ,_, throughout_IN the_ATI world_NN ,_, D16 156 there_EX are_BER hundreds_CDS of_IN D16 157 thousands_CDS of_IN people_NNS ruined_VBN because_CS politicians_NNS D16 157 have_HV told_VBN them_PP3OS what_WDT D16 158 they_PP3AS have_HV got_VBN to_TO think_VB and_CC say_VB and_CC do_DO D16 158 ._. D16 159 ^ most_AP people_NNS who_WPR complain_VB when_WRB the_ATI Church_NPL D16 159 makes_VBZ political_JJ D16 160 pronouncements_NNS imagine_VB that_CS religion_NN is_BEZ something_PN D16 160 to_TO be_BE kept_VBN within_IN D16 161 the_ATI four_CD walls_NNS of_IN a_AT church_NN ._. ^ but_CC religion_NN D16 161 does_DOZ n't_XNOT only_RB tell_VB a_AT man_NN how_WRB D16 162 to_TO pray_VB ._. ^ it_PP3 does_DOZ something_PN more_QL vital_JJ D16 162 than_IN that_DT ._. ^ it_PP3 tells_VBZ a_AT man_NN how_WRB D16 163 to_TO live_VB ._. ^ Jesus_NP Christ_NP was_BEDZ the_ATI founder_NN D16 163 of_IN the_ATI Church_NPL ._. ^ they_PP3AS called_VBD him_PP3O D16 164 a_AT political_JJ priest_NN ._. ^ they_PP3AS put_VBD him_PP3O to_IN D16 164 death_NN because_CS they_PP3AS said_VBD he_PP3A was_BEDZ D16 165 meddling_VBG in_IN politics_NN ._. D16 166 ^ they_PP3AS took_VBD him_PP3O before_IN the_ATI Roman_JNP D16 166 governor_NN ,_, Pontius_NP Pilate_NP ._. ^ *'_*' we_PP1AS D16 167 have_HV found_VBN this_DT man_NN perverting_VBG our_PP$ nation_NN D16 167 **'_**' ,_, they_PP3AS said_VBD ,_, *'_*' and_CC D16 168 forbidding_VBG to_TO give_VB tribute_NN to_IN Caesar_NP **'_**' ._. D16 169 ^ Christ_NP ,_, of_RB course_RB" ,_, did_DOD no_ATI such_ABL D16 169 thing_NN ._. ^ what_WDT had_HVD he_PP3A told_VBD them_PP3OS ?_? D16 170 ^ *'_*' render_VB to_IN Caesar_NP the_ATI things_NNS that_WPR D16 170 are_BER Caesar's_NP$ and_CC to_IN God_NP the_ATI D16 171 things_NNS that_WPR are_BER God's_NP$ ._. **'_**' D16 172 ^ that_DT 's_BEZ what_WDT he_PP3A had_HVD said_VBN ._. ^ what_WDT D16 172 he_PP3A fell_VBD out_RP with_IN his_PP$ enemies_NNS about_IN D16 173 was_BEDZ which_WDT are_BER the_ATI things_NNS of_IN God_NP and_CC D16 173 which_WDT are_BER the_ATI things_NNS of_IN Caesar_NP ._. D16 174 ^ of_RB course_RB" ,_, every_AT time_NN a_AT priest_NN fights_VBZ D16 174 the_ATI state_NN he_PP3A will_MD be_BE told_VBN not_XNOT D16 175 to_TO talk_VB politics_NN ._. ^ that_DT 's_BEZ what_WDT he_PP3A D16 175 expects_VBZ ._. ^ if_CS that_DT 's_BEZ what_WDT happened_VBD to_IN D16 176 Christ_NP himself_PPL ,_, the_ATI priest_NN is_BEZ not_XNOT D16 176 surprised_JJ it_PP3 should_MD also_RB happen_VB to_IN D16 177 him_PP3O ._. D16 178 ^ the_ATI law_NN of_IN God_NP ._. D16 179 ^ one_CD1 of_IN the_ATI duties_NNS of_IN religion_NN is_BEZ to_TO D16 179 teach_VB men_NNS to_TO keep_VB the_ATI law_NN D16 180 of_IN God_NP ._. ^ the_ATI law_NN of_IN God_NP has_HVZ a_AT great_JJ D16 180 deal_NN to_TO say_VB about_IN things_NNS which_WDTR D16 181 have_HV nothing_PN to_TO do_DO with_IN worship_NN ._. ^ thou_PP2 D16 181 shalt_MD not_XNOT steal_VB ._. ^ thou_PP2 shalt_MD D16 182 not_XNOT kill_VB ._. ^ thou_PP2 shalt_MD not_XNOT commit_VB adultery_NN D16 182 ._. ^ there_EX are_BER three_CD examples_NNS D16 183 of_IN religious_JJ matters_NNS which_WDTR have_HV nothing_PN to_TO D16 183 do_DO with_IN praying_VBG ._. ^ if_CS it_PP3 is_BEZ D16 184 the_ATI job_NN of_IN the_ATI Church_NPL to_TO see_VB that_CS the_ATI D16 184 law_NN of_IN God_NP is_BEZ kept_VBN then_RN it_PP3 must_MD D16 185 be_BE the_ATI duty_NN of_IN the_ATI Church_NPL to_TO protest_VB D16 185 when_WRB this_DT law_NN is_BEZ broken_VBN ._. D17 2 ^ changing_JJ opinions_NNS in_IN South_NP Africa_NP ._. D17 3 ^ it_PP3 can_MD hardly_RB be_BE questioned_VBN that_CS the_ATI D17 3 most_QL significant_JJ recent_JJ D17 4 development_NN in_IN the_ATI Church_NPL of_IN the_ATI Province_NP of_IN D17 4 South_NP Africa_NP has_HVZ been_BEN its_PP$ D17 5 participation_NN in_IN the_ATI conference_NN and_CC consultation_NN D17 5 arranged_VBN by_IN the_ATI world_NN D17 6 council_NN of_IN Churches_NPLS in_IN Johannesburg_NP between_IN D17 6 December_NR 7_CD and_CC December_NR D17 7 14_CD ._. ^ this_DT conference_NN has_HVZ been_BEN deliberately_RB D17 7 called_VBN a_AT *'_*' consultation_NN D17 8 **'_**' because_CS it_PP3 was_BEDZ that_DT as_QL much_RB as_IN a_AT D17 8 conference_NN in_IN the_ATI generally_RB accepted_JJ D17 9 use_NN of_IN that_DT term_NN ._. D17 10 ^ there_EX is_BEZ no_ATI need_NN to_TO report_VB at_IN this_DT D17 10 stage_NN what_WDT must_MD be_BE the_ATI D17 11 common_JJ knowledge_NN of_IN Church_NPL people_NNS the_ATI world_NN D17 11 over_RP *-_*- that_CS vast_JJ D17 12 differences_NNS of_IN interpretation_NN of_IN the_ATI racial_JJ D17 12 ramifications_NNS of_IN the_ATI D17 13 gospel_NN divide_VB the_ATI Dutch_JNP reformed_JJ Churches_NPLS from_IN D17 13 practically_RB all_ABN the_ATI D17 14 other_AP recognised_JJ Churches_NPLS ,_, and_CC certainly_RB the_ATI D17 14 Anglicans_NNPS ._. D17 15 ^ earlier_RBR in_IN 1960_CD the_ATI Archbishop_NPT of_IN Cape_NP D17 15 Town_NPL openly_RB challenged_VBD the_ATI D17 16 Dutch_JNP reformed_JJ Church_NPL regarding_IN the_ATI possibility_NN D17 16 of_IN Anglicans_NNPS and_CC the_ATI D17 17 Dutch_JNP reformed_JJ Church_NPL remaining_VBG co-members_NNS of_IN D17 17 the_ATI world_NN council_NN of_IN D17 18 Churches_NPLS ,_, so_QL strongly_RB did_DOD his_PP$ grace_NN feel_VB D17 18 about_IN their_PP$ interpretation_NN of_IN D17 19 *'_*' apartheid_NC ._. **'_**' D17 20 ^ however_RB ,_, negotiations_NNS proceeded_VBD ,_, and_CC early_RB D17 20 in_IN the_ATI past_JJB year_NN 1960_CD D17 21 \0Dr_NPT Bilheimer_NP ,_, associate_NN secretary_NN general_JJ of_IN D17 21 the_ATI world_NN council_NN of_IN D17 22 Churches_NPLS flew_VBD from_IN Geneva_NP to_TO prepare_VB the_ATI D17 22 way_NN for_IN a_AT conference_NN to_TO be_BE D17 23 held_VBN towards_IN the_ATI end_NN of_IN 1960_CD in_IN South_NP D17 23 Africa_NP ._. D17 24 ^ the_ATI preparations_NNS having_HVG been_BEN made_VBN ,_, the_ATI D17 24 conference_NN nearly_RB met_VBD its_PP$ D17 25 death_NN with_IN the_ATI deportation_NN of_IN Bishop_NPT Reeves_NP ._. ^ D17 25 in_IN fact_NN ,_, speaking_VBG at_IN a_AT D17 26 great_JJ united_JJ service_NN in_IN Durban_NP during_IN his_PP$ D17 26 official_JJ visitation_NN to_IN the_ATI D17 27 diocese_NN of_IN Natal_NP on_IN the_ATI very_AP day_NN on_IN which_WDTR D17 27 news_NN of_IN the_ATI deportation_NN was_BEDZ D17 28 announced_VBN ,_, the_ATI Archbishop_NPT stated_VBD that_CS it_PP3 D17 28 would_MD be_BE impossible_JJ for_IN the_ATI D17 29 conference_NN to_TO be_BE held_VBN within_IN the_ATI Union_NP of_IN D17 29 South_NP Africa_NP unless_CS Bishop_NPT D17 30 Reeves_NP were_BED able_JJ to_TO be_BE present_JJ ._. D17 31 ^ no_ATI permission_NN to_TO return_VB was_BEDZ granted_VBN by_IN D17 31 the_ATI government_NN to_IN Bishop_NPT D17 32 Reeves_NP but_CC by_IN a_AT gracious_JJ making_NN of_IN concessions_NNS D17 32 it_PP3 still_RB became_VBD D17 33 possible_JJ for_IN the_ATI conference_NN to_TO meet_VB upon_IN South_NP D17 33 African_JNP soil_NN :_: had_HVD this_DT D17 34 not_XNOT been_BEN possible_JJ ,_, it_PP3 is_BEZ questionable_JJ D17 34 whether_CS the_ATI main_JJB objective_NN of_IN D17 35 the_ATI conference_NN could_MD have_HV been_BEN reached_VBN *-_*- D17 35 namely_RB the_ATI burning_JJ question_NN D17 36 of_IN relations_NNS between_IN the_ATI world_NN council_NN of_IN D17 36 Churches_NPLS member_NN Churches_NPLS D17 37 within_IN South_NP Africa_NP ._. D17 38 ^ twentieth-century_JJB miracles_NNS still_RB happen_VB :_: the_ATI D17 38 conference_NN duly_RB met_VBD D17 39 in_IN Johannesburg_NP :_: 80_CD members_NNS of_IN the_ATI eight_CD D17 39 member_NN churches_NNS in_IN South_NP D17 40 Africa_NP plus_IN about_RB 10_CD officials_NNS of_IN the_ATI world_NN D17 40 council_NN of_IN Churches_NPLS met_VBD in_IN D17 41 solemn_JJ and_CC intensive_JJ conclave_NN for_IN a_AT whole_JJ week_NN D17 41 ,_, sessions_NNS lasting_VBG daily_RB D17 42 from_IN early_JJ morning_NN until_CS late_RB at_IN night_NN ._. ^ D17 42 the_ATI Church_NPL of_IN the_ATI Province_NP D17 43 delegation_NN included_VBD his_PP$ grace_NN the_ATI Archbishop_NPT D17 43 of_IN Cape_NP Town_NPL ,_, the_ATI Bishop_NPT D17 44 of_IN Natal_NP ,_, the_ATI Archdeacon_NPT of_IN Cape_NP Town_NPL ,_, D17 44 Professor_NPT Brookes_NP ,_, \0Dr_NPT Alan_NP D17 45 Paton_NP ,_, Professor_NPT \0Z_NP \0K_NP Matthews_NP ,_, Miss_NPT D17 45 Mary_NP Wilson_NP ._. D17 46 ^ sharp_JJ differences_NNS ._. D17 47 ^ sharp_JJ differences_NNS of_IN opinion_NN are_BER said_VBN to_TO D17 47 have_HV marked_VBN the_ATI three_CD D17 48 branches_NNS of_IN the_ATI Dutch_JNP reformed_JJ Church_NPL which_WDTR D17 48 consists_VBZ of_IN two_CD large_JJ D17 49 bodies_NNS ,_, the_ATI Nederduitse_&FW gereformeerde_&FW kerke_&FW D17 49 of_IN the_ATI Cape_NPL and_CC of_IN the_ATI D17 50 Transvaal_NP ,_, both_ABX more_QL moderately_RB *'_*' liberal_JJ D17 50 **'_**' than_IN the_ATI third_OD and_CC very_QL D17 51 much_RB smaller_JJR branch_NN representing_VBG the_ATI intransigent_JJ D17 51 viewpoint_NN of_IN Prime_NPT D17 52 Minister_NPT Verwoerd_NP and_CC other_AP ministers_NNS of_IN state_NN D17 52 ,_, the_ATI Nederduitsch_&FW D17 53 hervormde_&FW kerke_&FW of_IN Africa_NP ._. D17 54 ^ an_AT eighty_CD per_NNU \0cent_NNU" agreement_NN was_BEDZ D17 54 necessary_JJ before_CS any_DTI D17 55 resolution_NN of_IN the_ATI conference_NN could_MD be_BE passed_VBN ._. D17 55 ^ the_ATI following_NN are_BER some_DTI D17 56 of_IN the_ATI outstanding_JJ consultation_NN decisions_NNS *-_*- D17 57 ^ 1_CD1 ._. ^ the_ATI right_NN to_TO own_VB land_NN and_CC to_TO D17 57 participate_VB in_IN the_ATI government_NN of_IN D17 58 the_ATI country_NN is_BEZ *'_*' part_NN of_IN the_ATI dignity_NN of_IN D17 58 adult_JJ man_NN ._. **'_**' D17 59 ^ 2_CD ._. ^ there_EX are_BER no_ATI scriptural_JJ grounds_NNS D17 59 for_IN the_ATI prohibition_NN of_IN mixed_JJ D17 60 marriages_NNS ._. D17 61 ^ 3_CD ._. ^ there_EX can_MD be_BE no_ATI objection_NN in_IN D17 61 principle_NN to_IN the_ATI direct_JJ D17 62 representation_NN of_IN coloureds_NNS in_IN parliament_NN ._. D17 63 ^ 4_CD ._. ^ the_ATI migrant_JJ labour_NN system_NN has_HVZ *'_*' D17 63 disintegrating_JJ effects_NNS **'_**' on_IN D17 64 African_JNP life_NN ._. D17 65 ^ 5_CD ._. ^ the_ATI wages_NNS of_IN the_ATI vast_JJ majority_NN D17 65 of_IN non-whites_NNS are_BER far_RB too_QL low_JJ ._. D17 66 ^ 6_CD ._. ^ the_ATI *'_*' same_AP measures_NNS of_IN justice_NN D17 66 **'_**' claimed_VBN for_IN other_AP racial_JJ D17 67 groups_NNS should_MD apply_VB to_IN Asians_NNPS ._. D17 68 ^ 7_CD ._. ^ there_EX is_BEZ *'_*' not_XNOT sufficient_JJ D17 68 consultation_NN and_CC communication_NN D17 69 **'_**' between_IN the_ATI various_JJ racial_JJ groups_NNS ._. D17 70 ^ the_ATI real_JJ inner_JJB significance_NN of_IN each_DT of_IN D17 70 these_DTS decisions_NNS can_MD D17 71 probably_RB only_RB be_BE fully_RB appreciated_VBN by_IN those_DTS D17 71 who_WPR are_BER closely_RB acquainted_VBN D17 72 with_IN the_ATI inner_JJB life_NN of_IN South_NP Africa_NP ._. D17 73 ^ further_JJB points_NNS were_BED that_CS *'_*' all_ABN unjust_JJ D17 73 discrimination_NN **'_**' was_BEDZ D17 74 rejected_VBN :_: there_EX was_BEDZ a_AT call_NN for_IN the_ATI *'_*' D17 74 revision_NN of_IN job_NN reservation_NN and_CC D17 75 for_IN greater_JJR security_NN of_IN tenure_NN for_IN non-whites_NNS D17 75 in_IN housing_NN ._. **'_**' D17 76 ^ non-whites_NNS should_MD be_BE allowed_VBN freedom_NN of_IN D17 76 worship_NN in_IN urban_JJ areas_NNS ._. ^ all_ABN D17 77 racial_JJ groups_NNS have_HV an_AT equal_JJ right_NN to_TO D17 77 contribute_VB to_IN and_CC share_VB in_IN the_ATI D17 78 life_NN of_IN the_ATI country_NN ._. D17 79 ^ the_ATI following_JJ *'_*' joint_JJB statement_NN **'_**' was_BEDZ D17 79 issued_VBN by_IN the_ATI two_CD large_JJ D17 80 branches_NNS of_IN the_ATI Dutch_JNP reformed_JJ Church_NPL ,_, D17 80 namely_RB the_ATI Gereformeerde_&FW D17 81 Kerke_&FW of_IN the_ATI Cape_NPL and_CC of_IN the_ATI Transvaal_NP D17 81 *-_*- D17 82 ^ *'_*' a_AT policy_NN of_IN differentiation_NN can_MD be_BE D17 82 defended_VBN from_IN the_ATI Christian_JNP D17 83 viewpoint_NN that_CS it_PP3 provides_VBZ the_ATI only_AP realistic_JJ D17 83 solution_NN to_IN the_ATI problems_NNS D17 84 of_IN race_NN relations_NNS and_CC is_BEZ ,_, therefore_RB ,_, in_IN D17 84 the_ATI best_JJT interests_NNS of_IN the_ATI D17 85 various_JJ population_NN groups_NNS ._. ^ we_PP1AS do_DO not_XNOT D17 85 consider_VB the_ATI resolutions_NNS adopted_VBN D17 86 by_IN the_ATI consultation_NN as_CS in_IN principle_NN incompatible_JJ D17 86 with_IN the_ATI above_JJB D17 87 statement_NN ._. **'_**' D17 88 ^ the_ATI small_JJ ,_, extremist_JJ branch_NN of_IN the_ATI D17 88 Dutch_JNP reformed_JJ Church_NPL ,_, the_ATI D17 89 Nederduitsch_&FW hervormde_&FW kerke_&FW of_IN Africa_NP issued_VBD D17 89 this_DT separate_JJ D17 90 statement_NN *-_*- D17 91 ^ *'_*' we_PP1AS wish_VB to_TO state_VB quite_RB clearly_RB that_CS D17 91 it_PP3 is_BEZ our_PP$ conviction_NN that_CS D17 92 separate_JJ development_NN is_BEZ the_ATI only_AP just_JJ solution_NN D17 92 of_IN our_PP$ racial_JJ problem_NN ._. D17 93 ^ we_PP1AS ,_, therefore_RB ,_, reject_VB integration_NN in_IN any_DTI D17 93 form_NN ,_, as_IN a_AT solution_NN of_IN the_ATI D17 94 problem_NN ._. ^ the_ATI agreement_NN that_WPR has_HVZ been_BEN D17 94 reached_VBN contains_VBZ such_ABL D17 95 far-reaching_JJ declarations_NNS that_CS we_PP1AS can_MD not_XNOT D17 95 subscribe_VB to_IN it_PP3 ._. ^ we_PP1AS can_MD not_XNOT ,_, D17 96 therefore_RB ,_, identify_VB ourselves_PPLS with_IN it_PP3 ._. ^ D17 96 we_PP1AS ,_, further_RB ,_, wish_VB to_TO place_VB on_IN D17 97 record_NN our_PP$ gratefulness_NN to_IN the_ATI government_NN for_IN D17 97 all_ABN the_ATI positive_JJ steps_NNS D17 98 it_PP3 has_HVZ taken_VBN to_TO solve_VB the_ATI problems_NNS and_CC D17 98 to_TO promote_VB the_ATI welfare_NN of_IN the_ATI D17 99 different_JJ groups_NNS ._. **'_**' D17 100 ^ movement_NN of_IN thought_NN ._. D17 101 ^ for_IN those_DTS readers_NNS outside_IN South_NP Africa_NP who_WPR D17 101 are_BER sensitive_JJ to_IN the_ATI D17 102 widely_RB variant_JJ approaches_NNS to_IN her_PP$ complicated_JJ D17 102 problems_NNS ,_, it_PP3 will_MD be_BE D17 103 appreciated_VBN that_CS the_ATI statement_NN issued_VBN by_IN the_ATI D17 103 two_CD large_JJ branches_NNS of_IN the_ATI D17 104 Dutch_JNP reformed_JJ Church_NPL marks_VBZ a_AT considerable_JJ move_NN D17 104 ahead_RB of_IN the_ATI D17 105 intransigent_JJ position_NN of_IN the_ATI extremist_JJ branch_NN ._. ^ D17 105 while_CS there_EX is_BEZ a_AT great_JJ D17 106 distance_NN still_RB to_TO be_BE travelled_VBN before_CS complete_JJ D17 106 agreement_NN as_IN to_IN" the_ATI D17 107 policy_NN of_IN race_NN relationships_NNS as_CS viewed_VBN by_IN D17 107 Christians_NNPS can_MD be_BE reached_VBN ,_, D17 108 those_DTS who_WPR know_VB the_ATI deep_JJ traditions_NNS holding_VBG D17 108 the_ATI minds_NNS of_IN men_NNS in_IN South_NP D17 109 Africa_NP will_MD realise_VB that_DT movement_NN of_IN thought_NN D17 109 is_BEZ taking_VBG place_NN at_IN D17 110 encouraging_JJ speed_NN ,_, though_CS ,_, of_RB course_RB" ,_, this_DT D17 110 is_BEZ by_IN no_ATI means_NNS fast_JJ enough_QLP ._. D17 111 ^ the_ATI following_JJ general_JJ statement_NN issued_VBN by_IN D17 111 the_ATI conference_NN throws_VBZ D17 112 light_NN on_IN the_ATI situation_NN :_: *-_*- D17 113 ^ *'_*' the_ATI present_JJ situation_NN in_IN South_NP Africa_NP D17 113 is_BEZ a_AT result_NN of_IN a_AT long_JJ D17 114 historical_JJ development_NN and_CC all_ABN groups_NNS bear_VB D17 114 responsibility_NN for_IN it_PP3 ._. ^ the_ATI D17 115 South_NP African_JNP scene_NN is_BEZ *'_*' radically_RB affected_VBN D17 115 by_IN the_ATI decline_NN of_IN the_ATI D17 116 power_NN of_IN the_ATI west_NR ,_, and_CC by_IN the_ATI desire_NN D17 116 for_IN self-determination_NN among_IN the_ATI D17 117 people_NNS of_IN the_ATI African_JNP continent_NN ._. **'_**' D17 118 ^ *'_*' the_ATI spiritual_JJ unity_NN among_IN all_ABN men_NNS D17 118 who_WPR are_BER in_IN Christ_NP must_MD find_VB D17 119 visible_JJ expression_NN in_IN acts_NNS of_IN common_JJ worship_NN D17 119 and_CC witness_NN and_CC in_IN D17 120 fellowship_NN and_CC consultation_NN on_IN matters_NNS of_IN common_JJ D17 120 concern_NN ._. **'_**' D17 121 ^ the_ATI revival_NN of_IN heathen_JJ tribal_JJ customs_NNS is_BEZ D17 121 the_ATI result_NN of_IN a_AT deep_JJ D17 122 sense_NN of_IN frustration_NN and_CC a_AT loss_NN of_IN faith_NN in_IN D17 122 western_JJ civilisation_NN ._. D17 123 ^ *'_*' it_PP3 is_BEZ widely_RB recognised_VBN that_CS the_ATI D17 123 wages_NNS received_VBN by_IN the_ATI vast_JJ D17 124 majority_NN of_IN non-white_JJ people_NNS oblige_VB them_PP3OS to_TO D17 124 exist_VB well_RB below_IN the_ATI D17 125 generally_RB accepted_JJ minimum_NN ._. ^ concerted_JJ action_NN D17 125 is_BEZ required_VBN ._. ^ job_NN D17 126 reservation_NN must_MD give_VB way_NN to_IN more_QL equitable_JJ D17 126 systems_NNS ,_, and_CC there_EX must_MD be_BE D17 127 the_ATI opportunity_NN to_TO live_VB in_IN conformity_NN with_IN D17 127 human_JJ dignity_NN ._. **'_**' D17 128 ^ much_AP achieved_VBN ._. D17 129 ^ this_DT recent_JJ conference_NN then_RN ,_, has_HVZ achieved_VBN D17 129 much_AP ,_, although_CS it_PP3 D17 130 leaves_VBZ much_AP still_RB to_TO be_BE solved_VBN ._. D17 131 ^ Rome_NP was_BEDZ not_XNOT built_VBN in_IN a_AT day_NN :_: nor_CC D17 131 can_MD strongholds_NNS of_IN tradition_NN D17 132 reinforced_VBN with_IN stubborn_JJ religious_JJ conviction_NN ,_, D17 132 often_RB biassed_VBN and_CC D17 133 prejudiced_JJ ,_, be_BE broken_VBN down_RP in_IN a_AT moment_NN ._. ^ D17 133 only_RB those_DTS who_WPR know_VB from_IN D17 134 inside_JJB experience_NN can_MD fully_RB appreciate_VB how_WRB much_AP D17 134 ,_, how_WRB very_QL much_AP ,_, the_ATI D17 135 fact_NN that_CS the_ATI conference_NN has_HVZ been_BEN held_VBN ,_, D17 135 the_ATI fact_NN that_CS the_ATI delegates_NNS D17 136 came_VBD together_RB for_IN a_AT week_NN ,_, the_ATI fact_NN that_CS D17 136 untold_JJ pitfalls_NNS have_HV been_BEN D17 137 avoided_VBN and_CC difficulties_NNS ironed_VBN out_RP ,_, already_RB D17 137 means_VBZ in_IN South_NP Africa_NP ._. D17 138 ^ those_DTS who_WPR participated_VBD in_IN the_ATI discussions_NNS D17 138 say_VB that_CS they_PP3AS were_BED D17 139 deeply_RB conscious_JJ that_CS *'_*' much_AP prayer_NN was_BEDZ D17 139 made_VBN of_IN the_ATI whole_JJ Church_NPL D17 140 **'_**' for_IN this_DT conference_NN which_WDTR ,_, history_NN may_MD D17 140 well_RB prove_VB ,_, marked_VBD a_AT new_JJ phase_NN D17 141 of_IN respect_NN and_CC co-operation_NN between_IN those_DTS who_WPR D17 141 name_VB the_ATI name_NN of_IN Christ_NP D17 142 in_IN this_DT land_NN ._. D17 143 ^ tragic_JJ reading_NN though_CS it_PP3 makes_VBZ ,_, it_PP3 D17 143 was_BEDZ almost_RB a_AT miracle_NN that_CS the_ATI D17 144 conference_NN took_VBD place_NN ,_, and_CC one_CD1 for_IN which_WDTR D17 144 all_ABN Christians_NNPS must_MD be_BE D17 145 grateful_JJ ._. D17 146 ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ only_RB fair_JJ to_TO add_VB that_CS the_ATI D17 146 resolutions_NNS adopted_VBN by_IN the_ATI D17 147 conference_NN do_DO not_XNOT become_VB operative_JJ within_IN the_ATI D17 147 Nederduitsch_&FW D17 148 Gereformeerde_&FW Kerke_&FW of_IN the_ATI Cape_NPL and_CC of_IN the_ATI D17 148 Transvaal_NP until_CS their_PP$ D17 149 respective_JJ synods_NNS accept_VB ,_, amend_VB or_CC reject_VB D17 149 them_PP3OS ._. ^ but_CC it_PP3 can_MD be_BE D17 150 reasonably_RB hoped_VBN that_CS responsible_JJ leaders_NNS of_IN D17 150 those_DTS two_CD powerful_JJ D17 151 branches_NNS of_IN the_ATI Dutch_JNP reformed_JJ Church_NPL will_MD D17 151 bring_VB increasing_JJ pressure_NN D17 152 to_TO bear_VB on_IN the_ATI government_NN for_IN apartheid_NN to_TO D17 152 be_BE given_VBN a_AT strong_JJ moral_JJ D17 153 basis_NN ._. D17 154 ^ *'_*' delayed_JJ action_NN **'_**' ._. D17 155 ^ every_AT churchman_NN who_WPR wishes_VBZ to_TO be_BE informed_VBN D17 155 as_IN to_IN" the_ATI up_RP to_IN the_ATI D17 156 moment_NN spirit_NN of_IN things_NNS within_IN the_ATI Dutch_JNP D17 156 reformed_JJ Church_NPL in_IN South_NP D17 157 Africa_NP should_MD make_VB himself_PPL a_AT possessor_NN of_IN a_AT D17 157 copy_NN of_IN the_ATI book_NN delayed_JJ D17 158 action_NN ,_, which_WDTR is_BEZ an_AT ecumenical_JJ witness_NN from_IN D17 158 the_ATI Afrikaans_NNP speaking_JJ D17 159 Church_NPL to_IN which_WDTR the_ATI contributors_NNS are_BER eleven_CD D17 159 leading_JJ clergy_NNS of_IN the_ATI D17 160 Dutch_JNP reformed_JJ Church_NPL ,_, Professor_NPT \0B_NP \0B_NP D17 160 Keel_NP ,_, Professor_NPT \0Dr_NPT D17 161 \0A_NP \0S_NP Geyser_NP ,_, Professor_NPT \0Dr_NPT Ben_NP Marais_NP ,_, D17 161 Professor_NPT \0Dr_NPT \0A_NP D17 162 van_&FW Selms_NP ,_, Professor_NPT Hugo_NP du_&FW Plessis_NP ,_, D17 162 \0Ds_NPT \0M_NP Redelinghuys_NP ,_, \0Dr_NPT D17 163 \0G_NP \0C_NP Oosthuizen_NP ,_, \0Dr_NPT \0J_NP \0A_NP van_&FW Wyk_NP D17 163 ,_, \0Ds_NPT \0C_NP D17 164 Stutterheim_NP ,_, \0Ds_NPT \0C_NP Hattingh_NP ,_, \0Dr_NPT \0G_NP D17 164 \0J_NP Swan_NP ._. ^ I_PP1A have_HV named_VBN D17 165 each_DT of_IN these_DTS eleven_CD Dutch_JNP reformed_JJ Church_NPL D17 165 leaders_NNS deliberately_RB to_TO D17 166 make_VB it_PP3 quite_RB clear_JJ that_CS every_AT one_CD1 of_IN D17 166 them_PP3OS is_BEZ fully_RB a_AT member_NN of_IN the_ATI D17 167 Afrikaans_JNP section_NN of_IN the_ATI white_JJ population_NN of_IN D17 167 South_NP Africa_NP ._. ^ here_RN are_BER D17 168 the_ATI chapter_NN titles_NNS ,_, which_WDTR are_BER also_RB D17 168 significant_JJ :_: D17 169 *'_*' the_ATI bell_NN has_HVZ already_RB tolled_VBN **'_**' ;_; D17 169 *'_*' the_ATI first_OD gospel_NN and_CC the_ATI unity_NN D17 170 of_IN the_ATI Church_NPL as_IN witness_NN to_IN Christ_NP **'_**' ;_; D17 170 *'_*' the_ATI Church_NPL in_IN the_ATI D17 171 contemporary_JJ world_NN **'_**' ;_; *'_*' the_ATI communion_NN of_IN D17 171 the_ATI Saints_NPTS and_CC the_ATI colour_NN D17 172 problem_NN **'_**' ;_; *'_*' the_ATI new_JJ era_NN and_CC Christian_JNP D17 172 calling_NN regarding_IN the_ATI Bantu_NNPS in_IN D17 173 South_NP Africa_NP **'_**' ;_; *'_*' developing_VBG an_AT indigenous_JJ D17 173 Church_NPL in_IN South_NP Africa_NP **'_**' ;_; D17 174 *'_*' communication_NN and_CC human_JJ values_NNS **'_**' ;_; *'_*' D17 174 the_ATI Church_NPL and_CC racial_JJ D17 175 ideology_NN **'_**' ;_; *'_*' Christianity_NNP and_CC nationalism_NN D17 175 **'_**' *'_*' the_ATI D17 176 prophetic_JJ calling_NN of_IN the_ATI Church_NPL towards_IN the_ATI D17 176 state_NN ._. **'_**' D17 177 ^ the_ATI significance_NN of_IN this_DT composite_JJ work_NN is_BEZ D17 177 that_CS it_PP3 expresses_VBZ D17 178 forcibly_RB the_ATI fact_NN that_CS at_RB long_RB" last_RB" ,_, D17 178 after_IN *'_*' delayed_JJ action_NN **'_**' in_IN D17 179 fact_NN ,_, the_ATI former_AP strongholds_NNS of_IN spiritual_JJ and_CC D17 179 practical_JJ *'_*' apartheid_NN D17 180 **'_**' are_BER being_BEG permeated_VBN with_IN a_AT new_JJ D17 180 realisation_NN that_CS the_ATI walls_NNS of_IN Jericho_NP D17 181 do_DO weaken_VB under_IN the_ATI continued_JJ blast_NN of_IN the_ATI D17 181 trumpets_NNS of_IN truth_NN ._. D17 182 ^ \0E_NP \0H_NP Wade_NP D17 183 ._. ^ *'_*' the_ATI argument_NN is_BEZ about_IN power_NN **'_**' ._. D17 184 ^ Valerie_NP Pitt_NP writes_VBZ on_IN Christian_JNP choice_NN in_IN D17 184 politics_NN ._. D17 185 ^ Aneurin_NP Bevan_NP said_VBD ,_, ~ *'_*' the_ATI argument_NN D17 185 is_BEZ about_IN power_NN ,_, **'_**' and_CC D17 186 any_DTI serious_JJ *-_*- and_CC honest_JJ *-_*- politician_NN will_MD D17 186 agree_VB ._. ^ the_ATI matter_NN of_IN D17 187 politics_NN is_BEZ the_ATI control_NN and_CC management_NN of_IN D17 187 power_NN ,_, and_CC power_NN is_BEZ not_XNOT an_AT D17 188 abstraction_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 is_BEZ wealth_NN and_CC weapons_NNS ,_, D17 188 the_ATI brute_JJB force_NN of_IN sheer_JJB D17 189 numbers_NNS ,_, and_CC the_ATI weight_NN of_IN law_NN ._. ^ it_PP3 D17 189 is_BEZ above_IN all_ABN the_ATI command_NN of_IN human_JJ D17 190 loyalties_NNS ._. D17 191 ^ there_EX are_BER many_AP theories_NNS about_IN the_ATI balance_NN D17 191 of_IN these_DTS forces_NNS in_IN the_ATI D17 192 perfect_JJ society_NN ,_, and_CC many_AP reasons_NNS for_IN D17 192 believing_VBG that_CS X's_NP$ party_NN ,_, class_NN D17 193 or_CC nation_NN may_MD be_BE trusted_VBN with_IN them_PP3OS where_WRB D17 193 Y's_NP$ can_MD not_XNOT ._. ^ but_CC the_ATI day_NN to_IN D17 194 day_NN business_NN of_IN politics_NN ,_, at_IN \0U.N.O_NP or_CC the_ATI D17 194 parish_NN council_NN D17 195 meeting_NN ,_, is_BEZ the_ATI struggle_NN with_IN or_CC for_IN the_ATI D17 195 power_NN released_VBN by_IN events_NNS ,_, or_CC D17 196 by_IN the_ATI convictions_NNS and_CC abilities_NNS of_IN human_JJ D17 196 beings_NNS ._. D17 197 ^ in_IN old_JJ and_CC settled_JJ societies_NNS like_IN our_PP$ D17 197 own_AP the_ATI realities_NNS of_IN the_ATI D17 198 struggle_NN are_BER obscured_VBN because_CS it_PP3 is_BEZ not_XNOT D17 198 normally_RB expressed_VBN in_IN D17 199 violence_NN ._. ^ our_PP$ deepest_JJT instinct_NN is_BEZ to_TO D17 199 reject_VB the_ATI brute_JJB force_NN of_IN the_ATI D17 200 Congo_NP riots_NNS ,_, or_CC those_DTS of_IN \0St_NPT Pancras_NP as_CS D17 200 a-political_JJ ..._... since_CS for_IN us_PP1OS D17 201 politics_NN is_BEZ politikos_&FW ,_, civilis_&FW ,_, that_DT which_WDTR D17 201 belongs_VBZ to_IN the_ATI D17 202 citizen_NN as_IN a_AT citizen_NN ,_, and_CC is_BEZ ,_, therefore_RB ,_, D17 202 constitutional_JJ ,_, and_CC D17 203 responsible_JJ ._. ^ and_CC indeed_RB the_ATI marriage_NN of_IN D17 203 power_NN and_CC responsibility_NN is_BEZ D17 204 the_ATI first_OD ,_, the_ATI one_CD1 essential_JJ achievement_NN of_IN D17 204 any_DTI civilisation_NN ._. D17 205 ^ Machiavelli_NP ._. D17 206 ^ but_CC Machiavelli_NP ,_, a_AT much_RB less_QL respectable_JJ D17 206 author_NN than_IN Aristotle_NP ,_, D17 207 taught_VBD us_PP1OS that_CS politics_NN is_BEZ also_RB policy_NN ,_, D17 207 the_ATI use_NN of_IN power_NN for_IN a_AT D17 208 purpose_NN ,_, the_ATI manipulation_NN of_IN men_NNS and_CC events_NNS D17 208 in_IN the_ATI service_NN of_IN a_AT cause_NN ,_, D17 209 a_AT ruler_NN ,_, or_CC a_AT nation_NN ._. ^ the_ATI absence_NN of_IN D17 209 violence_NN does_DOZ not_XNOT mean_VB that_CS the_ATI D17 210 power_NN game_NN is_BEZ played_VBN out_RP ,_, only_RB that_CS it_PP3 D17 210 is_BEZ more_QL skilfully_RB ,_, and_CC more_QL D17 211 quietly_RB conducted_VBN ._.